Full Order Text
Order 15 · 30 Aug 2024 · CNR DLSH010063032023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS (Comm.) No. 513/23 Ankit Jain vs. Shivam Udyog Pvt. Ltd. 30.08.2024 Present : Plaintiff in person. Sh. Hemant Gupta, Advocate, for the defendant, through video-conferencing. Case file is perused. An application has been filed on behalf of the plaintiff u/o XLVII r/w Section 151 CPC for review of the order dated 25.07.2024. The said application has been registered as I.A. No. 5/24. 2. In the aforesaid application, it has been stated that vide order dated 25.07.2024, the application of the plaintiff under Order XXVI Rule 11 r/w Sec. 151 CPC, was dismissed by the court. It is further stated that the case of the plaintiff is based on the invoices, eway bills and ledger of the plaintiff, alongwith confirmation of accounts shared by the defendant and also include the credit note dated 27.02.2020. 3. It is further stated in the application that the application under Order XXVI Rule 11 CPC, was filed on behalf of the plaintiff, as the defendants have admitted the invoices, eway bills, and the confirmation of accounts, dated 06.112019 and 24.12.2019, but it was also stated that the confirmation of accounts dated 06.11.2019 and 24.12.2019, were subject to the aforementioned credit note. Therefore, the plaintiff was constrained to move the said application. 4. It is further stated in the application that the documents of the plaintiff were admitted by the defendants albit CS (Comm.) 513/23 page 1 of 8 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 1 of 8 -- conditionally, and therefore, it had become imperative for the plaintiff to seek the indulgence of the court, to appoint an impartial commission to conduct the forensic audit of defendant No.1. Furthermore, the plaintiff was not aware about the additional sham defence of fire in the factory of the defendant, when the aforesaid application under Order XXVI Rule 11 CPC was filed on behalf of the plaintiff. 5. It is further stated in the application that the findings of this court, in the order dated 25.07.2024, suffer from errors apparent on the face of the record and the new evidence brought on record during the examination and cross-examination of DW- 1, only strengthens the need for forensic audit and the same now ought to include the insurance claim made by the defendant, after the fire at their factory. 6. It has been prayed that in view of the above facts, the order dated 25.07.2024, may be reviewed and appropriate order for conducting the forensic audit of defendant No.1 may be passed. 7. The reply to this application was not filed on behalf of the defendant, despite opportunity. 8. Arguments on this application were addressed by Ms. Abha Vijayan, Advocate, for the plaintiff and Sh. Hemant Gupta, Advocate, for the defendant, on 12.08.2024, and during the arguments, the Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff has reiterated the contents of her present application. The Ld. Counsel for plaintiff has failed to file any judgment in support of her contentions, despite opportunity. 9. On the other hand, the Ld. Counsel for the defendant has argued that there is no error apparent on record, in the order CS (Comm.) 513/23 page 2 of 8 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 2 of 8 -- dated 25.07.2024 and once the court has taken a considered view, after considering the material on record, the said observations cannot be altered or modified or reviewed, by way of the present application. He has also relied upon the following judgments, in support of his contentions : (i) ‘OK Play India Pvt. Ltd. vs. A.P. Distributors’, reported as, ‘2021 (lawpack) (Delhi) 85396’; and (ii) ‘Nutan Kumar And Anr. vs. Rajesh Arora And Ors.’, reported as, ‘ 2012 (lawPack) (Delhi) 55230’. 10. I have carefully perused the case filed and I have also given my considered thoughts to the arguments addressed by the Ld. Counsels for the parties. I have also perused the judgments, cited by the Ld. Counsel for the defendant, in support of his contentions. 11. Perusal of the record shows that the Issues in the present suit were framed on 27.03.2024. Vide order dated 27.03.2024, with the consent of the parties, a Ld. Local Commissioner was also appointed, to record the evidence of the parties, and accordingly, the evidence of the witnesses of the parties were recorded by ld. Local Commissioner and the matter was fixed for final arguments, on 15.05.2024. In the meantime, an application under Order XXVI Rule 11 CPC (IA No.4/2024) was also filed on behalf of the plaintiff on 23.04.2024, and the said application was dismissed by this court vide order dated 25.07.2024, with following observations : “10. Perusal of the record shows that the plaintiff has filed the present suit for recovery of Rs.90,39,814/-, alongwith interest @18% per annum and for damages of Rs.8 Lakhs. The issues in the present suit were framed on 27.03.2024. Vide order dated 27.03.2024, a local commissioner was also appointed to record the evidence of the parties and the matter was listed for final arguments on 15.05.2024. At this stage, CS (Comm.) 513/23 page 3 of 8 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 3 of 8 -- an application under Order XI Rule 1(5) & (12) r/w Order XVIII Rule 17 r/w Section 151 CPC, (registered as IA/2/2024), was filed, on behalf of the plaintiff, on 30.05.2024, for taking additional documents on record. The said application has already been dismissed by this court, vide order dated 09.07.2024. 