Skip to main content
Court Order

Interim Order 15

CNR DLSH01006108202305 Dec 2024
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Interim Order 15 · 05 Dec 2024 · CNR DLSH010061082023

Order Details: COPY OF ORDER
Pdf Text: CS (COMM) 497/23
VIJAYANT KUMAR
Vs.
VIKAS GUPTA
05.12.2024.
Present: Sh. Paras Khurana and Sh. Raj Vardhan Upadhyay, Ld. Counsels
for plaintiff.
None for defendant.
O R D E R:
1. Matter is fixed for orders today on all the pending applications.
2. Perusal of the file reveals that the following applications are pending:-
(I) application under Order XI Rule 1(5) CPC r/w Section 151 CPC filed on
behalf of defendant for taking on record additional documents;
(II) application under Order XI Rule 1(5) CPC filed on behalf of plaintiff for
taking on record additional documents;
(III) application under Order VII Rule 10 r/w Section 151 CPC filed on be-
half of defendant.
3. First of all coming to the application filed by the defendant under Or-
der XI Rule 1(5) CPC. It is stated that the defendant has filed the documents
i.e. (i) copy of invoice bills issued by plaintiff, (ii) kachchi receipts issued by
plaintiff showing difference of weight (iii) billwise difference charts of
weight/outsize and rusted (iv) letters of complaint and written complaint,
emails (issued by parties to defendant) and statement of defendant’s parties
(v) ledger account of Rs.3,38,605/- issued by plaintiff through whatsapp and
CS Comm. No.497/23
	Vijayant Kumar vs. Vikas Gupta
Page no. 1 of 15
-- 1 of 15 --
(vi) ledger account statement of defendant. It is stated that the defendant
could not file these documents along with WS on earlier stage.
4. Further, it is stated that the invoice bills bearing nos. 1373, 1552, 1646,
1669, 2584, 2377 issued by the plaintiff do not have authorized signatures
and the plaintiff used to send kachchi receipts against goods and defendant
used to send back the difference of goods to plaintiff but the plaintiff did not
reduce the difference amount and again sent invoice bills without correction.
It is further stated that if these documents are not allowed to be taken on
record, the defendant shall suffer irreparable loss.
5. Plaintiff has filed reply to this application stating that the application
has been filed under a wrong provision of law, inasmuch as, Order XI Rule
1(5) applies to the documents filed by the plaintiff and is not related to defen-
dant. Further, it is stated that the Court had already struck off the right of the
defendant to file additional documents, vide order dated 18.07.2024 when it
was observed that no further time can be granted to the defendant to file the
application for taking on record the additional documents and therefore, it is
stated that the defendant is not entitled to file additional documents on record.
Also, the application does not disclose the "reasonable cause" for non-disclo-
sure of the documents along with written statement.
6. As the defendant only has stated that he could not file the additional
documents on earlier stage, the plaintiff has further relied upon the judgment
of the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in
“CEC-CICI JV & ORS. VS ORIEN-
TAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.” [CS(COMM) 7/2020, I.As. 11113/2022 &
17718/2022] decided on 15.05.2023, wherein it was
inter alia held that the
CS Comm. No.497/23
	Vijayant Kumar vs. Vikas Gupta
Page no. 2 of 15
-- 2 of 15 --
defendant cannot be permitted to file these documents on record without dis-
closing any "reasonable cause".
7. It is also stated that as per the defendant, the documents were issued by
the plaintiff through whatsapp but the defendant has failed to produce the
screenshot of whatsapp conversation between the parties. Also, the document
are not supported with a certificate under Section 63 of Bharatiya Sakshya
Adhiniyam, 2023. Further, it is stated that whether the invoice bears autho-
rized signature on behalf of plaintiff or not is a matter of trial. Plaintiff has
denied that he used to send kachchi receipts against goods or that the defen-
dant used to send back the difference of goods to the plaintiff. It is stated that
the false and fabricated story has been made by the defendant which is just an
afterthought. Prayer has been made to dismiss the application of the defen-
dant.
