Skip to main content
Court Order

Final Order 11

CNR DLSH01004768202322 Feb 2025
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Final Order 11 · 22 Feb 2025 · CNR DLSH010047682023

Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT
Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. HARUN PRATAP, PO, MACT-02,
DISTRICT SHAHDARA, KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI.
MACT No.: 371/23
CNR No. DLSH01-004768-2023
IN THE MATTER OF:-
1. Smt. Mantoraya Devi
(w/o deceased Sh. Ravi Karan)
2. Shashi Devi
(d/o deceased Sh. Ravi Karan)
3. Nanki Devi
(d/o deceased Sh. Ravi Karan)
4. Durgesh Yadav
(s/o deceased Sh. Ravi Karan)
5. Chhotu Yadav
(s/o deceased Sh. Ravi Karan)
6. Preet Devi
(d/o deceased Sh. Ravi Karan)
7. Jugun Devi
(mother of deceased Sh. Ravi Karan)
8. Lalli Yadav
(father of deceased Sh. Ravi Karan)
All R/o Village Umarawan Kachhar,
Distt. Kaushambi, U.P.
........ Petitioners
MACT No. 371/23
Mantoryaya Devi Vs. Mahesh Kumar & Ors. Page No. 1 of 22
-- 1 of 22 --
Vs.
1. Sh. Mahesh Kumar
S/o Sh. Maharaj Singh
R/o Village Nagala, Naru, PO- Bangaon,
Distt. Mainpuri, U.P.
(driver of offending vehicle no. DL1MA-7766)
…. (Driver)
2. Shri Ram Transport Corporation
Through its prop. Namely Yesh
H. No. A-5-D1 Swarn Park, Delhi
…. (Owner)
3. The Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
N-39, Bombay Life Building,
Connaught place, New Delhi
……….... Insurer
... Respondents
Date of institution of claim petition : 31.07.2023
Date of Arguments : 14.02.2025
Date of Award : 22.02.2025
Advocates appearing in the case:
For petitioner : Sh. Kumar Shivam
For respondent no. 1 & 2 : Sh. Sumit Yadav
For respondent no. 3 / Ins. com. : Sh. G D Sharma
AWARD
Vide this award, the Tribunal shall decide the DAR treated as MACT
claim petition bearing no. 371/23 under section 166(4) & 140 of Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988, filed for the petitioners and against the respondents as
MACT No. 371/23
Mantoryaya Devi Vs. Mahesh Kumar & Ors. Page No. 2 of 22
-- 2 of 22 --
mentioned in the memo of parties.
FACTS OF THE CASE
1. Briefly stated, the facts of the case are that on 25.05.2023, at about
12:30 a.m., one Ravi Karan (since deceased) along with his co-workers
namely Satish, Doje, Sunil, and a driver namely Norang were going to
Karol Bagh, Delhi from Loni Ghaziabad, on a truck bearing registration no.
UP-14KT-0646. The said truck was loaded with bricks and it was being
driven by its driver Naurang. It has been alleged that when the said truck
reached on the metro station flyover, Welcome, Delhi, suddenly its front
tyre got burst and the aforesaid Ravi Karan (since deceased) along with his
companions got down from the truck to change its tyre/stepny of the truck.
It has been alleged that thereon a truck bearing registration no.
DL1MA-7766 (hereinafter referred to as offending vehicle) came at a very
fast speed and rammed the stationary truck from the backside. It has been
further alleged that the offending vehicle was being driven by its driver i.e.
respondent no. 1 (R1 herein), at a very high speed and in a rash and
negligent manner without taking necessary precautions. It has been further
alleged that due to the forceful impact, Ravi Karan (since deceased), Sunil
and Doje got struck inside the truck and sustained grievous injuries. Ravi
Karan (since deceased) was thereon taken to GTB hospital where he was
declared ‘brought dead’ by the doctors and his MLC was prepared. The
postmortem was thereon conducted at mortuary of GTB Hospital vide PM
No. 856/23. An FIR in this regard was also registered at PS Welcome,
Delhi, vide FIR no. 434/23 for the offences u/s 279/337/338/304A IPC. The
MACT No. 371/23
Mantoryaya Devi Vs. Mahesh Kumar & Ors. Page No. 3 of 22
-- 3 of 22 --
present DAR thereafter came to be filed in due course on 31.07.2023.
