Full Order Text
Final Order 20 · 19 May 2026 · CNR DLSH010041012023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF MS. CHARU AGGARWAL: ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE-02; E COURT: SHAHDARA: KARKARDOOMA COURT: DELHI. CT Case No. 17/2023 Rekha w/o Sh. Dinesh Chaudhary r/o H. No. P-22, first floor, Gali no.1, Shankar Nagar extension, Krishna Nagar, Delhi-110051. …. Complainant. Versus 1. State (NCT of Delhi) 2. Jyoti w/o Rajendra 3. Rajendra 4. Nankhoo Yadav 5. Shailendra 6. wife of Shailendra (name not known) r/o H-33A, Dilshad Garden, Delhi. Present address:- I-111-B, I Pocket, Dilshad Garden, Delhi. 7. Station House Officer, P.S. Seema Puri, Delhi. ... Proposed accused. Date of institution : 05.07.2023 Date of reserving the order : 13.05.2026 Date of order : 19.05.2026 O R D E R 1. The present criminal complaint alongwith application u/s 156 (3) Cr. PC has been preferred by the complainant CT Case No. 17/2023 Rekha Vs. State and ors. Page No. 1/9 -- 1 of 9 -- Rekha against the respondents alleging the commission of offence under Section 307 IPC & 3 (v) SC/ST (POA) Act. 2. The case of the complainant is that she and respondents have family relations since long time as respondent no.2 Jyoti used to borrow money from the complainant’s husband. Once, complainant and her husband were in dire need of money so they contacted the respondent no.2 Jyoti and her husband regarding which a meeting was fixed amongst them and in the said meeting, it was discussed that an amount of Rs.13,57,000/- was due towards respondent no.2 to be taken by complainant’s husband. In order to discharge said liability, respondent no.2 issued a cheque bearing no. 000029 dated 13.05.2022 for a sum of Rs.13,57,000/-, however, on presentation the said cheque got dishonoured on 16.05.2022 with the remarks ‘funds insufficient’. 2.1 In para no.4 of the complaint, it is stated that the information regarding the dishonour of cheque was given to respondent no.2 who replied that cheque be returned to her and in lieu of the same, she would make cash payment. But thereafter, she stopped responding on the phone calls of complainant’s husband, but he continuously made efforts to contact her telephonically. Once, he was busy in his shop where several persons were present, therefore, he put his the phone on speaker when respondent no.2 picked up the phone call and said ‘ saale chamar teri itni himmat tu hamara address mangta hai tujhe pata nahi hai ki ham yadav hai aur tere ko wahi aakar ke mai goli maar dungi’. On the CT Case No. 17/2023 Rekha Vs. State and ors. Page No. 2/9 -- 2 of 9 -- resistance of complainant’s husband she again said ‘saale chamar chuhde, bhangi mujhse jaban chalata hai abhi aakar ke teri dukan me aag lagati hun aur tere se cheque chhinti hun’. 2.2 Further, para no.4 of the complaint is unclear and confusing. However, after reading the same, it seems that there is some property dispute between the parties. The relevant portion of paragraph no.4 is reproduced below: “It is pertinent to mention here that the father- in-law of accused Jyoti has already welding the shutter of shop of husband of complainant/applicant. The husband of complainant/applicant is the owner and in possession of shop no. H-33A, Dilshad Garde, Delhi-110095. The DDA has allot H-33A, ground floor, Dilshad Garden, Delhi for residence purpose but her father-in-law has illegally constructed 7 shops in residential premises and by way of GPA here father-in- law have sold out to other persons these shops. As per DDA record as inspection was conducted of this file at DDA office ITO, New Delhi, Sh. Nankhoo Yadav is not allotted of this premises in which 7 shop illegally constructed. The husband of complainant/applicant firstly running a small repairing shop in wooden box and later on with his hard earn money, he constructed his shop because father-in-law of accused Jyoti was sold out the adjoining shops to other persons hence accused Jyoti and her family members have evil eyes upon the shop of complainant/applicant’s husband. The husband of complainant/applicant has filed a criminal complaint against accused persons, her husband and her father-in-law, the wife of Shailendra and Shailendra and other.” 2.3 In para 5 of the complaint, it is further stated that on 20.05.2022 at about 2.00 pm, complainant reached at her husband’s shop where respondent no.2 along with her CT Case No. 17/2023 Rekha Vs. State and ors. Page No. 3/9 -- 3 of 9 -- family members (respondents no.3 to 6) were already present and gave merciless beatings to complainant’s brother and thrown equipment from his shop on the road and also abused him with casteist remarks. Respondent no.5 Shailendra also outraged the complainant’s modesty by touching her breast and respondent no.4 Nankhoo Yadav abused the complainant saying ‘sali chuhdi, bhangan hamari bahu ke cheque ko wapas kar varna tujhe sadak per nanga karke marenge ham yadav hai ’ . 