8. Heard. Perused the record. Perusal of the record reveals that the WS
was filed by the defendant on 18.04.2024 along with an application seeking
condonation of delay in filing the same. Along with WS, no document along
with list of documents was filed on behalf of defendant. Counsel for defen-
dant had sought some time to file the same and and it was directed that the
same be filed within 4 days with advance copy to the opposite counsel vide
order dated 18.04.2024. Thereafter, the defendant filed list of documents
along with documents on 01.05.2024. However, when the defendant filed a
fresh affidavit of admission/denial of documents of the plaintiff, the defen-
dant also filed documents from page nos. 68 to 115. The documents thus,
which was filed along with the fresh affidavit of admission/denial of the doc-
uments of the plaintiff on 22.05.2024 were not filed with the WS. However,
CS Comm. No.497/23
	Vijayant Kumar vs. Vikas Gupta
Page no. 3 of 15
-- 3 of 15 --
the same were filed prior to filing of the replication by the plaintiff and it is
only the application for taking on record the said documents which has been
filed subsequently.
9. Vide order dated 18.07.2024, it was directed that no further time can be
granted to the defendant to file the application for taking on record the addi-
tional documents i.e. from page nos. 68 to 115 which was filed along with the
fresh affidavit of admission/denial of the documents of the plaintiff. How-
20.08.2024, under Order VII Rule 14 CPC, when it was observed that Order
VII Rule 14 CPC is not applicable to Commercial Courts as per Order XI
Rule 7 CPC and further, the list of documents as per Order XI Rule 4 CPC
was also not filed by the defendant in respect of the additional documents.
10. Thereafter, the defendant’s counsel filed the present application under
Order XI Rule 1(5) CPC for taking on record the additional documents as
well as the list of documents. Meanwhile, the plaintiff also filed replication
along with an additional documents i.e. balance confirmation certificate from
the bank as Annexure-I to their application and it was observed that the plain-
tiff has not moved any specific application for taking on record the said bal-
ance confirmation certificate.
Order XI Rule 1(5) CPC is not applicable to the documents of the de-
fendant and the appropriate provision is under Order XI Rule 1(10) CPC.
Though, the application has been filed under Order XI Rule 1(5) CPC, but
counsel for defendant orally submitted that the same be considered to be one
under Order XI Rule 1(10) CPC.
CS Comm. No.497/23
	Vijayant Kumar vs. Vikas Gupta
Page no. 4 of 15
-- 4 of 15 --
11. In Robin Thapa v. Rohit Dora [Civil Appeal No.4507/2019 decided on
8th July, 2019] it has been held by the Supreme Court that the endeavour of
the Court has to be to decide disputes on merits and not on the defaults of the
parties. The relevant paragraph reads as under:
“8. Ordinarily, a litigation is based on adjudication on
the merits of the contentions of the parties. Litigation
should not be terminated by default, either of the
plaintiff or of the defendant. The cause of action does
require that as far as possible, adjudication be done on
merits.”
12. It is a trite law that mere citing of a wrong provision can not be said to
be hampering the duty of the court to do justice. It is the duty of the court to
do complete and substantial justice between the parties at dispute. In the case
titled as
“Prithvirajsinh Nodhuba Jadeha (D) by LRs v. Jayeshkumar
Chhakaddas Shah & Ors” [CIVIL APPEAL NO. 10521 OF 2013 (dated
04/10/2019)]
“ 8. It is well settled law that mere non mentioning of an incorrect provision is
not fatal to the application if the power to pass such an order is available with
the court.”
13. In the case titled as
“N. Mani v. Sangeetha Theatres & Ors.” [(2004) 12
SCC 278], it is held that:
“9. It is well settled that if an authority has a power under the law merely
because while exercising that power the source of power is not specifically
referred to or a reference is made to a wrong provision of law, that by itself
does not vitiate the exercise of power so long as the power does exist and can
be traced to a source available in law.”