2. Notice of the DAR petition was duly served upon all the respondents.
WS / Reply of Respondents
3. In their joint WS filed by respondent no. 1 and 2, being the driver and
owner of the offending vehicle respectively, it has been contended that the
R1 was driving his vehicle at a normal speed and that the alleged accident
took place due to the sole negligence on part of the deceased himself. It has
been further contended that the offending vehicle was duly insured with
respondent no. 3 (R3) i.e. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., vide policy no.
214600/312023/838, valid till 16.09.2023, in the name of R2, at the date
and time of the alleged accident. The respondent no. 1 and 2 denied the
averments of the DAR and prayed for its dismissal.
4. Respondent no. 3 i.e. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd, also filed its separate
detailed written statement, wherein it has been admitted that the offending
vehicle was duly insured with the company vide insurance policy no.
214600/312023/838, valid from 17.09.2022 to midnight 16.09.2023, issued
in the name of Shri Ram Transport Company, through prop. Yashpal Yadav
i.e. R2 herein. However, it has been contended that the accident took place
due to the sole negligence on the part of the deceased and thus, the
insurance company denied its liability to pay the compensation amount.
ISSUES
5. From the pleadings of the parties, following issues were framed by
MACT No. 371/23
Mantoryaya Devi Vs. Mahesh Kumar & Ors. Page No. 4 of 22
-- 4 of 22 --
the Ld. Predecessor vide order dated 22.12.2023, as under:-
(i) Whether respondent no. 1 was driving the offending vehicle No.
DL-1MA-7766 on 25.05.2023 at about 12:30 am at Shahdara to ISBT
towards near Metro Station Flyover Welcome, Delhi within the jurisdiction
of PS Welcome in a rash and negligent manner and caused the death of
deceased Sh. Ravi Karan? OPP
(ii) Whether petitioners are entitled for compensation, if so, to what
extent and from whom? OPP
(iii) Relief.
PETITIONER'S EVIDENCE
6. In order to prove their case, petitioners examined Ms. Mantoreya i.e.
the wife of deceased as PW1. She tendered her evidence by way of affidavit
Ex.PW-1/A and relied upon the following documents:-
Sl. No. Exhibit No. Particulars
1 Ex.PW1/1
(OSR)
Photocopy of Aadhar card of deceased Ravi
Karan
2 Ex.PW1/2
(OSR)
Copy of Aadhar card of of deponent
3 Ex.PW1/3
(OSR)
Copy of PAN card of Mantoreya Devi
4 Ex.PW1/4
(OSR)
Copy of Aadhar card of Shashi Devi (petitioner
no. 2)
5 Ex.PW1/5
(OSR)
Copy of PAN card of Shashi Devi (petitioner no.
2)
6 Ex.PW1/6
(OSR)
Copy of Aadhar card of Nanki Devi (petitioner
no. 3)
7 Ex.PW1/7 Copy of PAN card of Nanki Devi (petitioner no.
MACT No. 371/23
Mantoryaya Devi Vs. Mahesh Kumar & Ors. Page No. 5 of 22
-- 5 of 22 --
(OSR) 3)
8 Ex.PW1/8
(OSR)
Copy of Aadhar card of Durgesh Yadav
(petitioner no. 4)
9 Ex.PW1/9
(OSR)
Copy of PAN card of Durgesh Yadav (petitioner
no. 4)
10 Ex.PW1/10
(OSR)
Copy of Aadhar card of Chotu (petitioner no.5)
11 Ex.PW1/11
(OSR)
Copy of PAN card of Chotu (petitioner no.5)
12 Ex.PW1/12
(OSR)
Copy of Aadhar card of Priti (petitioner no.6)
13 Ex.PW1/13
(OSR)
Copy of PAN card of Priti (petitioner no.6)
14 Ex.PW1/14
(OSR)
Copy of Aadhar card of Jugun (petitioner no.7)
15 Ex.PW1/15
(OSR)
Copy of PAN card of Jugun (petitioner no.7)
16 Ex.PW1/16
(OSR)
Copy of Aadhar card of Lalli (petitioner no.8)
17 Ex.PW1/17
(OSR)
Copy of PAN card of Lalli (petitioner no.8)
18 Ex.PW1/18
(OSR)
Attested copy of DAR
19 Mark X Copy of death certificate of deceased Sh. Ravi
Karan
7. The PW-1 reiterated the contents of the DAR in her evidence
affidavit. However, she admitted during her cross examination that she was
MACT No. 371/23
Mantoryaya Devi Vs. Mahesh Kumar & Ors. Page No. 6 of 22
-- 6 of 22 --
not an eye witness to the accident. PW1 further deposed that her deceased
husband used to earn Rs. 22,000/- per month, however, she admitted that
she does not have any documentary evidence regarding the said income.
