Full Order Text
Interim Order 17 · 08 Oct 2024 · CNR DLSH010063032023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: 16 CS (COMM) 513/23 ANKIT JAIN Vs. SHIVAM UDYOG PVT LTD 08.10.2024 Present : Plaintiff in person. Sh. Hemant Gupta, Advocate, for the defendant, through video-conferencing. Case file is perused. An application under Order XVIII Rule 17 r/w Section 151 CPC, (IA/6/2024), has been filed, on behalf of the plaintiff, for recalling of DW-1 Sh. Jitendra Aggarwal, for his further cross-examination. 2. In this application, it has been mentioned that in order to controvert the case of the plaintiff, the defendant has relied upon the evidence of his witness Sh.Jitendra Aggarwal (DW-1), and in his testimony, DW-1 Sh. Jitendra Aggarwal has given vague and contradictory replies to the questions put to him, during his cross-examination, and therefore, the plaintiff may be permitted to recall DW-1 Sh. Jitendra Aggarwal, for his further cross-examination. 3. No reply to this application was filed, on behalf of the defendant, despite opportunity. 4. Arguments on this application were addressed by Ms. Apurva Upmanyu, Advocate, for the plaintiff, and Sh. Hemant Gupta, Advocate, for the defendant, on 28.09.2024. 5. During the course of arguments, the Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff has pointed out that DW-1 Sh. Jitendra Aggarwal has given vague replies to the queries of the Ld. Previous counsel of the plaintiff. She has further argued that to elaborate the said replies, the plaintiff now intends to recall DW-1 Sh. Jitendra Aggarwal, for his further cross-examination, and therefore, the application may be allowed. CS (Comm.) 513/23 page 1 of 4 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 1 of 4 -- 6. On the other hand, the Ld. Counsel for the defendant has argued that no ground for recalling of DW-1 Sh. Jitendra Aggarwal, has been disclosed in the application. He has further argued that DW-1 Sh. Jitendra Aggarwal was cross-examined at legnth, on behalf of the plaintiff, and therefore, there is no ground for further cross-examination of DW-1 Sh. Jitendra Aggarwal. He has further argued that a similar application bearing No.IA/2/2024, was also filed, on behalf of the plaintiff, for a similar relief and the said application had already been dismissed by this court, on 09.07.2024, and the said order has not been challenged by the plaintiff, till date. The Ld. Counsel for the defendant has also relied upon the judgment of the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi, in case titled as, ‘Smt. Shashi Sehdev vs. Sh. Narender Kumar Sharma’, reported as, ‘2022 (293) DLT 116’, in support of his contentions. 7. I have carefully perused the case file and I have also given my considered thoughts to the arguments addressed by the Ld. Counsels for the parties. I have also perused the judgment cited by the Ld. Counsel for the defendant, in support of his contentions. 8. Perusal of the record shows that the issues in the present suit were framed on 27.03.2024, and the evidence of the parties was concluded, before the Ld. Local Commissioner, and thereafter, several miscellaneous applications were filed, on behalf of the plaintiff, and the same were disposed off and vide order dated 25.07.2024, the matter was fixed for final argument. Thereafter, an application under Order XLVII Rule 1 r/w Section 151 CPC was filed, on behalf of the plaintiff, for review of the CS (Comm.) 513/23 page 2 of 4 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 2 of 4 -- order dated 25.07.2024. But, the said application was dismissed vide order dated 30.08.2024, and thereafter, the matter was again fixed for final arguments on 28.09.2024. At this stage, the present application has been filed, on behalf of the plaintiff. 9. Perusal of the record further shows that during the trial, to controvert the case of the plaintiff, the defendant has examined defendant No.2 Sh. Jitendra Aggarwal, as DW-1, and this witness was thoroughly cross-examined by the Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff, at length, running into seven pages. 10. It has been held by the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi, in case titled as, ‘Smt. Shashi Sehdev vs. Sh. Narender Kumar Sharma’, (Supra), as under : “13. A holistic reading of the aforesaid passages from Ram Rati makes it clear that, classically, the recall of a witness under Order XVIII Rule 17 has to be for clarifying any doubts which may exist, despite the evidence already recorded and that, in this context, the Court is entitled to co-opt the assistance of the parties and permit questioning, by the parties, of the recalled witness. Nonetheless, in exceptional cases, the parties may also be permitted to apply for recall of witnesses under Order XVIII Rule 17 for further examination or cross examination. In such cases, however, the Court would be exercising jurisdiction under Order XVIII Rule 17 read with Section 151 of the CPC. The manner in which Section 151 of the CPC would come in for application in such a case also stands identified by the Supreme Court in para 16 of Ram Rati11, which reads thus: “16. Some good guidance on invocation of Section 151 of the CPC to reopen an evidence or production of fresh evidence is also available in K.K. Velusamy (supra). To quote paragraph-14: “14. The amended provisions of the Code contemplate and expect a trial court to hear the arguments immediately after the completion of evidence and then proceed to judgment. Therefore, it was unnecessary to have an express provision for reopening the evidence to examine a fresh witness or for recalling any witness for further examination. But if there is a time gap between the completion of evidence and hearing of the arguments, for CS (Comm.) 513/23 page 3 of 4 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 3 of 4 -- whatsoever reason, and if in that interregnum, a party comes across some evidence which he could not lay his hands on earlier, or some evidence in regard to the conduct or action of the other party comes into existence, the court may in exercise of its inherent power under Section 151 of the Code, permit the production of such evidence if it is relevant and necessary in the interest of justice, subject to such terms as the court may deem fit to impose.” 14. The resultant legal position is that, whether under Order XVIII Rule 17 or Order XVIII Rule 17 read with Section 151 of the CPC, a party may be permitted to recall a witness for further examination or cross examination if (i) there exists any doubt, remaining after the recording of the evidence of the said witness that has already taken place, which is required to be clarified or (ii) after the evidence of the witness has been recorded, the party seeking recall has come across evidence on which he could not lay his hands earlier, or (iii) evidence in regard to the conduct or action of the other party has come into existence. 15. The decision in Ram Rati makes it perfectly clear that the recall of a witness is not to be permitted to fill up omission in the evidence already led by the witness, or to fill up any lacuna or omission in the evidence of the witness which has already been recorded. (emphasis supplied) 11. In these facts and circumstances of the present case and in view of the above judgment, I do not find any merit in the present application, and therefore, the same is hereby dismissed, subject to imposition of a cost of Rs.3,000/- on the plaintiff. IA/6/2024 is disposed of accordingly. Adjourned for payment of cost by the plaintiff and for final arguments on 04.11.2024. Brijesh Kumar Garg District Judge Commercial Court-01 Shahdara Distt, KKD, Delhi 08.10.2024 NR CS (Comm.) 513/23 page 4 of 4 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 4 of 4 --
