Skip to main content
Court Order

Final Order 21

CNR DLSH01007449202423 Dec 2025
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Final Order 21 · 23 Dec 2025 · CNR DLSH010074492024

Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT
Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF DJ (COMMERCIAL COURT)-03 (SHAHDARA)
KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI
PRESIDED BY: SH. SANJAY SHARMA-II, DHJS
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024
CNR No.: DLSH01-007449-2024
Punjab National Bank
Branch Office:
Mahila Colony Branch
Gandhi Nagar, Delhi-110032
….. Plaintiff
VERSUS
1. Raees Salmani (Borrower)
S/o Mr. Mohd. Shakeel Salmani
2. Mohd. Shakeel Salmani (Co-Borrower)
S/o Late Sharif Ahmed
3. Mrs. Askara Salmani (Co-Borrower)
W/o Mr. Mohd. Shakeel Salmani
All Residents of:
R/o IX-4024, Gali No. 16, Ajit Nagar
Gandhi Nagar, Delhi-110031
….. Defendants
Date of Institution : 05.12.2024
Date of Arguments : 20.12.2025
Date of Judgment : 23.12.2025
J U D G M E N T
THE SUIT:
1. The plaintiff,
through its Sr. Manager Mr. Ashok Kumar,
instituted a suit for a decree for recovery of Rs. 5,49,585.69/-
alongwith
pendente-lite and future interest @ 10.45% per annum
and penal interest @ 2% per annum against the defendants.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 1 of 27
-- 1 of 27 --
THE PARTIES:
2. Oriental Bank of Commerce is the lender. However,
Oriental Bank of Commerce amalgamated with Punjab National
Bank (
Hereinafter referred as ‘
the plaintiff’) w.e.f. 01.04.2020,
vide Gazette Notification dated 04.03.2020.
3. The defendant No. 1 is the principal borrower and the
defendant No. 2 and 3 are co-borrowers.
THE TRANSACTION:
4. On 12.06.2017, the defendants applied for ‘
Education
Loan’ in the sum of Rs. 4,00,000/-,
vide ‘
Loan Application Form
For All Retail Schemes (Individuals)’.
5. On 04.09.2017, the plaintiff sanctioned ‘
Education Loan’
in the sum of Rs. 4,00,000/- to the defendants on interest @
10.45% per annum for a period of 180 months excluding
moratorium period of 48 months (
Study Period + 12 Months
Grace Period). The defendants executed loan documents in
favour of the plaintiff. The plaintiff disbursed the loan amount,
vide loan A/c. No. 00856416000456. The defendants availed the
said ‘
Education Loan’.
6. Grievance of the plaintiff is that the defendants failed to
adhere to terms of repayment. On 01.07.2023, the defendants
made last payment in the sum of Rs. 5,314/-. The loan account
was classified as ‘
Non Performing Assets’ (NPA) on 30.08.2023.
The plaintiff sent demand notice dated 31.08.2023,
through
speed post, to the defendants. However, the defendants neither
replied the demand notice nor cleared the outstanding amount.
An amount of Rs. 5,49,585.69/- (
comprising Rs. 4,79,112.60/- as
principal amount and Rs. 70,473.09/- as accrued interest) was
due against the defendants, as on 24.09.2024. Therefore, the
plaintiff filed the suit for recovery.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 2 of 27
-- 2 of 27 --
WRITTEN STATEMENT:
7. In written statement, the defendants contended that the
plaintiff instituted the suit on the basis of an invalid General
Power of Attorney dated 27.11.2017 as the plaintiff had no nexus
with loan advanced by Oriental Bank of Commerce in 2017.
They contended that amalgamation of Oriental Bank of
Commerce with the plaintiff on 01.04.2020 would not validate
the said GPA retrospectively. They contended that the suit is
barred by limitation on the ground that the plaintiff instituted the
suit after 7 years from the date of disbursal of loan. They
contended that part payment
qua the said loan would not furnish
a fresh period of limitation to the plaintiff in absence of any
acknowledgement under Section 18 of ‘
The Indian Limitation
Act, 1963’. They contended that acknowledgement relied by the
plaintiff is defective as the said acknowledgement does not
mention that the defendants acknowledged their liability in clear
and unambiguous terms. They contended that in the said
acknowledgement, there is no mention of the date on which the
amount mentioned therein became due to the plaintiff. They
contended that the plaintiff has not complied with amalgamation
laws mandating the plaintiff to follow due process to pursue loan
accounts pertaining to Oriental Bank of Commerce. They
contended that the plaintiff has not approached the Court with
clean hands and suppressed material facts including payments
made by the defendants. They contended that the suit is bad for
mis-joinder of the defendant No. 2 and 3 and they are wrongly
impleaded and misrepresented as guarantors / co-borrowers.
They contended that the defendant No. 2 and 3 have never
participated in loan transaction and no liability can be fastened
upon them.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 3 of 27
-- 3 of 27 --
8. According to the defendants, the plaintiff misled the Court
to shift liability of the said loan account to the defendant No. 2
and 3 as
initially, Oriental Bank of Commerce opened and
maintained loan account in the name of the defendant No. 1 and
issued passbook to him. However, the plaintiff misrepresented
the said loan account as a ‘
joint account’ of the defendants. They
contended that unilateral modification of the loan account
without consent / authority of the defendant No. 2 and 3 is an act
of misrepresentation and manipulation to fasten liability upon the
defendant No. 2 and 3. They contended that the defendant No. 2
and 3 were not privy to original transaction and had no role in
sanction / disbursement of the said loan.
9. The defendants further contended that the plaintiff has
concealed payment of an amount of Rs. 1,29,000/- and credit
entry of Rs. 2,76,022.52/- in the said loan account. They
contended that the plaintiff made averment pertaining to receipt
of an Income Certificate dated 04.09.2019 whereas the plaintiff
was not lender at that time. They contended that the plaintiff has
not filed original income certificate containing stamp of Oriental
Bank of Commerce.