She also deposed that her parents in law i.e. the parents of the deceased live
with her, but they are not in a physical state to do any work because of old
age. She also deposed that her children were also not studying as she does
not have any money. PW1 also stated that her entire family was living in
Kaushambi, U.P. PW1 further deposed that her husband had died of
accidental injuries after two days of the accident and that his treatment was
done in government hospital and they did not spend any money on the said
treatment.
8. In order to prove their case, petitioners also examined Ravi Kumar
Singhal, being the employer of the deceased as PW2. He deposed that the
deceased used to work on his truck as brick labour on contract basis and that
he used to earn Rs. 800/- per day for his work of 8 hours. However, he
admitted that he had no document regarding the appointment, promotion or
salary voucher of the deceased Ravi Karan. During his cross-examination,
PW2 deposed that he was not present at the time of the accident. He further
deposed that he had no documentary evidence that the deceased had ever
worked with him.
9. The petitioners also examined an eye witness of the accident namely
Sh. Doje as PW3. He tendered his evidence by way of affidavit Ex. PW3/A
wherein he reiterated the contents of the DAR and relied upon his Aadhar
MACT No. 371/23
Mantoryaya Devi Vs. Mahesh Kumar & Ors. Page No. 7 of 22
-- 7 of 22 --
card as Ex. PW3/1 (OSR). During his cross-examination conducted by Ld.
Counsel for R3, PW3 specifically deposed that he was the eye witness of
the accident which occurred on 24/25.05.2023 at about 12:30 in the night.
He stated that the police recorded his statement at the hospital and that his
companions Ravi Karan and Satish had expired due to the accident while,
he had suffered injuries along with Sunil Kumar. He specifically stated that
the front right side/driver side tyre of their vehicle had got burst and that he
along with Sunil Kumar were trying to install the jack for changing the tyre
whereas Satish and Ravi Karan had gone to the backside of the truck for
getting the spare tyre. PW3 specifically stated that there was no heavy
traffic at that time and that they had taken their vehicle to the side of the
road before changing its tyre. He also stated that the offending vehicle was
of red colour and it had hit their truck from the backside. PW3 also stated
that he had called the police before becoming unconscious and that the
deceased Ravi Karan had expired at the spot itself.
10. PE was thereon closed by the Tribunal vide order dated 17.12.2024,
in view of the separate statement of Ld. Counsel for petitioner recorded to
this effect.
Respondents' Evidence
11. Respondents failed to lead any evidence in this case despite being
granted sufficient opportunities and the respondents evidence came to be
closed vide order dt 04.02.2025.
MACT No. 371/23
Mantoryaya Devi Vs. Mahesh Kumar & Ors. Page No. 8 of 22
-- 8 of 22 --
12. Final arguments heard. File perused.
Issue wise findings
ISSUE NO. 1
13.
Whether respondent no. 1 was driving the offending vehicle No.
DL-1MA-7766 on 25.05.2023 at about 12:30 am at Shahdara to ISBT
towards near Metro Station Flyover Welcome, Delhi within the jurisdiction
of PS Welcome in a rash and negligent manner and caused the death of
deceased Sh. Ravi Karan? OPP
14. In an action founded on the principle of fault liability, the proof of
rash and negligent driving of the offending vehicle is sine qua non.
