Full Order Text
Final Order 4 · 04 Mar 2024 · CNR DLSH010055622023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF MS. SURABHI SHARMA VATS: ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE-04: SHAHDARA: KKD COURT: DELHI. Crl. ID No.239/2023 1. Sh. Gaurav Babu S/o. Sh. Laxmi Narayan 2. Krishna, S/o Sh. Ram Pratap, Both R/o Ram Pratap, H. No.94, Gali no.2, Saboli Khadda, Mandoli, North East, Delhi-110093. ........... Revisionist Versus 1. The State & Ors. 2. Sagar S/o. Sh. Brijesh 3. Brijesh (father of Sagar) Both R/o H. No.590, Gali No.2, Saboli Khadda, Mandoli, North East, Delhi-110093. 4. Munna @ Chotu (friend of Sagar) Add. Not Known 5. Anjali (Sister of Sagar) 6. Mother of Sagar Both R/o H. No.590, Gali No.2, Saboli Khadda, Mandoli, North East, Delhi-110093. 7. Factory labour of Brijesh working at H. No.590, Gali No.2, Saboli Khadda, Mandoli, North East, Delhi-110093. ....Respondents Date of Institution : 15.09.2023 Order reserved on : 19.02.2024 Order delivered on : 04.03.2024 _____________________________________________________________________________ CR No. 239/2023 Gaurav Babu Vs. State & Ors. Page 1 of 10 -- 1 of 10 -- ORDER 1. This revision petition is preferred u/s. 397 Cr.P.C by the complainants against the order dated 18.05.2023 (hereinafter referred as impugned order) in case FIR No287/2022, PS. Harsh Vihar, State Vs. Sheelu & Ors. passed by Ld. MM-07, Shahdara, KKD Courts, Delhi, whereby Ld. Trial Court framed charge against the respondents/ accused persons only for the offences U/s 323/341/506(ii)/34 IPC. 2. An application under section 5 of Limitation Act, 1963 seeking condonation of delay in filing the present revision petition is also filed on record. Ld. Counsel for the revisionists submits that vide order dated 18.05.2023, . Ld. Trial Court has framed the charges against the accused persons after deciding the protest petition (for adding/ framing charges U/s 308 IPC) filed by the revisionists which was disposed off/ dismissed vide order dated 14.12.2022. Ld. Counsel further stated that he had initially filed a revision petition against the order dated 14.12.2022. However, since the Ld. MM framed the charge vide order dated 18.05.2023 during pendency of that revision petition, he withdrew the said revision petition and had filed another revision petition (present petition) challenging order on charge dated 18.05.2023. It is further submitted that due to this technical issue, this fresh revision petition against the order dated 18.05.2023 of Ld. MM, has been thus, filed with a delay of 14 days. 3. At the very outset, this Court deems it apposite to quote a Judgment on the point of condonation of delay i.e. 'Sheoraj Singh Through LRs and Ors. Vs. Union of India & Anr.' dated 09.10.2023, _____________________________________________________________________________ CR No. 239/2023 Gaurav Babu Vs. State & Ors. Page 2 of 10 -- 2 of 10 -- Civil Appeal No. 5867 of 2015, wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India has reiterated as under:- “16. In Collector, Land Acquisition, Anantnag & Anr. v. Mst. Katiji & Ors. the relevant High court did not condone the delay of 4 (four) days in presentation of an appeal by the Collector in a land acquisition matter for which the order rejecting the application under section 5 of the Limitation Act was carried in appeal. This Court opined that legislature had conferred power under section 5 in order to enable the courts to do substantial justice to the parties by disposing of matters on “merits”. It was further held that the expression “sufficient cause” employed by the legislature is adequately elastic to enable the courts to apply the law in a meaningful manner which sub-serves the ends of justice — that being the life-purpose for the existence of the institution of courts. Despite the liberal approach being adopted in such matters, which was termed justifiable, this Court lamented that the message had not percolated down to all the other courts in the hierarchy and, accordingly, emphasis was laid on the Courts adopting a (1987) 2 SCC 107. liberal and justice-oriented approach. The following passage from the decision is reflective of this Court’s realization that: “3. […] And such a liberal approach is adopted on principle as it is realized that: 4. When substantial justice and technical considerations are pitted against each other, cause of substantial justice deserves to be preferred for the other side cannot claim to have vested right in injustice being done because of a non-deliberate delay. 6. It must be grasped that judiciary is respected not on account of its power to legalise injustice on technical grounds but because it is capable of removing injustice and is expected to do so.” (bold in original)". 4. There is no strict jacket formula which may apply to all the situations and cases where there is a delay and thus, each case for condonation of delay is based on the existence or absence of the sufficient cause or explanation. Therefore, every such case has to be decided on its own cause or merits. It is also trite law that section 5 of Limitation Act must receive a liberal interpretation so as to advance the legal remedy/ substantial justice and delays in preferring a revision or _____________________________________________________________________________ CR No. 239/2023 Gaurav Babu Vs. State & Ors. Page 3 of 10 -- 3 of 10 -- appeal should ordinarily be condoned in the larger interest of justice, provided no gross or deliberate negligence or lack of bonafide is imputable to the parties seeking condonation of delay. Thus, the approach of the Court while disposing off an application for condonation of delay needs to be pragmatic and it has to be borne in mind that the substantive right of any party is not defeated at the very threshold simply because of some technical considerations. In the instance case at hand, keeping in view the reasons as explained in the application alongwith supporting affidavit of the revisionist, the delay in filing this revision petition is hereby, condoned. 