Full Order Text
Final Order 4 · 09 Jan 2024 · CNR DLSH010071432023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS no. 838/23 Manmohan Singh Vs. Rakesh Kumar IN THE COURT OF SH. ANKUR JAIN - II, ADJ-02, SHAHDARA DISTRICT, KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI CS No. 838/23 Manmohan Singh S/o Lt. Sh. Vasudev R/o House no.1/2115 East Ram Nagar Shahdara, Delhi-32. ….. Plaintiff Versus Rakesh Kumar S/o Sh. Harish Chandra R/o House no. B-1/1, DLF, Bhopura, Ghaziabad, UP. ….. Defendant O R D E R:- 1. The plaintiff has filed the present suit under Order XXXVII CPC for recovery of Rs. 5 lacs along with interest @ 18% per annum, future and pendentelite interest. Brief facts:- 2. That on 16.08.2013, defendant and the plaintiff agreed upon a collaboration agreement in respect of property bearing no. 1/2459, Bloc area 90 sq. yards, Khasra no. 834/113, Village Chandawal Abadi, Gali no. 24, Ram Nagar, Modern Shahdra, Delhi-32; that the condition of the Page 1 of 4 -- 1 of 4 -- CS no. 838/23 Manmohan Singh Vs. Rakesh Kumar said agreement is that the defendant will construct the suit plot or land after getting consultation from the family for consideration amount of Rs. 21,50,000/-; that as per the agreement, the defendant has received Rs. 4,50,000/- by way of cheque and Rs. 2,50,000/- in cash and the remaining amount of Rs. 14,50,000/- will be given after construction of 5th floor, defendant will receive Rs. 7 lacs and after the complete construction along with the renovation, the defendant will get Rs. 7,50,000/-; that it was in the agreement that on 20.08.2013, the defendant will give the possession of the land as per the terms of the agreement, period of limitation of complete construction will be one year; that as per the agreement, the plaintiff paid the complete amount, but the defendant left the constructed area without doing complete construction work; that as per the agreement, lift was not installed, construction of main gate was not done and electricity and light fitting was not done on ceiling area and balcony. Hence, this suit. 3. Arguments were addressed on the point of maintainability of the present suit. 4. At the very outset, it is apposite to mention that the present summary suit for recovery of Rs. 5 lacs along with interest @ 18% p.a. on the basis of agreement to sell between the parties on 16.08.2013 is not maintainable under the Page 2 of 4 -- 2 of 4 -- CS no. 838/23 Manmohan Singh Vs. Rakesh Kumar provisions of Order XXXVII CPC. The present suit is liable to be rejected on this ground alone. 5. Perusal of Para-3 of the plaint, also shows apparent contradictions between the terms of agreement dated 16.08.2013 and the averments mentioned by the plaintiff in the plain. As per the copy of the agreement dated 16.08.2013, filed by the plaintiff along with plaint, it shows that it is the defendant who has paid the amount of Rs. 7 lacs to the plaintiff which is also supported by a copy of cheque bearing no. 000025 dated 25.08.2013 issued by defendant in name of plaintiff for an amount of Rs. 4,50,000/-; where as in para-3 of plaint, plaintiff has mentioned that it is the defendant who had received the said amount of Rs.7 lacs out of which Rs. 4,50,000/- was received through cheque and Rs. 2,50,000/- in cash by the defendant. 6. Further, in Para-13 of the plaint, plaintiff has mentioned that the cause of action to file the present suit arose on 16.08.2013 and that it further arose on 20.08.2013 and the defendant was to complete the construction work within one year there from. It is pertinent to mention here that the present suit was filed by plaintiff on 10.11.2023 i.e. after 10 years when the cause of action arose, as above. It is further pertinent to mention here that serving of legal notice on 21.09.2022 upon the defendant does not give any Page 3 of 4 -- 3 of 4 -- CS no. 838/23 Manmohan Singh Vs. Rakesh Kumar cause of action to the plaintiff to file the present suit for recovery of amount pursuant to agreement dated 16.08.2013 between parties which was to be acted upon within one year therefrom. Hence, the present plaint is also liable to be rejected on the grounds of being barred by limitation under Order 7 Rule 11 ( d ) CPC. 7. No order as to the costs. 8. File be consigned to record room, after due compliance. Announced in the Open Court on this 9th day of January, 2024. (ANKUR JAIN-II) ADDITIONAL DISTRICT JUDGE –02, SHAHDARA, KKD COURTS, DELHI Page 4 of 4 -- 4 of 4 --
