Full Order Text
Final Order 8 · 18 May 2024 · CNR DLSH010052812023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF MS. KIRAN BANSAL, DISTRICT JUDGE, COMMERCIAL COURT-02, SHAHDARA, KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI CS (Comm) No. 433/2023 IN THE MATTER OF SH PANKAJ JAIN PROP OF PARIDHI TRADING CO. AT IX/6696, JANTA GALI, NEAR TRANSFORMER, GANDHI NAGAR, DELHI-110031. MOBILE 9818536410 …. PLAINTIFF VERSUS SHRI SHAITAN SINGH S/O SHRI DEVI SINGH (PROP.) OF VINAYAK FASHION, RAVANA RAJPUTH, DHAKA, DIST-BARMER, RAJASTHAN-34402 MOBILE 9567927383, 9950730378 …. DEFENDANT Date of Institution : 24.08.2023 Date of hearing Arguments : 18.05.2024 Date of judgment : 18.05.2024 CS(COMM) No. 433/2023 SH PANKAJ JAIN Vs. SHRI SHAITAN SINGH Page 1 of 14 -- 1 of 14 -- EX PARTE JUDGMENT: 1. The plaintiff has filed the present commercial suit for recovery of an amount of Rs.7,60,095/- along with future interest @ 18% p.a. with cost from the date of filing of the suit till realization against the defendant. 1.1 Brief facts of the case are that the plaintiff is a proprietor of firm who manages and controls its affairs, whether directly or indirectly and is therefore, stated to be acquainted with the facts and circumstances of the present case and is aware of all transactions pertaining to the present case, and thus, is stated to be competent to sign, verify, and institute the present case. It is stated that the plaintiff firm is engaged in the business of JEANS PANTS etc. and earned an amenable reputation and goodwill in the market and defendant is a proprietor of his firm and also deals in Jeans Pants and Garments and had approached the plaintiff and requested him to provide/supply goods and assured the plaintiff for timely payments of the goods and took their personal guarantee for the payment during the course of business transaction. 1.2 It is stated that upon the assurances of defendant, plaintiff started supplying goods / machines to the defendant and provided the goods, time to time as per the demands made by the defendant and raised the invoices accordingly. The goods supplied by plaintiff and received by the defendant are as under: Sr.No. Date Bill No. Amount 01. 13.03.2020 2919 71636 CS(COMM) No. 433/2023 SH PANKAJ JAIN Vs. SHRI SHAITAN SINGH Page 2 of 14 -- 2 of 14 -- 02. 26.06.2020 2981 62265 03. 14.07.2020 3012 81585 04. 01.08.2020 3037 78960 05. 01.08.2020 3038 93991 06. 11.12.2020 3396 79343 07. 11.12.2020 3397 66087 08. 06.01.2021 3461 107982 09. 16.01.2021 3489 76918 10. 05.03.2021 3654 65793 11. 05.03.2021 3655 70796 12. 18.03.2021 3704 85853 13. 02.04.2021 3743 83181 14. 02.04.2021 3744 81743 15. 02.04.2021 3745 73521 16. 03.04.2021 3752 183627 17. 02.07.2021 3840 85260 18. 14.07.2021 3859 77086 19. 22.07.2021 3868 161128 20. 03.09.2021 4004 88115 CS(COMM) No. 433/2023 SH PANKAJ JAIN Vs. SHRI SHAITAN SINGH Page 3 of 14 -- 3 of 14 -- 21. 07.09.2021 4022 69494 22. 14.09.2021 4043 81869 23. 19.10.2021 4182 94891 24. 21.11.2021 4210 66092 25. 23.12.2021 4239 140763 26. 07.01.2022 4256 176358 27. 26.02.2022 4365 160598 28. 20.03.2022 4456 79034 29. 20.03.2022 4457 69804 30. 20.03.2022 4458 66948 31. 20.03.2022 4459 73553 32. 20.03.2022 4460 85502 33. 20.03.2022 4461 87418 34. 20.03.2022 4462 92006 35. 03.04.2022 PT/22-23/11 77196 36. 06.04.2022 PT/22-23/19 75768 37. 06.04.2022 PT/22-23/20 70954 38. 17.04.2022 PT/22-23/49 88804 CS(COMM) No. 433/2023 SH PANKAJ JAIN Vs. SHRI SHAITAN SINGH Page 4 of 14 -- 4 of 14 -- 39. 14.06.2022 PT/22-23/103 96658 40. 19.08.2022 PT/22-23/247 251559 41. 16.09.2022 PT/22-23/396 93749 42. 14.12.2022 PT/22-23/543 98947 1.3 It is stated that as per the ledger account maintained at the office of plaintiff, defendant is liable for Rs.7,60,095/- as on 14.12.2022 and despite consistent reminders and persuasion from the plaintiff, defendant failed to make payment. Plaintiff has reminded the defendant severally through telephonic calls and various other modes, but, defendant paid no heed to the requests of the plaintiff. It is stated that as agreed the full payment was to be made immediately after completion of the order and when invoices were raised by plaintiff, thus, liability of defendants is overdue since about 8 month. 