14. Therefore, in the interest of justice, the application filed by defendant
under order XI Rule 1(5) CPC is treated to be filed under order XI Rule 1(10)
CPC, in interest of justice.
CS Comm. No.497/23
	Vijayant Kumar vs. Vikas Gupta
Page no. 5 of 15
-- 5 of 15 --
15. Order XI Rule 1(10) CPC provides that a defendant has to show a
‘rea-
sonable cause' to seek the permission of this court. In this regard, the Hon'ble
Calcutta High Court in the case of
“ITC Ltd v. J P Morgan Mutual Fund India
Pvt Ltd and Ors.” [G.A. 445 of 2020 With C.S. 146 of 2016 dated
11/06/2020], the Hon’ble Court observed that:
“11. Rule 1(7) of Order XI of the CPC relating to disclosure, discovery and
inspection of documents in suits sets down the procedure for filing of docu-
ments in a commercial suit by the defendant. Rule 1(7) requires the defendant
to file all documents in its power, possession, control or custody, pertaining
to the suit along with the written statement or the counter-claim with the
three exceptions under Order XI Rule 1(7) (c). These exceptions are identical
to the two exceptions under Order XIII Rule 1(3), save an additional excep-
tion where the defendant is called upon to answer to any case set up by the
plaintiff subsequent to the filing of the plaint. Under Order XI Rule 1(10), the
defendant can rely on documents which were in the defendant's power, pos-
session, etc. and not disclosed along with the written statement or counter-
claim subject to leave of court on the defendant establishing reasonable cause
for such non-disclosure.
…..
Order XI Rule 1(10) Save and except for sub-rule (7)(c)(iii), defendant shall
not be allowed to rely on documents, which were in the defendant's power,
possession, control or custody and not disclosed along with the written state-
ment or counter-claim, save and except by leave of Court and such leave
shall be granted only upon the defendant establishing reasonable cause for
non-disclosure along with the written statement or counter claim. Hence, un-
der the new law, i.e. post-2015, a defendant can rely on additional documents
provided the Court grants it leave to do so and upon being satisfied of the
reasons shown by the defendant for non-disclosure of the documents along
with the written statement.”
16. Certainly, the defendant was bound to file all document along with
their WS. The WS was filed on 18.04.2024 but no document was filed along
01.05.2024, the list of documents along with the documents was filed by the
defendant. The WS of the defendant was taken on record vide order dated
01.05.2024. The additional documents have been filed by the defendant on
22.05.2024. Though, as far as, the evidentiary value of the document i.e. the
CS Comm. No.497/23
	Vijayant Kumar vs. Vikas Gupta
Page no. 6 of 15
-- 6 of 15 --
whether the same are accompanied with the appropriate certificate regarding
the digital records or not shall be considered at the time of trial and this is not
the appropriate stage to consider the evidentiary value of the documents.
17. Also, though, vide order dated 18.07.2024, it was observed that no fur-
ther time can be granted to defendant to file the application for taking on
record the additional documents, still this fact cannot be lost sight of the fact
that the case is at the initial stage and issues are yet to be framed and trial is
yet to commence. Also, additional documents were filed by the defendant,
even before filing of the replication by the plaintiff. Therefore, interest of jus-
tice would be served if the application of the defendant is allowed subject to
some cost. The plaintiff can be compensated in monetary terms for the delay
caused. Application of the defendant for taking on record the additional docu-
ments is thus, allowed subject to cost of Rs.10,000/- payable to the plaintiff.
Cost be paid and receipt be placed on record.
