Full Order Text
Final Order 4 · 04 Sept 2023 · CNR DLSH010053402023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: 1 Reg. No. 1705/2023 FIR No. 812/2022 State Vs. Tarun P.S. Nand Nagri u/s 304-B/498-A/34 IPC 04.09.2023 Present: Sh. Parmod Kumar, Ld. Addl. PP for State. None for applicant/accused. This application under Section 439 Cr. PC seeking regular bail on behalf of applicant, is fixed for order. O R D E R 1. By this order, I shall dispose of an application u/s 439 Cr. PC seeking regular bail on behalf of applicant/accused. 2. Ld. Counsel for applicant/accused has submitted that investigation of present case has been completed and charge- sheet has been filed; that applicant/accused has been falsely implicated in the present case; that on the date of incident, applicant/accused was not at his home; that in the initial complaint given by father of deceased, there is no allegation of demand of dowry; that allegations against the applicant in the present case are false and manipulated; that deceased committed suicide due to depression as she was suffering from infertility and her treatment was going on; that parental family members of deceased have got registered the present FIR after a delay of about 20 days; that as per statement of father of deceased, he has stated that no one is responsible for the alleged incident and he does not want any action against anyone; that thereafter under a conspiracy, complainant and his family members have falsely implicated -- 1 of 5 -- 2 the applicant/accused in the present case; that applicant/accused is in JC since 19.04.2023 and his further detention in JC will not serve any fruitful purpose as applicant is no more required for any investigation; that applicant/accused is neither previous convict nor habitual offender; that applicant is permanent resident of Delhi and there is no chance of his fleeing from process of law. It has been further submitted that applicant/accused is ready to abide by all the conditions imposed by the court, if he is released on bail. Thus, Ld. Counsel has prayed for grant of bail to the applicant/accused. 3. Per contra, Ld. Addl. PP for State has opposed the present application by referring to the serious nature of allegations against applicant in the FIR. He has further argued that filing of charge sheet by itself would not entitle the applicant for bail and it is further argued that death in the present case has occurred within 7 years of marriage. Thus, it has been prayed that application may be dismissed. 4. I have heard arguments addressed on behalf of both sides and perused the material available on record. 5. Briefly, as per contents of FIR, present case has been registered on 26.10.2022 for the offence u/s 498A/304-B/34 IPC on the basis of complaint dated 20.10.2022 given by one Karan, brother of deceased, before the SDM concerned, wherein it has been alleged that marriage of her sister Pooja was solemnized with Tarun on 25.02.2020 as per Hindu rites and they have spent about Rs.9-10 lakhs in the said marriage as per their status. After marriage, in-laws of his sister -- 2 of 5 -- 3 started harassing her on account of demand of dowry; that Rs.50,000/-were given by his family members to the in-laws of his sister for purchasing second-hand car; that on 04.10.2022 his sister came to her parental home and she asked her mother for giving gold ear-rings and teeka, however, her mother refused to give the same on account of their bad financial condition, on which her husband took her back to matrimonial home and on 07.10.2022 they received telephone call from husband of her sister w.r.t. her death; that he has strong doubt that his sister was killed by her in-laws. 6. At the outset, it is worthwhile to mention that perusal of charge-sheet reveals that on 07.10.2022 at 10.15 am, statement of father of deceased was recorded by the Executive Magistrate (Seema Puri), wherein he has stated that the marriage of his daughter Pooja was solemnized with applicant on 25.02.2020 and she was happily residing in her matrimonial home without any difficulty from the side of her in-laws; that her daughter was not having any child from the said wedlock; that on 07.10.2022 at about 12.30 am, his son- in-law had telephonically informed that Pooja had hanged herself; that he did not know the reasons of the said incident as his daughter was not having any difficulty in her matrimonial home. He has further stated that no one is responsible for the said incident and he does not want any legal action against anyone for the same. 7. Pertinently, the father of deceased had initially not attributed any role to either the applicant or his family members with respect to the death of his daughter nor had -- 3 of 5 -- 4 said anything about dowry demand from the applicant or his family members, but later on, upon a complaint belatedly given to the SDM by the brother of deceased, allegations have been levelled against applicant/accused and his family members. However, it is worth mentioning that the said allegations are a matter of trial and veracity of the same can only be ascertained after evidence is led. In addition to this, there seems to be inconsistency with respect to the manner of death of deceased in the complaint given by the brother of deceased to SDM concerned vis-a-vis his statement recorded under Section 161 Cr. PC, as in the complaint it is stated that his sister has been intentionally killed by her husband and in- laws, whereas, in the statement u/s 161 Cr. PC, he has stated that his sister had committed suicide on the instigation of her husband/in-laws. Further, there seems to be no complaint regarding any dowry demand/cruelty prior to the alleged incident. Moreover, the plea raised on behalf of applicant/accused that deceased was depressed on account of her infertility, due to which she may have committed suicide, cannot be ruled out in the light of medical documents of deceased placed on record and this fact perhaps was admitted by the father of deceased in his statement recorded before the Executive Magistrate, wherein he has stated that his deceased daughter did not have any child. 8. Otherwise, investigation is complete and charge-sheet has already been filed in the present case. Further, applicant/accused is not found involved in any other criminal case. Also, there has been an unexplained delay of about 20 -- 4 of 5 -- 5 days in registering the FIR. Last but not the least, the applicant/accused has been in JC since 19.04.2023 i.e. 4.5 months now, so considering the above discussion, no fruitful purpose would be served by keeping him in further custody, more so, as trial would take substantial time to conclude. 9. Thus, keeping in view the totality of the facts and circumstances, applicant/accused is admitted to bail on his furnishing a bail bond in the sum of Rs. 25,000/- with one local surety of the like amount to the satisfaction of Ld. MM/Link MM/duty MM concerned subject to the conditions that: 1. Accused shall not threaten or influence the complainant or any prosecution witness in any manner whatsoever. 2. Accused shall not tamper with the evidence nor shall indulge in any illegal activities. 3. Accused shall not visit any place within close vicinity of residence of complainant. 4. Accused and his surety shall intimate the Court immediately of any change in their addresses and shall also furnish their mobile numbers to the IO/SHO concerned. It is clarified that anything expressed herein shall not tantamount to any opinion on the merits of the case. Application stands disposed of accordingly. (Vineet Kumar) ASJ-02/E-Court (Shahdara) KKD/Delhi/04.09.2023 -- 5 of 5 --