5. Ld. Counsel for both the revisionists/ complainants has argued on merits, that the incident in question had occurred due to furore and wrath of the accused persons with the revisionist no.1/ complainant due to previous instance which had occurred between the accused/ respondent Sagar and revisionist no.1/ complainant Gaurav Babu; that as per the MLCs, both the revisionists (Complainant and his landlord Krishna), have received multiple injuries on their person which makes it clear that both revisionists had been brutally beaten up, by the accused persons/ respondents. However, the doctor opined the injuries to be simple in nature; that the expert remained silent with regard to kind of weapon used by accused persons and had not recorded the statement of any of the victim. 6. It is further argued that on the plain reading of section 308 IPC, it makes clear that nature of injury is not required in order to invoke section 308 IPC and thus, in the present case, the injury has been caused on vital part of the body of the victims/ injured persons; Section _____________________________________________________________________________ CR No. 239/2023 Gaurav Babu Vs. State & Ors. Page 4 of 10 -- 4 of 10 -- 308 IPC should be invoked against the accused persons; that the Ld. Trial Court has relied on the MLC report and conflict in statement of victims but did not consider the fact that when these statements were recorded, both the victims were not in a condition to understand the situation due to pain; that even police tried to suppress the various facts and they did not carry out fair investigation in this case; that police did not record the statement of both the revisionists at the time of lodging of FIR in question; that the police officials did not bring on record the CCTV footage of camera installed in the street where incident took place, which is a crucial evidence. 7. Per Contra, it is argued by Ld. Addl. PP for the State that charge only U/s 323/341/506/34 IPC is made out against the accused persons and rightly so, Ld. Trial Court has framed the charges under these sections against all the accused persons. It is further argued that the Ld. Trial Court vide order dated 14.12.2022 has already dismissed the protest petition of the complainant/ revisionists herein on the ground that there is no sufficient material to point that the accused has mens rea for commission of offence under section 308 IPC, as it appears that the matter escalated on account the shove from the accused Sagar to the complainant and the attack from the dandas was made only thereafter and accordingly, vide the said order, Ld. MM took cognizance of the offences U/s 323/341/506/34 IPC. It is further argued by Ld. Addl. PP for the State that the Complainant/ injured Gaurav Babu had given his written complaint in the concerned P.S. mentioning all the facts therein. Thus, no question arises, of Police not recording his statement or Police adding or suppressing any contents from that complaint of the complainant/ _____________________________________________________________________________ CR No. 239/2023 Gaurav Babu Vs. State & Ors. Page 5 of 10 -- 5 of 10 -- injured, which forms the basis of present case FIR. 8. Arguments advanced by Sh. Saurabh Sharma and Sh. Rishabh Tyagi, Ld. Counsels for Revisionists, as also by Sh. Vineet Kumar, Ld. Addl. PP for the State/Respondent No.1 have been heard and the entire record is perused by this Court. 9. Needless to state that an order framing charge or discharge is not interlocutory in nature and is therefore, not affected by the statutory bar U/s 397(2) Cr.PC. In this view, this Court is fortified with a Judgment titled as 'Sanjay Kumar Rai vs The State Of Uttar Pradesh decided on 7 May, 2021, Crl. Appeal NO.472 OF 2021'. 10. Perusal of the order dated 14.12.2022 passed by Ld. Trial Court (Ld.MM-07/SHD/KKD/ Delhi) vide which he dismissed the protest petition of the revisionist and took cognizance of the offences U/s 323/341/506/34 IPC, reveals that : - "From the material on record, prima facie offence under section 308/326 IPC is not attracted at this stage. Both the victims have stated differently with respect to the weapon of offence and no such weapon has been recovered. Further, the opinion of the doctor with respect to the injuries, albeit at a vtial part, are that the same are simple. The gist of the offence under section 308 IPC is the mens rea of the accused. From the statement of the witnesses and other material on record, there is no sufficient material to point that the accused had mens rea for commission of offence under section 308 IPC, as it as it appears that the matter escalated on account the shove from the accused Sagar to the complainant and the attack from the dandas was made only thereafter. The accused initially had no weapons with them and they fled away after other persons gathered on the spot." _____________________________________________________________________________ CR No. 239/2023 Gaurav Babu Vs. State & Ors. Page 6 of 10 -- 6 of 10 -- 11. Now, adverting to the facts of the case, the complainant (revisionist herein) has stated in his complaint which culminated into the present case FIR, that on 18.05.2022 at about 07.30-08.00 am, he had gone to a shop in his neighbourhood for purchasing curd; that suddenly, accused Sagar came there and hit him with his elbow and his friend (Sagar's friend) slapped him; thereafter, complainant asked them as to why they were beating him, on which friend of accused Sagar again started beating him (complainant/ revisionist). It is further alleged that when he (complainant/ revisionist) shouted, whole family of accused Sagar and his labour working in the factory, also gave beatings to him; then, he (complainant/ revisionist) ran from the spot and took shelter in an unknown house. However, accused persons took him out of that house and again gave beatings to him. Meanwhile, landlord of complainant/ revisionist also came there to know about the matter and infact, he tried to pacify the matter. However, accused persons also attacked him (landlord) by hitting a danda on his head. Then, complainant was also attacked with the said danda. 