Full Order Text
Final Order 2 · 25 Oct 2023 · CNR DLSH010063282023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: Bail Application No. 2021/2023 State vs. Naresh Kumar Bail Application No. 2022/2023 State vs. Shivani Bail Application No. 2023/2023 State vs. Rajni & Bail Application No. 2024/2023 State vs. Deepmala FIR No. 205/2023 PS M.S. Park U/s 312/325/317/120 B IPC 25.10.2023 Present: Sh. L.D. Singh, Addl. PP for the State. Ms. Rajani Dogra, Counsel for applicants. Complainant with counsel Sh. B.K. Sharma. These are four applications moved on behalf of applicants, namely, Naresh Kumar, Shivani, Rajni and Deepmala seeking anticipatory bail. Reply filed by the IO. Arguments on the applications heard. Counsel for the applicants has submitted that applicant Deepmala was married to complainant Rahul on 25.12.2022 and soon after the marriage, she was tortured; she conceived in April 2023 and was continuously beaten by her husband and lastly on 07.06.2023 she was thrown away from her matrimonial house. She further submitted that the life of the applicant Deepmala came under danger due to her pregnancy and she was taken to GTB hospital, where pregnancy was terminated. She further submitted that the applicant has also made a complaint against her husband and inlaws but no action was Contd... -- 1 of 5 -- 2 taken. She further submitted that applicants Naresh Kumar and Rajni are the parents and applicant Shivani is the sister of applicant Deepmala who have nothing to do with the commission of offence and they are falsely dragged in the present case FIR by the complainant who is husband of applicant Deepmala. She further submitted that all the allegations in the FIR are false and concocted as no mother will abort her child at the cost of her own health unless there were some compelling circumstances. She further submitted that the applicants have joined the investigation and their custodial interrogation is not required. She further submitted that the applicants are apprehending their arrest in a false and motivated case filed by the complainant against his wife and inlaws and, therefore, it is requested that they may be admitted on anticipatory bail. Per contra, Addl. PP has strongly opposed the anticipatory bail applications. He submitted that the applicants have committed a heinous offence by causing the miscarriage which was not in good faith for the purpose of saving the life of a woman under the medical advice. He further submitted that there is nothing to show that applicant Deepmala had gone to Jyoti Nursing Home as no record in the name of patient Deepmala was found there or to the GTB Hospital as claimed in the applications. He further submitted that there is nothing on record that there was any threat to life of mother or the fetus which necessitated the abortion under the medical advice as the Contd... -- 2 of 5 -- 3 pregnancy was 5 months at that time. He further submitted that the applicants have voluntarily aborted the child and the same is required to be investigated by their custodial interrogation that how the child was aborted. He further submitted that the IO has been provided the voice recording conversation between the applicant Deepmala with her husband in which she has indirectly confessed the abortion of fetus by herself and her family members and did not controvert the allegation of the complainant. He further submitted that the custodial interrogation of the applicants is required to recover the body of fetus so that the cause of death can be determined and voice sample of applicant Deepmala is required so that the voice in the call recording can be verified. He further submitted that the applicants are not entitled to anticipatory bail in view of serious allegation of commission of heinous offence of aborting a child. Submissions considered. Police file perused. The present case FIR was registered on the statement of complainant Rahul in which it has been alleged that he got married to applicant Deepmala, D/o Naresh Kumar on 25.12.2022 in Arya Samaj Mandir. His wife got pregnant and as per ultrasound report dated 30.04.2023 of Noida International Institute of Medical Science, she was 8 weeks and 4 days pregnant. On 09.06.2023, his wife went to her parental house at Jag Jivan Nagar. On 17.06.2023, during telephonic conversation, she disclosed that she had aborted her unborn child and disposed Contd... -- 3 of 5 -- 4 the fetus with the help of her family members and also provided photo of fetus. It was further alleged that applicant Deepmala further told him that she had arranged the medicine from the neighbourhood for abortion and after aborting the child, the fetus was buried at unknown place. The complainant further alleged that this has been done by applicant Deepmala in conspiracy with her sister and parents and prayed that necessary action may be taken against them. The complainant has also provided photograph and telephonic conversation to the IO. As per the reply, during course of the investigation, the CCTV footage and the list of patients dated 14/15.06.2023 were required from Jyoti Nursing Home, however the CCTV footage could not be obtained as it was discarded and as per the list of patients provided by Jyoti Nursing Home, no patient in the name of Deepmala was found registered in the said nursing home. The applicants have not disputed the fact that the applicant Deepmala returned to her parental house and she was pregnant. There is nothing on record filed by the applicants to show that the health condition of the applicant Deepmala had deteriorated and her life came under danger and she was taken to GTB Hospital where the pregnancy was terminated as claimed in the applications. The conversation between applicant Deepmala with her husband i.e. the complainant was played in the mobile Contd... -- 4 of 5 -- 5 phone of the IO which, prime facie, supports the allegations of the prosecution. Keeping in view the seriousness and gravity of offence in committing the offence of foeticide and causing miscarriage of pregnancy of 5 months without the medical advice and further as the recovery of body of fetus is to be made so that the medical examination regarding cause of death can be ascertained and voice sample of applicant Deepmala is required, therefore custodial interrogation of the applicants may be required by the IO. Hence, the applications for anticipatory bail are dismissed. Copy dasti. (Balwant Rai Bansal) Special Judge (NDPS Act), Shahdara, Karkardooma Courts Delhi/ 25.10.2023 -- 5 of 5 --