18. Similar application of the plaintiff is under Order XI Rule 1(5) CPC.
Through this application, the plaintiff wishes to file on record the balance
confirmation certificate to show that the bank account of the plaintiff is
within the jurisdiction of the present Court wherein the plaintiff has received
payment from the defendant and therefore, the present Court has territorial
jurisdiction to try and decide the present suit. It is stated that no new facts and
issues are disclosed through this document and this document has been filed
only in rebuttal to the defence of the defendant as stated in their WS. The de-
fendant has not filed any reply to the said application and the counsel for de-
fendant has straightaway advance arguments on the same.
CS Comm. No.497/23
	Vijayant Kumar vs. Vikas Gupta
Page no. 7 of 15
-- 7 of 15 --
19. Order XI Rule 1 (5) CPC provides that the plaintiff can be allowed to
file additional documents after leave of court has been granted upon showing
of Reasonable Cause for non-disclosure of the documents along with the
plaint. The Hon'ble Delhi HC in the case of
“Eicore Technologies Pvt Ltd v.
Eexpedise Technologies Pvt Ltd” [(CS COMM 1146/2108) (DATED
29/10/2024)] has considered the scope of the term ‘reasonable cause' under
order XI Rule 1 (5) CPC. It has been observed as follows:
“8. As to what constitutes reasonable cause within the ambit of Order XI of
CPC, as amended by the Commercial Court Act, 2015, this Court in the case
of Bela Creation Pvt. Ltd. Versus Anuj Textiles, held as follows:
“24... “Reasonable cause”, necessarily, must refer to a cause which was out-
side the control of the petitioner, and which prevented the petitioner from fil-
ing the concerned documents along with the written statement.”
20. Perusal of the application filed by plaintiff reveals that the plaintiff has
filed application under Order XI Rule 1(5) CPC, however, the correct
provision is to be one Order XI Rule 1(1)(c)(ii) CPC. In the case of
“Valo
Automotive Pvt. Ltd. vs. Sprint Cars Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.”; [CM(M)324/2021,
Delhi High Court]. It was observed that the plaintiff has filed the present
application under Order XI Rule 1(5) CPC, but the Court may treat this
application under Order XI Rule 1 sub-rule (1)(c)(ii) CPC and it is argued
that mere citing of a wrong provision in the application would not be fatal so
long as the application would lie under another provision just as exercise of
power under a wrong provision would not imperil such exercise, where the
power exists, albeit elsewhere. It is stated that the crucial question is as to
whether the power exists or not. It is stated that through this application, the
plaintiff is not setting up any new case and filing of the additional documents
is necessary in order to rebut the case as stated by defendant in his WS.
21. In the judgment of Hon’ble High Court of Delhi, the case titled as
Valo
CS Comm. No.497/23
	Vijayant Kumar vs. Vikas Gupta
Page no. 8 of 15
-- 8 of 15 --
Automotive Pvt. Ltd. vs. Sprint Cars Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. CM(M)324/2021,
Delhi High Court, it is
inter alia held that,
“…..12. The learned Trial Court has referred to the
provisions of Order XI Rule 5 CPC, as applicable to the
commercial disputes. But, it has overlooked the provisions
of Order XI Rule 1(1)(c)(ii) CPC, which permits the plaintiff
to file documents in answer to the case set up by the
defendant subsequent to the filing of the plaint.The precise
case of the petitioner/plaintiff is that when the
respondents/respondents denied that invoices were ever
raised, the application was moved to bring the invoices on
record. Under Order XI Rule 5 CPC, the court can grant
leave to the plaintiff to file documents, not filed with the
plaint. The learned Commercial Court erred in over-looking
these provisions of the CPC…..”
22. In the judgment of Hon’ble High Court of Delhi, the case titled as
“
Hassad Food Company QSC & Anr. vs. Bank of India & Ors.” I.A.
