Skip to main content
Court Order

Final Order 4

CNR DLSH01004038202315 Sept 2023
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Final Order 4 · 15 Sept 2023 · CNR DLSH010040382023

Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT
Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. RAMESH KUMAR-II, ADDITIONAL
DISTRICT JUDGE-01 SHAHDARA DISTRICT,
KARKARDOOMA COURTS
DELHI
LAC No. 9/23
IN THE MATTER OF:-
Sh. Dinesh Bansal
S/o Late Sh. O.P. Bansal,
R/o A-9, Mansarovar Park
GT Road, Shahdara, Delhi. .........Petitioner
Versus
1. Union of India
Through Land Acquisition Collector
Distt. East [Erstwhile now Distt. Shahdara],
Delhi.
2. Municipal Corporation of Delhi
Through its commissioner,
Civic Centre, JLN Marg
Minto Road,
New Delhi-110002. .........Respondents
Date of Institution : 04.09.2006
Date of reserving judgment : 26.08.2023
Date of judgment : 15.09.2023
JUDGMENT
1 Vide this judgment, I shall decide the reference petition
filed under section 18 of Land Acquisition Act, 1894
(hereinafter referred to as 'L.A. Act, 1894') for enhancement of
the compensation arising out of common award
No.27/DC[E]/2003-04 dated 09.02.2004 passed by the Land
Acquisition Collector/ADM Distt. East Delhi with respect to
LAC No.9/23 1
-- 1 of 16 --
Chandrawali @ Shahdara, GT Road, Delhi.
2 For deciding the reference U/s 18 of the Land Acquisition
Act, 1894 (In short L.A. Act) r/w statement U/s 19 of the Act
sent by the LAC Delhi, the relevant dates and facts which are
necessary for adjudication in the present matter are being given
herein under:-
i) Date of notification U/s 4 of the Act : 18.02.2003
ii) Date of notification U/s 6 of the Act : 07.10.2003
iii) Date of award : 09.02.2004
iv) Area of the locality : GT Road,
Chandrawali @ Shahdara
v) Project : Construction of Grade
Separator-cum-Road
Over bridge at GT Road
Shahdara Delhi
vi) The land use of the area as per the award : Residential
3 The facts leading to the filing of the present petition are
that the notification dated 18.02.2003 under Section 4 of the
L.A. Act, 1894 was issued by the Land Acquisition Collector
(hereinafter referred to as "LAC") for acquisition of
land/properties coming in the way of construction of Grade
Separator-Cum-Road Over Bridge at GT Road Shahdara Delhi
situated in the Revenue Estate of Village Chandrawali @
Shahdara, which was followed by the Notification dated
07.10.2003 under Section 6 & of L.A. Act, 1894. Keeping in
view the use of the land under acquisition as Residential, the
LAC assessed the market value of the land @ Rs.1,281/- per sq.
mtr. with respect to 6817.50 sq. mtrs. of land which came to
Rs.87,33,217.50. Further, solatium at the rate of 30% of market
value alongwith the additional amount @ 12% of market value
LAC No.9/23 2
-- 2 of 16 --
w.e.f. 18.02.2003 to 17.02.2004 was allowed apart from cost of
structure appended to the said land and statutory interest under
Section 34 of the Act. Thus, an Award for total amount of
Rs.1,72,28,621.85 was passed by the LAC.
4 Being aggrieved from the lesser rate fixed by the LAC for
the acquired land, the petitioner filed a petition under Section 18
of L.A. Act, 1894 before the LAC. The LAC sent the present
reference petition to this court for adjudication and notices
were issued to the respondent no.1 and 2 and subsequently
the present case was listed for trial.
5 In the present petition, the petitioner has contended that
the LAC has assessed the market value of the acquired land on
the basis of lowest rates possible and the market value of the
acquired property was not less than Rs.50,000/- per sq. mtr. as
on the date of notification U/s 4 of the LA Act. The petitioner
further contended that the acquired property was being used for
commercial purposes wherein the petitioner was carrying on the
business of Timber & Plywood under the name & style of M/s
Laxmi Timbers Trading Co. for the last more than 20 years.
