Full Order Text
Order 6 · 26 Feb 2024 · CNR DLSH010049602023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. RAMESH KUMAR-II, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT JUDGE, SHAHDARA DISTRICT, KARKARDOOMA COURTS: DELHI Civil Suit No.584/2023 In the matter of:- Ms. Charu Gulati .... Plaintiff Versus Mr. Sushant Gulati & Anr. .... Defendants ORDER Vide this order, I shall dispose off the application of the plaintiff under Order 39 Rule 1 & 2 CPC r/w Section 151 CPC. The defendant no.1 has filed reply to the present application denying all the assertions made therein and has prayed for dismissal of the said application. Brief facts as set up by the plaintiff in the plaint are that the property bearing no.N-29, 4/2482, 1st Floor, Gali No.13, Bihari Colony, Shahdara, Delhi-32 is a 3 BHK admeasuring 200 sq. yds. Out of Khasra No.419, Situated in the area of Village Udhanpur in the abadi of Gali no.12 & 13, Bihari Colony, Shahdara, Delhi (hereinafter referred to be as ‘suit property’) was purchased by the mother of the plaintiff and defendant no.1 vide registered sale deed. It is further averred that after the death of father of plaintiffs the interference and influence of the defendant no.1 in the life of plaintiff kept on increasing and considering the negative attitude and behaviour of the defendant no.1 and his wife towards the plaintiff, the mother of plaintiff and defendant no.1 decided to execute a Will, to ensure that there remained clarity on account of rights of the plaintiff, in case of demise of the mother. Vide the CS No.584/23 1 -- 1 of 10 -- said Will, the plaintiff’s mother Willed plaintiff to be the absolute owner of half share of the suit property to the exclusion of the defendant no.1 other than the share in suit property, all the movable properties of the mother were also Willed to the absolute ownership of the plaintiff. It is further averred that after the death of the mother plaintiff on 14.07.2020, the plaintiff fell into the shackles of depression and anxiety attacks and in the suit property, felt lonely even in the company of the defendant no.1 and his wife and their child. It is further averred that the defendant no.1 on the other hand was not bothered by the difficulties face by the plaintiff, but was more bothered by the Will dated 01.06.2017 in which their late mother had declared them to be equal shares of the suit property. It is further averred that the defendant no.1 got to know about the Will after about six months of the death of mother and thereafter the attitude of the defendant no.1 and his wife completely changed for the worse towards the plaintiff. The original Will is in the possession of the defendant no.1. Thereafter, the defendant no.1 with the encouragement of his wife and some of his cousins and relatives like Hitesh Gulati, Latika Chaddha and her husband Lalit Chaddha started pressuring the plaintiff to transfer her share in the suit property by way of relinquishment deed in favour of the defendant no.1. It is further averred that the plaintiff has been undergoing medical treatment for issues pertaining to depression and anxiety disorders since 2020 and the negative impact the relationship of defendant no.1 and his wife towards the plaintiff has been a catalyst to the same. It is further averred that the defendant no.1 with his dominant position in his relationship with the plaintiff, using undue influence got the plaintiff to execute a relinquishment deed dated 06.10.2022 which CS No.584/23 2 -- 2 of 10 -- was induced by undue influence and coercion while the defendant no.1 was holding real and apparent authority over the plaintiff in their relationship. It is further averred that after execution of the relinquishment deed the attitude and behaviour of the defendant went back to the way it was, that is of pure contempt and distaste and the defendant no.1 and his wife have been pressuring the plaintiff to vacate the suit property and as such the plaintiff was constrained to move a complaint before DCW who referred her to DLSA for legal aid. It is further averred that contrary to the assurances of the defendant no.1, he has asked the plaintiff to vacate the suit property, and he has himself vacated the suit property alongwith his wife and daughter while leaving behind the suit property with all rooms locked except plaintiff’s own bedroom, with access to mostly empty kitchen and hall only. It is further averred that the defendant no.1 has been pressuring the plaintiff to vacate the premises and has further intimated to the plaintiff that he is going to let out the property on rent. The plaintiff has also been getting information from relatives that defendant no.1 is going to sell the suit property. It is further averred that the plaintiff despite the struggles in her life, exploitation at the hands of her own brother i.e. defendant no.1 intends to pursue higher studies abroad and she in fact is in the process for completing VISA with regard to her admission to University of Europe for Applied Sciences but the relevant certificates and documents required to prove her qualifications as sought by the PG University are in possession of the defendant no.1 and she is not sharing the same with her. The defendant no.1, while the plaintiff is requesting for her qualification documents/data stored exclusively in his hard drive, is non- CS No.584/23 3 -- 3 of 10 -- committal towards the same and has his eyes set on the jewellery that his mother left behind for plaintiff. The defendant no.1 is demanding the plaintiff to hand over the same to him. Hence, the present suit. The defendant no.1 filed written statement taking preliminary objections to the effect that in the year 2009 the deceased father of the defendant no.1 alongwith him took a home loan in respect of suit property and at the time of taking said home loan, the deceased father of the defendant no.1 finding it difficult to get the home loan because of his old age and various old age ailments and accordingly the defendant no.1 was made co- applicant in the said home loan. It is further stated that later on after the death of father of the defendant no.1 in 2013, the said home loan was transferred to India Bulls and the defendant no.1 was again made co-applicant alongwith his mother. The defendant no.1 has been paying all the installments of the said home loan starting from the beginning and the same fact can be confirmed by the bank statements of the defendant no.1. It is further stated that the mother of the plaintiff and defendant no.1 expired on 14.07.2020 and thereafter in July 2020 the plaintiff has taken over all the assets of deceased parents including cash approx. 