3250/2019 in CS(COMM) 9/2018, wherein it is
inter alia held that,
“…..7. Case of the plaintiffs is that these documents could
not be filed earlier at the time of institution of the present
suit due to an administrative oversight on the part of the
plaintiffs, given the large volume of documents filed at that
point of time. Plaintiffs on realizing the omission have
preferred the present application at the earliest. It is also
claimed that the documents being sought to be placed on
record by way of this application are closely related to the
documents already on record and no new case is being
sought to be set up and the present documents are being filed
to bring completeness and context to the facts and
documents already on record. The application also notes that
the pleadings are yet to be completed and issues have not
been settled by this Court. Even till date when this
application was heard, the replications of the plaintiffs have
not been taken on record and issues had not been settled by
the Court. Learned counsel for the plaintiffs relies upon the
decision of the Division Bench of the Gujarat High Court
according to which under the Commercial Courts Act even if
CS Comm. No.497/23
	Vijayant Kumar vs. Vikas Gupta
Page no. 9 of 15
-- 9 of 15 --
Order VII Rule 14(3) CPC was not applicable, however
Order XI Rule 1(5) of CPC being applicable the plaintiffs
can be permitted to rely upon the documents not disclosed
along with the plaint with the leave of the Court subject to
compliance of the conditions mentioned under Order XI
Rule 1(5) as applicable to the Commercial Suits.…..”
“.....18. In the pleas taken in the present application the
defendants neither dispute the relevancy of the documents
nor that the documents sought to be filed do not relate to
them and the only objection taken is that the plaintiffs cannot
be allowed to file the documents at the belated stage. As
noted above in the present suit the pleadings are not
complete as yet as the replications are yet to be taken on
record and hence it cannot be said that the plaintiffs have
filed the present application so belatedly that it cannot be
allowed. Further the plaintiffs have very fairly taken the plea
of administrative oversight which can occur when the
number of documents is voluminous. Thus the plaintiffs
have made out a reasonable cause for not filing the
documents with the plaint.”
“19. There is yet another fact which needs consideration.
Most of the documents now sought to be filed by the
plaintiffs relate to the defendant banks which even the
defendant banks were required to disclose on affidavit along
with their written statements. However, without giving the
complete disclosure of the facts and the documents, the
defendants have put the plaintiffs to strict proof of the same.
By the present application, the plaintiffs are neither setting
up a new case nor withdrawing any admission. In similar
situation, a Single Bench of this Court in M/s. Fankaar's case
(supra) has permitted additional documents to be placed on
record. Consequently, the application is allowed.....”
23. Upon the bare perusal of the provision, it is clear that even though it is
the duty of the plaintiff to file all the documents in its power, possession or
custody of plaintiff on the date of filing of the suit. However, therein an
exception has been carved out by the legislature in Order XI Rule 1 (1) (c)
CS Comm. No.497/23
	Vijayant Kumar vs. Vikas Gupta
Page no. 10 of 15
-- 10 of 15 --
CPC which provides that the general rule regarding disclosure of documents
shall be shall not apply to those documents produced by the plaintiff in an
answer to any case set up by defendant subsequent to filing of plaint. Order
XI Rule 1 sub-rule (1)(c)(ii) CPC as applicable to the commercial disputes
permits the plaintiff to file the additional documents in answer to the case set
up by the defendants subsequent to filing of the suit.
24. In the case of
“Bhutani and Co. Pvt Ltd. Vs. Vias Dev” CM(M)
1072/2023 dated 13/09/2023, wherein, the Hon'ble Delhi High court has
observed that :
“12. In the opinion of this Court, the reliance placed on the said
document by the Respondent is not contrary to its pleadings in the suit.
The issue of permitting the plaintiff to file documents alongwith its
replication in the commercial suit has been considered by this Court in
several judgements and the Court has permitted the plaintiff to file said
documents. In fact, provisions of Order 11 CPC as amended by
Commercial Courts Act, 2015 and more specifically Order 11 Rule 1(1)
(c)(ii) of CPC therein contemplates that the plaintiff will be entitled to
file on record documents to answer the case set up by the defendant.