LAC has not treated the structures standing on such lands as
'land' as defined under the Act and has failed to granted 30%
solatium on the market value of the structures as well as
additional amount of 12% as provided under section 23 of the
Act on the same and that the market value of the structures has
also been incorrectly assessed at low rates. He further stated that
the petitioner was not present at the time of announcement of
the award and that the LAC has grossly erred in fixing the
market value of the commercial land of the petitioner on the
basis of lowest sales transactions of internal residential
LAC No.9/23 3
-- 3 of 16 --
properties of Vishwas Nagar, Bholanath Nagar & Azad Nagar
without making further enquires or enquiring as to the
genuineness of the sale transactions referred in the award. He
took various grounds in the petition inter alia that the LAC has
assessed extremely low value for the commercial land of the
petitioner and that the LAC has not taken into consideration the
development of the area and the prevailing market rates at the
time of acquisition. The LAC has failed to appreciate that the
land of the petitioner was freehold land value of which was
much higher than leasehold lands and that even the Govt. of
India levied certain charges in the form of percentage while
converting leasehold land to freehold. It is further contended
that the LAC failed to appreciate that the acquired land was
situated in an approved industrial cum commercial area where
all amenities for running industrial establishments were
available much prior to the date of notification under section 4
of the Act and these facilities were in the form of grant of
license to run a factory, branches of several banks in the area,
proximity to a railway station, National Highway-8 i.e. GT
Road, availability of regular transport facilities, hospitals,
educational institutions, supply of electricity and various forms
of communication. It is further contended that the market value
of the land if sold in the open market under the prevalent
conditions of demand and supply, would not be less than Rs.50
thousands per sq. mtr. which the petitioner claims to be the fair
market value of his land and he therefore prayed that he be
granted market value of his land at the rate of Rs. 50,000/- per
sq. mtr. besides other statutory benefits.
6 Both the respondents have filed their separate written
LAC No.9/23 4
-- 4 of 16 --
statement/reply. The respondent no.1 i.e. Union of India took
various preliminary objections in its written statement that the
petition is not maintainable as the LAC has already assessed the
correct market value of the land in question at the time of
publication of the notification under section 4 of the L.A. Act
and the value assessed by the LAC is quite reasonable and
sufficient and that the present petition was time barred.
7 The MCD also filed its written statement stating that the
present petition is not maintainable and there is no legal
infirmity in the award passed. The MCD further averred that
the ADM / LAC had rightly assessed the compensation since the
entire acquired area was residential in nature and prayed for
dismissal of the reference petition. The MCD further averred
that the award is based upon sound reason.
8 Replication to the written statements was not filed by the
petitioner.
9 From the pleadings of the parties, following issues were
framed by my Ld. Predecessor vide order dated 16.07.2007:-
1 What was the market value of the land in
question at the time of issuance of notification under Section
4 of the LA Act? Onus on parties.
2 Whether the petitioner is entitled for enhancement in
compensation, if so, to what amount? OPP
3 Relief?
10 The present case has also passed through two rounds of
litigation. My Ld. Predecessor had, vide order dated 12.04.2016
enhanced the market value of the acquired property of the
petitioner on the basis of the market value assessed with respect
to the properties acquired vide award No.2/2007-08, Jhilmil
LAC No.9/23 5
-- 5 of 16 --
Tahirpur Delhi in case titled Chandra Pratap Singh Vs. UOI &
Anr. bearing LAC no.1/2009 and assessed the market value of
the acquired property @ Rs.6594/- per sq. mtr. along with all the
statutory benefits and the proportionate amount of the value of
structures as mentioned in the award to the extent of
Rs.1,72,935/-. The said judgment was passed on the above
stated judgment wherein the date of notification U/s 4 of the LA
Act was 12.04.2006 and the date of notification in the present
case is 18.02.2003 i.e. almost three years prior to the date of
notification U/s 4 of the LA Act with respect to the properties
acquired vide award no.2/07-08, Jhilmil Tahirpur Delhi.
11 Since the judgment dated 12.04.2016 passed by my Ld.
Predecessor was on the basis of circle rates, the said matter was
also remanded back by the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi vide
order dated 21.12.2017 in LA appeal No.257/2017 stating that in
opportunity to lead additional evidence would be given to all the
parties since the circle rates could not be taken as the sole basis
for the assessment of market value.
12 In the earlier proceedings, ld. counsel for petitioner
examined as many as 08 witnesses in support of her claim which
have been discussed and dealt by my Ld. Predecessor at the time
of passing of the judgment dated 12.04.2016.