2.4 It is alleged that since the date of incident, complainant is in deep shock and depression since her dignity was affected. She made several complaints to Police Station, ACP and DCP regarding the incident but no action was taken on her complaints, hence the present complaint. 3. Pursuant to the directions of the Court, an Action Taken Report was filed by the concerned ACP. It stated that initially no public witness supported the complainant’s allegations. However, later the complainant produced two persons, namely Sunita and Ritik, as witnesses, who both claimed that the respondents used casteist remarks against the complainant. Upon analyzing the CDRs of all persons involved in the incident (complainant, witnesses, and respondents), it was revealed that the respondents were not present at the spot on the date and time of the alleged incident. Specifically, respondent no.4, Nankhoo Yadav, was in Karol Bagh, Delhi; respondent no.5, Shailendra, was in Dayanand Vihar, Delhi; respondent no.2, Jyoti, and respondent no.3, Rajendra, were at their residence in Dilshad CT Case No. 17/2023 Rekha Vs. State and ors. Page No. 4/9 -- 4 of 9 -- Garden; Richa was in Ghaziabad, U.P.; witness Sunita was in Vishwas Nagar, Delhi; and witness Ritik was found to be an interested witness, being employed in the shop of the complainant’s husband. 3.1 The Action Taken Report further mentioned that one independent witness, Jitender Rana, was examined. He stated that none of the respondents had visited the complainant’s husband’s shop on 20.05.2022. He also disclosed that there was an ongoing property dispute between the parties regarding ownership of shop no. H-33A, Dilshad Garden, Delhi. 3.2 During the enquiry, respondent no.4, Nankhoo Yadav, furnished a court order dated 23.03.2023 passed by the Ld. Senior Civil Judge (Shahdara), whereby an eviction order was passed in his favour and against the complainant’s husband. 4. I have heard Ld. counsel for complainant and perused the record. 5. Learned Counsel for complainant has raised strong objection on the Action Taken Report filed by concerned ACP, conducting preliminary enquiry. He submitted that as per Section 18A of SC/ST Act, preliminary enquiry cannot be conducted. However, this court finds no force in this argument. In Avdesh VS. O.P. Singh criminal appeal no.7557/2019 decided on 05.01.2022, the Hon’ble Apex Court has held that preliminary inquiry is not barred under the Act and action taken report cannot be equated with preliminary inquiry. The relevant portion of the judgement is CT Case No. 17/2023 Rekha Vs. State and ors. Page No. 5/9 -- 5 of 9 -- reproduced as under: - “ 22…….A plain reading of section 18A(1)(a) of SC/ST Act makes it clear that preliminary enquiry shall not be required for registration of an FIR against any person. In other words, preliminary enquiry is not a prerequisite for registration of a FIR. The aforesaid provision empowers the concerned Police Officer to register an FIR without preliminary enquiry. Section 18A(1)(a) does not bar a preliminary enquiry. The Police Officer concerned may, in his discretion, conduct a preliminary enquiry if the nature and tenor of the complaint so requires. Subsection (b) of Section 18A(1) empowers the Investigating Officer to arrest any person against whom an accusation of committing an offence under the SC/ST Act has been made, without obtaining approval for arrest, if the arrest of such person is necessary. The enabling provisions of Section 18A(1) are not to be construed as a bar on preliminary enquiry or a mandate to arrest every person against whom an accusation of having committed an offence under the SC/ST Act is made. The power to arrest may be exercised without approval for the arrest only if such arrest is necessary. Similarly, an FIR may be registered without a preliminary enquiry. There is no bar on holding a preliminary enquiry, or obtaining an approval before arresting a person. The High Court, in exercise of its extraordinary jurisdiction under Articles 226 or 227 of the Constitution of India or its inherent jurisdiction under section 482 of the Cr.P.C., 1973 to prevent the abuses of the process of any Court or otherwise to secure the ends of justice, does not interfere with proceedings under the SC/ST Act on the sole ground that a preliminary enquiry had been held or on the ground that an arrest had been made after obtaining approval. Moreover, section 18A of the SC/ST Act has no application to proceedings under section 156(3) of the Cr.P.C., 1973 in a Court of law. 23. In any case, the High Court has very rightly held that calling for an ATR cannot be equated to directing an inquiry or even preliminary enquiry.” 