10. The defendants contended that the plaintiff wrongly
classified loan account as ‘
Non Performing Asset’ (NPA) in
breach of guidelines issued by RBI mandating that an account
can be classified as ‘
Non Performing Asset’ (NPA) in case of
non-payment for 90 days. They contended that classification of
loan account as ‘
Non Performing Asset’ (NPA) was premature
and it vitiates the claim of the plaintiff. The plaintiff instituted
the suit on 05.12.2024 and an amount of Rs. 2,76,022.52/- was
credited to loan account on 06.12.2024 and therefore, the suit is
premature.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 4 of 27
-- 4 of 27 --
11. According to the defendants,
initially, the plaintiff made a
demand of Rs. 4,90,706.69/-,
vide demand notice whereas the
plaintiff filed the suit for recovery of an amount of Rs.
5,49,585.69/-. Therefore, there is material discrepancy in
statement of account and the claim of the plaintiff. They
contended that in Para No. 14 of the plaint, the plaintiff claimed
an amount of Rs. 5,49,585.69/- comprising principal amount of
Rs. 4,79,112.60/- and interest amount of Rs. 70,473.09/-. They
contended that claim for interest amount of Rs. 70,473.09/- is
arbitrary, excessive and illegal. They contended that there is no
explanation for difference of an amount of Rs. 58,879/- between
amount demanded,
vide demand notice and this suit. They
contended that the plaint does not disclose clear, coherent and
legally enforceable claim and therefore, it is liable to be rejected
under Order 17 Rule 11(a) and (d) CPC.
12. To add further, the defendants contended that loan
documents were not properly explained to them and their
signatures were obtained under coercion. They contended that
loan documents were not read over or explained to them. They
contended that penal interest @ 2% per annum is contrary to
Section 23 of ‘
The Indian Contract Act, 1872’. They contended
that the plaintiff did not issue any notice before classification of
account as ‘
Non Performing Asset’ (NPA) on 30.08.2023. They
denied receipt of loan recall notice dated 31.08.2023.
REPLICATION:
13. In the replication, the plaintiff denied averments made in
the written statement and reiterated averments made in the plaint.
The plaintiff contended that the defendant No. 2 and 3 executed
Agreement of Term Loan, Affidavits and Balance and Security
Confirmation Letter and the suit is within limitation.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 5 of 27
-- 5 of 27 --
ISSUES:
14. On 09.06.2025, the Court framed issues, as under:
(1) Whether GPA dated 27.11.2017 is defective and
for that reason, authorized representative of the
plaintiff had no authority to file the suit?
(OPD)
(2) Whether the suit is barred by limitation?
(OPD)
(3) Whether there is non-compliance with
amalgamation laws and scheme and the plaintiff has
not followed due process to pursue accounts of
Oriental Bank of Commerce?
(OPD)
(4) Whether there is suppression of material facts?
(OPD)
(5) Whether the suit is bad for misjoinder of the
defendant No. 2 and 3?
(OPD)
(6) Whether the plaintiff made unilateral
modification in the identity of the account holder and
wrongly reflected the account as jointly held by the
defendant No. 1 to 3?
(OPD)
(7) Whether the plaintiff suppressed part payments /
installments of Rs. 1,29,000/- and credit of Rs.
2,76,022.52/- into the loan account?
(OPD)
(8) Whether the plaintiff withheld copy of Income
Certificate dated 04.09.2019, if so, its effect?
(OPD)
(9) Whether the loan account was wrongly classified
as ‘
Non Performing Asset’ (NPA)?
(OPD)
(10) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree for
recovery of Rs. 5,49,585/-, as prayed?
(OPP)
(11) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to
pendente-lite
and future interest @ 10.45% per annum with
monthly rest and penal interest @ 2% per annum?
(OPP)
(12) Relief.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 6 of 27
-- 6 of 27 --
THE PLAINTIFF’S EVIDENCE:
15. The plaintiff examined Mr. Ashok Kumar, Sr. Manager as
PW-1. He deposed, on strength of evidence-affidavit Ex.PW1/1.
He relied on documents, as under:
Sl No. Description Exhibit
1. Gazette Notification dated 04.03.2020 Ex.PW1/A
2. GPA dated 27.11.2017 in favour of Mr. Ashok Kumar Ex.PW1/B
3. Loan Application Form dated 12.06.2017 Ex.PW1/C
4. Sanction Letter dated 04.09.2017 Ex.PW1/D
5. Affidavits of co-borrowers dated 07.09.2017 Ex.PW1/E
6. Agreement of Term Loan for Education dt 07.09.2017 Ex.PW1/F
7. Undertakings dated 28.09.2017 Ex.PW1/G
8. Letter for Auto Recovery dated 07.09.2017 Ex.PW1/H
9. Balance & Security Confirmation dated 01.05.2023 Ex.PW1/I
10. Income Certificate of the defendant No. 2 Ex.PW1/J
11. Fee Receipts dated 12.06.2017, 23.10.2017 and
23.05.2018
Ex.PW1/K
12. Statement of Bank Account and NPACR Ex.PW1/L
13. Demand Notice dated 31.08.2023 and postal receipt Ex.PW1/M
14. ‘
Non-Starter Report’ dated 10.09.2024 Ex.PW1/N
15. Affidavit under Order 11 Rule 6(3) of ‘
The
Commercial Courts Act, 2015’
Ex.PW1/O
16. Certificate under Section 2A(b) and 2A(c) of ‘
The
Information and Technology Act, 2000’
Ex.PW1/P
THE DEFENDANTS’ EVIDENCE:
16. The defendant No. 1 appeared as DW-1. He deposed, on
strength of evidence-affidavit Ex.DW1/A. He relied on
documents, as under:
Sl No. Description Exhibit
1. Copy of Bank Statement of the defendant No. 1 Ex.DW1/1
2. Copy of passbook of loan A/c. No. 00856416000456 Ex.DW1/2
3. Income Certificate of father of the defendant No. 1 Ex.DW1/3
17. DW-2 Mr. Ashok Kumar, Sr. Manager, PNB, Gandhi
Nagar Branch, Delhi brought statement of loan account of the
defendants w.e.f. 01.06.2024 to 31.12.2024 Ex.DW2/A.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 7 of 27
-- 7 of 27 --
APPEARANCE:
18. The Court has heard arguments of Ms. Jyoti Gautam, Ld.
Counsel for the plaintiff, Mr. Rajkumar, Ld. Counsel for the
defendant No. 1 and Mr. Zuber Salmani, Ld. Counsel for the
defendant No. 2 and 3 and perused written arguments filed by the
defendants.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PLAINTIFF:
19. Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff contended that Oriental Bank
of Commerce advanced an education loan in the sum of Rs.
4,00,000/- to the defendant No. 1 in order to enable him to
pursue ‘
Master of Dental Surgery’ from ‘
Institute of Dental
Studies and Technologies’ pursuant to loan application filed by
the defendants Ex.PW1/C,
vide sanction letter dated 04.09.2017
Ex.PW1/D. She contended that the defendants executed loan
documents in favour of the plaintiff,
vide Affidavits of Co-
Borrowers Ex.PW1/E, Agreement of Term Loan for Education
Ex.PW1/F and Undertakings Ex.PW1/G. She contended that the
loan amount was disbursed to ‘
Institute of Dental Studies and
Technologies’ on furnishing Fee Receipts Ex.PW1/K. She
contended that the defendants failed to adhere to financial
discipline and deposit regular installments leading to
classification of account as ‘
Non Performing Asset’ (NPA) on
30.08.2023. She contended that the plaintiff issued loan recall
notice dated 31.08.2023 Ex.PW1/M to the defendants,
through
speed post. However, the defendants failed to clear the loan
account. She contended that an amount of Rs. 5,49,585.69/- was
due against the defendants, as on 24.09.2024,
vide statement of
account Ex.PW1/L. She contended that contentions raised by the
defendants are evasive and therefore, the plaintiff is entitled to a
decree for recovery of the suit amount with interest.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 8 of 27
-- 8 of 27 --
CONTENTIONS OF THE DEFENDANTS:
20. Ld. Counsels for the defendants contended that the
plaintiff instituted the suit on the basis of an invalid GPA
executed in favour of PW-1 Mr. Ashok Kumar, Sr. Manager.
They contended that Oriental Bank of Commerce disbursed loan
on 04.09.2017 and at that time, Punjab National Bank had no
connection with Oriental Bank of Commerce. They contended
that GPA filed by PW-1 Mr. Ashok Kumar was executed on
27.11.2017. They contended that amalgamation of Oriental Bank
of Commerce with Punjab National Bank would not validate the
said GPA retrospectively. In this regard, Ld. Counsels for the
defendants referred cross-examination of PW-1 Mr. Ashok
Kumar, Sr. Manager that he had no knowledge of the loan
transaction and he had neither signed nor witnessed execution of
loan documents. On that basis, Ld. Counsels for the defendants
contended that the plaint is signed, verified and instituted by a
person not authorized by the plaintiff and PW-1 Mr. Ashok
Kumar, Sr. Manager is not a competent witness.
21. Ld. Counsels for the defendants contended that loan was
advanced on 04.09.2017 and the plaintiff instituted the suit for
recovery on 05.12.2024 i.e. after 7 years from the date of
advancement of loan and therefore, the suit is barred by
limitation. They contended that Balance and Security
Confirmation Letter dated 01.05.2023 Ex.PW1/I and payment of
Rs. 5,314/- made on 01.07.2023 were executed / deposited after
expiry of period of limitation and therefore, the said confirmation
letter and deposit would not extend period of limitation under
Section 18 of ‘
The Indian Limitation Act, 1963’. They contended
that in any other case, the said confirmation letter does not state
the date on which the said amount became due and it is not valid.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 9 of 27
-- 9 of 27 --
22. Ld. Counsels for the defendants contended that the
plaintiff has not complied with scheme of amalgamation of
Oriental Bank of Commerce with Punjab National Bank as the
plaintiff is relying upon GPA dated 27.11.2017 executed before
amalgamation on 01.04.2020.
23. Ld. Counsels for the defendants contended that the
plaintiff has suppressed material facts from the Court. They
contended that the plaintiff suppressed payment of Rs. 1,29,000/-
made by the defendant No. 1 and credit of Rs. 2,76,022.52/- into
loan account on 06.12.2024. They contended that the plaintiff
suppressed and fabricated identity of account holder(s) and status
of loan account. They contended that
initially, Oriental Bank of
Commerce opened loan account in the name of the defendant No.
1 and issued a passbook to him whereas post-amalgamation, the
plaintiff reflected the said account as ‘
joint account’ of the
defendants. They contended that the plaintiff changed status of
the loan account in the absence of any consent of / agreement
with the defendant No. 2 and 3. They contended that unilateral
modification of status of an ‘
individual account’ to ‘
joint
account’ is fabrication of record with the intent to fasten liability
upon the defendant No. 2 and 3.
