Skip to main content
Court Order

Final Order 7

CNR DLSH01004758202311 Jul 2024
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Final Order 7 · 11 Jul 2024 · CNR DLSH010047582023

Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT
Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SHRI ARVIND BANSAL
ADDL.SESSIONS JUDGE – 05 (SHAHDARA DISTRICT)
KARKARDOOMA COURTS : DELHI
Criminal Appeal No. 123/2023
In the matter of:
Taruna Yadav
w/o Shri Gajender Singh Yadav
d/o Late Shri Devender Kumar
r/o H. No. 60, Gali No. 4, Ganga Vihar,
Shahdara, Delhi-110094.
Also at: Jack Compound-II, Ghukna Mod,
Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh.
……….Appellant
Vs.
(I) Gajender Singh Yadav (Husband)
s/o Shri Brijpal Yadav
(ii) Brijpal Yadav (Father-in-law)
(iii) Pushpa Devi (Mother-in-law)
w/o Shri Brijpal Yadav
(iv) Deepak (Brother-in-law)
s/o Shri Brijpal Yadav
all r/o H. No. 122, Harbansh Nagar,
Meerut Road, District Ghaziabad, U.P.
Fresh add: E-151, Sec. XVII, Kavi Nagar
Industrial Area, Ghaziabad, U.P-201002.
……….Respondents
Date of Institution : 01.08.2023
Reserved on : 15.05.2024
Announced on : 11.07.2024
J U D G M E N T
Taruna Yadav vs. Gajender Singh Yadav
Page 1 of 11
-- 1 of 11 --
1. Vide this judgment, the Court shall decide instant
Appeal filed by appellant/wife u/s 29 of Prevention of Women
from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (hereinafter referred as ‘DV
Act’) against impugned judgment dated 26.06.2023 of Ld. Trial
Court thereby directing the respondent no.1/husband to pay
Rs.8,000/- per month to appellant/wife and two children as
maintenance, and compensation of Rs. 50,000/- to the
appellant/wife for her mental trauma.
2. Succinctly stated, it is the case of appellant/wife as
narrated in the impugned judgment:
That marriage between Taruna Yadav and Gajender
Singh Yadav was solemnized as per Hindu rights and ceremonies
on 10.12.2005 at H. No. 60, Gali No. 4, Ganga Vihar, Shahdara,
Delhi-110094. Two children namely Prathik and Nitik were born
from the said wedlock. Parents of the complainant had spent
Rs.4,50,000/- in marriage. They gave motorcycle and other
dowry articles consisting of gold and silver jewellery to the
respondents. Soon after their wedding, respondent no. 1,2,3 & 4
started taunting the petitioner for not bringing enough dowry and
started demanding one Maruti car. Respondents used to abuse
and beat the complainant even in the state of fever and sickness.
She was kept starved for days by the respondents. She stated that
in the year 2008, the father of complainant had died of
electrocution and compensation of Rs. 2,00,000/- was given by
the concerned authorities and respondents started demanding that
compensation amount also. They used to say that complainant
had six working brothers and also had property in village and tell
her not to come home if Rs. 02 lacs is not paid to them alongwith
Taruna Yadav vs. Gajender Singh Yadav
Page 2 of 11
-- 2 of 11 --
Maruti car. She also stated that on 09.10.2009, respondent no. 2
called her but she could not go as she was feeding her younger
son. Thereafter, respondent no. 2 started shouting at and abusing
her. Respondent No. 1,2,3 & 4 started beating her with fist and
kick blows. Petitioner made a complaint against the respondents
regarding the cruelties committed by them upon her, and filed a
petition u/s 12 of D.V. Act.
3. Respondents appeared before Ld. Trial Court and
file their reply to the application of appellant/wife u/s 12 of D.V.
Act. Interim application filed by appellant/wife before Ld. Trial
Court u/s 23 D.V. Act was decided and interim maintenance of
Rs. 3600/- per month was granted to her. Thereafter, matter was
taken up for complainant evidence. In support of her case,
complainant examined herself as CW-1 and tendered her
evidence by way of affidavit Ex.CW1/A. She relied upon various
documents Ex.CW1/1(OSR) to Ex.CW1/10(OSR) and document
Mark‘A’. She was duly cross-examined by Ld. Counsel for
respondent/husband. After completion of complainant evidence,
respondent examined himself as RW-1 and tendered his evidence
by way of affidavit Ex.RW1/1 and relied upon the documents
Ex.RW1/A to Ex.RW1/C and documents Mark‘X’ to Mark‘Z-2’.
