Full Order Text
Order 8 · 29 Feb 2024 · CNR DLSH010050652023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS (COMM.) No.432/2023 S B Sales Corporation Through its Partner Vs. Narendra Gupta 29.02.2024 Present: Sh. Akash Gupta, Ld. Counsel for plaintiff. Sh. Aditya Goel, Ld. Counsel for defendant has joined the proceedings through VC and Ms. Chanchal Sharma has appeared in the Court. Previous cost of Rs.5,000/- imposed on plaintiff on the last date paid in cash to Ld. Counsel for defendant. It is submitted by defendant that plaintiff has filed replication on record without leave of this Court. This plea of the defendant is factually incorrect because in order dated 05.01.2024 of this Court plaintiff was given liberty to file replication in due course. Reply to plaintiff’s application under Order 11 Rule 1 CPC filed. Submissions heard. Record perused. This is a money suit filed by plaintiff, a partnership firm, for recovery of Rs.25,73,858/- alongwith interest. The suit amount is said to be unpaid dues of goods sold and supplied. Admittedly, the business between the parties is 8-9 years old and started in 2015. Alongwith the plaint necessary documents were filed by the plaintiff. However, it is submitted that in the WS, when the ledger was filed by the defendant qua the business carried out with the plaintiff several sale transactions qua the business carried out between them were found to be omitted. As per Ld. Counsel for plaintiff the necessity to file 8 invoices alongwith relevant bilties arose on account of incorrect/inaccurate ledger filed by defendant alongwith the WS. The application is opposed by Ld. Counsel for defendant with a plea that the plaintiff should have filed these documents -- 1 of 2 -- alongwith the plaint. It is argued that the defendant would be prejudiced if this application is allowed. Defendant has also relied on case titled Saregama India Limited Vs. Zee Entertainment Enterprises Limited, 2023 Latest Caselaw 1910 Del of Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in the case in hand. Evidence/trial is yet to start. The explanation put forth by Ld. Counsel for plaintiff that the necessity to file these documents arose on account of claimed faulty ledger is found to be per se satisfactory. In the considered view of this Court, these documents are not going to prejudice the defendant in any manner. As such the application is allowed subject to additional cost of Rs.7500/- to be paid to defendant. Put up for final arguments on 28.03.2024. parties. (SURINDER S. RATHI) District Judge Commercial Court-03 Shahdara District, KKD Delhi/29.02.2024 -- 2 of 2 --