11. Perusal of the record further shows that on 23.04.2024, the affidavit of the plaintiff was filed and the same was tendered in evidence, before the Ld. Local Commissioner, on 27.04.2024. Cross-examination of PW1 Sh. Ankit Jain was concluded before the Ld. Local Commissioner on 27.04.2024. With the affidavit Ex.PW1/A, the present application was also filed by the plaintiff. 12. Perusal of the record further shows that the Ld. Local commissioner had already recorded the evidence of both the parties, as the recording of the evidence of the defendant was also completed by her on 04.05.2024. The Ld. Local Commissioner had already filed her report, alongwith the record of evidence of the parties, in the court on 13.05.2024. 13. From the contents of the application and the facts that the previous application of the plaintiff under Order XI Rule 1(5) and Order XVIA Rule 6(1) (d)& (12) r/w Order XVIII Rule 17 r/w Section 151 CPC, had already been withdrawn by the plaintiff on 01.06.2024, being infructuous, this court is of the considered opinion that the present application has been filed by the plaintiff, only to fill up the lacunae in his cause. Furthermore, the additional documents, forensic audit of which has been sought by the plaintiff, by virtue of the present application, are alleged to have been filed before the court of the concerned M.M., where the proceedings between the parties, under Section 138 N.I. Act are pending. Therefore, in the considered opinion of this court, the forensic audit of the documents, pertaining to the proceedings under Section 138 N.I. Act, cannot be ordered in the present proceedings. Furthermore, it is a settled legal proposition that the plaintiff has to stand on his own legs and is required to prove his case himself, by leading reliable and cogent evidence. The plaintiff cannot be permitted to take benefit of his own lapses. 14. Therefore, I do not find any merit in the present application, and the same is hereby dismissed, being devoid of any merits. It is ordered accordingly.” 12. It has been held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, in case title as, “S. Murali Sundram vs. Jothibai Kannan & CS (Comm.) 513/23 page 4 of 8 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 4 of 8 -- Ors.”, passed in Civil Appeal Nos. 1167-1170 of 2023 dated 24.02.2023, as under : “5.1 While considering the aforesaid issue two decisions of this Court on Order 47 Rule 1 read with Section 114 CPC are required to be referred to? In the case of Perry Kansagra (supra) this Court has observed that while exercising the review jurisdiction in an application under Order 47 Rule 1 read with Section 114 CPC, the Review Court does not sit in appeal over its own order. It is observed that a rehearing of the matter is impermissible in law. It is further observed that review is not appeal in disguise. It is observed that power of review can be exercised for correction of a mistake but not to substitute a view. Such powers can be exercised within the limits of the statute dealing with the exercise of power. It is further observed that it is wholly unjustified and exhibits a tendency to rewrite a judgment by which the controversy has been finally decided. After considering catena of decisions on exercise of review powers and principles relating to exercise of review jurisdiction under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC this Court had summed upon as under: “(i) Review proceedings are not by way of appeal and have to be strictly confined to the scope and ambit of Order 47 Rule 1 CPC. (ii) Power of review may be exercised when some mistake or error apparent on the fact of record is found. But error on the face of record must be such an error which must strike one on mere looking at the record and would not require any longdrawn process of reasoning on the points where there may conceivably by two opinions. (iii) Power of review may not be exercised on the ground that the decision was erroneous on merits. (iv) Power of review can also be exercised for any sufficient reason which is wide enough to include a misconception of fact or law by a court or even an advocate. (v) An application for review may be necessitated by way of invoking the doctrine actus curiae neminem gravabit.” 5.2 It is further observed in the said decision that an error which is required to be detected by a process of reasoning can hardly be said to be an error on the face of the record. 