Respondent was also duly cross-examined by the opposite party.
After hearing final arguments, Ld. Trial Court decided the matter
and
inter-alia directed respondent no. 1/husband to pay
Rs.8,000/- per month to appellant/wife and two children as
maintenance, and compensation of Rs. 50,000/- to appellant/wife
for her mental trauma.
Being aggrieved by the impugned judgment,
Taruna Yadav vs. Gajender Singh Yadav
Page 3 of 11
-- 3 of 11 --
appellant preferred the present appeal before this Court.
Notice of the present appeal was issued to
respondent no. 1 who appeared in compliance thereof. Reply was
filed on behalf of respondent by Ld. Counsel. Copy was supplied
to the appellant.
Arguments of both the parties heard.
4. Learned counsel for appellant/wife seeks setting
aside of the impugned judgment dated 26.06.2023 on the
following grounds:
a) that impugned judgment is based on surmises
and conjectures;
b) that Ld. Trial Court committed an error by not
assessing the correct income of the respondent no. 1;
c) that Ld. Trial Court did not correctly
appreciate the principle laid down by Hon’ble Delhi
High Court in case titled
‘Annurita Vohra vs.
Sandeep Vohra’ 110(2004) DLT 546 and Ld. Trial
Court did not give three shares of the income of
respondent no.1 to the appellant as per aforesaid
judgment;
d) that Ld. Trial Court did not appreciate that
respondent no. 1 was drawing Rs.30,800/- per month
in the year 2018 and it was improbable that he was
earing Rs. 20,500/- per month in the year 2023; &
e) that Ld. Trial Court did not appreciate that the
appellant is unemployed and fully dependent upon
her family members.
Taruna Yadav vs. Gajender Singh Yadav
Page 4 of 11
-- 4 of 11 --
5. Ld. Counsel for appellant/wife reiterated the
aforesaid grounds while making submissions before the Court.
He vociferously submitted that appellant/wife and the two
children were entitled to maintenance more than what was finally
decided by Ld. Trial Court. It is the argument that the
observation and assessment of Ld. Trial Court regarding the
monthly salary of respondent no. 1/husband was faulty and
therefore, he sought setting aside of impugned judgment and
grant of all the reliefs sought by appellant/wife in her petition u/s
12 D.V. Act.
6.
Per contra, Ld. Counsel for respondent no.1/husband
denied all the allegations made by appellant/wife against him in
the present appeal as well as in her petition before Ld. Trial
Court. He stated that Ld. Trial Court rightly considered the facts
and circumstances of the case to grant final maintenance to wife
and children, and no ground to set aside the same is made out.
7. Submissions heard. Record including Trial Court
Record carefully perused.
8. The issue of domestic relationship between
appellant/wife and respondent no.1/husband is not disputed by
any of the parties. The factum of marriage of the parties on
10.12.2005 is admitted and further, the factum of parties having
resided together as husband and wife at the matrimonial home is
also not disputed. Further, the birth of two children from the
wedlock and the factum of said children residing with
appellant/wife is also admitted by both the parties.
Taruna Yadav vs. Gajender Singh Yadav
Page 5 of 11
-- 5 of 11 --
In terms of Sec. 2(f) of D.V. Act which defines the
term ‘Domestic Relationship’, since appellant/wife and
respondent no.1/husband are legally wedded and have resided
together in a shared household, domestic relationship between
both of them stands established. Further, no aspect of the
domestic relationship between the parties is under dispute in the
present matter and therefore, no further discussion on this aspect
is called for.
9. Further, the issue of domestic violence has been
dealt in detail by Ld. Trial Court in the impugned judgment
while discussing the allegations of domestic violence in the
affidavit Ex.CW1/A of appellant/wife vis-a-vis her cross-
examination. Ld. Trial Court also discussed the affidavit
Ex.RW1/A and the cross-examination of respondent
no.1/husband in the impugned judgment. A bare perusal of the
evidence adduced by both the parties before Ld. Trial Court
would suggest that appellant/wife suffered domestic violence at
the hands of respondent no.1/husband and his family members.