1.4 It is stated that defendant by retaining the sum of Rs.7,60,095/- of the plaintiff, having derived and enjoyed benefits thereof, have unjustly enriched himself and as such defendant is liable to pay interest @ 18% per annum. It is stated that the pre mediation was instituted as per the provision of Commercial Courts Act, however, the defendant failed to appear and certificate of Non-Starter Report was issued on 31.07.2023. 1.5 It is stated that the cause of action for the present suit arose in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant, when defendant approached the plaintiff for supply of goods and order was placed and he failed to pay CS(COMM) No. 433/2023 SH PANKAJ JAIN Vs. SHRI SHAITAN SINGH Page 5 of 14 -- 5 of 14 -- his dues to the plaintiff and it further arose when he had not been regular in making timely payments to the plaintiff for the goods supplied by them. 1.6 It is stated that plaintiff firm is situated within the territorial jurisdiction of this court and part cause of action has arisen within the territorial jurisdiction of this court as the orders were accepted here. It is further stated that the subject matter of the suit is a "Commercial dispute as defined in Section 2(1) (c) of the Commercial Courts, Commercial Division and Commercial Appellate Division of High Courts Ordinance, 2015. 2. Summons of the suit have been served upon the defendant through electronic mode i.e. whatsapp and the defendant, thus, deemed to be served on 06.10.2023, however, as the WS was not filed within the stipulated period of 30 days, the right of the defendant to file WS was closed and defendant was proceeded ex parte vide order dated 14.12.2023. 3. In support of its claim, the plaintiff has examined Sh. Abhay Aggarwal, Proprietor of M/s. A.A. Enterprises as PW-1 and he tendered his affidavit as Ex.PW1/A in evidence. He has reiterated the facts averred in the plaint and relied upon the following documents: Copy of my Aadhar Card as Ex.PW1/1 (OSR); Bill No. 2919, dated 13.03.2020 as Ex.PW1/2; Bill No. 2981, dated 26.06.2020 as Ex.PW1/3; Bill No. 3012, dated 14.07.2020 as Ex.PW1/4; Bill No. 3037, dated 01.08.2020 as Ex.PW1/5; Bill No. 3038, dated 01.08.2020 as Ex.PW1/6; Bill No. 3396, dated 11.12.2020 as Ex.PW1/7; Bill No. 3397, dated 11.12.2020 as Ex.PW1/8; CS(COMM) No. 433/2023 SH PANKAJ JAIN Vs. SHRI SHAITAN SINGH Page 6 of 14 -- 6 of 14 -- Bill No. 3461, dated 06.01.2021 as Ex.PW1/9; Bill No. 3489, dated 16.01.2021 as Ex.PW1/10; Bill No. 3654, dated 05.03.2021 as Ex.PW1/11; Bill No. 3655, dated 05.03.2021 as Ex.PW1/12; Bill No. 3704, dated 18.03.2021 as Ex.PW1/13; Bill No. 3743, dated 02.04.2021 as Ex.PW1/14; Bill No. 3744, dated 02.04.2021 as Ex.PW1/15; Bill No. 3745, dated 02.04.2021 as Ex.PW1/16; Bill No. 3752, dated 03.04.2021 as Ex.PW1/17; Bill No. 3840, dated 02.07.2021 as Ex.PW1/18; Bill No. 3859, dated 14.07.2021 as Ex.PW1/19; Bill No. 3868, dated 22.07.2021 as Ex.PW1/20; Bill No. 4004, dated 03.09.2021 as Ex.PW1/21; Bill No. 4022, dated 07.09.2021 as Ex.PW1/22; Bill No. 4043, dated 14.09.2021 as Ex.PW1/23; Bill No. 4182, dated 19.10.2021 as Ex.PW1/24; Bill No. 4210, dated 21.11.2021 as Ex.PW1/25; Bill No. 4239, dated 23.12.2021 as Ex.PW1/26; Bill No. 4256, dated 07.01.2022 as Ex.PW1/27; Bill No. 4365, dated 26.02.2022 as Ex.PW1/28; Bill No. 4456, dated 20.03.2022 as Ex.PW1/29; Bill No. 4457, dated 20.03.2022 as Ex.PW1/30; Bill No. 4458, dated 20.03.2022 as Ex.PW1/31; Bill No. 4459, dated 20.03.2022 as Ex.PW1/32; Bill No. 4460, dated 20.03.2022 as Ex.PW1/33; Bill No. 4461, dated 20.03.2022 as Ex.PW1/34; Bill No. 4462, dated 20.03.2022 as Ex.PW1/35; Bill No. PT/22-23/11, dated 03.04.2022 as Ex.PW1/36; CS(COMM) No. 433/2023 SH PANKAJ JAIN Vs. SHRI SHAITAN SINGH Page 7 of 14 -- 7 of 14 -- Bill No. PT/22-23/19, dated 06.04.2022 as Ex.PW1/37; Bill No. PT/22-23/20, dated 06.04.2022 as Ex.PW1/38; Bill No. PT/22-23/49, dated 17.04.2022 as Ex.PW1/39; Bill No. PT/22-23/103, dated 14.06.2022 as Ex.PW1/40; Bill No. PT/22-23/247, dated 19.08.2022 as Ex.PW1/41; Bill No. PT/22-23/396, dated 16.09.2022 as Ex.PW1/42; Bill No. PT/22-23/543, dated 14.12.2022 as Ex.PW1/43; Ledger as Ex.PW1/44. 