Full Order Text
Final Order 7 · 18 Sept 2026 · CNR DLSH010047572025
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF MS. CHARU AGGARWAL: ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE-02; E COURT: SHAHDARA: KARKARDOOMA COURT: DELHI. CNR NO. DLSH01-004757-2025 Crl. (R) No. 164/25 Rani Devi W/o Sh. Dinesh Kumar R/o 10, Gali No. 01, Bhrampuri, Delhi 110053. …........…. Revisionist. Versus 1. State of NCT of Delhi Through SHO PS Jafrabad. 2. Dinesh Kumar S/o Late Sh. Ram Kishan R/o 10, Gali No. 01, Bhrampuri, Delhi 110053. 3. Laxmi Devi W/o Sh. Satish Kumar R/o 10, Gali No. 01, Bhrampuri, Delhi 110053. …………. Respondents. Date of filing : 14.08.2025 Date of arguments : 07.09.2026 Date of order : 18.09.2026 O R D E R 1. The present revision petition under Sections 438 of the BNSS has been filed by the revisionist/ Cr. Rev. No. 164/25 Rani Devi Vs. State of NCT of Delhi and ors. Page No. 1/9 -- 1 of 9 -- complainant/victim, challenging the order dated 14.07.2025 passed by the Learned JMFC-05, Shahdara, Karkardoma, whereby charge u/s 324/341/506/34 IPC has been framed against respondent no. 2 & 3 herein, in FIR No. 542/20 titled as State Vs. Dinesh Kumar and Anrs. (registered at the behest of revisionist) 2. Respondent no. 2 & 3 are husband and sister-in- law (nanad) of the revisionist/complainant. 3. The revisionist’s grievance is that, despite the presence of material on record disclosing the ingredients of an offence under Section 307 IPC, the Learned Trial Court omitted to frame charges under the said provision against respondents no. 2 and 3. 4. The necessary facts to decide the present revision are that on 11.12.2020 on receipt of DD No. 25A at PS Jafrabad, IO ASI Naresh Kumar along with Ct. Srikant reached at the spot i.e. H.No. 10, Gali No. 1, Brahmpuri, Ghonda, Delhi where they came to know that injured had been shifted to JPC Hospital. IO ASI Naresh reached at JPC Hospital and collected the MLC of complainant/victim Rani on which alleged history was mentioned as domestic violence. Thereafter, on 12.12.2020, the statement of complainant was recorded in which she stated that on 11.12.2020 at about 8:15 am, some altercation took place between her and her sister-in-law Laxmi (respondent no. 3) due to which her husband Dinesh (respondent no. 2) got agitated and started quarreling with her. On her resistance, Cr. Rev. No. 164/25 Rani Devi Vs. State of NCT of Delhi and ors. Page No. 2/9 -- 2 of 9 -- she was caught hold by respondents no. 2 & 3 who started beating her with fist and blows, sticks and iron chain and also strangulated her with hands thereby threatened to kill her. The complainant made a PCR call; the police officials shifted her at Jag Parvesh Hospital. After treatment, she was sent back. On 12.12.2020, the FIR was registered against respondents no. 2 & 3 for the offences u/s 323/341/506/34 IPC. As per MLC of complainant/revisionist, she received injuries on both her arms, thighs and back, those injuries were opined by the doctor as “simple/blunt”. 5. After completion of investigation, charge sheet was filed before concerned MM. Respondents no. 2 & 3 were summoned and vide impugned order dated 14.07.2025, charge u/s 324/341/506/34 IPC was framed against the accused persons to which they pleaded not guilty and matter was listed for PE. 6. Being aggrieved by the order on charge dated 14.07.2025, the instant revision has been preferred by the revisionist/complainant on the following grounds :- (a) Impugned order has been passed based on conjectures and surmises without applying judicial mind. (b) From the allegations mentioned in the charge sheet, prima facie offence u/s 307 IPC is made out which is not considered in the impugned order. 7. I have heard Ld. counsels for both the sides and Ld. Add. APP and also perused the material on record including written submissions filed on behalf the revisionist. Cr. Rev. No. 164/25 Rani Devi Vs. State of NCT of Delhi and ors. Page No. 3/9 -- 3 of 9 -- 8. Ld. LAC for the revisionist argued that revisionist was beaten black and blue with iron chain and wooden sticks by the respondents no.2 and 3, which clearly makes out their intention to kill her. He also submitted that nature of injuries sustained by the injured are completely immaterial to attract section 307 IPC. He further submitted that prima face case was required for framing of the charge and probative value of the evidence available on record would be seen during the course of trial, which was not required to be seen at the time of framing of the charge. He would next contend that in view of the number and nature of injuries caused by the respondents no.2 and 3 apart from charges already framed, charge under Section 307 IPC is required to be framed but Ld. Trial court failed to properly appreciate the material on record and omitted to frame the charge under the said provision. 9. On the other hand, it was argued by the Ld. Cl. for the respondent no.2 and 3 that they have been falsely implicated in this case due to ongoing matrimonial dispute between the parties. He also submitted that medical evidence available on record does not support the charge under Section 307 IPC as none of the injuries was on any of the vital part of the body, because of which intention to kill was conspicuously missing which is main ingredient to attract 307 IPC. Thus, he prayed to dismiss the present revision. 10. The revisionist has relied upon several judicial precedents to contend that the Court is not inexorably bound by the police report submitted under Section 173 Cr.P.C. and Cr. Rev. No. 164/25 Rani Devi Vs. State of NCT of Delhi and ors. Page No. 4/9 -- 4 of 9 -- the Court, while exercising its jurisdiction at the stage of charge, is empowered to independently evaluate the material placed on record and that the Court is not a mere post office to mechanically accept the conclusions of the Investigating Agency. 