Although there is plain vanilla denial of the allegations of
appellant/wife in the affidavit of respondent no.1/husband, none
of the denials could be substantially proved on record. None of
the members of the family of respondent no.1/husband appeared
as a witness before Ld. Trial Court to refute or challenge the
allegations of appellant/wife.
As such, there is nothing on record to find fault with
the observation of Ld. Trial Court that appellant/wife is a victim
of domestic violence and thus, entitled to protection/relief as
Taruna Yadav vs. Gajender Singh Yadav
Page 6 of 11
-- 6 of 11 --
provided by, and as made out, under the D V Act.
10. Ld. Counsel for appellant/wife emphasised that Ld.
Trial Court erred in correctly assessing the monthly salary of
respondent no.1/husband and consequently, faulted in grant of
appropriate amount of final maintenance to wife and children. To
bolster the argument, Ld. Counsel relied upon an order/judgment
dated 29.09.2018 of Ld. Family Court, North-East District in
case titled ‘Taruna Yadav vs. Gajender Singh Yadav’ wherein
Ld. Court while assessing the monthly income of respondent
no.1/husband to be Rs.30,800/- granted maintenance of Rs.
12,000/- per month (Rs.4000/- each) to wife and children. It is
argued that it was highly improbable that respondent
no.1/husband was earning only a sum of Rs.20,500/- in the year
2023 against a salary of Rs. 30,800/- in the year 2018. It is, thus,
submitted that a case to enhance the final maintenance of made
out in favour of appellant/wife.
Ld. Counsel further strengthened his argument for
grant of enhanced maintenance on the ground that Ld. Trial
Court did not correctly appreciate the judgment of Hon’ble Delhi
High Court in case titled
Annurita Vohra (supra). It is stated that
the monthly income should have been divided into five shares
with three shares to wife and children and Ld. Trial Court
granted only two shares in their favour. It is stated that even by
that calculation vis-a-vis monthly income of Rs. 20,500/-, the
wife and children were entitled to maintenance of Rs. 12,000/-
per month while Ld. Trial Court granted only Rs. 8000/- as
maintenance and the same be accordingly modified.
Taruna Yadav vs. Gajender Singh Yadav
Page 7 of 11
-- 7 of 11 --
11. This is Court has considered the aforesaid
arguments and has also gone through the judgment of Hon’ble
Delhi High Court as referred above as also observation of Ld.
Trial Court in this regard. Firstly, respondent no. 1/husband has
relied upon his bank statement for the year 2021 to 2023 before
Ld. Trial Court wherein the company M/s Ruby Lifting
Equipment Company has credited an amount of Rs. 20,500/- in
his account on monthly basis without any change over a period of
time. Secondly, appellant/wife, at no point of time brought any
other document on record controverting the said bank statement
of respondent no. 1/husband. While she orally challenged the
claim of husband in her affidavit and original petition, no
question regarding the claim being false or any increment in the
monthly salary over a period of time was put to respondent no.
1/husband during his cross-examination as RW-1. Thirdly, it
must be understood that Ld. Trial Court decided the final
maintenance on the basis of evidence adduced by the parties and
not on the basis of a smart guess work. Ld. Trial Court was
bound to consider the evidence and not the bald averments of the
parties.
12. As regards the argument for interpretation of
judgment of Hon’ble Delhi High Court, it is observed that while
Hon’ble Delhi High Court observed that ‘a satisfactory
approached would be to divide the Family resource Cake in two
portions to the husband since he has to incur extra expenses in
the course of making his earning, and one share each to the other
members’, it granted a maintenance of Rs. 15,000/- per month to
Taruna Yadav vs. Gajender Singh Yadav
Page 8 of 11
-- 8 of 11 --
the wife and children despite observing that they would
ordinarily be entitled to approximately to Rs. 18,000/- out of the
disposable income of Rs. 32,000/- per month.
In the present case, it is undisputed that
appellant/wife is residing in the matrimonial home while
respondent no. 1/husband is residing in a rented accommodation.
