Skip to main content
Court Order

Order 6

CNR DLSH01007236202424 Jul 2025
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Order 6 · 24 Jul 2025 · CNR DLSH010072362024

Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS
Pdf Text: 4 MACT 2546/24
GUDDI MATHUR AND ORS. Vs. SACHIN KUMAR AND ORS.
24.07.2025
Present: Sh. Upender Singh, Ld. Counsel for petitioner.
R1 already ex parte.
None for R2.
Sh. Ankit Kalra, Ld. Counsel for R3 i.e. insurance company.
Heard. Perused.
Arguments on application under Section XI read with Section 151 CPC filed on
behalf of R3 on the last date of hearing heard.
File perused.
It is the contention on behalf of R3 that the petitioners had previously filed two
claim petitions regarding the same cause of action before different Tribunals and the same came to
withdrawn by the petitioner in due course. Hence, the present claim petition is barred by
res judicata.
Herein, it is pertinent to note that the petitioners have previously filed two different
claim petitions before two different Tribunal regarding the same cause of action. However, it is a
matter of record that both the said petitions have been withdrawn by the petitioners with liberty to file
afresh. Both those petitions have thereafter been allowed to be withdrawn by the respective Tribunals
with liberty as prayed by the petitioners.
As far as the present claim petition is concerned, it is apparent that the previous
petition between the same parties litigating under the same title has not been heard and finally
decided. Hence, the bar of
res-judicata is not applicable in the present claim petition.
Therefore, the application at hand is hereby dismissed being devoid of merits.
Meanwhile, pleadings of the parties are complete on record. On the basis of pleadings of the
parties, following issues are hereby framed as under:
(i) Whether the claim petition is barred by limitation or not ? OPR
(ii) Whether deceased namely Soran Singh died on account of injuries sustained in
accident having taken place on 30.10.2022 at about 09:00 am near HP Gas Godam, Chakkar Road,
Bijnor, within the jurisdiction of PS Kotwali Shahar, Distt. Bijnor, U.P. due to rash and negligent
driving of driver of vehicle no. UP-20AZ-4901 by respondent no. 1 ? OPP
(iii) Whether petitioners are entitled to compensation, if so to what amount and from
whom? OPP.
(iv) Relief.
Be put up for PE on 11.09.2025.
Petitioner is hereby directed to furnish advance copy of evidence by way of affidavit of the
proposed witnesses to the respondents atleast 15 days prior to the NDOH either against receipt or by
placing the same on judicial file under intimation to the respondents to be collected by the parties as
per their respective convenience.
(HARUN PRATAP)
PO-MACT-02/SHD/KKD
24.07.2025
-- 1 of 1 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.