24. Ld. Counsels for the defendants contended that the suit is
bad for
misjoinder of the defendant No. 2 and 3. They contended
that the plaintiff is misrepresenting the defendant No. 2 and 3 as
guarantors / co-borrowers. They contended that the defendant
No. 2 and 3 were not privy to loan transaction and they never
participated in loan transaction. They contended that the plaintiff
made the defendant No. 2 and 3 as guarantors / co-borrowers
without their consent or explaining them legal implication of the
documents and got executed documents under influence.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 10 of 27
-- 10 of 27 --
25. Ld. Counsels for the defendants further contended that the
plaintiff suppressed income certificate dated 04.09.2019 bearing
official stamp of Oriental Bank of Commerce. They contended
that the plaintiff filed an income certificate dated 04.09.2019
bearing stamp of Punjab National Bank whereas Oriental Bank
of Commerce amalgamated with Punjab National Bank on
01.04.2020,
vide Gazette Notification dated 04.03.2020
Ex.PW1/A.
26. Ld. Counsels for the defendants contended that averments
made in the plaint regarding liability of the defendants are
contradictory. They contended that the plaintiff demanded an
amount of Rs. 4,90,706.69/-,
vide demand notice Ex.PW1/M
whereas the plaintiff stated the principal amount as Rs.
4,79,112.60/-. They contended that the plaintiff is claiming
interest amount of Rs. 70,473.09/-. They contended that
pre-suit
interest claimed by the plaintiff is arbitrary, excessive and illegal.
They contended that the plaintiff has not explained difference of
Rs. 58,879/- between the demand notice and the suit amount.
27. Ld. Counsels for the defendants contended that the
plaintiff wrongly classified loan account of the defendants as
‘
Non Performing Asset’ (NPA) in breach of RBI guidelines
mandating that an account can only be classified as ‘
Non
Performing Asset’ (NPA) in case of non-payment for 90 days.
They contended that the plaintiff did not serve loan recall notice.
They contended that the plaintiff filed a notice Ex.PW1/M
alongwith photocopy of postal receipts. However, there is no
tracking report regarding service of the said notices upon the
defendants. They contended that the plaintiff cannot file a suit for
recovery in the absence of intimation of classification of the
account as ‘
Non Performing Asset’ (NPA) and demand notices.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 11 of 27
-- 11 of 27 --
28. Ld. Counsels for the defendants contended that this Court
does not have pecuniary jurisdiction to try this suit as the claim of
the plaintiff on the date of institution of the suit was below Rs.
3,00,000/-. In that regard, they referred statement of account
Ex.DW2/A wherein an amount of Rs. 2,91,649.17/- is shown due,
as on 31.12.2024. They contended that the plaintiff did not deduct
the said amount of Rs. 2,91,649.17/- in its statement of account
Ex.PW1/L. They contended that if the plaintiff deducted the said
amount from the suit amount, the claim of the plaintiff would
have been below the pecuniary jurisdiction of this Court.
29. Ld. Counsels for the defendants contended that the plaintiff
instituted the suit after 17 months from the date of classification of
loan account as ‘
Non Performing Asset’ (NPA). They contended
that the plaintiff has not furnished any justification for such
inordinate delay in filing of the suit.
30. Ld. Counsels for the defendants relied upon judgments, as
under:
Judgment Citation
S.P. Chengalvaraya Naidu vs. Jagannath 1993 SUPP 3 SCR 422
Dalip Singh vs. State of U.P. & Ors. 2010 (2) SCC 114
K.D. Sharma vs. Steel Authority of India
Ltd. & Ors.
Civil Appeal No. 4270/2008
decided on 09.07.2008 (SC)
DUTY OF THE BORROWERS:
31. Before appraisal of evidence, this Court would like to place
its concern on record that Oriental Bank of Commerce advanced
an education loan to the defendant No. 1 in order to enable him to
pursue ‘
Master of Dental Surgery’. The defendant No. 1 admitted,
in his cross-examination, that he had applied and utilized
education loan. The defendant No. 2 and 3 were the co-borrowers
and they are parents of the defendant No. 1. Pursuant to the said
loan, the defendant No. 1 completed ‘
Master of Dental Surgery’.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 12 of 27
-- 12 of 27 --
32. It would have been fair on the part of the defendants that
they would have cleared the loan account. However, the
defendants raised generic, standard and evasive defences to
escape from their liability. It is highly unexpected from such a
highly educated person to deny his liability on vexatious,
frivolous and baseless grounds. It is not only that the defendants
raised general and usual defences, but they also accused the
plaintiff of suppression and misrepresentation of the facts as well
as fabrication of documents.
33. Nationalized Banks are custodians of public money. They
disburse loans to traders, students, property buyers etc. to meet
their financial constraints. There is a corresponding duty on
borrowers to repay loan as per agreement so that the said money
can be disbursed to other needy persons.
34. In
M/s. ICICI Bank Limited vs. Umesh Rai, 2018 SCC
OnLine Del 9540, Hon’ble High Court of Delhi held, as under:
“10. Banks and financial institutions, which disburse
loans to citizens, operate on the trust and faith that
the citizens who avail of loans would pay back the
same honesty and with diligence. Banks hold the
money of the public in trust with them, and the
financial cycle of investments, deposits and loans are
essential for the functioning of the economy. If
people, who avail loans, default in payment of the
same and also avoid the Court processes, there would
be enormous distress in the system.
11. Courts also have a duty to safeguard public
money and by applying completely incorrect
principles of procedure and evidence, suits filed by
these financial institutions cannot be dismissed in this
manner. A perusal of the documents filed in this case
shows that the Bank has filed the entire set of original
documents on record. The statement of accounts
clearly shows that the Defendant paid several of the
instalments but defaulted in some of the instalments.
The Plaintiff bank, having placed all the original
documents on record except the loan recall notice,
has established its case.”
(
emphasis supplied)
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 13 of 27
-- 13 of 27 --
ISSUE NO. 1:
(1) Whether GPA dated 27.11.2017 is defective and
for that reason, authorized representative of the
plaintiff had no authority to file the suit?