It is also undisputed that the husband is also paying some
miscellaneous expenses like the electricity bill. In such
circumstances, the approach of Ld. Trial Court not granting
maintenance ‘strictly’ as per five parts of the family cake, is
justified and reasonable. Ld. Trial Court has carefully factored in
the aforesaid circumstances while granting the amount of final
maintenance.
13. At this stage, it would also be relevant to reiterate
that Ld. Family Court has already granted a maintenance of Rs.
12,000/- per month to appellant/wife and her children, and
respondent no. 1/husband is regularly paying the same. Ld. Trial
Court also considered this aspect while deciding the final
maintenance in the present matter under D V Act.
It would also be apposite to quote the observation of
Hon’ble Delhi High Court in case titled
‘Mamta Bhardwaj vs.
Vinod Kumar Bhardwaj’ (dated 29.10.2021) wherein it was
observed that that ‘the Supreme Court in ‘Rajnesh vs. Neha’
while approving the judgments of High Court of Bombay in
‘Vishal vs. Aparna’, 2018 SCC OnLine Bom 1207 and Delhi
High Court in ‘R.D. vs. B.D’ 2019 SCC OnLine Del 9526, has
observed in the light of question of overlapping jurisdiction for
Taruna Yadav vs. Gajender Singh Yadav
Page 9 of 11
-- 9 of 11 --
grant of maintenance that Sec. 20(1)(d) of the DV Act makes it
clear that the maintenance granted under the DV Act would be in
addition to an order of maintenance under Section 125 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Cr.PC) and any other law for
the time being in force. It was observed by the Supreme Court
that the legislative mandate envisages grant of maintenance to
wife under various statutes. There is no bar to seek maintenance
both under the DV Act and Section 125 of the Cr.PC or
the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 or the Hindu Adoption and
Maintenance Act, 1956. The only obligation imposed on the wife
would be to disclose the earlier maintenance being granted to her
in the previously instituted proceedings so that the quantum of
maintenance in the subsequent proceedings could be fixed taking
into account the maintenance already awarded in favour of the
wife in any previously instituted proceedings.
In the light of aforesaid observations of Hon’ble
Supreme Court and Hon’ble Delhi High Court, it is noted that
Ld. Trial Court is completely justified to decide the quantum of
maintenance in subsequent proceedings (D V Act proceedings in
the present facts) while taking into account the maintenance
already awarded in favour of the wife in any previously instituted
proceedings (before Family Court). In these circumstances, the
approach of Ld. Trial Court granting final maintenance of Rs.
8000/- per month to wife and children while considering the
previous maintenance of Rs. 12000/- per month granted by Ld.
Family Court, cannot be find fault with. In the light of above
discussion, the arguments of Ld. Counsel for appellant/wife are
misconceived and therefore, cannot be considered.
Taruna Yadav vs. Gajender Singh Yadav
Page 10 of 11
-- 10 of 11 --
14. It is pleaded in the appeal that Ld. Trial Court did
not grant any other relief to appellant/wife despite specific prayer
in the petition u/s 12 D V Act. In the opinion of this Court, such a
pleading appears to have been made without careful reading of
the impugned judgment dated 26.06.2023 of Ld. Trial Court. It is
observed that Ld. Trial Court has granted ‘protection order’ u/s
18 of DV Act, ‘residence order’ u/s 19 of DV Act and
‘compensation of Rs. 50000/-’ u/s 22 of DV Act in favour of
appellant/wife in the impugned judgment besides grant of final
maintenance to wife and children. The pleading in the appeal is,
thus, misconceived.
15. The impugned judgment is certainly passed after
considering status of the parties and their respective liabilities in
life. The judgment is well-reasoned and there is no justified
ground to set aside the impugned judgment dated 26.06.2023 of
Ld. Trial Court which is based on correct understanding of the
law and the facts and circumstances of the case. Present appeal
is, accordingly, dismissed, and judgment dated 26.06.2023 is
sustained.
13. File of present Appeal be consigned to Record
Room after due compliance.
Dictated & announced in the open
Court on 11.07.2024.
(ARVIND BANSAL)
Additional Sessions Judge-05 (Shahdara)
Karkardooma Courts, Delhi
Taruna Yadav vs. Gajender Singh Yadav
Page 11 of 11
-- 11 of 11 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.