13 After the present case was remanded back for additional
evidence, the ld. Counsel for the petitioner adduced additional
evidence and examined PW3 Sh. Nishant Patwari, LAC (West),
Raja Garden, New Delhi and PW4 Sh. Ranjan Kohli, Law
Manager, Punjab and Sindh Bank, Asset Recovery Branch,
Ashram Chowk. The petitioner relied upon the entire evidence
led in case titled Jyotsana Gupta Vs. UOI bearing LAC no.12/23
LAC No.9/23 6
-- 6 of 16 --
and therefore relied upon the Master Plan of 1962 along with the
Zonal development plan of Zone E. In addition, the petitioner
proved the schedule of L&DO rates of the various commercial
properties of Delhi w.e.f. 01.04.2000 and which were published
during the trial in the present case. The petitioner contended that
the said rates were retrospective in nature and should be
considered for assessment of market value as in the case of the
properties acquitted vide award No.2/07-08, Jhilmil Tahirpur
Delhi. The said rates were exhibited as Ex.PW12/1 in case titled
Jyotsana Gupta vs. UOI (supra).
14 The petitioner further summoned a witness from the
office of LAC, West to prove the award No.4/DC(W)/10-11,
Basai Darapur in which the LAC had assessed all the statutory
benefits on the value of structure as well. The said award is
Ex.PW9/1. The petitioners also relied upon the Zonal
development plan of Zone E by summoning a witness from the
concerned department and the said plan was exhibited as
Ex.PW14/1 and Ex.PW14/2 in case titled Jyotsana Gupta vs.
UOI (supra). Even the master plan stated that the area of
Shahdara between GT Road and Railway Line was commercial
since the year 1962 and the same ought to have been taken into
consideration at the time of assessment of the market value.
Thus the petitioner, in totality, examined as many as 10
witnesses to prove the location and market value of the acquired
property as on the date of notification u/s 4.
15 The respondent no.1 did not lead any evidence except the
award and the MCD filed an evidence by way of affidavit, in the
earlier round of litigation stating that the said land have been
handed over to the PWD vide letter dated 09.03.2012. Along
LAC No.9/23 7
-- 7 of 16 --
with the said evidence, the MCD exhibited the copy of the letter
as well as the list dated 05.11.2012 of all the roads which have
been handed over to the PWD and exhibited the letters
Ex.R2W1/1 and Ex.R2W1/2.
16 The respondents chose not to lead any additional evidence
in support of their claim or in rebuttal. However, the MCD
averred that the order dated 12.04.2016 should be set aside as
the compensation assessed is just, fair and reasonable.
17 After conclusion of additional evidence of all the parties,
the matter was fixed for final arguments.
18 Ld. Counsel for the petitioner and ld. Counsel for
respondent no.2 filed their respective written arguments and they
submitted that they do not want to submit anything else beyond
written submissions. The respondent no.1 did not file any written
submissions despite giving opportunity.
19 I have perused the evidence and written arguments as
filed by the parties and also perused the record. On perusal of
record, my issue-wise finding is as follows:-
ISSUE NO.1 & 2
20 Both issues are being disposed off together being inter-
connected. The onus to prove issue no.1 was upon both the
parties, whereas onus to prove issue no.2 was upon the petitioner.
First and foremost, for the ascertainment of the actual market
value, it is necessary to consider the admissions made by all the
parties in the pleadings as well as in their evidence led in support
of their contentions. The relevant portion of the award announced
by the LAC is reproduced herein under:-
“The properties under acquisition are situated
adjacent to Shahdara Flyover and have residential as well
LAC No.9/23 8
-- 8 of 16 --
as commercial activities in the vicinity. These properties
are situated very close to the Metro Station Shahdara. There
is also a commercial market nearby the properties under
acquisition. The properties are under use of both for
commercial as well as residential. However, the land use of
the properties under acquisition is residential.”
21 The LAC, while assessing the market value of the land has
observed that the acquired properties were commercial as well
as residential and there was a commercial market in existence at
the time of the announcement of the award. The LAC has not
stated as to on what basis the land use of the acquired property
was held to be residential in spite of him making admissions
that there were commercial as well as residential properties in
the area.
22 As per section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act, the market
value of the acquired properties is liable to be ascertained/
determined as on the date of issuance of notification U/s 4 of the
L.A. Act which in this particular case is 18.02.2003. The
petitioner has duly stated that the rate of Rs.1281/- per sq. mtrs.
as assessed by the LAC is extremely meagre for the prime
commercial property of the petitioner and that the acquired area
was on the main GT Road. Even the award bears a mention of
the fact that the acquired properties are on Main GT Road
Shahdara.
23 Section 23 of L.A. Act, 1894 provides that in order to
determine the amount of compensation to be awarded for land
acquired under this Act, the Court shall take into
LAC No.9/23 9
-- 9 of 16 --
consideration the market value of the land on the date of
publication of notification under section 4 (1) of the Act.