However, the standard of proof is not as strict as applied in criminal cases
and evidence is tested on the touchstone of principle of preponderance of
probabilities
. It is well settled that the procedure followed for proceedings
conducted by an accident tribunal is similar to that followed by a civil court
and in civil matters the facts are required to be established by
preponderance of probabilities only and not by strict rules of evidence or
beyond reasonable doubts as are required in a criminal prosecution. The
burden of proof in a civil case is never as heavy as that is required in a
criminal case, but in a claim petition under the Motor Vehicles Act, this
burden is infact even lesser than that in a civil case. Reference in this regard
can be made to the propositions of law laid down by Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of
Bimla Devi & Ors. Vs Himachal Road Transport
Corporation & Ors, reported in (2009) 13 SC 530, which were reiterated in
the subsequent judgment in the case of
Parmeshwari Vs Amir Chand & Ors,
2011 (1) SCR 1906 (Civil Appeal No. 1082 of 2011) and also recently in
MACT No. 371/23
Mantoryaya Devi Vs. Mahesh Kumar & Ors. Page No. 9 of 22
-- 9 of 22 --
another case
Mangla Ram Vs. Oriental Insurance Co. ltd. & Ors., 2018 Law
Suit (SC) 303.
15. In the present case, the petitioners have examined the wife of
deceased as PW-1 to prove their contentions apart from examining an eye
witness of the incident as their star witness as PW-3. Both the said
witnesses have categorically stated in their examination on oath that the
accident was caused due to rash and negligent act of respondent no. 1 being
driver of the offending vehicle. The said contentions are duly corroborated
by the findings of the police as mentioned in the site plan, postmortem
report along with other documents pertaining to criminal case in respect of
the incident in question brought on record as Ex. PW1/18 (colly) and no
ground has been made out by the respondents to disbelieve the same.
16. Respondent no.1 i.e. driver of the offending vehicle, respondent no.2
i.e. the owner of offending vehicle and respondent no. 3 i.e. Insurance
Company, have neither impeached the testimony of PW-1 & PW-3 nor they
have led any defence evidence to substantiate their claim that the accident
was caused due to fault of the deceased or that they have been falsely
implicated in the present case. The evidence of the star witness in this case
i.e. PW-3, makes it apparently clear that the offending vehicle had rammed
the truck of the victim from the backside at a time when there was no heavy
traffic on the road and such an act of ramming a vehicle at its backside is
ipso-facto sufficient proof of rash and negligent act on part of the driver of
the offending vehicle. The testimony of PW3 on the aspect of rash and
MACT No. 371/23
Mantoryaya Devi Vs. Mahesh Kumar & Ors. Page No. 10 of 22
-- 10 of 22 --
negligent act of respondent no.1 while driving the offending vehicle, has
remained unimpeached and his testimony has to be accepted on its face
value itself as the same has successfully stood the test of cross-examination.
17. The very fact that R-1 has already been specifically arrayed as an
accused in case FIR No. 437/23, PS Welcome, Delhi for the offences u/s
279/337/304A IPC is itself a strong circumstance to support the above said
testimony of PW-3 on these issues. The copies of FIR, Site plan, seizure
memos, mechanical inspection report and notice u/s 133 MV Act, brought
on record as part of DAR Ex. PW1/18 (colly) also corroborate the oral
testimony of PW-1 & PW-3.
18. Besides the above, respondent no. 1 namely Mahesh Kumar was the
best witness who could have stepped into the witness box to challenge the
depositions being made by PW-1 and PW-3, regarding the above accident
and its manner etc., but he has not done so. Therefore, an adverse inference
on this aspect is also required to be drawn against the respondents in view
of the law laid down in case of
Cholamandalam M.S. General Insurance
Company Ltd. Vs. Kamlesh, reported in 2009 (3) AD (Delhi)
19. In view of the above, it could be safely assumed that the offending
vehicle was being driven by R-1 indeed at the time of incident and the fatal
injuries to the deceased took place on account of the incident in question
itself.