50 lacs and golds articles and FDRs and PPF and saving accounts and guardian account and locker and jewellery etc. It is further stated that on regular persuasion by the defendant no.1 and other relatives a meeting in September, 2022 comprising of the plaintiff and the defendant no.1 and other relatives was held and it was mutually decided that the suit property would be held by the plaintiff and a new property would be purchased from the family funds in the name of the plaintiff and remaining assets such cash CS No.584/23 4 -- 4 of 10 -- cash approx. 50 lacs and gold articles and FDRs, and PPF, savings accounts and guardian account and locker and jewellery etc. would be distributed equally between the plaintiff and defendant no.1. Accordingly, the plaintiff has executed relinquishment deed dated 03.10.2022 in respect of her share in the suit property in favour of the defendant no.1. Simultaneously a property bearing H.No.3&4, Gali No.5, Shalimar Park Ext., Shahdara, Delhi-32 was purchased from the family funds in the name of the plaintiff vide sale deed dated 03.10.2022. It is further stated that after execution of relinquishment deed dated and execution of sale deed dated 03.10.2022, the defendant no.1 requested/demanded the plaintiff to produce/show the other details of assets for the proper distribution but the plaintiff kept the matter pending on false and frivolous grounds and as such the defendant no.1 has issued a legal notice to the plaintiff. Arguments on this application were heard. During the course of arguments, ld. Counsel for plaintiffs submitted that the plaintiff is the rightful owner of the half portion of the suit property and that the plaintiff is grossly prejudiced by the acts of the defendant No.1 who has from time to time affected the rights/title/interest of the plaintiff in the suit property as well as affected her mental health and well-being. Ld. counsel for plaintiff further submitted that the defendant No.1 has from time to time affected the mental well-being of the plaintiff and caused wrongful loss to the plaintiff by exercising coercion and undue influence on her and making her sign away her right and title in the suit property. Ld. counsel for plaintiff further submitted that the defendant No.1 has further been deliberately concealing the plaintiffs documents, her data necessary for Visa formalities and CS No.584/23 5 -- 5 of 10 -- admission to University of Europe for Applied Sciences as a bargaining chip to get the plaintiff out of her home and for her to hand over the jewellery bequeathed to her by her mother. Ld. counsel for plaintiff further submitted that the plaintiff has prima facie case in her favor and the balance of convenience also lies in favor of the plaintiff and irreparable loss and injury would be caused to the plaintiff if the interim reliefs are not granted to the plaintiff as against the defendants. Ld. counsel for plaintiff further submitted that the present application has been moved bona fide and in the interest of justice and no prejudice would be caused to the defendants if the same is allowed, rather grave injustice would be caused to the plaintiff if the interim reliefs are not granted. Therefore, ld. Counsel for plaintiff requested to allow the present application to pass the following orders:- i. direct the defendant No.1 to share the data/documents pertaining to plaintiff in his possession, with the plaintiff, which is necessary for completion of her formalities with respect to admission with University of Europe for Applied Sciences; restraining the defendants, their agents, successors or assigns from alienating or creating third party interest in the suit property; ii. Restrain the defendants, their agents, successors or assigns from alienating or creating third party interest in the suit property; and iii. Restrain the defendant, his agents, successors, assigns from interfering with and affecting the mental and physical well-being of the plaintiff. Per contra, ld. Counsel for defendant no.1 vehemently opposed the present application, submitting that the defendant no.1 has been paying all the installments of the said home loan CS No.584/23 6 -- 6 of 10 -- starting from the beginning in respect of the suit property and the same fact can be confirmed by the bank statements of the defendant no.1. Ld. counsel for defendant no.1 further submitted that after the death of mother of defendant no.1 in July 2020, the plaintiff has taken over all the assets of deceased parents including cash approx. 50 lacs and golds articles and FDRs and PPF and saving accounts and guardian account and locker and jewellery etc. but on regular persuasion by the defendant no.1 and other relatives a meeting in September, 2022 comprising of the plaintiff and the defendant no.1 and other relatives was held and it was mutually decided that the suit property would be held by the defendant no.1 and a new property would be purchased from the family funds in the name of the plaintiff and remaining assets such cash cash approx. 