Full Order Text
Final Order 10 · 12 Mar 2024 · CNR DLSH010059822023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. REETESH SINGH, DISTRICT JUDGE COMMERCIAL COURT-04, SHAHDARA, KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI CNR No. DLSH01-005982-2023 CS (Comm) No.479/2023 In the matter of :- Punjab & Sind Bank having Its Head Office at: Bank House, 21, Rajendra Place, New Delhi. Branch Office at : Viveka Nand School Branch, Anand Vihar, Delhi-110092 ......Plaintiff (Through Ld. Counsel Sh. Prabhakar Awasthi) Versus 1. Sh. Umesh Aggarwal S/o Sh. Heera Lal Aggarwal ...... Defendant no.1 (Defendant no.1 is deceased) 2. Smt. Vandana Aggarwal W/o Sh. Umesh Aggarwal Both Resident of : B-36, Mansarovar Park, East Delhi, Shahdara, Delhi-110032 Defendant no.2 (Defendant No.2 is Ex-parte) Date of institution of the case : 25.09.2023 Date of final arguments : 07.03.2024 Date of judgment : 12.03.2024 CS (Comm) No. 479/2023 Page 1 /5 -- 1 of 5 -- EX- PARTE JUDGMENT 1. This suit has been filed by the plaintiff M/s Punjab & Sind Bank against Sh. Umesh Aggarwal (borrower) and his wife Smt. Vandana Aggarwal (Co-borrower) praying for a decree for recovery of Rs.4,18,731.95p along with interest pendent lite and future @ 11.10% per annum compounded with monthly rests and costs of the suit. 2. Plaintiff has averred that the defendants no.1 and 2 on 27.12.2018 requested the plaintiff bank for grant of a Vehicle/Term Loan under the Apna Vahan Loan Scheme for purchase of Maruti Suzuki ECCO CNG Van for a sum of Rs.3,96,000/- which was granted by the plaintiff bank vide sanction letter dated 31.12.2018 against Loan account no.09011200047371. The loan was to be repaid with interest @ 9.10% per annum with monthly rests (subject to change as per RBI/PLR of plaintiff bank) and the same was disbursed in the loan account of the defendants on 04.01.2019. 3. It is averred that against the said loan, the defendants executed loan documents which are detailed in Para 5 of the plaint. However, the defendants 1 and 2 failed to adhere to financial discipline and did not repay the loan in terms of the loan agreement. On 30.06.2021 the defendants executed a revival letter and deposited Rs.6,000/- towards part payment of the loan after which no payment was made. Several requests were made by the plaintiff bank to the defendants to make payments but they did not do so. It is averred that the plaintiff served a notice dated 02.08.2021 on the defendants under Section 13 (2) of the SARFAESI Act 2002 to the defendants 1 and 2 but they did not respond. It is averred that as on 01.09.2023, Rs.4,18,731.95p was due against the defendants in respect of the loan account payable with interest @ 11.10% per annum (including 2% penal interest) w.e.f. 01.09.2023. 4. Before filing of this suit, the plaintiff bank availed the remedy of pre- institution mediation under Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act 2015 CS (Comm) No. 479/2023 Page 2 /5 -- 2 of 5 -- before the Shahdara District Legal Services Authority on 02.08.2023 which was closed as Non-Starter on 28.08.2023. 5. By order dated 26.09.2023, summons of the suit was issued to the defendants for 26.10.2023. On 26.10.2023 it is recorded that summons sent by speed post and registered post were received back with the report that no such person was found at the given address. On an application of the plaintiff bank under Order V Rule 20 of the CPC on the ground that no other address was available, the defendants were directed to be served by way of publication in newspaper ‘Statesman’. Publication of summons was carried out in edition dated 02.11.2023 of the said newspaper. However, on 06.12.2023 it was informed that in another suit CS (Comm.) No.539/2023 titled Punjab and Sind Bank vs. Mr. Umesh Aggarwal it was reported that Sh. Umesh Aggarwal had died. On 15.01.2024 it was informed that the defendant no.2 Smt. Vandana Aggarwal was still residing at the same premises and dasti summons were directed to be issued against the defendant no.2. On 14.02.2024 it was reported that Smt. Vandana Aggarwal had left the given premises quite some time ago and her current address was not available. As summons had already been served by way of publication upon the defendant no.2 Smt. Vandana Aggarwal, who stands impleaded as a co-borrower, she was proceeded ex- parte by order dated 27.02.2024. It may be noted that on 27.02.2024, Sh. Prabhakar Awasthi, Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff bank had stated at the Bar that he was not moving any application to implead legal heirs of the deceased defendant no.1 Sh. Umesh Aggarwal as he did not have any information of his legal heirs except his wife Smt. Vandana Aggarwal who was already impleaded as defendant no.2. 