MACT No. 371/23
Mantoryaya Devi Vs. Mahesh Kumar & Ors. Page No. 11 of 22
-- 11 of 22 --
20. Having ruled so, this Tribunal now proceeds to assess the wrongful
act, neglect or default of R-1, if any, in driving the offending vehicle at the
relevant time. Admittedly, R-1 has not explained the circumstances under
which his vehicle (i.e. the offending vehicle) hit Sh. Ravi Karan (since
deceased). In the absence of any averment or evidence regarding any
mechanical defect in the offending vehicle or any material depicting any
negligent/sudden act or omission on the part of the deceased or any other
such person, the only inference possible in the given facts and
circumstances is that of neglect and default on the part of R-1 in driving the
offending vehicle at the relevant time. In view of the above discussion, this
Tribunal is constrained to hold R-1 guilty of gross neglect and default in
driving the offending vehicle at the relevant time leading to the fatal injuries
to the deceased Ravi Karan.
21. Furthermore, in view of the medical records, postmortem report
placed on record by the petitioners, no doubt or dispute is left regarding the
fatal injuries to the deceased Ravi Karan in the above accident.
22. Therefore, in view of the above discussion, this Tribunal holds that
the deceased Ravi Karan suffered fatal injuries on account of neglect and
default of R-1 while driving the offending vehicle at the relevant time. The
issue at hand is thus decided against the respondents and in favour of the
petitioners.
MACT No. 371/23
Mantoryaya Devi Vs. Mahesh Kumar & Ors. Page No. 12 of 22
-- 12 of 22 --
Issue no. (ii)
Whether petitioners are entitled for compensation, if so, to what extent and
from whom? OPP
23. On the basis of findings upon issue no. (i), it is clear that the incident
in question had occurred due to rash and negligent driving of offending
vehicle by R-1 and fatal injuries had been caused to the deceased in the
incident. Hence, petitioners being the LRs and dependent of the deceased
are entitled to compensation in this case.
24. The issue at hand is accordingly decided in favour of the petitioners
and against the respondents.
LIABILITY
25. Now, the question arises as to which of the respondent is liable to pay
the compensation amount. The respondent no. 1 Mahesh Kumar is the
principal principal
tort feasor being the driver of the offending vehicle,
while the respondent no. 2 is vicariously liable being the owner of the
offending vehicle. Herein, it is pertinent to note that the respondent no. 3 i.e.
Insurance Company has specifically admitted in its written statement that
the offending vehicle was duly insured at the time of accident with
respondent no. 3 vide policy No. no. 214600/312023/838 valid from
17.09.2022 to midnight 16.09.2023. At the same time, the respondent no. 3
have failed to bring on record or to prove any breach of the terms or
conditions of the said insurance policy by the respondents no. 1 and 2 in any
manner.
MACT No. 371/23
Mantoryaya Devi Vs. Mahesh Kumar & Ors. Page No. 13 of 22
-- 13 of 22 --
26. Hence, on the basis of entire above stated facts and circumstances and
discussion of evidence, this Tribunal is of the opinion that respondent no.3
i.e. insurance company, is liable to pay the entire compensation to the
petitioner on behalf of respondent no.1 and 2, without any recovery rights.
ISSUE NO. 3
RELIEF:-
COMPUTATION OF COMPENSATION
27. As far as computation of compensation is concerned, the same shall
be under the following heads :-
MEDICAL EXPENSES
28. It is clear from above stated facts and circumstances that the deceased
had expired immediately after the accident and no medical expenditure was
undertaken by the petitioner in the treatment of the deceased before his
death, hence, petitioner is not entitled to any compensation under this head
on account of absence of any evidence brought on record in this regard.
LOSS OF DEPENDENCY
29. In the present case, perusal of the Aadhar card of Sh. Ravi Karan Ex.
PW1/1 reveal that date of birth of the deceased was 22.04.1987 and the
same has not been disputed in any manner by the respondents. Therefore,
the deceased was thus aged about 36 years at the time of the incident
resulting in his death on 25.05.2023.