(OPD)
35. The said issue was framed on the contention of the
defendants that PW-1 Mr. Ashok Kumar, Sr. Manager of the
plaintiff instituted the suit on the basis of GPA dated 27.11.2017
Ex.PW1/B whereas Oriental Bank of Commerce amalgamated
with the plaintiff on 01.04.2020,
vide Gazette Notification dated
04.03.2020 Ex.PW1/A. On that premise, the defendants
contended that the said GPA is relating to pre-amalgamation
period and the plaintiff has not issued a fresh GPA in favour of
PW-1 Mr. Ashok Kumar, Sr. Manager. Ld. Counsels for the
defendants contended that amalgamation of Oriental Bank of
Commerce with the plaintiff on 01.04.2020 would not validate
GPA dated 27.11.2017 Ex.PW1/B retrospectively. Therefore, the
defendants contended that the plaintiff instituted a suit on the
basis of an invalid / defective GPA.
36. This Court does not find any merit in the said contention.
Oriental Bank of Commerce amalgamated with the plaintiff on
01.04.2020,
vide Gazette Notification dated 04.03.2020
Ex.PW1/A. Therefore, the officers of the plaintiff can institute
the suit for recovery of the amount due to Oriental Bank of
Commerce on the basis of General Power of Attorney already
executed in their favour. In this regard, it would be appropriate to
refer Para No. 2, 4, 9 of ‘
Scheme of Amalgamation of Oriental
Bank of Commerce into Punjab National Bank’ is, as under:
“(2) Upon the commencement of this Scheme, the
undertakings of the Transferor Banks shall vest or be
deemed to vest or be taken over by the Transferee
Bank without requiring any act, deed, consent or
instrument for transfer of the same.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 14 of 27
-- 14 of 27 --
(4) Without prejudice to the generality of sub-
paragraph (1) and in respect of movable assets other
than those dealt with in sub-paragraph (3), including
but not limited to debts, actionable claims, earnest
monies, receivables, bills, credits, loans, advances
and deposits, if any, forming part of the undertaking,
whether recoverable in cash or in kind or for value to
be received, bank balances, etc., the same shall stand
transferred to and vested in the Transferee Bank
without any notice or other intimation to any person
to the end and intent that the rights of the Transferor
Banks to recover or realize the same stands
transferred to the Transferee Bank, and to the extent
such assets is a debt, loan, receivable, advance or
deposit, appropriate entries should be passed in their
respective books to record the aforesaid change,
without any notice or other intimation to such
debtors, depositors or persons as the case may be.
(9) If, immediately before the commencement of this
Scheme, any cause of actions, suit, decrees, recovery
certificates, appeals or other proceedings of whatever
nature in relation to any business of the undertakings
which have been transferred under paragraph 3, is
pending by or against the Transferor Banks before
any court or tribunal or any other authority (including
for the avoidance of doubt, an arbitral tribunal), the
same shall not abate, be discontinued or be, in any
way prejudicially affected by reason of the transfer of
the undertakings of the Transferor Banks or of
anything contained in this Scheme but the suit, appeal
or other proceeding may be continued, prosecuted
and enforced by or against the Transferee Bank.”
(
emphasis supplied)
37. It is evident that post-amalgamation, the right to recover
the amount advanced by Oriental Bank of Commerce vested into
the plaintiff and the plaintiff can initiate proceedings for recovery
of loans advanced by Oriental Bank of Commerce.
38. It does not stand to reason as to why GPA executed on
27.11.2017 in favour of PW-1 Mr. Ashok Kumar would cease to
have effect in view of amalgamation on 01.04.2020. There was
no necessity for execution of a fresh GPA in his favour
39. PW-1 Mr. Ashok Kumar, Sr. Manager was duly authorized
to institute this suit for recovery of the amount advanced to the
defendants.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 15 of 27
-- 15 of 27 --
40. In any case, PW-1 Mr. Ashok Kumar, Sr. Manager is a
principal officer of the plaintiff and he can file a suit for recovery
against the defendants.
41. In
United Bank of India vs. Naresh Kumar and Others,
(1996) 6 SCC 660, Hon’ble Supreme Court of India held, as
under:
“10. … Reading Order 6 Rule 14 together with Order
29 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure it would
appear that even in the absence of any formal letter of
authority or power of attorney having been executed
a person referred to in Rule 1 of Order 29 can, by
virtue of the office which he holds, sign and verify
the pleadings on behalf of the corporation. …
13. The court had to be satisfied that Shri L.K.
Rohatgi could sign the plaint on behalf of the
appellant. The suit had been filed in the name of the
appellant company; full amount of court fee had been
paid by the appellant-Bank; documentary as well as
oral evidence had been led on behalf of the appellant
and the trial of the suit before the Sub-Judge,
Ambala, had continued for about two years. It is
difficult, in these circumstances, even to presume that
the suit had been filed and tried without the appellant
having authorised the institution of the same. The
only reasonable conclusion which we can come to is
that Shri L.K. Rohatgi must have been authorised to
sign the plaint and, in any case, it must be held that
the appellant had ratified the action of Shri L.K.
Rohatgi in signing the plaint and thereafter, it
continued with the suit.”