50 lacs and gold articles and FDRs, and PPF, savings accounts and guardian account and locker and jewellery etc. would be distributed equally between the plaintiff and defendant no.1. Ld. counsel for defendant no.1 further submitted that accordingly, the plaintiff has executed relinquishment deed dated 03.10.2022 in respect of her share in the suit property in favour of the defendant no.1 and simultaneously a property bearing H.No.3&4, Gali No.5, Shalimar Park Ext., Shahdara, Delhi-32 was purchased from the family funds in the name of the plaintiff vide sale deed dated 03.10.2022. Ld. counsel for defendant no.1 further submitted that after execution of relinquishment deed dated and execution of sale deed dated 03.10.2022, the defendant no.1 requested/demanded the plaintiff to produce/show the other details of assets for the proper distribution but the plaintiff kept the matter pending on false and frivolous grounds. Ld. counsel for defendant no.1 further CS No.584/23 7 -- 7 of 10 -- submitted that there is no prima facie case in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant no.1 and even no balance of convenience lies in favour of the plaintiff and as such ld. Counsel for defendant no.1 requested to dismiss the application of the plaintiff. I have considered the submissions made on behalf of the plaintiff and defendant no.1. 7 To succeed in an application under Order 39 Rule 1 & 2 CPC, the plaintiff has to prove three ingredients: 1 That he has a prima facie case in his favour. 2 That balance of convenience lies in favour of the plaintiff. 3 That if the injunction is not granted the plaintiff shall suffer irreparable loss or injury. 8 The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Kashi Math Samsthan v. Srimad Sudhindra Thirtha Swamy 2010 AIR (SC) 296 held that "it is well settled that in order to obtain an order of injunction, the party who seeks for grant of such injunction has to prove that he has made out a prima facie case to go for trial, the balance of convenience is also in his favour and he will suffer irreparable loss and injury if injunction is not granted. But it is equally well settled that when a party fails to prove prima facie case to go for trial, question of considering the balance of convenience or irreparable loss and injury to the party concerned would not be material at all, that is to say, if that party fails to prove prima facie case to go for trial, it is not open to the Court to grant injunction in his favour even if, he has made out a case of balance of convenience being in his favour and would suffer irreparable loss and injury if no injunction order is granted." CS No.584/23 8 -- 8 of 10 -- The plaintiff has filed the present suit for rescission and cancellation of relinquishment deed dated 03.09.2022, temporary and permanent injunction, declaration qua suit property and mandatory injunction and consequential relief of partition by metes and bounds. It is the case of the plaintiff that the defendant no.1 induced the plaintiff to execute a relinquishment deed dated 06.10.2022 and after execution of the relinquishment deed the attitude and behaviour of the defendant no.1 changed and the defendant no.1 and his wife have been pressuring the plaintiff to vacate the suit property. The defendant no.1 took a stand that on regular persuasion by the defendant no.1 and other relatives a meeting in September, 2022 comprising of the plaintiff and the defendant no.1 and other relatives was held and it was mutually decided that the suit property would be held by the plaintiff (inadvertently it has been mentioned as ‘plaintiff’, whereas it should have been mentioned as defendant no.1) and a new property would be purchased from the family funds in the name of the plaintiff and remaining assets would be distributed equally between the plaintiff and defendant no.1 and accordingly, the plaintiff has executed relinquishment deed dated 03.10.2022 in respect of her share in the suit property in favour of the defendant no.1. The defendant no.1 also took the stand that a property bearing H.No.3&4, Gali No.5, Shalimar Park Ext., Shahdara, Delhi-32 was purchased from the family funds in the name of the plaintiff vide sale deed dated 03.10.2022. However, the defendant no.1 has not produced any documents to prove these facts. If the defendant no.1 had been paying all the installments of the home loan qua suit property, then he should CS No.584/23 9 -- 9 of 10 -- have got transferred the ownership rights qua suit property in his favour at the relevant time but he did not do so. The plaintiff on the other hand has placed on record copy of his medical treatment including psychotherapy report which depicts the mental condition of the plaintiff was not stable. Therefore, the plaintiff has successfully been able to make out a prima facie case in her favour and balance of convenience also lies in favour of the plaintiff and there are chances of irreparable harm being caused to the plaintiff if injunction is not granted in her favour however only in respect of prayer no.2 made in the present application. Further, it would be in the interest of the parties and also in order to preserve the suit property and also to avoid the multiplicity of litigations, parties are directed to maintain status quo in respect of suit property. However, the prayers no.1 and 3 made in the present application are declined. Accordingly, the application is partly allowed and defendant no.1, his agents, successors, or assigns are hereby restrained from from alienating or creating third party interest in the suit property, till the disposal of this suit. It is made clear that nothing herein mention would tantamount to expression of opinion on the merit of the case. Application is accordingly disposed off. (Typed to the dictation directly, corrected and pronounced in open court on 26.02.2024). (RAMESH KUMAR-II) ADDL. DISTRICT JUDGE-01 SHAHDARA DISTRICT KARKARDOOMA COURTS KARKARDOOMA COURTS DELHI DELHI CS No.584/23 10 -- 10 of 10 --
