Full Order Text
Final Order 21 · 11 Apr 2026 · CNR DLSH010072342023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF MS. CHARU AGGARWAL: ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE-02; E COURT: SHAHDARA: KARKARDOOMA COURT: DELHI. Crl. (R) No. 342/2023 1. Jasbir Singh S/o Late Sh. Darshan Singh R/o H. No. WZ-308, Gali no.1, Gurunanak Nangar, Tilak Nagar, Delhi. 2. Smt. Kulwant Kaur @ Kulvinder Kaur w/o Sh. Jasbir Singh r/o H. No. WZ-308, Gali no.1, Gurunanak Nangar, Tilak Nagar, Delhi. 3. Harpreet Kaur w/o Sh. Sukhvinder Singh r/o G-82, 3rd floor, street no.7, near DEN Montu Sah Cable, Sant Nagar Extension, Tilak Nagar, Delhi. 4. Rashmeet Kaur w/o Karanjeet Singh r/o H. No. 68, 69, 71, first floor, Om Vihar, Phase III, Uttam Nagar, D.K. Mohan Garden, New Delhi-110059. …........…. Revisionist. Versus 1. State (NCT of Delhi. 2. Gurvinder Kaur w/o Harvinder Singh r/o H. No. 26A, Gali no.4, Cr. Rev. No. 342/2023 Jasbir Singh Vs. State and anr. Page No. 1/18 -- 1 of 18 -- Rashid Market, Jagatpuri Delhi-110051. …………. Respondents. Date of filing : 20.11.2023 Date of arguments : 01.04.2026 Date of order : 11.04.2026 O R D E R 1. The present revision petition under Sections 397/399 Cr.P.C. along with an application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act has been filed by the revisionists (four in number), assailing the orders dated 19.04.2023 and 15.07.2023 passed by the Learned Metropolitan Magistrate (Mahila Court-01), District Shahdara in FIR No. 83/2019 under Sections 498A/406/34 IPC P.S. Jagat Puri registered at the instance of complainant Gurvinder Kaur against revisionists and her husband Harvinder Singh. 2. Revisionist nos. 1 and 2 are the parents-in-law (father- in-law and mother-in-law), while revisionist nos. 3 and 4 are sisters-in-law (nanad) of respondent no.2/complainant Gurvinder Kaur. 3. By order dated 19.04.2023, all the revisionists and also the husband of complainant were directed to be charged for offences under Section 498A/34 IPC, while being discharged from the offence under Section 406/34 IPC. Subsequently, vide order dated 15.07.2023, charges under Section 498A/34 IPC were formally framed against all of them by the Learned Trial Court. These orders have not been Cr. Rev. No. 342/2023 Jasbir Singh Vs. State and anr. Page No. 2/18 -- 2 of 18 -- challenged by the husband Harvinder Singh of the complainant. 4. I shall first take up the application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act. It is stated in the application that prior to filing the present revision, the revisionists had preferred Criminal Revision No. 2776/2023 within the prescribed period of limitation, challenging only the order dated 15.07.2023 whereby charges were formally framed against them. At that stage, they were under the impression that the order dated 15.07.2023 was the final order on charge, as it bore their signatures. Subsequently, they realized that the detailed order dated 19.04.2023 was in fact the substantive order on charge which also required challenge. Accordingly, they withdrew the earlier revision with liberty granted by the Ld. ASJ to file a fresh revision assailing both orders. The said revision was dismissed as withdrawn by the Ld. ASJ vide order dated 03.11.2023. Thereafter, in November itself, the present revision was filed. Learned counsel for the revisionists has argued that since the earlier revision was filed within limitation and the present revision was instituted within about 15 days of withdrawal, the delay is bona fide and deserves to be condoned. 5. On the other hand, the Ld. Addl. PP and counsel for respondent no.2, Gurvinder Kaur, have strongly opposed the application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act. They contend that once a revision petition has been withdrawn, the same cannot be re-agitated afresh on identical grounds. Withdrawal amounts to abandonment of the challenge, and Cr. Rev. No. 342/2023 Jasbir Singh Vs. State and anr. Page No. 3/18 -- 3 of 18 -- permitting a fresh revision would defeat the principle of finality in judicial proceedings. They further submit that the plea of “bona fide mistake” is untenable, as the revisionists were represented by counsel and ought to have been aware that the detailed order dated 19.04.2023 was the operative order on charge. According to them, the present revision is nothing but an attempt to circumvent limitation by re-filing on the same grounds, and therefore no sufficient cause is made out for condonation of delay. 6. Arguments considered. 