Full Order Text
Final Order 5 · 23 Feb 2024 · CNR DLSH010056632023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SHRI ARVIND BANSAL ADDL. SESSIONS JUDGE–05 (SHAHDARA DISTRICT) KARKARDOOMA COURTS : DELHI Criminal Revision No. 243/2023 Police Station: Vivek Vihar Vimal Kumar S/o Sh. Ganesh Dass R/o H. No. 802, Street No. 5, Jwala Nagar, Shahdara, Delhi-110032. ....... Revisionist Vs. 1. The State (GNCT of Delhi) Through S.H.O. Police Station Vivek Vihar Delhi-110094 2. Inspector Narender Singh S.H.O. Police Station Vivek Vihar ...... Respondents Date of institution : 12.09.2023 Date of reserving order : 08.01.2024 Date of order : 23.02.2024 O R D E R 1. Vide this order, the Court shall decide one revision petition filed by revisionist, challenging impugned orders dated 18.07.2023 passed by Ld. Trial Court, thereby ordering issuance of NBWs against the accused/revisionist and order dt. 02.08.2023 passed by Court of Ld. CMM, Shahdara, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi, thereby initiating process u/s 82 Cr.P.C. against the revisionist in FIR No. 254/2023 PS Vivek Vihar titled “State Vs. Vimal Rahi S/o Ganesh Dass”. Vimal Kumar Vs. State Page 1 of 9 -- 1 of 9 -- 2. The facts leading to registration of FIR No. 254/2023 PS Vivek Vihar, and the filing of present revision petition are follows: On 29.06.2023, HC Anuj of PS Vivek Vihar was on patrolling duty as per DD no. 6A. When he returned to Jwala Nagar Police Booth after dropping one HC Subhash, one secret informer met him and stated that Vimal Rahi (revisionist herein) who was the BC of that area and had also been externed, is living in Delhi and is present at his house. He further informed that illicit liquor is supposed to be landed at his house since it was a dry day. On the basis of secret information, HC Anuj alongwith Ct. Kailash went to the house of revisionist Vimal Rahi where HC Anuj met son of revisionist namely Akshay Rahi and verbal altercation took place between them. On alarm being raised by Akshay Rahi, his father/revisionist came there and physical altercation took place between revisionist and his son Akshay Rahi on one side and HC Anun and Ct. Kailash on the other. Revisionist started calling his relatives there on which, wife of revisionist namely Poonam, daughter of revisionist namely Bhumi, daughter-in-law of revisionist namely Anjali, and relatives of revisionist namely Reena, Shobha, Sapna and Sahil came at the spot and they all assaulted HC Anuj and Ct. Kailash. During the said assault, Akshay Rahi strangulated HC Anuj, Poonam bit on his right hand and co-accused persons extended beatings upon HC Anuj and Ct. Kailash using fist and legs blows. On the basis of MLCs of HC Anuj and Ct. Kailash and statement of HC Anuj, FIR 254/2023 under Section Vimal Kumar Vs. State Page 2 of 9 -- 2 of 9 -- 307/186/353/332/341/506/34 IPC and 53/116 DP Act was registered against all the abovesaid accused persons. On 18.07.2023, an application was filed by IO/Deputed IO before the Court of Ld. MM-02/Shahdara requesting issuance of NBWs against accused Vimal Rahi wherein it was submitted that multiple raids were conducted to nab accused Vimal Rahi. Ld. Court issued NBWs against the accused for 02.08.2023. On 02.08.2023, SI Amit Malik submitted a report before Ld. CMM, Shahdara qua execution of NBWs issued against accused. It was reported that on 01.08.2023, raid was conducted at the house of accused Vimal Rahi, however, he was not found and his wife stated that his whereabouts are not known to them. On 02.08.2023, deputed IO/SI Amit Malik moved an application before the Court of Ld. CMM, Shahdara, Karkardooma Courts seeking issuance of Process U/s 82/83 Cr.P.C. Ld. CMM ordered issuance of process U/s 82 Cr.P.C. against accused Vimal Rahi, however, declined the request of issuance of process U/s 83 Cr.P.C. 3. Ld. MM-02/Shahdara made following observations while passing the impugned order dated 18.07.2023: “Case diary seen. As per case diary, multiple raids have been conducted to nab the accused on multiple dates. It seems that accused is deliberately avoiding process of law. In view of the submissions and averements made in the application, NBW be issued against the accused for 02.08.2023.” Vimal Kumar Vs. State Page 3 of 9 -- 3 of 9 -- 4. Ld. CMM/Shahdara made following observations while passing the impugned order dt. 02.08.2023: “…... Heard. Case diary perused. Considering the reasons mentioned in the application and submissions made by the