Full Order Text
Interim Order 17 · 21 Oct 2024 · CNR DLSH010047572023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS (Comm.) No. 384/23 Mr. Jatinder Kumar Wadhwa Sol Prop of Atul Enterprises vs. T.R. Sawhney Motors Private Limited 21.10.2024 Present : Sh. Pawas Aggarwal, Advocate, for the plaintiff through video-conferencing. Sh. Vikas Sharma, Advocate, for the defendant, through video-conferencing. Case file is perused. Application bearing No. IA/7/2024 This application has been filed, on behalf of the plaintiff, under Section 151 CPC, on 27.09.2024, for modification of the order dated 31.07.2024. It is stated in the application that on 28.08.2024, the plaintiff filed a previous application for modification of the order dated 31.07.2024, and for grant of one more opportunity to record the evidence of the defendant, before the Ld. Local Commissioner, and the said application was allowed by this court vide order dated 29.08.2024, subject to imposition of a cost of Rs.10,000/-, to be desposited with the office of the DLSA, and thereafter, the matter was fixed for recording the evidence before the Ld. Local Commissioner, on 13.09.2024. 2. It is further stated in the application that on 13.09.2024, the Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff received a ‘Whatsapp’ message from the Ld. Local Commissioner that the witness of the defendant is seriously ill and was having some heart problem, and therefore, the recording of the evidence was not possible today and the Ld. Counsel for the defendant has requested for adjournment. It is further stated that the Ld. Local Commissioner also sent the medical documents of the witness of CS (Comm.) 384/23 page 1 of 8 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 1 of 8 -- the defendant, to the Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff, and perusal of the said documents indicated that the witness was unwell since 13.08.2024, and was unable to appear before the Ld. Local Commissioner on 13.09.2024. 3. It is further stated in the application that the fact that this witness was unwell since 13.08.2024, was not informed by the defendant to this court, on 29.08.2024, when the previous application was allowed by the court, subject to imposition of a cost of Rs.10,000/- on the plaintiff, and therefore, the cost imposed on the plaintiff, vide order dated 29.08.2024, may be waived off. 4. Despite opportunity, no reply to this application was filed, on behalf of the defendant. 5. Sh. Arjun Aggarwal, Advocate, for the applicant/ plaintiff and Sh. Vikas Sharma, Advocate, for the defendant, had addressed their arguments on this application on 27.09.2024. During the course of arguments, the Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff has reiterated the contents of his application. 6. On the other hand, the Ld. Counsel for the defendant has stated that the witness could not appear before the Ld. Local Commissioner on 13.09.2024, due to his sickness. 7. Perusal of the record shows that the previous application under Section 151 CPC, (IA/05/2024), for modification of the order dated 31.07.2024, was filed on behalf of the plaintiff, on 29.08.2024. The said application was disposed of by the Court, with the consent of the Ld. Counsels for the parties, with following observations: CS (Comm.) 384/23 page 2 of 8 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 2 of 8 -- “The Ld. Counsel for the defendant does not want to file any written reply to this application. Submissions of the Ld. Counsel for the parties are heard on this application. During the course of arguments, the Ld. Counsel for the defendant has stated that he is having no objection, in case, one more opportunity is granted to the plaintiff, for recording the evidence of the defendant and his cross- examination, before the Ld. Local Commissioner. In view of the submissions of the Ld. Counsels for the parties and in the interest of justice, the present application is hereby allowed, subject to imposition of a cost of Rs.10,000/- on the plaintiff. The cost be deposited with the Office of the DLSA, Shahdara District, within a period of one week from today. Subject to deposition of the cost, one more opportunity is granted to the plaintiff, for cross-examination of the witness of the defendant. The evidence of the defendant, shall be recorded before the ld. Local Commissioner, as per previous order dated 31.07.2024, on No further opportunity shall be granted for examination of the witnesses of the defendant under any circumstance. I.A. No. 05/24 is disposed off accordingly.” 8. Perusal of the above order dated 29.08.2024, shows that the previous application under Section 151 CPC, (IA/05/2024), was filed by the plaintiff for the same relief of modification of the order dated 31.07.2024, and the same had already been disposed of vide order dated 29.08.2024. 9. In the present application there is no prayer regarding the modification of the order dated 31.07.2024. But, it has been prayed that the cost imposed on the plaintiff vide order dated 29.08.2024, may be waived off. No reasonable or sufficient ground has been disclosed in the application for again modifying the order dated 31.07.2024, and no reasonable or sufficient ground has been disclosed in the application for CS (Comm.) 384/23 page 3 of 8 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 3 of 8 -- waiving the cost imposed on the plaintiff, vide order dated 29.08.2024. It is also relevant to note that this application has not been filed by the plaintiff, for modification of the order dated 29.08.2024. 10. In these circumstances, I do not find any merit in the present application of the plaintiff and the same is hereby dismissed, being devoid of any merits. It is ordered accordingly. IA/7/2024 is disposed of accordingly. Application bearing No. IA/6/2024 11. This application has been filed, on behalf of the defendant, under Section 151 CPC, for grant of time to the defendant for recording his evidence, before the Ld. Local Commissioner. 