Full Order Text
Final Order 3 · 26 Nov 2024 · CNR DLSH010065772024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: Bail Application No.1914/2024 FIR No.246/2024 U/s 307/323/452/506/147/148/149/34 IPC Police Station: Mansarovar Park Salman vs. State Video Conferencing is functional. 26.11.2024 Order on Anticipatory Bail Application. Present: Shri Ghanshyam, Subs. Ld. Addl. PP for State. Shri Pradeep Teotia, Ld. Counsel for applicant. Shri Ajay Tyagi, Ld. Counsel for complainant. IO/Insp. Vikas Malik in person. 1. This is an application u/s 482 BNSS seeking grant of anticipatory bail to applicant Salman. 2. It is stated by Ld. Defence counsel that accused/applicant has been falsely implicated in the present case. It is also submitted that there is a property dispute between complainant and accused/applicant as per the FIR itself and therefore, the possibility of exaggeration of allegations or false implication cannot be ruled out. It is submitted that as per prosecution, accused/applicant fired gun-shot in the air, however, he can only be seen having a pistol in his hand in CCTV footage and not firing the same. It is argued that recovery of allegedly used cartridge has not been effected from the spot falsifying the case of prosecution. It is contended that custodial interrogation of accused/applicant is not required in the present case as offence u/s 307 IPC is not made out against him. It is argued that the role of accused/applicant be segregated from the other co-accused and be granted anticipatory bail as investigation has already been completed. It is also stated that accused/applicant shall abide by all the conditions imposed by the Court, if granted anticipatory bail. -- 1 of 4 -- -2- 3. The bail application has been opposed by subs. Ld. Addl. PP for State assisted by Ld. Counsel for complainant and IO arguing that there are serious allegations against the accused and therefore, application be dismissed. It is argued that accused/applicant has been avoiding the investigation for long and his conduct be kept in mind by the Court while deciding his application. 4. Submissions heard. Record including chargesheet perused. 5. It is observed that FIR was registered on 26.04.2024 and accused/applicant has been absconding apparently to avoid the investigation since registration of FIR No. 246/2024 PS Mansarovar Park. There is no reason to disbelieve that accused/applicant had no knowledge of registration of present case against him particularly in the light of the fact of arrest of three co-accused. Without going into the veracity of allegations against the accused/applicant, it is observed that he can be seen having a pistol in his hand in the CCTV footage. Admittedly, the pistol has yet not been recovered and police custody of accused/applicant is imperative to recover allegedly used pistol. It is the argument of Ld. Defence counsel that firing of a gun-shot in the air may attract only offence u/s 336 IPC which is bailable in nature. In the opinion of this Court, the said act of the accused would also attract offence u/s 25/27 Arms Act, which is non-bailable in nature. It is the argument of Ld. Defence counsel that accused/applicant did not fire any gun-shot at or towards the complainant/victim and as such, offence u/s 307 IPC is not made out against him. In this regard, it is observed that there are categorical allegations even against co-accused that he gave danda blow on the head of complainant/victim causing injury on his head. The presence of -- 2 of 4 -- -3- accused/applicant at the spot is apparently not denied. It is also not denied at this stage that he was not accompanying co-accused or was not carrying katta/pistol. In these circumstances, the common intention of accused/applicant to participate in the alleged offence can be prima facie made out as such, the argument of Ld. Defence counsel that offence u/s 307 IPC is not made against accused/applicant, cannot be considered at this stage of proceedings and cannot be a ground to admit the accused/applicant to anticipatory bail. 6. Taking note of the conduct of accused/applicant since registration of FIR, the fact that he can be seen with pistol in his hand in the available CCTV footage, the fact that he was accompanying co- accused who attacked the complainant/victim with danda on his head, the fact that accused/applicant has been absconding and has failed to join the investigation for last more than six months and the fact that case required custody/custodial interrogation of accused/applicant for recovery of pistol/katta allegedly carried or used by him, no ground to enlarge the accused/applicant to anticipatory bail is made out. The application is, accordingly, dismissed. 7. Application is disposed of accordingly. 8. Before parting with present bail application, it is observed that despite identity of accused/applicant being known to IO, he failed either to arrest him or even to take coercive steps against him. No application seeking issuance of NBWs was moved before concerned Ld. JMFC in the past six months. IO appears to have acted and investigated the matter irresponsibly. IO preferred to file chargesheet against co-accused, however, failed either to arrest or to seek NBWs against accused/applicant. The reasons for such conduct have not been explained by IO despite Court confronting him with aforesaid questions. It appears that undue favour has been extended to -- 3 of 4 -- -4- accused/applicant for the last six months by taking no coercive steps against him. Such a conduct on the part of IO is not warranted. Let conduct of IO/Insp. Vikas Malik be brought to the knowledge of worthy DCP/Shahdara to look into the matter and seek explanation of IO. 9. Copy of this order be sent to worthy DCP/Shahdara. 10. Order dasti. 11. TCR be sent back to Ld. Trial Court. (ARVIND BANSAL) Additional Sessions Judge-05 (Shahdara) Karkardooma Courts, Delhi/26.11.2024 -- 4 of 4 --