5.3 In the case of Shanti Conductors (P) Ltd. (supra), it is observed and held that scope of review under Order 47 CS (Comm.) 513/23 page 5 of 8 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 5 of 8 -- Rule 1 CPC read with Section 114 CPC is limited and under the guise of review, the petitioner cannot be permitted to reagitate and reargue questions which have already been addressed and decided. It is further observed that an error which is not selfevident and has to be detected by a process of reasoning, can hardly be said to be an error apparent on the face of record justifying the court to exercise its power of review under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC”. (emphasis supplied) 13. It was also held by the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi, in case titled as, ‘ OK Play India Pvt. Ltd. vs. A.P. Distributors’, reported as, ‘2021 (lawpack) (Delhi) 85396’, as under : 13. The courts have repeatedly held that the powers of review are limited and are not equivalent to an appeal. The scope of review has been succinctly stated by the Supreme Court in Kamlesh Varma Vs. Mayawati & Ors. (2013) 8 SCC 320 wherein the following governing principles of review have been laid down- "Summary of the principles 20. Thus, in view of the above, the following grounds of review are maintainable as stipulated by the statute: 20.1. When the review will be maintainable: (i) Discovery of new and important matter or evidence which, after the exercise of due diligence, was not within knowledge of the petitioner or could not be produced by him; ii) Mistake or error apparent on the face of the record; (iii)Any other sufficient reason. The words "any other sufficient reason" have been interpreted in Chhajju Ram Vs. Neki AIR 1922 PC 112 and approved by this Court in Moran Mar Basselios Catholicos Vs. Most Rev. Mar Poulose Athanasius AIR 1954 SC 526 to mean "a reason sufficient on grounds at least analogous to those specified in the rule". The same principles have been reiterated in Union of India Vs. Sandur Manganese & Iron Ores Ltd. (2013) 8 SCC 337. 20.2. When the review will not be maintainable: (i) A repetition of old and overruled argument is not enough to reopen concluded adjudications. (ii) Minor mistakes of inconsequential import. (iii) Review proceedings cannot be equated with the original hearing of the case. (iv) Review is not maintainable unless CS (Comm.) 513/23 page 6 of 8 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 6 of 8 -- the material error, manifest on the face of the order, undermines its soundness or results in miscarriage of justice. (v) A review is by no means an appeal in disguise whereby an erroneous decision is reheard and corrected but lies only for patent error. (vi) The mere possibility of two views on the subject cannot be a ground for review. (vii) The error apparent on the face of the record should not be an error which has to be fished out and searched. (viii) The appreciation of evidence on record is fully within the domain of the appellate court, it cannot be permitted to be advanced in the review petition. (ix) Review is not maintainable when the same relief sought at the time of arguing the main matter had been negatived." 14. An error has thus to be one on the face of the order. The Court cannot be called upon to delve deep to "discover" an error. A re-argument or introduction of new pleas is also not permissible. In the present matter, it is evident that the learned counsel for the applicants/respondents has actually argued out his case which ideally ought to have been presented when the main petition was considered. Be that as it may, these submissions are considered at this juncture. (emphasis supplied) 14. It was also held by the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi, in case titled as, ‘ Nutan Kumar And Anr. vs. Rajesh Arora And Ors.’, reported as, ‘ 2012 (lawPack) (Delhi) 55230’, as under : 9. There is no doubt to the settled legal proposition that a prayer seeking review of an order can be granted only if the parameters of review as contained in Order 47 of the Code are satisfied. There must be a material irregularity or an error apparent on the face of the record or it must be shown that the evidence has been appreciated illegally. (emphasis supplied) 15. When the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi, is applied to the facts and circumstances of the present case, it is observed that the plaintiff has failed to disclose any error or illegality, in the CS (Comm.) 513/23 page 7 of 8 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 7 of 8 -- Order dated 25.07.2024, for which the said order may be reviewed by this Court. Furthermore, no specific error or illegality in the order dated 25.07.2024, has been mentioned in the application. 16. In these circumstances and in view of the settled legal position, as discussed above, I do not find any merit in the present application and the same is hereby dismissed, being devoid of any merits. It is ordered accordingly. The I.A. No.5/2024 is disposed off accordingly. Adjourned for final arguments on 28.09.2024. Brijesh Kumar Garg District Judge Commercial Court-01 Shahdara Distt, KKD, Delhi 30.08.2024 NR CS (Comm.) 513/23 page 8 of 8 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 8 of 8 --