12. It is stated in the application that vide order dated 31.07.2024, this court had granted time to the defendant for recording the additional evidence before the Ld.Local Commissioner, on 14.08.2024. But, on 14.08.2024, the defendant went to the office of the Ld. Local Commissioner, with his Advocate, but, a message was received from the Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff that he will not be able to cross-examine the defendant, because he was out of India, and therefore, on that date, the testimony of the defendant could not be recorded. 13. It is further stated in the application that on 29.08.2024, the defendant was present in the court, and on the request of the defendant and his counsel, the matter was adjourned for [date withheld], for recording the evidence of the defendant before the Ld. Local Commissioner. CS (Comm.) 384/23 page 4 of 8 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 4 of 8 -- 14. It is further stated in the application that on 31.07.2024, an application was also filed on behalf of the plaintiff, and vide order dated 29.08.2024, this court had granted time to the plaintiff to examine the defendant, on 13.09.2024. 15. It is further stated in the application that the defendant is a senior citizen of 65 years of age and was having heart problem and on 13.09.2024, he fell seriously ill and the AR of the defendant rushed him to the hospital due to severe chest pain, and therefore, he failed to appear before the Ld. Local Commissioner, for recording of his evidence. It has been prayed that one more opportunity may be granted to the defendant for recording of his evidence. With this application, the defendant has also filed the photocopies of some documents, regarding the ailment of DW Sh. Rakesh Bhardwaj. 16. Despite opportunity, no reply to this application was filed on behalf of the plaintiff. 17. The Ld. Counsels for the parties had addressed their arguments on this application also, on 27.09.2024. 18. Perusal of the record shows that the plaintiff has filed the present suit against M/s T.R. Sawhney Motors Pvt. Ltd., in which DW-1 Sh. Rakesh Bhardwaj s/o Sh. V.B. Bhardwaj, was working as a group president. 19. Perusal of the record further shows that vide order dated 13.02.2024, the issues were framed in the present suit and a Local Commissioner was also appointed for recording the evidence of the parties, and the matter was also fixed for final arguments on 22.03.2024. CS (Comm.) 384/23 page 5 of 8 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 5 of 8 -- 20. Perusal of the record further shows that the final arguments were also concluded by the Ld. Counsels for the parties on 27.05.2024, and the matter was adjourned for judgment on 03.07.2024. On 03.07.2024, an application under Order XVIII Rule 17 r/w Section 151 CPC, (IA/4/2024), was filed on behalf of the defendant, for leading the additional evidence. The said application was allowed by the court, vide order dated 31.07.2024, and another opportunity was granted to the defendant to record his evidence, before the Ld. Local Commissioner on 14.08.2024. 21. Perusal of the record further shows that the additional evidence of the defendant could not be concluded even on 14.08.2024 and vide order dated 29.08.2024, another opportunity was granted to the parties for recording the additional evidence of the defendant, on 13.09.2024. 22. Perusal of the record further shows that the evidence of the defendant could not be recorded even on 13.09.2024, and now, the present application (IA/6/2024), has been filed on behalf of the defendant, on 27.09.2024. 23. Perusal of the record further shows that during the trial, the defendant had already examined Sh. Rakesh Bhardwaj, as DW-1, before the Ld. Local Commissioner, on 12.03.2024, and his cross-examination was also concluded on 12.03.2024. The Ld. Counsel for the defendant has closed the evidence of the defendant on 12.03.2024. 24. Perusal of the record further shows that on 09.07.2024, the defendant had moved an application under Order XVIII Rule 17 CPC, for leading the additional evidence, and the CS (Comm.) 384/23 page 6 of 8 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 6 of 8 -- said application was allowed by this court vide order dated 31.07.2024, whereby, the defendant was permitted to lead the additional evidence regarding the board resolution, in favour of DW-1 Sh.Rakesh Bhardwaj. 25. Perusal of the medical documents of DW-1 Sh. Rakesh Bhardwaj indicates that he was having some heart trouble on 13.09.2024, and he was medically examined at Delhi Heart Hospital on 13.09.2024 at about 11.30 a.m.. 26. Perusal of the medical record further shows that DW-1 Sh.Rakesh Bhardwaj was under the medical treatment even prior to 13.09.2024. 27. In these circumstances and in the interest of justice, the present application under Section 151 CPC, (IA/6/2024), is hereby allowed and one more opportunity is granted to the defendant to examine DW-1 Sh. Rakesh Bhardwaj, before the 28. Other modalities for leading the additional evidence of DW-1 Sh. Rakesh Bhardwaj shall remain the same, as per order dated 31.07.2024. 29. The date for recording the additional evidence of DW-1 Sh. Rakesh Bhardwaj is now refixed as 05.11.2024. A copy of this order be given DASTI to the Ld. Counsels for the parties and be also sent to the Ld. Local Commissioner for information and necessary compliance. IA/6/2024 is disposed of accordingly. CS (Comm.) 384/23 page 7 of 8 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 7 of 8 -- Adjourned for filing the report with complete record of additional evidence, by the Ld. Local Commissioner, and for final arguments on 21.11.2024. Brijesh Kumar Garg District Judge Commercial Court-01 Shahdara Distt, KKD, Delhi 21.10.2024 NR CS (Comm.) 384/23 page 8 of 8 D.J.(Comm)-01/SHD/KKD/Delhi -- 8 of 8 --