7. It is undisputed that the earlier revision petition bearing Criminal Revision No. 2776/2023 filed by the revisionists was dismissed as withdrawn vide order dated 03.11.2023 passed by the then Ld. ASJ. A perusal of the said order reveals that the withdrawal was occasioned due to a technical defect, and liberty was expressly granted to the revisionists to file a fresh petition. The explanation about the said technical ground furnished by the revisionists in the present application is that the earlier challenge was confined to the order dated 15.07.2023 whereby charges were formally framed, but had inadvertently omitted to assail the detailed order on charge dated 19.04.2023 under a mistaken impression, and upon realizing that the detailed order dated 19.04.2023 was the substantive order, they sought to challenge both. The explanation put forth by the revisionists is found to be satisfactory. Cr. Rev. No. 342/2023 Jasbir Singh Vs. State and anr. Page No. 4/18 -- 4 of 18 -- Furthermore, it is also not in dispute that the earlier revision petition was filed by the revisionists within the prescribed period of limitation and the present revision was instituted within about two weeks of withdrawal of the earlier petition. The order dated 03.11.2023 passed by the then Ld. ASJ (Shahdara) makes it clear that the earlier revision was not adjudicated on merits but was withdrawn on technical grounds. 8. In the totality of circumstances, it is evident that the earlier revision was withdrawn on technical grounds, without adjudication on merits and the revisionists have satisfactorily explained the cause for the delay in filing the instant petition. The explanation appears bona fide and not a device to protract proceedings. 9. The objection of the prosecution that withdrawal amounts to abandonment is noted. However, in the present case, the withdrawal was not unconditional; it was accompanied by liberty granted by the Ld. ASJ to file afresh. Once such liberty has been granted, the revisionists cannot be deprived of their right to challenge both orders on merits. The principle of finality of proceedings does not override the statutory discretion vested in the Court under Section 5 of the Limitation Act to condone delay where sufficient cause is shown. 10. In view of the above discussion, the court is satisfied that sufficient cause having been shown by the revisionists to file the instant revision beyond the period of limitation, accordingly , the delay in filing the present revision petition Cr. Rev. No. 342/2023 Jasbir Singh Vs. State and anr. Page No. 5/18 -- 5 of 18 -- is hereby condoned. The application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act stands allowed. 11. Reverting to the merits of the revision: the FIR in the present case was registered on the complaint of respondent no. 2, Gurvinder Kaur, dated 03.12.2018, lodged at the Crime Against Women (CAW) Cell, Patparganj, Delhi. In her complaint, she levelled allegations of harassment and cruelty against her husband, Harvinder Singh, and her in- laws (the revisionists) on account of dowery demand. 12. After completion of investigation, chargesheet under Section 498A/406/34 IPC was filed before Ld. Trial court, after taking cognizance, husband of Gurvinder Kaur and her in-laws (revisionists) were summoned by the Ld. trial court. 13. Vide impugned orders dated 19.04.2023 and 15.07.2023, the Gurvinder Kaur’s husband and revisionists were charged for the offence under Section 498A IPC. Being aggrieved by the said order, revisionists have filed the instant revision on the following grounds:- the impugned order is based on surmises and conjectures and is erroneous on facts as well as on law; submissions of the revisionists were not considered; Gurvinder Kaur has led peaceful and happy married life for long 9 years with Harvinder Singh without any complaint by her either against her husband and other inlaws; she is habitual complainant who has filed several complaints against them on 20.03.2018, 11.07.2018, 16.11.2018 and 07.03.2019; Cr. Rev. No. 342/2023 Jasbir Singh Vs. State and anr. Page No. 6/18 -- 6 of 18 -- her complaint is vague; there is no medical document on record to support her allegations; during her cross examination in DV Act, she took contradictory stands as at one place, she stated that that she wants to live with her husband, then said that she does not want to live with him, thereafter she said that she can live with her inlaws but with her husband despite levelling serious allegations against her father- in-law; Ld. Trial court did not consider that complainant was pressing her husband to live separate from her parents; there are no allegations against revisionists no.3 and 4 who both are married and happily living their matrimonial life; family of complainant is in the habit of filing complaints; her brother namely Gurmeet Singh is already divorced; the impugned order has been passed in mechanical manner. 