Full Order Text
Interim Order 5 · 13 Feb 2024 · CNR DLSH010069862023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS (Comm.) No. 574/23 M/s Impressive Data Service Pvt. Ltd. vs. Union of India 13.02.2024 Present : Sh. Sumit Kumar, Advocate, proxy counsel for the plaintiff. Ms. Seema K.Grover, Advocate, for the defendants. Case file is perused. An application has been filed, on behalf of defendant No.1, for deleting its name from the array of parties, (registered as IA/01/2024), on 12.01.2024 . 2. In the application, it is stated that vide memorandum, dated 24.09.2021, published in Gazette of India, on 01.10.2021, all the assets and liabilities of ‘Ordinance Factory Board’, have been transferred by the Ministry of Defence to ‘New Defence Public Section Undertaking’ and therefore, the defendant No.1 has no role to place over the superintendence or control of Indian Ordinance Factory and therefore, defendant No.1 is not a necessary party to the present proceedings. Therefore, the name of defendant No.1 may be deleted from the array of parties. A copy of the gazette notification, dated 01.10.2021, is also filed with the present application. 3. Reply to this application has been filed, on behalf of the plaintiff, wherein, it is stated that the defendant No.1 is the administrative head of the defence production and each and every activity of the defendant No.2 is controlled and monitored by the defendant No.1 and therefore, the defendant No.1 is a necessary party to the present proceedings. Therefore, the present application may be rejected. CS (Comm.) 574/23 page 1 of 4 D.J.(Commercial Court)-01/Shahdara/KKD/Delhi -- 1 of 4 -- 4. Arguments on this application were addressed by Sh. Shivnath Mahanta, Advocate, for the plaintiff and Ms. Seema Grover, Advocate, for both the defendants, on 31.01.2024. During the course of arguments, the Ld. counsels for the parties have reiterated their pleadings. 5. I have carefully perused the case file and I have also given my considered thoughts to the arguments addressed by the Ld. counsels for the parties. 6. It is observed that vide gazette notification, dated 01.10.2021, all the activities pertaining to production of arms, ammunitions, weapons, vehicles, defence equipment and non- defence equipment, under the Department of Defence Production (Ministry of Defence), have been transferred to new DPSUs, w.e.f. 01.10.2021. The relevant portion of the gazette notification, dated 01.10.2021, is reproduced below for ready reference : The Gazette of India CG-DEL-E-01102021-230101 EXTRAORDINARY PART I—Section 3 PUBLISHED BY AUTHORITY NEW DELHI, FRIDAY, OCTOBER 1, 2021/ASVINA 9, 1943 MINISTRY OF DEFENCE (Department of Defence Production) RESOLUTION New Delhi, the 1st October, 2021 No.7(E)– By virtue of the Memorandum of Understanding dated 29th September, 2021 entered into between the President of India (acting through Shri Puneet Agarwal, Joint Secretary to Government of India, Department of Defence Production (DDP), Ministry of Defence) and Munitions India Limited, Armoured Vehicles Nigam Limited, Advanced Weapons and Equipment India Limited, Troop Comforts Limited, Yantra India Limited, India Optel Limited and Gliders India Limited(the seven companies collectively referred to as “New DPSUs”), the activities in the CS (Comm.) 574/23 page 2 of 4 D.J.(Commercial Court)-01/Shahdara/KKD/Delhi -- 2 of 4 -- production of arms, ammunitions, weapons, vehicles, defence equipment and non-defence equipment (which were earlier undertaken by the 41 units of Ordnance Factory Board (“OFB”) under Department of Defence Production, Ministry of Defence) have been transferred to the New DPSUs with effect from 1st October, 2021 (“Appointed Date”), asper the structure set out in Annexure A. Further, the management, control, operations and maintenance of certain identified non-production units of OFB and identified surplus land at 16 production units of OFB have been transferred to the Directorate of Ordnance (Coordination & Services) (“Directorate”) under the DDP with effect from 1stOctober, 2021, as set out in Annexure B. 2. On and with effect from the Appointed Date, OFB, which has been set up vide Ministry of Defence letter no. 1(82)/78/D(Fy.I) dated 09.01.1979, shall cease to exist as a body. 3. All the assets and liabilities of OFB stand transferred to the New DPSUs and the Directorate, as per the structure set out in Annexures A and B. 4. All the existing contracts, agreements, deeds, purchase orders and Memorandum of Understandings entered into by OFB or any of its production and non-production units with various suppliers, contractors, vendors, companies, Organisations and individuals in respect of supply of plant and machinery, raw materials, purchase of land and building, Transfer of Technology and supply of services or any other arrangement, subsisting on the date of transfer of business and/or required for operations of the New DPSUs and Directorate (as per the structure set out in Annexures A and B) and with subscribers of all types of services to be provided by the New DPSUs and Directorate, will also stand transferred to the New DPSUs and the Directorate (as per the structure set out in Annexures A and B) with effect from the Appointed Date. 5. The New DPSUs and the Directorate will be solely responsible for honouring these contracts, agreements, deeds, purchase orders and Memorandum of Understandings for their due performance and in case of disputes to sue and be sued as the successor/assignee under the contracts, agreements, deeds, purchase orders and Memorandum of Understandings and shall be liable for any defaults, delays, or non- performance. 6. With effect from the Appointed Date, any reference, in any correspondence, bills, notices, and other documents to the OFB, having been issued prior to the Appointed Date shall, wherever the context so permits and allows, be read as reference to the New DPSUs and the Directorate, as per the structure set out in Annexures A and B. 7. With effect from the Appointed Date, in any bill, notice, or other document issued by the New DPSUs and the Directorate, bearing any reference to the OFB, shall, wherever the context so permits and allows, be read as reference to the New DPSUs and the Directorate, as per the structure set out in Annexures A and B. 8. With effect from the Appointed Date, all cheques, drafts or other instruments under which payment is to be made in favour of the Government of India in respect of monies owed to the OFB, wherever the context so permits and allows, be drawn in favour of the New DPSUs and the Directorate, as per the structure set out in Annexures A and B. CS (Comm.) 574/23 page 3 of 4 D.J.(Commercial Court)-01/Shahdara/KKD/Delhi -- 3 of 4 -- 7. From the above gazette notification, it is clear that the management, control, operation and maintenance of certain identified non-production units of Ordinance Factory Board and identified surplus land at 16 production units of Ordinance, has been transferred to the Directorate of Ordnance (Directorate) under the DDP, w.e.f. 01.10.2021, as set-out in ‘Annexure-B’ attached with the gazette notification. 8. In the considered opinion of this court, since vide gazette notification, dated 01.10.2021, new DPSUs and Directorate have been made responsible for honouring all the contracts, agreements, deeds, purchase orders and memorandum of understanding, for their due performance, w.e.f. 01.10.2021, the defendant No.1 is neither a necessary nor a proper party to the present proceedings. 9. In these circumstances and in the interest of justice, the present application is hereby allowed and the name of defendant No.1 be deleted from the array of parties. Application bearing No. IA/01/2024 is disposed of accordingly. Amended memo of parties be filed by the plaintiff within a period of two weeks from today, with advance copy to the Ld. counsel for the defendant. Adjourned for completion of pleadings and for first case management hearing on 04.03.2024. (Brijesh Kumar Garg) District Judge (Commercial Court)-01 NR Shahdara Distt, KKD/13.02.2024 CS (Comm.) 574/23 page 4 of 4 D.J.(Commercial Court)-01/Shahdara/KKD/Delhi -- 4 of 4 --