IO, the Court is satisfied that accused Vimal Rahi is deliberately not joining the investigation and concealing himself to evade the process of law. Therefore, let process U/s 82Cr.P.C. be issued against the accused Vimal Rahi S/o Sh. Ganesh Dass by way of affixation, bearing of drums and publications in one English and one Hindi daily newspaper as per the provisions U/s 82 Cr.P.C., returnable for 12.09.2023 at 12:00 noon and a complete 30 days time be given to the accused to produce himself before IO/SHO concerned as perthe provisions under Cr.P.C. and join the investigation of the present case. However, at this stage, there is nothing on record to suggest that the accused is about to dispose of the whole or path of his property, or is about to remove the whole or part of his property from the local jurisdiction of this Court, the request for issuance of process under Section 83 Cr.P.C. is declined. Application at hand stands disposed of. Copy of this order be given dasti to IO, as prayed for.” 5. The revisionist raised the following grounds: a) That the impugned order dt. 18.07.2023 issuing NBWs against the revisionist be set aside and that in view of the externment order dt. 14.03.2023 U/s 47 of D.P. Act passed by Addl. DCP, Shahdara District, Delhi externing the revisionist for two years, he can not be declared having absconded or concealing himself. b) That the police officials of PS Vivek Vihar acted vindictively against accused/revisionist and his family and wife of revisionist had also filed a complaint in this regard on 26.01.2023. Vimal Kumar Vs. State Page 4 of 9 -- 4 of 9 -- c) That accused/revisionist had filed a complaint u/s 200 Cr.P.C r/w Sec. 156(3) Cr.P.C before Ld. CMM Shahara against respondent no. 2, HC Ajeet and HC Nitin on 25.03.2023 for commission of various offences and filing of such a complaint escalated the wrath of respondent no. 2 and his team against the revisionist and as such, false FIR was registered against him. d) That Ld. MM passed the impugned order dated 18.07.2023 without appreciating the facts, and without application of mind. & e) That Ld. Trial Court did not consider the guidelines of Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in ‘Sunil Tyagi vs. State of NCT of Delhi’ and passed the impugned order dated 02.08.2023 without perusing the documents and without any inquiry. 6. Ld. Counsel for revisionists reiterated the aforesaid grounds while making arguments before this Court. It is stated that Ld. Trial Court passed impugned orders without considering the material on record and applicable law and the fact that revisionist had been externed from Delhi for a period of two years and as such, no proceedings either of issuance of NBWs or proclamation u/s 82 Cr.P.C could have been initiated against him. He pleaded this Court to set aside the impugned orders. 7. Notice of the revision Petition was served upon the respondent no. 1/State through Ld. Addl. PP for State. Report/reply was filed by IO/SI Amit Malik and the same was Vimal Kumar Vs. State Page 5 of 9 -- 5 of 9 -- considered the reply of State to the revision petition of the accused/revisionist. Copy thereof was supplied to revisionist. 8. Per contra, it argued by Ld. Addl. PP for State that impugned orders have been rightly passed by Ld. Trial Court after considering the reports of IO and perusing the case diary. It is stated that IO was constrained to get NBWs and process u/s 82 Cr.P.C issued against the accused/revisionist as he was evading the process of law and was not found at any of his known addresses. It is pleaded that orders be upheld and Ld. Trial Court be directed to proceed u/s 82 Cr.P.C against accused/revisionist. 9. Submissions heard. Record perused. 10. This Court has perused both the impugned orders dated 18.07.2023 & 02.08.2023. The Court also perused the application of IO moved before the Ld. Trial Court on 18.07.2023 for issuance of NBWs. It is noted that IO has specifically recorded in the application that several raids were conducted to nab accused/revisionist Vimal. IO has referred to one raid dated 01.07.2023, 05.07.2023 and 17.07.2023. His wife Poonam Rahi did not disclose his whereabouts to the investigating agency when raid was conducted at his house in Delhi. Since custodial interrogation was required and one hard disc had to be recovered, IO moved an application seeking issuance of NBWs against accused/revisionist. The Court considered the detailed application and perused the case diary. The case diary confirmed that multiple Vimal Kumar Vs. State Page 6 of 9 -- 6 of 9 -- raids had been conducted to nab accused/revisionist on multiple dates. In view of such circumstances, Court ordered issuance of NBWs against accused/revisionist for 02.08.2023. 