11. All the precedents relied by the revisionist are perused by this court. There is no dispute regarding this settled proposition that the Court retains the authority to frame charges for offences not specifically mentioned in the charge-sheet, provided the record contains sufficient material to prima facie establish the commission of such offences. The statutory scheme under Sections 227 and 228 Cr.P.C. confers upon the Court the duty to sift and weigh the evidence to ascertain whether a prima facie case exists for framing charges. Consequently, even if the charge-sheet does not include certain offences, the Court may frame charges for such offences if the material on record discloses the ingredients thereof. This principle ensures that the process of justice is not thwarted by inadvertence, omission, or error on the part of the Investigating Officer. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has consistently held that the Court’s jurisdiction at the stage of charge is independent and substantive, and it cannot be curtailed merely because the police report is silent on certain offences. 12. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties at considerable length, after careful perusal of the record of the case and giving thoughtful consideration to the rival contentions raised, this Court is of the considered opinion Cr. Rev. No. 164/25 Rani Devi Vs. State of NCT of Delhi and ors. Page No. 5/9 -- 5 of 9 -- that keeping in view the facts and circumstances of the case, the present revision deserves to be dismissed. 13. A combined reading of the impugned order, medical evidence in the form of MLC of the revisionist, police report under Section 173 Cr.P.C. and other attending circumstances of the case, would leave no room for doubt that charges for commission of offences punishable under Sections of the IPC have been rightly framed by the learned trial court. 14. A bare perusal of the provisions under Section 307 IPC would show that intention or knowledge of the accused is of paramount importance so as to constitute an offence under Section 307 IPC. Number or nature of injuries would come later. 15. It is pertinent to note that in determining the question as to whether an offence under Section 307 IPC would be made out against an accused or not, would depend on the intention of the accused, which is a question of fact and not a question of law. It goes without saying that it would all depend on the given fact situation of each case. It is not necessary that injury sufficient for causing death, should have been inflicted by the accused. However, what is material to attract the provisions of Section 307 IPC is the guilty intention or knowledge with which the act (s) or all was done, irrespective of its result. 16. The abovesaid observations made find support from the judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Harikishan and State of Haryana v. Sukhbir 1988 AIR SC Cr. Rev. No. 164/25 Rani Devi Vs. State of NCT of Delhi and ors. Page No. 6/9 -- 6 of 9 -- 2127. The relevant observations made by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Harikishan and State of Haryana's case (supra), are re-produced as under:— “ On the first question as to acquittal of the accused under Section 307/149 IPC, some significant aspects may be borne in mind. Under Section 307 IPC what the Court has to see is, whether the act irrespective of its result, was done with the intention or knowledge and under circumstances mentioned in that section. The intention or knowledge of the accused must be such as is necessary to constitute’ murder. Without this ingredient being established, there can be no offence of “attempt to murder”. Under Section 307 the intention precedes the act attributed to accused. Therefore, the intention is to be gathered from all circumstances, and not merely from the consequences that ensue. The nature of the weapon used, manner in which it is used. motive for the crime, severity of the blow, the part of the body where the injury is inflicted are some of the factors that may be taken into consideration it, determine the intention. In this case, two parties in the course of a fight inflicted on each other injuries both serious and minor. The accused though armed with ballam never used the sharp edge of it. They used only the blunt side of it despite they being attacked by the other side. They suffered injuries but not provoked or tempted to use the cutting edge of the weapon. It is very very significant. It seems to us that they had no intention to commit murder. They had no motive either. The fight as the High Court has observed, might have been a sudden flare up. Where Cr. Rev. No. 164/25 Rani Devi Vs. State of NCT of Delhi and ors. Page No. 7/9 -- 7 of 9 -- the fight is accidental owing to a sudden quarrel, the conviction under Section 307 is generally not called for. We, therefore, see no reason to disturb the acquittal of accused under Section 307 IPC.” 17. Thus, the intention and knowledge of the accused are the matters of inference to be drawn from totality of facts and circumstances of each case and the same cannot be measured merely from the results. 18. In the present case, as per the MLC of the revisionist, she has sustained injuries in the alleged incident on her thighs, arms and back that too ‘simple’ in nature. None of the injuries suffered by the complainant has been found on any vital part of the body. Had there been intention to kill, accused persons would have certainly made attempts to cause one or more injuries on any vital part of the body of the injured, particularly when they were allegedly armed with iron chains and wooden sticks. 19. After giving anxious consideration to the peculiar fact situation of the present case, this Court has come to the conclusion that since the intention of the accused persons to cause death of the complainant has been found conspicuously missing, thus accused persons (respondents no. 2 & 3) are not liable to be charged under Section 307 IPC. 20. Under these circumstances, it can be safely concluded that no charge under Section 307 IPC could have been framed against the respondents. Cr. Rev. No. 164/25 Rani Devi Vs. State of NCT of Delhi and ors. Page No. 8/9 -- 8 of 9 -- 21. In view of above discussion, this court finds no infirmity or illegality in the impugned order. Accordingly, the revision is hereby dismissed. Copy of this order along with TCR be sent to Ld. Trial Court for information. Revision file be consigned to Record Room. Announced in the open (Charu Aggarwal) Court on 18.09.2026. ASJ-02/E-Court/Shahdara KKD Court, Delhi. Cr. Rev. No. 164/25 Rani Devi Vs. State of NCT of Delhi and ors. Page No. 9/9 -- 9 of 9 --