(
emphasis supplied)
42. Ld. Counsels for the defendants contended that PW-1 Mr.
Ashok Kumar, Sr. Manager has no knowledge of facts of case as
he neither signed nor witnessed execution of loan documents,
‘
he could not state the date of execution of loan documents’,
‘
date of amalgamation of Oriental Bank of Commerce with the
plaintiff’, ‘
he was appointed as a ‘Probationary Officer’ in 2014’,
‘
he could not state the date of classification of the account as
‘Non Performing Asset’ (NPA)’, ‘
date of issuance of loan recall
notice to the defendants and date of balance confirmation letter’.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 16 of 27
-- 16 of 27 --
43. Precisely, this contention was answered in
M/s. ICICI
Bank Ltd. vs. Ashok Sharma, RFA 572/2015 decided on
01.06.2018 by Hon’ble High Court of Delhi, while dealing with a
similar contention, as under:
“8. The question put by the Court to the witness also
proved that the witness was deposing truthfully. The
fact that he may not have witnessed the Defendant's
signing the documents, does not render the documents
fraudulent or unbelievable. In large organizations like
the Plaintiff Bank, when the Principal Officer is
deposing as a witness, it cannot be expected that the
said Principal Officer would be witnessing the
signatures of all the customers on the original
documents that have been produced. So long as the
originals are produced on record and the same are not
denied and there is no allegation that the same are
forged and fabricated, there can be no reason for the
Court to disbelieve the same. The original documents
having been placed on record and duly exhibited, the
averments in the suit stand proved. The finding of the
Trial Court that as the witness had not personally
witnessed the Defendant signing the agreement, the
same cannot be believed, is a completely incorrect
approach. The Defendant has not disputed his
signatures on the original agreement, which is placed
on record. Thus there is no reason to disbelieve the
same.”
(
emphasis supplied)
44. In this case, the defendant No. 1 admitted that he applied
and availed education loan. The defendant No. 2 and 3 have not
appeared into the witness box to dispute existence, authenticity
and credibility of loan application and loan documents filed by
the plaintiff.
45. Therefore, the plaint was signed, verified and instituted by
a duly authorized person and there is no infirmity in GPA dated
27.11.2017 Ex.PW1/B and Mr. Ashok Kumar, Sr. Manager is a
competent witness and he duly proved loan documents pertaining
to loan of Rs. 4,00,000/- advanced to the defendants.
46. Accordingly, issue No. 1 is decided in favour of the
plaintiff and against the defendants.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 17 of 27
-- 17 of 27 --
ISSUE NO. 2:
(2) Whether the suit is barred by limitation?
(OPD)
47. The said issue was framed on the contention of the
defendants that the loan was advanced on 04.09.2017 and the suit
was instituted on 05.12.2024, after 7 years from the date of
advancement of loan, and further that Balance and Security
Confirmation Letter 01.05.2023 Ex.PW1/I was executed after
three years from the expiry of period of limitation and therefore,
it would not furnish a fresh period of limitation, and that the said
letter dated 01.05.2023 is incomplete, vague and unenforceable
for want of independent witness and absence of date on which
the said amount became due to the plaintiff.
48. The plaintiff sanctioned an amount of Rs. 4,00,000/- to the
defendants,
vide sanction letter dated 04.09.2017 Ex.PW1/D.
According to the statement of account Ex.PW1/L, the said
amount was directly transferred to ‘
Institute of Dental Studies
and Technologies’. The said amount was repayable after
moratorium of 48 months comprising study period of 3 years and
12 months grace period. Therefore, cause of action arisen in
favour of the plaintiff since 03.08.2021. In the meanwhile, the
defendants made payments in the said loan account till
01.07.2023,
vide statement of account Ex.PW1/L. Moreover, the
defendants executed Balance and Security Confirmation Letter
dated 01.05.2023 Ex.PW1/I whereby the defendants
acknowledged liability of Rs. 4,84,098.69/-, as on 01.05.2023.
Therefore, computing period of limitation either from tenure of
repayment or acknowledgement dated 01.05.2023 or last payment
of Rs. 5,314/- on 01.07.2023, the suit filed by the plaintiff on
05.12.2024 is within limitation. Accordingly, issue No. 2 is
decided in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 18 of 27
-- 18 of 27 --
ISSUE NO. 3:
(3) Whether there is non-compliance with
amalgamation laws and scheme and the plaintiff has
not followed due process to pursue accounts of
Oriental Bank of Commerce?
(OPD)
49. The said issue was framed on contention of the defendants
that the plaintiff has not complied with amalgamation laws and
scheme and not followed due process to pursue accounts of
Oriental Bank of Commerce. It appears that the said contention
was premised on the basis of challenge to GPA dated 27.11.2017
Ex.PW1/B pertaining to post-amalgamation period. However, the
said challenge has already been rejected. Moreover, the
defendants have neither stated nor demonstrated any non-
compliance of scheme of amalgamation by the plaintiff or breach
of any law pertaining to amalgamation, if any.
50. Accordingly, issue No. 3 is decided in favour of the
plaintiff and against the defendants.
ISSUE NO. 4:
(4) Whether there is suppression of material facts?
(OPD)
51. The said issue was framed on contention of the defendants
that the plaintiff has concealed payment of Rs. 1,29,000/- and
credit entry of Rs. 2,76,022.52/- in loan account of the
defendants. It may be noted that PW-1 Mr. Ashok Kumar, Sr.
Manager admitted, in his cross-examination, that an amount of
Rs. 1,29,000/- has been paid by the defendants and that an
amount of Rs. 2,91,649.17/- was due, as on 31.12.2024. In that
regard, the defendants relied upon statement of loan account for
the period from 06.12.2024 to 31.12.2024 Ex.DW2/A wherein an
amount of Rs. 2,76,022.52/- was credited into loan account.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 19 of 27
-- 19 of 27 --
52. In this regard, Ld. Counsels for the defendants contended
that PW-1 Mr. Ashok Kumar, Sr. Manager categorically stated,
in his cross-examination, that the plaintiff has not obtained any
subsidy from the Government for want of relevant documents at
appropriate stage and no subsidy was credited to loan account of
the defendants. Therefore, they contended that the plaintiff
concealed the said payments and deposit and the plaintiff has not
given due credit of the said payments and deposit.
53. As regards payment of Rs. 1,29,000/-, it can be stated in
statement of loan account of the defendants Ex.PW1/L payments
made by the defendants are duly credited. The defendants have
neither shown any deposit receipt or proof of transfer of any
amount which was not credited in the said loan account.