14. Learned counsel for the revisionist has argued that at the stage of framing of charge, there must be prima facie material on record to proceed against the accused persons for the alleged offences; however, in the present case, the chargesheet does not make out any offence whatsoever. He submitted that neither complainant's prime complaint nor the statements of the witnesses recorded under Section 161 Cr. PC disclose the commission of any criminal offence by any Cr. Rev. No. 342/2023 Jasbir Singh Vs. State and anr. Page No. 7/18 -- 7 of 18 -- of the revisionists. It was argued thar bare perusal of the chargesheet reveals no allegation of dowry demand or cruelty upon complainant to such an extent as to drive her to commit suicide or cause grievous injury to herself. According to the learned counsel, every allegation in the chargesheet is vague and general without any specification and no criminality can be attributed on the basis of such allegations, therefore, the learned counsel urged that material is not sufficient to frame charges against the revisionists, hence he prayed to set-aside the impugned order. 15. Addl. PP duly assisted by Ld. counsel for respondent no.2 has argued that material on record clearly makes out the prima facie case against the revisionists, hence they argued in favor of impugned order. 16. I have considered the arguments of Ld. counsel for revisionists, Ld. Addl. PP and Ld. counsel for respondent no.2. Entire record perused. 17. The order assailed in the present revision is against the framing of charge, therefore, the settled proposition of law is required to be discussed at first place. It is a settled position of law that for framing a charge not only suspicion but grave suspicion is required. The purpose of framing a charge is to intimate to the accused the clear, unambiguous and precise nature of accusation that the accused is called upon to meet in the course of a trial as observed in V.C. Shukla V State through C.B.I., 1980 Supp SCC 92. The prosecution is required to establish a prima facie case before a charge can be framed. The Supreme Cr. Rev. No. 342/2023 Jasbir Singh Vs. State and anr. Page No. 8/18 -- 8 of 18 -- Court in Union of India V Prafulla Kumar Samal & another, (1979) 3 SCC 4 considered scope of inquiry at the stage of framing of charge as per Section 227 of the Code in Sessions criminal trial and observed as under: - “10(1) That the Judge while considering the question of framing the charges under Section 227 of the Code has the undoubted power to sift and weigh the evidence for the limited purpose of finding out whether or not a prima facie case against the accused has been made out. 10(2) Where the materials placed before the Court disclose grave suspicion against the accused which has not been properly explained the Court will be, fully justified in framing a charge and proceeding with the trial. 10(3) The test to determine a prima facie case would naturally depend upon the facts of each case and it is difficult to lay down a rule of universal application. By and large however if two views are equally possible and the Judge is satisfied that the evidence produced before him while giving rise to some suspicion but not grave suspicion against the accused, he will be fully within his right to discharge the accused. 10(4) That in exercising his jurisdiction under Section 227 of the Code the Judge which under the present Code is a senior and experienced Judge cannot act merely as a Post office or a mouthpiece of the prosecution, but has to consider the broad probabilities of the case, the total effect of the evidence and the documents produced before the Court, any basic infirmities appearing in the case and so on. This however does not mean that the Judge should make a roving enquiry into the pros and cons of the matter and weigh the evidence as if he was conducting a trial.” 18. Here, admittedly Gurvinder Kaur was married Harvinder Singh in 2009, and the couple was blessed with two sons. Owing to marital discord, they initially separated in March 2018. Although their disputes were subsequently Cr. Rev. No. 342/2023 Jasbir Singh Vs. State and anr. Page No. 9/18 -- 9 of 18 -- resolved and they resumed cohabitation, the reconciliation did not last, and they finally separated in May 2018. Thereafter, on the complaint filed by Gurvinder Kaur before the CAW Cell, the FIR in the present case was registered. 