4. It is pertinent to mention that vide order dated 24.04.2023, an application under Order XVIII Rule 17 CPC filed on behalf of plaintiff for leading additional evidence and the same was allowed in the interest of justice and the additional evidence was tendered in evidence. 5. In the additional evidence PW-1 has relied upon the following two documents i.e.: E-way Bills of Invoices Ex.PW1/45 to Ex.PW1/86; Thereafter, on the statement of plaintiff, PE was closed. As the right of defendant to file WS was already closed vide order dated 14.12.2023, thus, no date was fixed for DE and the matter was fixed for final arguments. 6. The court has thoroughly gone through the testimony of witness and perused the material on record and have also duly considered the arguments advanced by ld. counsel for plaintiff and gone through the law and precedents on the point. 7. The suit is commercial in nature and squarely falls within the purview of Section 2 (1) (C) of Commercial Courts Act and plaintiff has also CS(COMM) No. 433/2023 SH PANKAJ JAIN Vs. SHRI SHAITAN SINGH Page 8 of 14 -- 8 of 14 -- duly complied with mandatory provision of Pre-Institution Mediation and Conciliation as provided in Section 12 A of Commercial Courts Act. 8. As far as territorial jurisdiction is concerned, the plaintiff has stated in para 17 of the plaint that plaintiff office is situated within the jurisdiction of the present court and therefore, the present court has the territorial jurisdiction to try and entertain the present suit. Mere supply of goods from the office of plaintiff situated within the jurisdiction of present court would not confer jurisdiction on the present court. However, on the invoices Ex.PW1/2 to Ex.PW1/43, the bank details are given wherein the defendant was to make payment of the amount as mentioned in the invoices. The said bank account of the plaintiff in IDFC First is situated at Gandhi Nagar, Delhi – 110031. 9. The Hon'ble Delhi High Court in Satyapal Vs. Slick Auto Accessories Pvt. Ltd. & Ors., 2014 SCC Online Del 998 has held that “Since the trial court has written, in my opinion, a very thorough and an excellent judgment, I would like to reproduce the relevant paras of the judgment of the trial court instead of using my words. The relevant paras of the trial court are 19 to 25 and the same read as under: "ISSUE NO. 1: "19. The question to be answered is as to whether this court has no territorial jurisdiction to try and entertain the present suit. The onus to prove this issue was upon the defendant. 20. The defendants have contended that the office/factory of the defendants is situated in Bhiwadi, District-Alwar, Rajasthan and the delivery of the goods was also made at Bhawadi, District-Alwar, Rajasthan at the office/factory of the defendants and therefore no part of the cause of action arose within the jurisdiction of this court. DW1 has deposed CS(COMM) No. 433/2023 SH PANKAJ JAIN Vs. SHRI SHAITAN SINGH Page 9 of 14 -- 9 of 14 -- on these lines. 21. There is no doubt the material was supplied by the plaintiff to the defendants at Bhiwadi, District-Alwar, Rajasthan. The same is clear from the invoices Ex. PW1/A and Ex. PW1/B. However even if the material was delivered at Bhiwadi, District-Alwar, Rajasthan it is clear that the material was supplied from the office/factory of the plaintiff situated at Jwala Nagar, Shahdara, Delhi-32 which falls within the jurisdiction of this court. 22. It is a well established principle of law that where, under a contract no place of payment is specified, the debtor must seek his creditor and therefore a suit for recovery is maintainable at the place where the creditor resides or works for gain, because a part of the cause of action arises at that place also with the contemplation of section 20 (c) of the Code of Civil Procedure. Reference may be made to the judgments titled as "State of Punjab V. A. K. Raha" reported as AIR 1964 CALCUTTA 418 (DB), "Jose Paul v. Jose" reported as AIR 2002 KERALA 397 (DB), "Rajasthan State Electricity Board V. M/s Dayal Wood Works" reported as AIR 1998 ANDHRA PRADESH 381, "Munnisa Begum V. Noore Mohd." Reported as AIR 1965 ANDHRA PRADESH 231 and "State of U.P.v. Raja Ram" reported as AIR 1966 AllAHABAD 159. 