12.1. In this regard, it would be appropriate to refer to the judgement of
this Court in (i) Hassad Food Company Q.S.C. & ANR. vs. Bank of
India & Ors.; 2019/DHC/5253 (ii) Khurmi Associates (P) Ltd. vs.
Maharishi Dayanand Co-Operative Group Housing Society, 2022 SCC
OnLine Del 1011 (iii) Bennet Coleman & CO. Ltd. vs. Arg Outlier
Media Pvt Ltd & Ors.; 2023/DHC/001726.
12.2. Further replying upon the judgment of this Court in Bennet
Coleman (Supra) the Court held that the additional documents are
permitted to be taken on record on the ground that the additional
documents are in support of the pleadings and issues are yet to be
framed in the suit. The relevant extract of the judgment reads as under:
“11. The judgments in Hassad Food Company (supra), Mahesh
Chaudhri (supra) and Nitin Gupta (supra) were considered by me
in Khurmi Associates (P) Ltd. v. Maharishi Dayanand Co- CS
(COMM) 633/23 S B Sales Corporation Vs.Satish Kumar Mittal
Page No.8 of 12 Operative Group Housing Society, 2022 SCC
OnLine Del 1011. Relying upon the judgments in Hassad Food
Company (supra) and Mahesh Chaudhary (supra), the additional
CS Comm. No.497/23
	Vijayant Kumar vs. Vikas Gupta
Page no. 11 of 15
-- 11 of 15 --
documents were permitted to be taken on record on the ground that
issues were yet to be framed in the suit and the documents were in
support of the pleadings of the plaintiff company.
12. The facts in the present case are very similar to the facts in
Khurmi Associates (supra). Issues are yet to be framed in the suit.
It is an admitted position that the additional documents were filed
on behalf of the plaintiff on the same date as the replication. A
perusal of the pleadings in the suit would also show that the
aforesaid documents sought to be filed are not contrary to the
pleadings of the plaintiff in the suit. In my considered view, the
aforesaid documents would be relevant for the adjudication of the
present suit. (Emphasis Supplied)””
25. It is stated that through this application, the plaintiff is not setting up
any new case and filing of the additional documents is necessary in order to
rebut the case as stated by defendant in his WS. Therefore, in the interest of
justice and in view of the above judgment, the application of the plaintiff is
considered to be one under Order XI Rule 1 sub-rule (1)(c)(ii) CPC as
amended by the Commercial Courts Act. The list of documents along-with
the additional documents have been filed by the plaintiff.
26. The case is still at the initial stage and evidence of both parties is yet to
be recorded. Moreover, the documents which have plaintiff now wishes to
place on record are necessary to rebut the defence of the defendant as stated
in the W.S. This fact also cannot be lost sight of that the case had not
proceeded on merits after the filing of the WS. The document i.e. balance and
security confirmation certificate was filed by the plaintiff along with
replication itself and only the application for taking on record the said
document has been filed later on. Application of the plaintiff filed under
Order XI Rule 1(5) CPC is now considered to be one under Order XI Rule 1
CS Comm. No.497/23
	Vijayant Kumar vs. Vikas Gupta
Page no. 12 of 15
-- 12 of 15 --
sub-rule (1)(c)(ii) CPC as amended by the Commercial Courts Act, is thus,
allowed, in the interest of justice.
27. Now coming to the third application filed by the defendant under Or-
der VII Rule 10 CPC. It is stated on behalf of defendant that the plaintiff firm
is a GST registered firm which is at Meerut Zone, Commissionerate, Ghazi-
abad and the present Court does not have territorial jurisdiction to try and de-
cide the present suit as no cause of action has arisen in favour of plaintiff
within the jurisdiction of the present Court.
28. The plaintiff has filed reply to this application stating that the principal
office of the plaintiff as well as bank account of the plaintiff in which the de-
fendant has made partial payment with respect to the commercial transaction
between the parties is within the territorial jurisdiction of the present Court.