19. In order to examine whether prima facie charges under Section 498A IPC are made out against the revisionists, the complaint dated 03.12.2018 filed by Gurvinder Kaur, along with the statements recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. during investigation, are relevant for consideration. At this stage, it is pertinent to note that during investigation, the supplementary statement of Gurvinder Kaur was recorded, as well as the statements under Section 161 Cr.P.C. of her mother and two brothers. The statements of Gurvinder Kaur’s mother and brothers are consistent with her complaint dated 03.12.2018. 20. Gurvinder Kaur has filed three complaints dated 20.03.2018, 11.07.2018 and 03.12.2018 in CAW Cell, Patparganj, Delhi perusal of which shows that contents of all her complaints are identical. FIR has been registered on her complaint dated 03.12.2018. The allegations levelled by Gurvinder Kaur in her said complaint dated 03.12.2018 and also in other complaints against the revisionists are summarized as under: (i) That she was married to accused Harvinder Singh on 03.01.2009, and from the said wedlock, two sons were born; That soon after the marriage, the accused persons began taunting her for bringing insufficient dowry; (ii) That her husband Harvinder Singh was a habitual Cr. Rev. No. 342/2023 Jasbir Singh Vs. State and anr. Page No. 10/18 -- 10 of 18 -- drinker, used to watch pornographic movies even prior to marriage, and thereafter compelled her to engage in unnatural sexual acts, and upon her refusal, subjected her to abuse and physical assault; (iii) That her father-in-law cast an evil eye upon her and attempted to establish physical relations with her, and when she disclosed this to her mother-in-law, the latter supported him, stating that he too was a man of the family and hence there was no harm; (iv) That the accused persons compelled her to undergo abortions on several occasions, particularly in December 2017 and January 2018, causing her severe physical and mental trauma; (v) That on 20.03.2018, the accused persons ousted her and her elder son (then aged 8 years) from the matrimonial home, retaining all her stridhan. At that time, she lodged a written complaint at the CAW Cell, which was later kept pending at her request; (vi) That on 13.04.2018, the disputes were amicably settled and she resumed cohabitation with her husband, but the conduct of the accused persons did not change; instead, they intensified the cruelty and harassment; (vii) That on 25.04.2018, the accused persons threatened to kill her and forcibly obtained her signatures on eight cheques; (vii) That on 22.05.2018, all accused persons again expelled her and her children from the matrimonial house; (viii) That on 21.06.2018, the accused persons trespassed Cr. Rev. No. 342/2023 Jasbir Singh Vs. State and anr. Page No. 11/18 -- 11 of 18 -- into her parental home and attacked her and her parents with bricks and stones, in respect of which a PCR call was made vide DD No. 49B, though no police action ensued; (ix) That the accused persons attempted to kidnap her children, regarding which she lodged a complaint at P.S. Jagat Puri on 16.11.2018 vide DD No. 17B; (x) That on 03.12.2018, her husband and mother-in-law abused her outside Court No. 22 at Karkardooma Courts. 21. As per section 498A IPC, cruelty means any conduct which is of such a nature as is likely to drive a woman to commit suicide or cause grave injury or death to life or harassment with a view to coerce her or any person related to her to meet any unlawful demand for any dowry or valuable security. The cruelty under this provision can be either physical, mental or both. It is also settled law that dowery demand is not essential to attract this offence. 22. The Hon’ble superior courts in catena of judgments have observed that tendency has developed that in dowry demand cases the entire family of husband even his distinct relatives are roped into without there being any specific allegations against them, therefore courts are expected to be more careful while dealing with husband’s other family members especially, distinct relatives. Reference be made to Digamber and others VS. State of Maharashtra, SLP No. (criminal) 2122/2020 decided by Hon’ble Apex court on 20/12/2024, relevant portion is reproduced as under:- “ A mere reference to the names of family members in a criminal case arising out of a matrimonial dispute, without specific allegations Cr. Rev. No. 342/2023 Jasbir Singh Vs. State and anr. Page No. 12/18 -- 12 of 18 -- indicating their active involvement