24 In Kapil Mehra Vs. UOI (MANU/SC/0947/2014), the
Hon'ble Apex Court has observed that "market value is
ordinarily the price the property may fetch in the open market if
sold by a willing seller unaffected by the special needs of a
particular purchase, and where definite material is not
forthcoming either in the shape of sales of similar lands in the
neighborhood at or about the date of notification under Section 4
(1) or otherwise, other sale instances as well as other evidence
have to be considered. It has been further observed that for the
purpose of fiXation of fair and reasonable market value of any
type of land, abnormally high value or abnormally low value
sales should be carefully discarded".
The factors have also been mentioned in para 10, which
are required to considered in determining the market value of
the land as:-
a. existing geographical situation of the land;
b. existing use of the land;
c. Already available advantages, like
proXimity to national or state highway or road and/or
developed area and;
d. Market value of other land situated in the
same locality/village/area or adjacent or very near to the
acquired land.
25 In Karnataka Urban Water Supply & Drainage Board
& Ors. Vs. K.S. Gangadharappa & Anr.
LAC No.9/23 10
-- 10 of 16 --
(MANU/SC/0598/2009), the Hon'ble Apex Court has observed
as:-
"11. It can be broadly stated that the element of
speculation is reduced to minimum if the underlying
principles of fiXation of market value with reference to
comparable sales are made as:-
i. when sale is within a reasonable time of the
date of notification under Section 4 (1);
ii. it should be a bona fide transaction;
iii. it should be of the land acquired or of the land
adjacent to the land acquired; and
iv. it should possess similar advantages."
26 In the case of Krapa Rangiah Vs. Special Deputy
Collector Land Acquisition reported in [1982] 2 SCC 374, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court was pleased to hold that where similar
lands are acquired under the same notification, the same rate of
compensation should be awarded for other lands acquired under
the same notification. In the case of Bhag Singh & Ors. Vs.
Union Territory of Chandigarh reported in [1992] 4 SCC 692,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court was pleased to observe that
judgment of a court in a land acquisition case determining the
market value of a land in the vicinity of the acquired land even
though not inter parties could be admitted in evidence as an
instance from which the market value could be inferred. It was
further observed that there would be no difficulty in accepting
such judgment as one furnishing the basis for determining the
market value of the acquired land if the opposite parties do not
genuinely dispute the position that the judgment relied upon
LAC No.9/23 11
-- 11 of 16 --
could be accepted as the basis for determination of the market
value of the acquired land. In the case of Goa Housing Board
versus Ramesh Chandra Govind Pawaskar reported in [2011] 10
SCC 371, the Hon’ble Supreme Court was pleased to reiterate
that similarly situated land in the same area having the same
advantages and acquired under the same notification should be
awarded in same compensation.
27 In the present matter, the LAC itself admitted that there
was a commercial market in the vicinity and that the properties
are under the use of both commercial as well as residential.
28 Apart from the said admission made by the LAC, the
petitioner and other property owners have also proved the Zonal
development plan of Zone E as Ex.PW14/1 and Ex.PW14/2 in
which the acquired area marked at Point A has been clearly
shown to be commercial. Even the master plan clearly mentions
that the entire area between GT Road and Railway lines
Shahdara is commercial. The respondents did not give any
rebuttal evidence to rebut the said contention.
29 The respondent no.1 also admits the fact that the LAC has
admittedly considered the acquired property to be commercial.
30 It is pertinent to mention that the L&DO, Ministry of
Urban Development had revised the land rates of various
commercial leasehold properties in Delhi vide list dated
02.05.2017 w.e.f. 01.04.2000 and the commercial land rates for
the entire East Delhi was the same which included the area of the
properties acquired vide award No.2/07-08, Jhilmil Tahirpur as
well as the present area.
LAC No.9/23 12
-- 12 of 16 --
31 Admittedly, the acquired properties were freehold in
nature and the acquired area of Chandrawali, Shahdara GT Road
is touching the area of Jhilmil Tahirpur and there is no evidence
on behalf of the respondents to negate the contention of the
petitioner and the evidence proved by him. Since the L&DO
rates for entire East Delhi were the same and there is no
distinction made in the said rates, I am of the opinion that the
market value as assessed in respect of the properties acquired
vide award No.2/07-08 can be taken as the basis for the
assessment of the market value in the present award as well
specially when the date of notification U/s 4 of the LA Act in the
present case is only three years prior to the date of notification
u/s 4 of the LA Act of award no.2/07-08, Jhilmil Tahirpur Delhi.