MACT No. 371/23
Mantoryaya Devi Vs. Mahesh Kumar & Ors. Page No. 14 of 22
-- 14 of 22 --
30. The petitioners have failed to file any document pertaining to the
employment of the deceased Sh. Ravi Karan to show that he used to earn
Rs.800/- per day or that he possessed any specific skill. Furthermore, it is
pertinent to note that the deceased and his entire family admittedly resided
in the state of U.P. only and even the Truck on which the deceased was
allegedly employed as a contract labour also bears the registration no. of the
State of U.P. Therefore, in absence of any documents on record to show that
deceased used to earn Rs.800/- per day, this Tribunal has assessed the
income of deceased at parity with ‘
minimum wages’ of U.P prevalent at the
time of accident i.e. Rs. 10,089/- per month on the date of accident.
31. Furthermore, as per the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court titled
as
“National Insurance Company Limited Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. (2017)
16 SCC 680”, 40% addition shall be given to the deceased towards future
prospects as he was below 40 years of age at the time of incident and he
was self employed. Therefore, the monthly income of the deceased with
40% future prospects comes out to be Rs. 10,089/- + 4035.60/- (10,089/- X
40/100) = Rs. 14,124.60/- per month.
32. As held above, the deceased Ravi Karan was having his wife, parents
and five children dependent upon him on the date of the incident. Therefore,
all the eight petitioners shall be treated as dependents of the deceased for
the purpose of the present petition. Furthermore, since there were total 08
dependents of the deceased, hence, 1/5th of the earnings of the deceased
Ravi Karan shall be deducted towards his personal and living expenses.
MACT No. 371/23
Mantoryaya Devi Vs. Mahesh Kumar & Ors. Page No. 15 of 22
-- 15 of 22 --
Therefore, in the entire given facts and circumstances, deduction of 1/5th of
total income is made for personal living expenses of deceased. Hence, an
amount of Rs. 2,824.92/- (Rs. 14,124.60/5) is required to be deducted from
annual income of deceased. Finally, annual dependency of dependents is
calculated as under (annual income) – (annual expenses of deceased) i.e.
(Rs.1,69,495/- – Rs. 33,899/-) = Rs.1,35,596/- per annum.
33. Moreover, in view of the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in case of “
Sarla Verma & Ors. Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation &
Anr”., (2009) 6 SCC 121, which has also been upheld by the Constitutional
Bench of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of “
National Insurance
Company Ltd. Vs Pranay Sethi & Ors”. SLP (Civil) No. 25590 of 2014,
decided on 31.10.2017, the multiplier of ‘15’ is held applicable for
calculating the loss of dependency caused to the petitioner on account of
death of the deceased. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, the
total loss of dependency qua the deceased in the present case comes out to
be Rs. 1,35,596/- X 15 = Rs. 20,33,940/-.
LOSS OF CONSORTIUM / LOSS OF LOVE AND AFFECTION
34. In “
Magma Vs. General Insurance Co. Ltd Vs. Nanu Ram & Ors”.
2018 ACJ 2782, it was observed by Hon'ble Supreme Court that
'consortium' is a compendious term, which encompasses 'spousal
consortium', 'parental consortium' and 'filial consortium'. The right to
consortium would include the company, care, help, comfort, guidance,
solace and affection of the deceased, which is a loss to his entire family.
MACT No. 371/23
Mantoryaya Devi Vs. Mahesh Kumar & Ors. Page No. 16 of 22
-- 16 of 22 --
Spousal Consortium allows compensation to surviving spouse for loss of
'company, society, co-operation, affection and aid of the other in every
conjugal relation'. The Hon'ble Supreme Court further observed in said
judgment that parental consortium is granted to the child upon the
premature death of a parent, for loss of 'parental aid, protection, affection,
society, discipline, guidance and training. Similarly, filial consortium is to
be granted to each of the surviving dependent parents on the death of their
child.
35. In the facts and circumstances of the present case, the computation of
compensation under this head is as follows :
Filial Consortium : Rs. 96,000/- (Rs. 48,000/- X 2)
Spousal Consortium : Rs. 48,000/- (Rs. 48,000/- X 1)
Parental Consortium : Rs. 2,40,000/- (Rs. 48,000/- X 5)
36. Hence, the petitioner is hereby awarded a total sum of Rs.
3,84,000/- on account of loss of consortium/loss of love and affection under
this head.