12. It is argued by Ld. Counsel for the revisionist that impugned order whereby charge has been framed against the accused persons only under sections 323/341/506(ii)/34 IPC is an erroneous order since charge U/s 308 IPC is also made out against the accused persons in the present matter as severe injury has been caused to the complainant as well as to the landlord, Sh. Krishna on the vital parts of their body and injury could have proven fatal. _____________________________________________________________________________ CR No. 239/2023 Gaurav Babu Vs. State & Ors. Page 7 of 10 -- 7 of 10 -- 13. At this juncture, section 308 IPC is reproduced herein for ready reference :- Section 308 IPC - "Attempt to commit culpable homicide - Whoever does any act with such intention or knowledge and under such circumstances that, if he by that act caused death, he would be guilty of culpable homicide not amounting to murder, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to three years, or with fine, or with both..." 14. Ld. Counsels for the revisionists have submitted that since the victims have suffered injuries on head, forearm, legs i.e. on vital parts of the body and deadly weapon i.e. Iron rod was used to commit offences, therefore, charge U/s 308/34 IPC is made out against all the accused persons. Per contra, Ld. Addl. PP for the State has submitted that the complainant Gaurav Babu has filed written complaint on the next day of incident and on this written complaint, the present case FIR has been registered. Further, witnesses are not consistent on issue of nature of weapon used. Moreover, during the investigation, as per the charge- sheet itself, enquiries were made by IO from the people residing in the vicinity and they told that both the parties are in habit of leveling accusations against each other. 15. MLC of the victim Gaurav reveals abrasions on his person and MLC of the victim Krishna reveals a lacerated wound over frontal lobe and abrasion and swelling over left forearm and over left leg. Nature of injuries of both the victims has been opined as Simple. _____________________________________________________________________________ CR No. 239/2023 Gaurav Babu Vs. State & Ors. Page 8 of 10 -- 8 of 10 -- 16. From the bare perusal of the complaint which culminated into the present case FIR, it transpires that initially, when the main accused Sagar restrained the victim/ revisionist Gaurav Babu, he (accused Sagar) was not having any weapon with him and he alongwith his friend had beaten the complainant with elbow and slaps. Thereafter, as per the allegations, the whole family of accused Sagar alongwith labour working in their factory, gave beatings to the complainant/ revisionist and his landlord using dandas. In his statement recorded U/s 161 Cr.PC, Sh. Krishna, Landlord of the complainant/ revisionist has stated that the accused persons gave beating to him with sariya (iron rod) and with Wiper having iron danda. 17. Weapon of offence has been stated differently by the victims in their statements, as in the statement of complainant, it is mentioned only as danda and in the statement of other witnesses, it is mentioned as sariya (Iron rod) and at other place in these statements, one of the weapons used is mentioned as Wiper. There seems to be a discrepancy about the nature of weapon used in the present matter. Admittedly, in the present matter, accused were initially not carrying/ having any weapons with them. Intention or knowledge as required U/s 308 IPC cannot be imputed or proved at this stage of charge. Further, detailed appreciation of facts or Mini Trial is neither contemplated nor permissible, at this stage. 18. The impugned order on charge dated 18.05.2023 passed by Ld. MM, Shahdara, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi vide which charge U/s _____________________________________________________________________________ CR No. 239/2023 Gaurav Babu Vs. State & Ors. Page 9 of 10 -- 9 of 10 -- 323/341/506(ii)/34 IPC is framed against the accused persons/ respondents, does not suffer from any error or illegality. The facts and circumstances of the present matter, as discussed above, do not call for any interference in the order on charge dated 18.05.2023 passed by Ld. MM, Shahdara, Karkardooma Courts, in exercise of revisional jurisdiction by this Court. Accordingly, in view of the foregoing discussion, the present revision petition stands dismissed and the impugned order dated 18.05.2023 passed by Ld. Trial Court is hereby, upheld. 19. Nothing expressed hereinabove, shall tantamount to any opinion on the merits of the case. 20. Revision file be consigned to Record Room. Copy of this order be sent to Learned Trial Court for necessary intimation and be given dasti to the revisionist. Announced and dictated in the open court on 04.03.2024 (SURABHI SHARMA VATS) ASJ-4/Shahdara/KKD/ Delhi. _____________________________________________________________________________ CR No. 239/2023 Gaurav Babu Vs. State & Ors. Page 10 of 10 -- 10 of 10 --