54. As regards contention relating to entry dated 06.12.2024 in
the sum of Rs. 2,76,022.52/-, it can be stated that the said entry is
relating to the period of post-institution of the suit. It is neither
the case of the defendants nor it can be that the defendants
deposited the said amount of Rs. 2,76,022.52/- into loan account.
The said amount was transferred to the loan account of the
defendants from HNPACR / CGFSEL on 06.12.2024. The said
amount was transferred to the said account by the Government to
mitigate the loss of the plaintiff-bank on account of non-payment
of loan amount by the defendants. The defendants cannot derive
any advantage from transfer of the said amount to the loan
account. It is not the case of the defendants that the Government
subsidized their education loan. This Court is of the considered
opinion that there is no suppression of the facts by the plaintiff.
55. Accordingly, issue No. 4 is decided in favour of the
plaintiff and against the defendants.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 20 of 27
-- 20 of 27 --
ISSUE NO. 5:
(5) Whether the suit is bad for misjoinder of the
defendant No. 2 and 3?
(OPD)
56. As regards contention of Ld. Counsels of the defendants
that the defendant No. 2 and 3 were not privy to loan transaction
and they never participated in loan transaction and they are
misrepresented as co-borrowers / guarantors is concerned, it can
be stated that the defendant No. 2 and 3 have not appeared into
the witness box to substantiate their contentions.
57. From perusal of evidence on record, it is evident that the
defendant No. 2 and 3 applied alongwith the defendant No. 1 for
education loan of Rs. 4,00,000/-,
vide loan application
Ex.PW1/C and they furnished affidavits as co-borrowers,
vide
Ex.PW1/E (colly.) and signed Agreement of Term Loan for
Education Ex.PW1/F. They also furnished Undertakings
Ex.PW1/G to the plaintiff and signed Balance and Security
Confirmation Letter Ex.PW1/I.
58. As regards contention that the defendant No. 2 and 3 are
elderly persons and the plaintiff obtained their signatures under
influence without explaining the documents and their legal
implication, it can be stated that the defendant No. 1 was a
Graduate in dental surgery on the date of application for loan.
The defendant No. 1 applied education loan for ‘
Master of
Dental Surgery’. He is a well educated person. It cannot be
believed that the bank obtained signatures of the defendant No. 2
and 3 on so many documents spanning over a long period under
influence. Moreover, there is no complaint filed by the defendant
No. 2 and 3 that bank officials obtained their signatures under
influence without explaining legal implication of the documents.
The contention raised by the defendants is without merit.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 21 of 27
-- 21 of 27 --
59. The defendant No. 2 and 3 are co-borrowers and their
liability is joint and several with the defendant No. 1.
60. The suit is not bad for mis-joinder of the parties.
61. Accordingly, issue No. 5 is decided in favour of the
plaintiff and against the defendants.
ISSUE NO. 6:
(6) Whether the plaintiff made unilateral
modification in the identity of the account holder and
wrongly reflected the account as jointly held by the
defendant No. 1 to 3?
(OPD)
62. As regards contention regarding post-amalgamation
unilateral modification in the status of loan account by the
plaintiff from ‘
individual account’ to ‘
joint account’, it can be
stated that it would not have any affect on liability of the
defendants. It does not stand to reason as to how the liability of
the defendants can be affected by referring loan account as ‘
joint
account’ instead of an ‘
individual account’. Loan account
number of loan advanced to the defendants would remain same.
63. Accordingly, issue No. 6 is decided in favour of the
plaintiff and against the defendants.
ISSUE NO. 7:
(7) Whether the plaintiff suppressed part payments /
installments of Rs. 1,29,000/- and credit of Rs.
2,76,022.52/- into the loan account?
(OPD)
64. This issue has already been decided in favour of the
plaintiff and against the defendants while discussing issue No. 4.
ISSUE NO. 8:
(8) Whether the plaintiff withheld copy of Income
Certificate dated 04.09.2019, if so, its effect?
(OPD)
65. There is no merit in the contention that the plaintiff
withheld original Income Certificate dated 04.09.2019.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 22 of 27
-- 22 of 27 --
66. A perusal of income certificate dated 04.09.2019
Ex.PW1/J would show that the said certificate is bearing seal of
Oriental Bank of Commerce. Merely the plaintiff affixed its seal
at the time of filing of the suit would not by itself give rise to an
inference that the plaintiff has misrepresented that the defendant
No. 2 submitted income certificate to it and not to Oriental Bank
of Commerce.
67. Accordingly, issue No. 8 is decided in favour of the
plaintiff and against the defendants.
ISSUE NO. 9:
(9) Whether the loan account was wrongly classified
as ‘
Non Performing Asset’ (NPA)?
(OPD)
68. As regards contention that the plaintiff wrongly classified
loan account as ‘
Non Performing Asset’ (NPA) and the plaintiff
neither intimated classification of loan account as ‘
Non
Performing Asset’ (NPA) nor proved service of loan recall
notice, it can be stated that a perusal of statement of loan account
Ex.PW1/L would show that loan account of the defendants more
or less remained above Rs. 5,00,000/- since 30.11.2021 and the
defendants were irregular in making payment of interest or
repayment of loan. The account was more and less dormant and
therefore, the plaintiff rightly classified the loan account as ‘
Non
Performing Asset’ (NPA) on 30.08.2023.
69. Moreover, loan recall notice is served upon the borrower
so as to put him / her on notice about status of loan account and
regularize the loan account.