LOSS OF ESTATE & FUNERAL EXPENSES
37. A total sum of Rs. 36,000/- is awarded in favour of petitioners under
both the heads i.e. Rs. 18,000/- on account of 'loss of estate' and Rs.18,000/-
for 'funeral expenses' of the deceased, as per the law laid down in “
National
Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors.” (Supra).
MACT No. 371/23
Mantoryaya Devi Vs. Mahesh Kumar & Ors. Page No. 17 of 22
-- 17 of 22 --
38. The total amount of compensation to be granted in favour of the
petitioner in this case is thus Rs. 20,33,940/- + Rs. 3,84,000/- + Rs. 36,000/-
= Rs. 24,53,940/-.
ISSUE NO.3 / RELIEF
39. In view of the the findings on the aforesaid issues, the petitioner is
hereby awarded a sum of Rs. 24,53,940/- (Rupees Twenty Four Lakh Fifty
Three Thousand Nine Hundred and Fourty Only) along with interest @ 8%
per annum from the date of filing of DAR till its deposition by the insurer
i.e. respondent no. 3. However, it is directed that the amount of interim
award, if any, shall be excluded from the above amount and calculations of
compensation.
RELEASE/APPORTIONMENT OF COMPENSATION TO THE
PETITIONERS
40. Finally, out of the aforesaid awarded amount, the petitioner no. 1
namely Smt. Mantoreya is hereby awarded Rs. 13,53,940/-, out of which
Rs. 12,00,000/- is directed to be kept with
UCO Bank, Karkardooma Court
Branch, Delhi bearing account no. 20780110171912; IFSC: UCBA0002078
in MACAD in the form of 60 monthly fixed deposit receipts (FDRs) of Rs.
20,000/- payable in equal amounts for a period of 1 to 60 months in
succession, as per the scheme formulated by the Hon'ble Delhi High Court
vide order dated 08.01.2021 in FAO No. 842/2003, titled as
Rajesh Tyagi &
Ors. Vs. Jaibir Singh & Ors. The amount of FDRs on maturity would be
released in her savings/MACT Claims SB Account, maintained with UCO
MACT No. 371/23
Mantoryaya Devi Vs. Mahesh Kumar & Ors. Page No. 18 of 22
-- 18 of 22 --
Bank, KKD Branch, Delhi. Remaining amount of Rs. 1,53,940/- and the
interest component to be paid by the respondent no. 3 is also directed to be
released into her account, which can be withdrawn and utilized by the
petitioner no. 1 as per her volition.
41. Out of the awarded amount, the petitioner namely Shashi Devi i.e.
major daughter of deceased is awarded a sum of Rs. 1,00,000/- and the
same is directed to be kept with
UCO Bank, Karkardooma Court Branch,
Delhi bearing account no. 20780110171912; IFSC: UCBA0002078 in
MACAD in the form of 10 monthly fixed deposit receipts (FDRs) of Rs.
10,000/- each payable in equal amounts for a period of 1 to 10 months in
succession, as per the scheme formulated by the Hon'ble Delhi High Court
vide order dated 08.01.2021 in FAO No. 842/2003, titled as
Rajesh Tyagi &
Ors. Vs. Jaibir Singh & Ors. The amount of FDRs on maturity would be
released in their savings/MACT Claims SB Account, maintained with UCO
Bank, KKD Branch, Delhi.
42. Out of the awarded amount, the petitioners i.e. minor children of
deceased namely Nanki Devi, Preet Devi, Chhotu Yadav and Durgesh
Yadav are awarded a sum of Rs. 1,00,000/- each and the same is directed to
be kept with
UCO Bank, Karkardooma Court Branch, Delhi bearing
account no. 20780110171912; IFSC: UCBA0002078 in MACAD in an
FDR till the date they attain age of maturity, as per the scheme formulated
by the Hon'ble Delhi High Court vide order dated 08.01.2021 in FAO No.