6. It is also settled law that while an application under section 156(3) CR.PC is filed, court is empowered to verify the veracity of the complaint to ensure that it has not been filed with oblique motive to harass a person and to settle CT Case No. 17/2023 Rekha Vs. State and ors. Page No. 6/9 -- 6 of 9 -- personal scores. Verification of complainant’s assertion is necessary not only to assess the disclosure of commission of cognizable offence but also to rule out the possibility of harassment by unscrupulous litigant to innocents. The directions to register a FIR has serious consequences and may lead to curtail somebody’s personal liberty as well, therefore, action taken reports filed by the police cannot be brushed aside lightly especially when it is not filed in routine manner but contains important aspects of the matter. 7. In the present case, not only the instant application but the complaint also deserves to be dismissed at this stage itself not for one but for several reasons to be discussed hereinafter:- ( i) firstly, the complainant alleges that the respondents harassed her and her husband with caste-based derogatory remarks on 16.05.2022 and 20.05.2022. However, despite the seriousness of the allegations, no PCR call was made at the time of the alleged incidents, nor was any immediate police complaint filed. Instead, complaints were lodged more than one year after the alleged incidents. Such unexplained and inordinate delay in reporting raises grave doubts about the veracity and genuineness of the allegations. In criminal jurisprudence, prompt reporting is considered a safeguard against fabrication, and the absence thereof weakens the credibility of the complainant’s case. (ii) Secondly, the complainant, in her complaint under Section 200 Cr.P.C., in the instant application, and even in her initial police complaints, did not disclose the names of CT Case No. 17/2023 Rekha Vs. State and ors. Page No. 7/9 -- 7 of 9 -- any persons in whose presence the alleged casteist remarks were made. The names of witnesses were introduced for the first time during the enquiry conducted by the ACP for filing the Action Taken Report (ATR). This belated disclosure strongly suggests that the witnesses were subsequently introduced to bolster her case, thereby diminishing their reliability and casting doubt on the authenticity of the allegations. (iii) Thirdly, the ATR reveals that litigation was pending between the parties regarding shop no. H-33A, Dilshad Garden, Delhi. An eviction order dated 23.03.2023 was passed against the complainant and her family members and in favour of the respondents. The present complaint was filed in July 2023, i.e., after the eviction order. This timing clearly indicates that the complaint is a counterblast to the eviction proceedings and has been initiated with an ulterior motive to falsely implicate the respondents in a criminal case, thereby harassing them and attempting to settle a civil dispute through criminal process. (iv) Fourthly, the ATR further records that independent witness Jitender Rana categorically stated that none of the respondents visited the complainant’s husband’s shop on 20.05.2022. The CDR analysis also confirmed that the respondents were not present at the alleged place of incident at the relevant time. The only witness produced by the complainant, Ritik, was found to be an interested witness, being employed in her husband’s shop. Thus, there is no credible independent corroboration of the allegations. CT Case No. 17/2023 Rekha Vs. State and ors. Page No. 8/9 -- 8 of 9 -- 8. In light of the above circumstances, this Court is of the considered view that the real grievance of the complainant arises out of the property dispute and the eviction order passed against her and her family members. The present complaint appears to be motivated by personal vendetta and has been filed with mala fide intent to misuse the criminal justice system. On a careful perusal of the averments in the complaint, the Court does not find the commission of any offence, much less a cognizable offence. Accordingly, the application under Section 156 (3) BNSS as well as the present complaint are hereby dismissed in entirety. File be consigned to record room. Announced in the open (Charu Aggarwal) Court on 19.05.2026. ASJ-02/E-Court/Shahdara KKD Court, Delhi. CT Case No. 17/2023 Rekha Vs. State and ors. Page No. 9/9 -- 9 of 9 --