23. In the judgment titled as "State of Punjab v. A. K. Raha" reported as AIR 1964 CALCUTTA 418 (DB) it was clearly held: "...........The general rule is that where no place of payment is specified in the contract either expressly or impliedly, the debtor must seek the creditor, see The Eider (1893) P 119 at p. 136, Drexel v. Drexel. (1916) 1 Ch 251 at p. 261, North Bengal, Das Brothers Zemindary Co. Ltd V. Surendera Nath Das, ILR (1957) 2 Cal 8. The obligation to pay the debt involves the obligation to find the creditor and to pay him at the place where he is when the money is payable. The application of the general rule is not excluded because the amount of debt is disputed...." 24. In the judgment titled as Sreenivasa Pulvarising vs Jal Glass & Chemicals pvt. Ltd. reported as AIR 1985 Cal 74 it was also held: "......In a contract of the nature now under consideration CS(COMM) No. 433/2023 SH PANKAJ JAIN Vs. SHRI SHAITAN SINGH Page 10 of 14 -- 10 of 14 -- performance of the contract consists not only of delivery of the goods but also of payment of the price. Therefore, cause of action for a suit on breach of such a contract would arise not only where the goods were to be delivered but also where the price would be payable on such delivery....." It was further held: ".......9. Therefore, the law continues to remain the same and in a suit arising out of a contract, a part of the cause of action arises at the place where in performance of the contract any money to which the suit relates in payable...." Adverting to the facts of the present case office/factory of the Plaintiff is situated at Jwala nagar, Shahdara, Delhi-32. No place of payment has been specified in the contract/bills/invoices. The defendants are liable to make the payment for the goods supplied to them. No application was made by the defendants to the plaintiffs for fixing a place of payment and Sec. 49 of the Indian Contract Act cannot apply to the facts of the case. Therefore, the payment was to be made at the office of the plaintiff. Further the purchase order was placed at Jwala Nagar, Shahdara, Delhi-32 and the goods were supplied from Jwala nagar, Shahdara, Delhi-32 Therefore a part of th cause of action definitely arises at Jawala Nagar, Shahdara, Delhi-32. Hence the present suit for recovery of the sale price can be filed before this court as the office of the plaintiff is situated within the territorial limits of the jurisdiction of the court. 25. I therefore hold that this court has the territorial jurisdiction to try and entertain the present suit. This issue is therefore decided in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants." (underlining added) 6. I completely agree with the conclusion of the trial court because it is settled law that the debtor has to seek the creditor and since no place of payment was agreed upon, payment would have been made to the seller/appellant who is residing and working for gain at New Delhi. Trial court has also rightly relied upon Section 49 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 that it was upon the respondent no.1/defendant no. CS(COMM) No. 433/2023 SH PANKAJ JAIN Vs. SHRI SHAITAN SINGH Page 11 of 14 -- 11 of 14 -- 1 to fix the place of payment and which has not been done, and therefore payment would have been made by the debtor to the creditor at the place of the creditor/plaintiff/appellant.” 10. There is nothing on record to suggest that any place of payment was agreed upon between the parties. As no place of payment seems to have been agreed upon by the parties, the principal that the “debtor must seek the creditor” would apply. From the Ledger, it is revealed that part payment has been received at IDFC Bank Account of plaintiff. The bank account of the plaintiff bank is in IDFC Bank at Gandhi Nagar Branch which falls within the jurisdiction of present court and therefore, the present court has territorial jurisdiction to decide the present case. 11. The defendant, has not filed their written statement along with statement of truth, affidavit of admission and denial of documents as well as its own documents within the stipulated period of 30 days from its service and even upto 120 days from the date of his service along with an application for condonation of delay. 