32 The written arguments submitted by the MCD are also
only a reiteration of their written statement and the respondent
no.2 has vehemently argued that circle rates could not be taken
as the sole basis for the determination of the market value in the
present case as per the judgment passed by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India in case titled UOI Vs. Savitri Devi,
2017 SCC online 1400. This court is also of the view that the
circle rates cannot be taken as the basis for assessment of market
value in the present case and is thus relying upon the judgments
passed in case titled Chandra Pratap Singh Vs. UOI & Anr.
which pertains to the award No.2/07-08 wherein the market
value has been enhanced to Rs.48,000/- per sq. mts. as on the
date of notification U/s 4 of the LA Act in the said case i.e.
12.04.2006. Since the said market value was determined on the
basis of L&DO rates relied upon by the LAC himself, there is
LAC No.9/23 13
-- 13 of 16 --
no reason why the said rates cannot be relied by this court, more
specifically when the location and potentiality of the properties
acquired vide the present award is similar to that of award
no.2/07-08, Jhilmil Tahirpur.
33 The petitioner has also relied upon another judgment titled
Ali Mohammad Beigh & Ors. Vs. State of J&K reported in AIR
2017 SC 1518 in which Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that
“when the acquired lands are identical and similar and the
acquisition is for the same purpose, it would not be proper to
discriminate between the land owners unless there are strong
reasons.”
34 The Hon'ble Apex Court has held in Lal Chand Vs. UOI
(supra) that "the distance between the two properties, the nature
and situation of the property, proximity to the village or a road
and several other factors may all be relevant in determining the
market value. Mere production of some exemplar deeds without
'connecting' the subject matter of the instrument, to the acquired
lands will be of little assistance in determining the market
value".
The aforesaid judgment has also been relied upon by the
respondent no.2 itself and the said judgment has to be construed
as a whole and cannot be read in piecemeal.
35 This court has already decided the market value with
respect to the properties acquired vide the same notification and
the present award and the present case is also no exception.
36 Hence for the foregoing reasons recorded above since the
date of notification in the present case is 18.02.2003, this court
LAC No.9/23 14
-- 14 of 16 --
deems it fit to award Rs.30,000/- per sq. mtrs. as the actual
market rate with respect to the acquired properties duly
acquired vide award No.27/DC(E)/2003-04, Chandrawali @
Shahdara Delhi after due deduction to the market value
assessed at Rs.48,000/- per sq. mts. for the properties acquired
vide award No.2/07-08 wherein the date of notification U/s 4 of
the LA Act was 12.04.2006.
37 The LAC has awarded an amount of Rs.1,281/- per sq.
mtrs. Therefore the petitioner is held entitled to an enhancement
@ Rs.28,719/- per sq. mtrs. over and above Rs.1,281/- per sq.
mtrs. as on the date of notification U/s 4 i.e. 18.02.2003.
Besides the said market value, the petitioner would also be
entitled to solatium @ 30% as per the provisions of LA Act and
additional amount U/s 23(1-A) and 28 of the LA Act.
38 Besides the above stated value, the petitioner would be
also entitled to the value of structures of Rs.1,17,352/-. Issue
no.1 and 2 are disposed off accordingly.
RELIEF:
39 In view of the findings of issue No.1 & 2, the petitioner is
entitled to the market value @ Rs.30,000/- per sq. mtrs. as on
18.02.2003. In addition, the petitioner would also be entitled to
all statutory benefits i.e. 30% solatium on the market value in
view of the compulsory nature of acquisition U/s 23(2) of the
LA Act and an additional amount of 12% per annum on the
market value from the date of notification U/s 4 of the LA Act
till date of possession or award whichever is earlier as per
section 23(1A) of the LA Act. Besides the petitioner would also
be entitled to interest on the enhanced amount of compensation
LAC No.9/23 15
-- 15 of 16 --
@ 9% per annum from the date of dispossession till expiry of
one year and thereafter @ 15% per annum till the date of
payment of the balance amount.
40 Reference is answered accordingly. Parties to bear their
own costs. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly.
41 A copy of this judgment be sent to the concerned LAC for
information and necessary compliance within three months of
its receipt. File be consigned to Record Room as per rules.
(Typed to the dictation directly corrected and
pronounced in open court on 15.09.2023).
(RAMESH KUMAR-II)
ADDL. DISTRICT JUDGE-01
SHAHDARA DISTRICT
KARKARDOOMA COURTS
DELHI
LAC No.9/23 16
-- 16 of 16 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.