Full Order Text
Final Order 8 · 18 Jan 2024 · CNR DLSH010056032023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: -1- Bail Matters No. 1805/2023 State Vs. Ram Kumar FIR No. 191/2023 PS Shahdara U/s 419/420/506/34 IPC 18.01.2024 This is an application u/s 438 Cr.PC for grant of anticipatory bail moved on behalf of the applicant/accused Ram Kumar. Present:- Sh. Sobit, Ld. Additional PP for the State. Sh. Praveen Chaudhary, Ld. counsel for applicant/accused Ram Kumar. Sh. Pradeep Prajapati and Sh. Charanjeet Singh, Ld. counsel for complainant. IO/SI Brij Mohan is present from DIU Shahdara. ORDER 1. It is submitted by Ld. Counsel for the applicant/ accused that he has been falsely implicated in this case and the present FIR is counter blast to the civil suit filed by the applicant in CS No. 566/2022 titled Dinesh Sharma and Ors. Vs. Dalchand and Ors for declaration, permanent and mandatory injunction and applicant is the co-plaintiff in the said suit. It is further submitted that a trust deed was executed in 1973 and father of the applicant was one of the trustees and after his father, applicant/accused Ram Kumar became one of the trustees of the said property/ temple and complainant is only a trespasser in the said property/temple without any right and authority and he wants to grab the property of the trust with his associates, who was appointed in 2007, in the temple only to conduct certain rituals. It is further submitted that applicant/accused had joined the investigation after being served the notice u/s 41 A Cr.PC and -- 1 of 5 -- -2- provided all the documents required by the IO and cooperated during the investigation and for the last several months, the interim bail of the accused was granted and extended time to time and no purpose would be served by sending the applicant/ accused behind the bars as Section 420 IPC is punishable upto 7 years. 2. The bail application is opposed by Ld. APP for the State, who argued that the applicant/accused has played an active role in the crime and he collected the donation from the various persons on behalf of the trust along with co-accused Dinesh Sharma, who represented himself as one of the trustees, even after he was expelled from the trust in December, 2022 and still, they carried their illegal activities and did not give receipt of the payments received by them on behalf of the trust and the investigation is still pending. 3. IO has filed a reply and opposed the bail application. 4. Ld. Counsel for complainant opposed the bail application and reiterated the arguments of Ld. APP and further submits that in case, the accused is granted bail stringent conditions must be imposed upon him. 5. I have heard the rival contentions of the bail application and perused the record. 6. As per the prosecution case, the present case was registered on the complaint of complainant Dalchand Sharma against applicant/accused and others on 26.06.2023 with the allegations that complainant was a Mahant of Shree Durga Mandir Trust (Regd.), Durga Mandir, Durga Puri Chowk, Shahdara Delhi and on 21.08.2022, he was appointed as the -- 2 of 5 -- -3- Chairman of the said trust and in the elections, accused Dinesh Sharma was removed from the post of Secretary and he was just a trustee and on 26.12.2022, he was expelled from the trust after the meeting and consent of all. On 29.10.2022, co-accused Dinesh Sharma had a meeting with illegal trustees. On 10.06.2022, they had got executed one gift deed from Rajiv Chauhan which was reported to the police. Co-accused Dinesh Sharma during his tenure of Secretary of trust had not taken the rent of shop of the trust for a period of 85 months from accused Saurabh Bhardwaj and had run the electricity on theft and had not deposited the rent of his office for a period of 26 months. After being expelled from the trust, on 12.06.2022, co-accused Dinesh Sharma had put hoardings, pamphlets etc. on new year and other festivals claiming himself to be the Secretary of the Trust and he represent himself to be the Secretary of the Trust and collected donations on Holi i.e. 05.03.2023 and used filthy language against the real trustees including the complainant. It is also alleged that applicant/accused and others had taken donation from Krishan Sharma Giriniz, Vijay, Narender and others and did not give the receipt and also threatened them. 7. The FIR is registered u/s 419/420/506/34 IPC and the maximum punishment of said offences is up to 7 years and initially, IO did not give notice u/s 41-A of Cr.PC to the applicant/accused and only on the directions of the court, the IO had given the said notice. The applicant/accused had complied with the notice and as per the IO, accused had joined the investigation. The investigation is still incomplete. -- 3 of 5 -- -4- 8. The present case was registered due to dispute in the trust and that applicant and his associates i.e. his brother Ashok Sharma, Dinesh Sharma, Saurabh Bhardwaj, Pawan Sharma and Raju Singhal had represented themselves to be the office bearers and collected money. As per the IO, nothing is to be recovered from applicant/accused and the case is dependent of recording of the statement of the witnesses and donation receipts, elections documents of the trust, documents relating to the members of the trust during the relevant period. As per reply, IO had already collected the registration documents of Durga Mandir Trust and also the supplementary trust deed of the Sub-Registrar Office, the applicant has on interim bail on last several months and investigation has not been concluded even after 06 months of the registration of FIR. Ld. Counsel submits that he is further ready to cooperate the investigation. There is no previous involvement of the accused brought on record. The applicant/accused is permanent resident of said locality and there is no possibility to flee and the role attributive to him is that he was part of the team of co-accused Dinesh Sharma and others who had collected the donations. The civil dispute is also pending between the parties in this regard. 9. Considering the above facts and circumstances, the bail application of applicant/accused Ram Kumar is allowed and he is admitted to anticipatory bail on his furnishing a personal bond in the sum of Rs. 30,000/- with one surety of like amount to the satisfaction of IO/SHO concerned in the event of his arrest subject to the following conditions:- -- 4 of 5 -- -5- i) That the applicant/accused shall make himself available for interrogation by a police officer as and when required. ii) That the applicant/accused shall not, directly or indirectly, make any inducement, threat or promise to any person acquainted with the facts of the case including complainant so as to dissuade him from disclosing such facts of the court or to any police officer. iii) That the applicant/accused shall not leave India without the previous permission of the court iv) That the applicant/accused shall not carry any activity on behalf of trust without the leave of the court and shall provide all his phone numbers and residential addresses to the IO/SHO concerned. 10. In case any of the conditions is violated, the complainant/prosecution is at liberty to file cancellation of bail. 11. Nothing mentioned herein shall tantamount to any expression on the merits of the case. The bail application is accordingly disposed of. Copy of this order be sent to IO/SHO concerned and be given dasti to Ld. counsel for accused. (Kumar Rajat) ASJ-07/SHD/KKD Courts/Delhi 18.01.2024 -- 5 of 5 --