70. There is no proposition of law that service of loan recall
notice is mandatory and in absence of proof thereof, the suit is
considered as without cause of action and premature.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 23 of 27
-- 23 of 27 --
71. In
M/s. ICICI Bank Ltd. vs. Kamini Sharma and Another,
2018 SCC OnLine Del 6933, Hon’ble High Court of Delhi while
dealing with an appeal arising out of dismissal of suit on account
of failure of the plaintiff to file original loan recall notice held, as
under:
“13…..The Plaintiff bank could have maintained the
suit for recovery even in the absence of the loan
recall notice so long as the disbursement of loan and
availing of the same is admitted. In this case, all the
loan documents in original are placed on record. The
loan recall notice is merely a document which takes
away the luxury of payments in instalments granted
to the Defendants and nothing more. The fact that the
Defendants have defaulted in making the payments,
does not in any manner depend upon the existence of
the loan recall notice. The Defendants, after service
of the said notice, cannot avail of the facility of
paying through instalments and have to make the
entire payment at one go. The Plaintiff bank could
have very well filed the suit for recovery when the
Defendants defaulted on making the payments. The
loan recall notice merely gives closure to the entire
transaction and nothing more.”
72. In
M/s. ICICI Bank Ltd. vs. Dilkash Star Vision &
Communication Pvt. Ltd. And Others, 2018 SCC OnLine Del
9542, Hon’ble High Court of Delhi held, as under:
“10. The Trial Court has also erred by holding that
the service of the recall notice has not been proved.
The same has been sent by Speed Post AD which is
sufficient service. The bank cold have made the effort
to check the Tracking report and file the same with
its evidence, which it has not done. However, that by
itself does not mean that the overdraft facility has not
been availed of and the outstanding is not payable.”
73. In this case, the plaintiff sent loan recall notice Ex.PW1/M
to the defendants,
through speed post, to their correct addresses,
as mentioned in loan application Ex.PW1/C. It is not the case of
the defendants that they had informed their latest addresses to the
plaintiff.
74. Accordingly, issue No. 9 is decided in favour of the
plaintiff and against the defendants.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 24 of 27
-- 24 of 27 --
ISSUE NO. 10:
(10) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree for
recovery of Rs. 5,49,585/-, as prayed?
(OPP)
75. Therefore, the plaintiff proved that Oriental Bank of
Commerce had advanced a loan amount of Rs. 4,00,000/- to the
defendants,
vide sanction letter Ex.PW1/D. The defendants duly
availed the said loan. However, they neither regularized loan
account nor cleared the amount due against them.
76. As regards contention that there is unexplained delay of 17
months in institution of the suit from the date of classification of
loan account as ‘
Non Performing Asset’ (NPA), it can be stated
that the defendants allowed interest component of loan amount
accrued to loan account. The defendants could have cleared the
loan account in time. At one stage, the defendants did not clear
the loan account. At another stage, the defendants are
complaining that the plaintiff instituted the suit after 17 months
from classification of loan account as ‘
Non Performing Asset’.
77. Precisely, this issue was answered by Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India in a Five-Judge Bench judgment in
Central Bank
of India vs. Ravindra & Ors., (2002) 1 SCC 367, as under:
“46. … Firstly, the bank can afford to wait or delay
the filing of the suit only during the period of
limitation which delay would not be illegitimate.
Secondly, noting prevents the debtor, even during the
period of this delay, to pay or tender the amount of
interest as and when it falls due and thereby prevent
its capitalisation. ...”
78. According to statement of loan account Ex.PW1/L, the suit
amount of Rs. 5,49,585.69/- is comprising two components.
First, principal amount of Rs. 4,79,112.60/- due against the
defendants, as on 24.09.2024.
Second, accrued interest in the
sum of Rs. 70,473.09/- w.e.f. 01.09.2023 to 24.09.2024. The
plaintiff is entitled to a decree for recovery of Rs. 5,49,585/-.
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 25 of 27
-- 25 of 27 --
79. Accordingly, issue No. 10 is decided in favour of the
plaintiff and against the defendants.
ISSUE NO. 11:
(11) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to
pendente-lite
and future interest @ 10.45% per annum with
monthly rest and penal interest @ 2% per annum?
(OPP)
80. Grant of
pendente-
lite and future interest is within
discretion of the Court. The plaintiff is claiming
pendente-lite
and future interest @ 10.45% per annum with monthly rests and
penal interest @ 2% per annum against the said loan account.
The rate of interest claimed by the plaintiff is on higher side. In
view of the nature of loan and current bank rate of interest, the
plaintiff is awarded interest @ 9% per annum. Accordingly, issue
No. 11 is decided in favour of the plaintiff and against the
defendants.
R E L I E F
81. Therefore, the suit of the plaintiff is decreed with costs and
a decree in the sum of Rs. 5,49,585/- alongwith
pendente-lite and
future interest @ 9% per annum is passed in favour of the
plaintiff and against the defendants. Decree sheet be drawn. File
be consigned to record room.
Announced in the open Court SANJAY SHARMA-II
on this 23rd December, 2025 DJ (Commercial Court)-03 (Shahdara)
Karkardooma Courts, Delhi
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 26 of 27
-- 26 of 27 --
Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors.
CNR No.: DLSH01-007449-2024
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024
23.12.2025
Present : Ms. Jyoti Gautam, Ld. Counsel with Mr. Alok
Maina, Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff (
through Video
Conferencing).
Mr. Rajkumar, Ld. Counsel with Mr. Akash
Kashyap and Ms. Nidhi Narula, Ld. Counsel for the
defendant No. 1.
Mr. Zuber Salmani, Ld. Counsel with Ms. Gulshan
and Ms. Aanchal, Ld. Counsel for the defendant No.
2 and 3.
Vide separate judgment, the suit of the plaintiff is
decreed with costs and a decree in the sum of Rs.
5,49,585/- alongwith
pendente-lite and future
interest @ 9% per annum is passed in favour of the
plaintiff and against the defendants. Decree sheet be
drawn. File be consigned to record room.
Sanjay Sharma-II
DJ (Commercial Court)-03
Shahdara, KKD, Delhi
23.12.2025
CS (Comm.) No. 617/2024 Punjab National Bank vs. Raees Salmani & Ors. Page No. 27 of 27
-- 27 of 27 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.