842/2003, titled as Rajesh Tyagi & Ors. Vs. Jaibir Singh & Ors. The amount
MACT No. 371/23
Mantoryaya Devi Vs. Mahesh Kumar & Ors. Page No. 19 of 22
-- 19 of 22 --
of FDRs on maturity would be released in his savings/MACT Claims SB
Account, maintained with UCO Bank, KKD Branch, Delhi.
43. Out of the awarded amount, the petitioners i.e. parents of deceased
namely Jugun Devi (mother of deceased) and Sh. Lalli Yadav (father of
deceased) are awarded a sum of Rs. 3,00,000/- each, out of which total
amount of Rs. 3,00,000/- each is directed to be kept with
UCO Bank,
Karkardooma Court Branch, Delhi bearing account no. 20780110171912;
IFSC: UCBA0002078 in MACAD in the form of 15 monthly fixed deposit
receipts (FDRs) of Rs. 20,000/-each payable in equal amounts for a period
of 1 to 15 months in succession, as per the scheme formulated by the
Hon'ble Delhi High Court vide order dated 08.01.2021 in FAO No.
842/2003, titled as
Rajesh Tyagi & Ors. Vs. Jaibir Singh & Ors. The amount
of FDRs on maturity would be released in their savings/MACT Claims SB
Account, maintained with UCO Bank, KKD Branch, Delhi.
44. All the FDRs to be prepared as per aforesaid directions, shall be
subject to the following conditions:-
(a) The original fixed deposit shall be retained by the bank in safe
custody and copies of the same be provided to the petitioner with the
statement containing FDR number, FDR amount, date of maturity and
maturity amount.
(b) The maturity amounts of the FDR(s) be credited by Electronic
Clearing System (ECS) in the savings bank account of the claimant.
(c) No loan, advance, withdrawal or pre-mature discharge be allowed on
MACT No. 371/23
Mantoryaya Devi Vs. Mahesh Kumar & Ors. Page No. 20 of 22
-- 20 of 22 --
the fixed deposits without permission of the Court.
(d) The concerned bank shall not issue any cheque book and/or debit
card to claimant / his guardian. However, in case the debit card and /or
cheque book have already been issued, bank shall cancel the same before
the disbursement of the award amount.
(e) The bank shall make an endorsement on the passbook of the claimant
to the effect that no cheque book and/or debit card have been issued and
shall not be issued without the permission of the Court.
45. Respondent no. 3, being insurer of the offending vehicle, is directed
to deposit the award amount with interest @ 8% per annum till date with
UCO Bank, Karkardooma Court Branch within 30 days as per above order,
failing which insurance company shall be liable to pay interest @ 12% p.a
for the period of delay. Concerned Branch Manager, UCO Bank,
Karkardooma Court Branch is directed to transfer the share amount of the
petitioners in their bank account / FDRs as per above-said directions, on
completing necessary formalities as per rules. The Branch Manager, is
further directed to keep the said amounts in fixed deposits in name of this
Court in auto renewal mode every 15 days, till the claimants approach the
bank for disbursement, so that the award amount starts earning interest from
the date of clearance of the cheques. Soft copy of the award be uploaded on
official website of Delhi District Courts i.e. https://delhidistrictcourts.nic.in.
46. Form IV-A and Form-V, in terms of MCTAP, shall be read as part of
the Award. Copy of the award be given dasti to the petitioner and also to
MACT No. 371/23
Mantoryaya Devi Vs. Mahesh Kumar & Ors. Page No. 21 of 22
-- 21 of 22 --
counsel for the insurance company for compliance. Copy of this award
alongwith one photograph each, specimen signatures, copy of bank
passbooks and copy of residence proof of the petitioners, be sent to Nodal
Officer of UCO Bank, Karkardooma Court Branch, Delhi for information
and necessary compliance.
Announced in open Court on this
22nd Day of February, 2025
(HARUN PRATAP)
PO-(MACT-02), SHAHDARA
KKD COURTS/DELHI.
MACT No. 371/23
Mantoryaya Devi Vs. Mahesh Kumar & Ors. Page No. 22 of 22
-- 22 of 22 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.