Full Order Text
Interim Order 10 · 02 Sept 2025 · CNR DLSH010051132023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: RCA No. 88/23 Sharda vs. BSES YPL 02.09.2025 Present : Appellant with Sh. Ashish Agarwal Ld. Counsel. Sh. Akhilesh Tejpal Advocated stated to be appearing for R1/BSES. Sh. Gopi Kishan Ld. Counsel for R2. Today, matter is listed for arguments on appeal. This is an appeal by virtue of which judgment and decree dated 03.07.2023 passed by the court of Ld. Civil Judge in Civil Suit No. 1093/18 titled as ‘Sharda vs. BSES YPL & Anr.’ has been challenged. Vide the impugned judgment, Ld. Trial Court had dismissed the suit of the plaintiff. Perusal of record reveals that the suit before the Ld. Trial court was filed seeking declaration, mandatory and permanent against the defendants and the same was valued at Rs. 200/-, Rs. 130/- and Rs. 130/- respectively, upon which a court fees of Rs. 46/- was affixed. In the light of judgment titled as “ Court on its own Motion Vs. Rambir Singh” Office reference no. 1/2014 (Hon’ble Mr. Justice Valmiki Mehta) DOD 14.10.2014 , the Hon'ble Delhi High Court has held that any appeal from Decrees and Orders passed by Civil Judges in suits where pecuniary jurisdiction is up to Rs.1000/-, have to be filed before the courts of Sr. Civil Judge / ASCJ and not before the court of District Judge / ADJ. Therefore, applying the aforesaid settled law to the facts of the present matter, it is clear that this court cannot hear the present appeal as the impugned judgment was passed by Ld. Civil Judge in a civil -- 1 of 2 -- suit which was valued at Rs. 460/- only and suffice it to say that appeal from the same should have been preferred before the court of Ld. Sr. Civil Judge / Ld. ASCJ. In view of the above, put up this matter before Ld. Principal District & Sessions Judge, Shahdara District, KKD Courts Delhi for appropriate orders, on 06.09.2025. Parties / Ld. Counsels for parties are directed to appear before Ld. Principal District & Sessions Judge, Shahdara District on the aforesaid date. Ahlmad is directed to send the file complete in all respects to the said court. (Gaurav) District Judge-01/ SHD KKD/Delhi/02.09.2025 -- 2 of 2 --