should be nipped in the bud. It is a well-recognized fact, borne out of judicial experience, that there is often a tendency to implicate all the members of the husband’s family when domestic disputes arise out of a matrimonial discord. Such generalized and sweeping accusations unsupported by concrete evidence or particularized allegations cannot form the basis for criminal prosecution. Courts must exercise caution in such cases to prevent misuse of legal provisions and the legal process and avoid unnecessary harassment of innocent family members. In the present case, appellant Nos.2 to 6, who are the members of the family of appellant No.1 have been living in different cities and have not resided in the matrimonial house of appellant No.1 and respondent No.2 herein. Hence, they cannot be dragged into criminal prosecution and the same would be an abuse of the process of the law in the absence of specific allegations made against each of them.” Hon’ble Apex Court in Payal Sharma v. State of Punjab 2024 SCC ONLINE SC, while relying upon the cases of ‘ Geeta Mehrotra v. State of U.P. : (2012) 10 SCC 741 and Kahkashan Kausar v. State of Bihar : (2022) 6 SCC 599’ had noted as under: “In the decision in Geeta Mehrotra v. State of U.P., this Court held that mere casual reference of the names of the family members in a matrimonial dispute without allegation of active involvement in the matter would not justify taking cognizance against them overlooking the tendency of over implication viz., to draw the entire members of the household in the domestic quarrel resulting in matrimonial dispute, especially when it happens soon after the wedding. In the decision in Kahkashan Kausar @ Sonam v. State of Bihar, this Court quashed proceedings in so far as family members of the husband on the ground that the allegations against them are general and ominous in nature. In matters like the one at hand when relatives not residing in the same house where the alleged Cr. Rev. No. 342/2023 Jasbir Singh Vs. State and anr. Page No. 13/18 -- 13 of 18 -- victim resides, the courts shall not stop consideration by merely looking into the question where the accused is a person falling within the ambit of the expression ‘relative’ for the purpose of Section 498- A, IPC, but should also consider whether it is a case of over implication or exaggerated version solely to implicate such person(s) to pressurise the main accused. It is also relevant to refer to the decision of this Court in State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal, wherein after considering the statutory provisions and the earlier decisions, this Court referred to various categories of cases where the inherent powers under Section 482, Cr. P.C. could be exercised by High Court to prevent abuse of process of Court or otherwise to secure ends of justice. One among such categories is where the allegations made in the FIR or complaint are so absurd and inherently improbable on the basis of which no prudent man could ever reach a just conclusion that there is sufficient ground for proceeding against an accused.” 23. The Ld. trial court has framed the charge under Section 498A IPC against the revisionists observing that there are specific allegations against the revisionists in the chargesheet, however, the said observation is contrary to the record since a bare perusal of the complaint dated 03.12.2018 and the statements recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. of the witnesses contains only bald and omnibus allegations against the revisionists that after a few days of Gurvinder Kaur’s marriage, the accused persons (revisionists) started taunting her for bringing less dowry. However, no specific incident, date, time, or month has been mentioned in relation to these allegations. The complaint does not assign any specific role to the individual accused persons. It does not state how each accused allegedly harassed her, what exact words were used, or what precise acts were committed. It is also pertinent to mention that Cr. Rev. No. 342/2023 Jasbir Singh Vs. State and anr. Page No. 14/18 -- 14 of 18 -- during the course of arguments, the court was informed that revisionist no.3 Harpreet Kaur ( Nanad of complainant Gurvinder Kaur ) was already married prior to the marriage of Gurvinder Kaur with Harvinder Singh and she was leading a happy married life with her husband, which is not disputed by the complainant side as well. Complainant has not whispered even a single word as to when Harpreet Kaur (revisionist no.3) visited her parental home and committed attrocity upon complainant, as alleged. The allegations in the charge-sheet against all the revisionists are vague, sweeping, and general in nature, which cannot form the basis of framing charge. The entire complaint appears to be a reiteration of the statutory language of Section 498A IPC, using terms like “harassment” and “cruelty” without narrating specific instances. Courts have consistently held that such evasive and omnibus allegations, made without supporting particulars, cannot be the foundation for criminal prosecution. 