11. On the next date i.e. 02.08.2023, a report regarding execution of NBWs against accused alongwith an application seeking issuance of process u/s 82/83 Cr.P.C was filed before Ld. CMM, Shahdara. This Court has perused the report, application and the impugned order dated 02.08.2023. It is specifically recorded in the application that on 25.07.2023, raid was conducted at Shahdara address of accused/revisionist while on 29.07.2023, raid was conducted at the Vasundhara, Ghaziabad address of accused/revisionist. However, accused could not be found. Court considered the submissions of IO and after being satisfied that accused Vimal Rahi was deliberately not joining the investigation and concealing himself to evade the process of law, ordered issuance of process u/s 82 Cr.P.C against him. 12. It is noted that recently vide order dated 20.02.2024, Hon’ble High Court of Delhi dismissed the anticipatory bail application of accused/revisionist. The argument of Ld. Counsel for accused/revisionist that the present FIR was registered against him and his family members out of personal vendetta and vindictive attitude of respondent no. 2 and his team of police officials of PS Vivek Vihar has been rejected even by the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi. There appears no reasonable justification Vimal Kumar Vs. State Page 7 of 9 -- 7 of 9 -- for considering such an argument in a revision petition seeking setting aside of impugned orders issuing process u/s 82 Cr.P.C. Such an argument may be a probable defence of accused/revisionist during trial of case FIR No. 254/2023 PS Vivek Vihar. 13. It is also the argument of Ld. Counsel for accused/revisionist that Ld. Trial Court did not consider the guidelines of Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in Sunil Tyagi’s case (supera) while passing impugned order dated 18.07.2023 & 02.08.2023. In this regard, it is noted that vide order dated 09.09.2022, Hon’ble Supreme Court in case titled ‘Union of India vs. Sunil Tyagi & Anr.’ has stayed the operation of judgment of Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in Sunil Tyagi’s case. In such circumstances, accused/revisionist cannot plead non- compliance of the guidelines in the said matter either by the IO or by Ld. Trial Court. 14. It is the argument that since accused/revisionist had been externed from the territory of Delhi for a period of two years, there was no ground for the IO to visit his address at Shahdara for execution either of NBWs or process u/s 82 Cr.P.C. In the opinion of this Court, such an arguments cannot be considered in the light of peculiar facts and circumstances of the present case where the alleged offence was committed by accused/revisionist during the period of externment within the territory of Delhi. It is also oberved that IO was not wholly unjustified in visiting the place of accused/revisionist for Vimal Kumar Vs. State Page 8 of 9 -- 8 of 9 -- execution of NBWs as accused/revisionist could have been found at his place despite the externment order against him. Further, it is specifically noted in the application of the IO as well as order of Ld. Trial Court dated 02.08.2023 that a raid was conducted even at the Ghaziabad address of accused/revisionist and as such, the ground of visit to the Shahdara address cannot be pleaded to seek setting aside of the impugned orders. In the opinion of this Court, IO was justified not only in seeking issuance of NBWs but also process u/s 82 Cr.P.C accused/revisionist. Further, Ld. Trial Court also considered all the facts and circumstances including the report and case diary of the IO before passing both the impugned orders dated 18.07.2023 and 02.08.2023. In the opinion of this Court, there is no illegality or impropriety or incorrectness in the orders of Ld. Trial Court. No ground to set aside either of the orders in exercise of limited revisional jurisdiction is made out. Accordingly, present revison is dismissed. 15. File of present revision be consigned to Record Room after due compliance. Dictated & announced in the open Court on 23.02.2024. (ARVIND BANSAL) Addl. Sessions Judge-05 (Shahdara) Karkardooma Courts, Delhi Vimal Kumar Vs. State Page 9 of 9 -- 9 of 9 --