6. The plaintiff bank led evidence and examined Sh. Suresh Kumar, Senior Manager as PW-1 who deposed by way of his affidavit Ex.PW1/A and tendered in evidence the following documents :- (a) Copy of General Power of Attorney vide Ex.PW-1/1 (OSR) CS (Comm) No. 479/2023 Page 3 /5 -- 3 of 5 -- (b) Original Authorization letter dated 11.09.2023 vide Ex.PW-1/2 (c) Original Sanction letter dated 31.12.2018 vide Ex.PW-1/3 (d) Original Attested memo of documents dated 31.12.2018 vide Ex.PW-1/4 (e) Original letter of Hyphenation-cum-agreement for vehicle dated 31.12.2018 vide Ex.PW-1/5 (f) Copy of Notice dated 02.08.2021 under Section 13 (2) of the Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act vide Ex.PW-1/6 (g) Statement of account for the period 04.01.2019 to 01.09.2023 vide Ex.PW-1/7 (h) Certificate of Non-Starter Report dated 28.08.2023 vide Ex.PW-1/8 (I) Revival letter dated 21.01.2021 vide Ex.PW-1/9 (j) Certificate under Section 65 B of Indian Evidence Act vide Ex.PW-1/10. 6. As the defendant no.2 was ex-parte, PW-1 was not subjected to any cross-examination. Plaintiff thereafter closed its evidence. 7. Arguments were addressed by Sh. Prabhakar Awasthi, Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff who submitted that the case of the plaintiff in the plaint and evidence led stood unrebutted. He submitted that even though the defendant no.1 Sh. Umesh Aggarwal had died, his wife Smt. Vandana Aggarwal being co-borrower and defendant no.2 will be equally liable to repay the loan amount. He submitted that the plaintiff was therefore entitled to the decree as prayed for. 8. I have heard the Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff and have perused the record of the case. Defendant no.1 is deceased. Defendant no.2 did not appear to defend the suit. The averments made by the plaintiff in the plaint and evidence led by PW-1 have gone unrebutted and unchallenged. The documents placed on record by the plaintiff are deemed to have been admitted by the defendant no.2. The plaintiff has proved on record, amongst others, the sanction letter, loan documents, notice dated 02.08.2021 and statement of loan account for the period 04.01.2019 to 01.09.2023. The same reveals that as on CS (Comm) No. 479/2023 Page 4 /5 -- 4 of 5 -- 01.09.2023 an amount of Rs.4,18,731.95p was due and outstanding against the defendant no.2. The plaintiff is held entitled for recovery of the same. 9. Plaintiff has claimed interest @ 11.10% per annum compounded with monthly rests, which seems to be excessive. In the opinion of this Court grant of simple interest @ 9% per annum on the amount of Rs.4,18,731.95p from the date of filing of the suit till the date of realisation shall meet the ends of justice. Costs of the suit are awarded in favour of the plaintiff. Legal fees and expenses of the plaintiff are assessed at Rs.11,000/-. RELIEF :- 10. For the reasons recorded above, suit of the plaintiff is decreed in the following manner :- (a) Plaintiff is granted a decree for recovery of Rs.4,18,731.95p along with simple interest @ 9% per annum from the date of filing of the suit till the date of realisation against the defendant no.2; (b) Plaintiff shall be entitled to Legal fees and expenses of Rs.11,000/- and costs of the suit along with simple interest @ 9% per annum from the date of the decree till the date of realization, against the defendant no.2. 11. Decree sheet be prepared. File be consigned to record room. Announced in the open (REETESH SINGH) court on this 12th day DISTRICT JUDGE of March 2024 (COMMERCIAL COURT)-04 SHAHDARA, KKD COURTS, DELHI CS (Comm) No. 479/2023 Page 5 /5 -- 5 of 5 --