24. The complainant has levelled serious allegations that the revisionists forcibly got her abortion. However, no medical record, prescription, or hospital document has been produced to substantiate the claim of abortion. In the absence of such material, the allegation remains uncorroborated. 25. The complainant has alleged that her father-in-law attempted to establish physical relations with her and that her mother-in-law condoned such conduct. This is indeed a grave and serious allegation. However, upon careful Cr. Rev. No. 342/2023 Jasbir Singh Vs. State and anr. Page No. 15/18 -- 15 of 18 -- scrutiny, the Court finds that the allegation is wholly devoid of particulars. The complainant has not specified the date, month, year, or even the circumstances under which such an incident allegedly occurred. 26. It is not plausible that a woman, if subjected to such a traumatic and significant incident, would fail to recall and narrate the specific details of the occurrence. Allegations of sexual misconduct or attempts to establish physical relations are of such gravity that they ordinarily leave a lasting impression on the victim’s memory. The absence of any particulars, such as the place of occurrence, the time of day, or the sequence of events casts serious doubt on the veracity of the allegation. Furthermore, no contemporaneous complaint was lodged by the complainant at the time of the alleged incident. Courts have consistently held that vague and unsubstantiated allegations, particularly of such serious nature, cannot form the basis for framing charge. 27. The complainant has further alleged that the revisionists attempted to kidnap her children from school, for which she claims to have lodged a police complaint vide DD entry. While the said complaint is on record, even a bare perusal of it reveals that it lacks essential particulars. No specific date, time, or circumstances of the alleged incident have been mentioned. 28. Kidnapping of children is a grave allegation, and if such an incident had truly occurred, it is expected that the complainant would have provided precise details such as the date and time of occurrence and the manner in which the Cr. Rev. No. 342/2023 Jasbir Singh Vs. State and anr. Page No. 16/18 -- 16 of 18 -- attempt was made. It is not plausible that a mother, alleging an attempt to kidnap her own children, would fail to recall and narrate such critical particulars. The absence of these details renders the allegation vague and unreliable. 29. Moreover, the complaint does not disclose whether any independent witness, such as school staff, other parents, or bystanders, observed the alleged attempt. Nor does it indicate any immediate police action or investigation based on the DD entry. In the absence of corroboration or contemporaneous evidence, the allegation remains a bare assertion. 30. In the present case, the allegations against the revisionists are general in nature, lacking in particulars, vague, bald and omnibus. Thus, no grave suspicion arises against the revisionists warranting framing of charge against them. The material on record is insufficient to proceed under Section 498A/34 IPC or any allied provisions. 31. In view of above discussion, the impugned orders dated 19.04.2023 and 15.07.2023 are hereby set aside. Present revision is allowed, consequently, all the revisionists are hereby discharged for the offences under Section 498A/34 IPC, as no prima facie case is made out against them. Revisionists Jasbir Singh, Kulwant Kaur, Harpreet Kaur, and Rashmeet Kaur are directed to furnish bond under Section 437-A Cr. PC (New Section: 481 BNSS) for a period of six months in the sum of Rs.20,000/- with one surety each in the like amount before Ld. Trial court within a week. Trial Court record be sent back along with a copy of Cr. Rev. No. 342/2023 Jasbir Singh Vs. State and anr. Page No. 17/18 -- 17 of 18 -- this order. Revision file be consigned to Record Room. Announced in the open (Charu Aggarwal) Court on 11.04.2026. ASJ-02/E-Court/Shahdara KKD Court, Delhi. Cr. Rev. No. 342/2023 Jasbir Singh Vs. State and anr. Page No. 18/18 -- 18 of 18 --