The plaintiff in its plaint has stated that the orders were placed by the defen-
dant in Delhi at registered office of the plaintiff at Gandhi Nagar for supply
of goods and also cause of action stated to have arisen within the jurisdiction
of the present Court. Further, it is stated that in the plaint that the bank ac-
count of the plaintiff in which the defendant has made part payment is situ-
ated within the jurisdiction of the present Court and therefore, the present
Court has territorial jurisdiction to try and entertain the present suit. It is a
settled proposition of law while considering the application under Order VII
Rule 10 CPC, it is only the plaint and the documents filed along with the
plaint which are required to be seen.
CS Comm. No.497/23
	Vijayant Kumar vs. Vikas Gupta
Page no. 13 of 15
-- 13 of 15 --
29. In the case titled as
“Jabir Hussain Trading As M/S Hakeem vs Ali As-
gar Trading As M/S. Hakeem” in RFA(COMM) 88/2024 (Delhi HC), decided
on 15 April, 2024, it has been observed that :
6. It is settled law that the question whether a plaint is required to be re -
turned at the threshold stage has to be examined on a demurrer, that is
accepting all averments made in the plaint to be correct. In Exphar SA
& Anr. v. Eupharma Laboratories Ltd. & Anr.: (2004) 3 SCC 688, the
Supreme Court had observed as under
"9. Besides, when an objection to jurisdiction is raised by way of
demurrer and not at the trial, the objection must proceed on the ba-
sis that the facts as pleaded by the initiator of the impugned pro-
ceedings are true. The submission in order to succeed must show
that granted those facts the court does not have jurisdiction as a
matter of law. In rejecting a plaint on the ground of jurisdiction, the
Division Bench should have taken the allegations contained in the
plaint to be correct. However, the Division Bench examined the
written statement filed by the respondents in which it was claimed
that the goods were not at all sold within the territorial jurisdiction
of the Delhi High Court and also that Respondent 2 did not carry on
business within the jurisdiction of the Delhi High Court..."
30. In the case titled as
“M/S Meyer Apparel Ltd vs M/S Panchanan Inter-
national Pvt Ltd” [CM(M) 1511/2018 (Delhi HC)] decided on 11 March,
2020, wherein it was held that :
8. It is a settled position of law that an application under Order 7
Rule 10 CPC is disposed of by considering the plaint with a demur.
The defence of the Defendant in the Written Statement is not to be
taken into account.
31. Perusal of the invoice reveals that there is a stipulation that all disputes
are subject to Delhi jurisdiction only and also the bank account of the plain-
tiff is stated in the invoice wherein the defendant was to make payment. The
balance confirmation certificate establishes that the bank account of the
plaintiff is within the jurisdiction of the present Court. Therefore, on the basis
of averments in the plaint, prima facie the present Court has territorial juris-
CS Comm. No.497/23
	Vijayant Kumar vs. Vikas Gupta
Page no. 14 of 15
-- 14 of 15 --
diction to try and decide the present Case. Accordingly, the application filed
by the defendant under order VII Rule 10 CPC stands dismissed in above said
terms with liberty to the defendant to address the issue again as per law after
the trial and at the time of final arguments.
32. All the pending applications stands disposed off accordingly. Plaintiff
to file affidavit of admission/denial of the documents of the defendant which
have now been taken on record within 3 weeks with advance copy to the op-
posite counsel. Defendant also to file affidavit of admission/denial of the ad-
ditional documents of the plaintiff which is to be taken on record within 3
weeks with advance copy to the opposite counsel.
33. Put up for admission/denial of documents as well as settlement of
issues on 16.01.2025.
(Kiran Bansal)
District Judge, Commercial Court-02,
Shahdara District, Karkardooma Courts,
Delhi / 05.12.2024.
Digital signature not appended as the same have expired and renewal of the same has been applied.
CS Comm. No.497/23
	Vijayant Kumar vs. Vikas Gupta
Page no. 15 of 15
-- 15 of 15 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.