12. The averments made in the plaint (which is supported with the affidavit and statement of truth) remain uncontroverted, unrebutted and unchallenged and can be presumed to be admitted as correct, as the defendant, though appeared before the court, but failed to file her written statement along with statement of truth, affidavit of admission and denial of documents of the plaintiff and failed to file her own documents as well as any application for condonation of delay within the stipulated period from the date of her service. The defendant has failed to contest the case or put up any defence. CS(COMM) No. 433/2023 SH PANKAJ JAIN Vs. SHRI SHAITAN SINGH Page 12 of 14 -- 12 of 14 -- 13. The testimony of PW-1 remains uncontroverted, unrebutted and unchallenged as the defendant, though appeared through counsel before the court but did not cross examine the witness. There is no reason to disbelieve the testimony of PW-1 who has reiterated, reasserted and reaffirmed all the facts, as elaborated in the plaint. All the relevant documents and relevant averments have been proved in the evidence and affidavit of Sh. Abhay Aggarwal, Proprietor of M/s. A.A. Enterprises (PW-1). 14. Perusal of the non starter reveals that the plaintiff has applied for pre institution mediation on 14.07.2023. The non starter report was issued on 31.07.2023. As per the Section 12A of the Commercial Court Act, the period consumed for pre institution mediation is not to be taken into account for computing the limitation. The first bill is dated 13.03.2020 and last invoice is dated 14.12.2022. Last payment received as per Ledger Ex.PW1/44 is 26.06.2022. Thus, the suit filed by the plaintiff on 24.08.2023 is filed within the period of limitation. 15. Perused the documents proved by the plaintiff at the time of evidence. All the Invoices Ex.PW1/2 to Ex.PW1/43 relied upon by the plaintiff can be taken into account against the defendant as the same bears the details of defendant including its name and address in the column of 'Billed to' as well as the goods provided by the plaintiff in column of 'Description of Goods'. Moreover, all the Invoices Ex.PW1/2 to Ex.PW1/43 bears 'GST No. 07AEWPJ 8617C1Z7. 16. Furthermore, plaintiff has filed invoices along with the photocopy of E-way Bills of Invoices Ex.PW1/45 to Ex.PW1/86 which apparently shows that articles as mentioned in the invoices Ex.PW1/2 to Ex.PW1/43 were CS(COMM) No. 433/2023 SH PANKAJ JAIN Vs. SHRI SHAITAN SINGH Page 13 of 14 -- 13 of 14 -- delivered to the defendant, thus, plaintiff has proved the delivery of goods provided to the defendant and thus, it is directed that the plaintiff is entitled to recover an amount of Rs.7,60,095/- from the defendant as principal. The plaintiff is also entitled to an interest on the said amount at reasonable rate as the defendant has deprived him of the said amount. 17. The plaintiff has claimed pendete lite and future interest at the rate of 18% per annum from the date of institution of the present suit till its realisation. Though there is a stipulation on the invoice Ex.PW1/2 to Ex.PW1/43 that interest @ 18% per annum will be charged, if the payment is not made within the stipulated period. However, such unilaterally printed terms and conditions on the invoices do not form a binding contract. Plaintiff, however, is entitled to interest at a reasonable rate. Thus, in the interest of justice, it is directed that plaintiff shall be entitled to interest @ 8% on the principal amount of Rs.7,60,095/- from the date of institution till its realisation. 18. In view of the unrebutted testimony of PW1 and the documents proved on record, the suit of the plaintiff is decreed for an amount of Rs.7,60,095/- as principal amount along with interest @ 8% from the date of institution of the suit till its realisation alongwith cost to the extent of court fees. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly. File be consigned to record room. ANNOUNCED IN OPEN COURT ON 18.05.2024 (Kiran Bansal) District Judge, Commercial Court- Shahdara, Karkardooma Delhi/18.05.2024 CS(COMM) No. 433/2023 SH PANKAJ JAIN Vs. SHRI SHAITAN SINGH Page 14 of 14 -- 14 of 14 --
