Full Order Text
Order 13 · 25 Jul 2024 · CNR DLSH010063032023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS (Comm.) No. 513/23 Ankit Jain vs. Shivam Udyog Pvt. Ltd. 25.07.2024 Present : Ms. Abha Vijayan, Advocate, for the plaintiff through video-conferencing. Sh. Hemant Gupta, Advocate, for the defendant through video-conferencing. Case file is perused. An application under Order XXVI Rule 11 r/w Section 151 CPC, (IA/4/2024), has been filed on behalf of the plaintiff, on 23.04.2024. It is stated in the application that the plaintiff has filed the present suit for recovery of an amount of Rs.58,70,009/-, excluding interest, which is payable by the defendants jointly and severally, as the defendants No.2 & 3, in collusion with each other, fraudulently and malafidely fabricated and manipulated the documents and have presented the same before the concerned M.M., during the proceedings under Section 138 N.I. Act. 2. It is further stated in the application that a notice under Order XI Rule 5 CPC, as applicable to the Commercial disputes, was also served upon the defendants through email dated 15.04.2024, seeking production of certain documents, regarding their GST account and bank statements. 3. It is further stated in the application that the plaintiff is seeking indulgence of this court to appoint a Commission to conduct a forensic audit of the audit reports, income tax returns and ledger, as admitted by the defendants and the commission CS (Comm.) 513/2023 page 1 of 5 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 1 of 5 -- may be directed to conduct the forensic audit, in the light of the documents sought to be produced on demand under Order XI Rule 5 CPC, and hence, the present application. 4. It is further stated in the application that the defendants may be directed to furnish the legible true copies of the documents to be the subject of forensic audit and a Chartered Accountant be appointed as a commission to conduct the forensic audit of the admitted documents. 5. Reply to this application has been filed, on behalf of the defendants, wherein, it is stated that the plaintiff is required to prove his case by bringing the documents on record and therefore, the question of examination of any document, by an outside agency, does not arise at all. It is further stated that, in case, the defendant has filed any forged and fabricated documents, the concerned authority shall take notice of the same and this court shall also take cognizance of the same. 6. It is further stated in the reply that the alleged documents were filed by the defendant, before the concerned M.M. East, Karkardoma Courts, Delhi, and the plaintiff has failed to challenge the order of the said court, and therefore, the said order has attained finality. 7. It is further stated in the reply that the present application has been filed by the plaintiff to wriggle out of the admitted documents, which are part of the present record. It is further stated that the income tax returns and audit reports filed by the defendants, in proceedings under Section 138 of the N.I. CS (Comm.) 513/2023 page 2 of 5 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 2 of 5 -- Act, were duly certified and audited by the Chartered Accountant of the defendant, and therefore, notice under Order XI Rule 5 CPC, is of no consequence, as the plaintiff can always summon the concerned authority to prove the said documents. It is further stated that the said documents are having no relevance in the present matter. It has been prayed that the application be dismissed with heavy costs. 8. Arguments on this application were addressed by Ms.Abha Vijayan, Advocate, for the plaintiff and Sh. Hemant Gupta, Advocate, for all the defendants, on 01.06.2024. During the course of arguments, the Ld. Counsels for the parties have reiterated the contents of their pleadings. 9. I have carefully perused the case file and I have also given my considered thoughts to the arguments addressed by the Ld. Counsels for the parties. 10. Perusal of the record shows that the plaintiff has filed the present suit for recovery of Rs.90,39,814/-, alongwith interest @18% per annum and for damages of Rs.8 Lakhs. The issues in the present suit were framed on 27.03.2024. Vide order dated 27.03.2024, a local commissioner was also appointed to record the evidence of the parties and the matter was listed for final arguments on 15.05.2024. At this stage, an application under Order XI Rule 1(5) & (12) r/w Order XVIII Rule 17 r/w Section 151 CPC, (registered as IA/2/2024), was filed, on behalf of the plaintiff, on 30.05.2024, for taking additional documents on record. The said application has already been dismissed by this court, vide order dated 09.07.2024. CS (Comm.) 513/2023 page 3 of 5 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 3 of 5 -- 11. Perusal of the record further shows that on 23.04.2024, the affidavit of the plaintiff was filed and the same was tendered in evidence, before the Ld. Local Commissioner, on 27.04.2024. Cross-examination of PW1 Sh. Ankit Jain was concluded before the Ld. Local Commissioner on 27.04.2024. With the affidavit Ex.PW1/A, the present application was also filed by the plaintiff. 12. Perusal of the record further shows that the Ld. Local commissioner had already recorded the evidence of both the parties, as the recording of the evidence of the defendant was also completed by her on 04.05.2024. The Ld. Local Commissioner had already filed her report, alongwith the record of evidence of the parties, in the court on 13.05.2024. 13. From the contents of the application and the facts that the previous application of the plaintiff under Order XI Rule 1(5) and Order XVIA Rule 6(1) (d)& (12) r/w Order XVIII Rule 17 r/w Section 151 CPC, had already been withdrawn by the plaintiff on 01.06.2024, being infructuous, this court is of the considered opinion that the present application has been filed by the plaintiff, only to fill up the lacunae in his cause. Furthermore, the additional documents, forensic audit of which has been sought by the plaintiff, by virtue of the present application, are alleged to have been filed before the court of the concerned M.M., where the proceedings between the parties, under Section 138 N.I. Act are pending. Therefore, in the considered opinion of this court, the forensic audit of the CS (Comm.) 513/2023 page 4 of 5 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 4 of 5 -- documents, pertaining to the proceedings under Section 138 N.I. Act, cannot be ordered in the present proceedings. Furthermore, it is a settled legal proposition that the plaintiff has to stand on his own legs and is required to prove his case himself, by leading reliable and cogent evidence. The plaintiff cannot be permitted to take benefit of his own lapses. 14. Therefore, I do not find any merit in the present application, and the same is hereby dismissed, being devoid of any merits. It is ordered accordingly. IA/4/2024 is disposed of accordingly. Adjourned for final arguments on 12.08.2024. Brijesh Kumar Garg District Judge Commercial Court-01 Shahdara Distt, KKD, Delhi NR 25.07.2024 CS (Comm.) 513/2023 page 5 of 5 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 5 of 5 --
