Full Order Text
Interim Order 21 · 14 Mar 2026 · CNR DLSH010038542024
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. SANJAY GARG-II, PRINCIPAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE, SHAHDARA, KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI Sessions Case No. 240/2024 CNR No. DLSH01-003854-2024 State Vs. 1. Mahender, S/o Sh. Ramlal, R/o A-3/406, Nand Nagri, Delhi. 2. Sumitra, W/o Sh. Mahender, R/o A-3/406, Nand Nagri, Delhi. 3. Praveen @ Chander Shekhar, S/o Sh. Mahender, R/o A-3/406, Nand Nagri, Delhi. 4. Dinesh, S/o Sh. Mahender, R/o A-3/406, Nand Nagri, Delhi. FIR No. : 128/2016 Police Station : Nand Nagri Under Sections : 308/34 IPC Chargesheet presented on : 07.10.2023 Judgment reserved on : 06.02.2026 Judgment pronounced on : 14.03.2026 J U D G M E N T 1. Accused Mahender is the husband of accused Sumitra and the SC No. 240/2024 State v. Mahender & Ors. Page 1 of 16 -- 1 of 16 -- father of accused Praveen @ Chander Shekhar and Dinesh. All the four accused persons are facing trial for the commission of offence punishable under Section 308/34 IPC. CASE OF THE PROSECUTION: 2. The case of the prosecution is that upon receipt of DD No. 61B dated 08.02.2016, HC Ravinder along with Constable Amit reached the spot i.e. Main Road, Primary School, near Block A-4, Nand Nagri, Delhi, where they came to know that the injured had been taken to GTB Hospital in a private vehicle. Since no eye witness was available at the spot, they both went to the hospital and obtained the MLC of the complainant/injured Ashok Kumar, who was under treatment. After the complainant was declared fit for statement, his statement was recorded by HC Ravinder. 3. In his statement, the complainant stated that on 08.02.2016 at about 2:15 p.m., when he was going to A-4, Nand Nagri and had reached near the school, he saw that some boys were quarreling with each other. The complainant intervened to pacify the said boys. While he was doing so, the accused Sumitra caught hold of his collar and asked him not to meddle in their affair. When the complainant tried to free himself, the accused Mahender struck a danda on his hand and the accused Dinesh started beating him with kicks and fist blows. The accused Praveen came from behind and inflicted injury with a brick on the head of the complainant. SC No. 240/2024 State v. Mahender & Ors. Page 2 of 16 -- 2 of 16 -- As a result thereof, the complainant became dizzy and his head started bleeding profusely. In the meantime, the friend of the complainant namely Sanjay reached the spot and rescued the complainant from the accused persons. He also took the complainant to GTB Hospital for treatment. 4. On the basis of the above statement of the complainant, FIR under Section 308/34 IPC was registered and the investigation of the case was assigned to SI Gaurav Kumar. During investigation, he prepared the site plan of the spot at the instance of the complainant and recorded the statements of the witnesses under Section 161 CrPC. Consequent upon the transfer of SI Gaurav Kumar, the further investigation of the case was assigned to ASI Devi Ram. On 04.12.2016, ASI Devi Ram arrested the accused Mahender on the identification of the complainant and recorded his disclosure statement. Despite efforts, neither the weapon of offence could be recovered nor the whereabouts of the remaining three accused persons could be traced. ASI Devi Ram obtained the final opinion on the MLC of the complainant. The nature of injury was opined as simple. After the transfer of ASI Devi Ram, the further investigation of the case was assigned to SI Niraj Singh. He issued notice under Section 41A CrPC to the accused Sumitra, Dinesh and Praveen @ Chander Shekhar, who joined the investigation on 01.08.2023 but no recovery could be effected at their instance. After the completion of investigation, the chargesheet was filed before the Ld. MM on 07.10.2023. SC No. 240/2024 State v. Mahender & Ors. Page 3 of 16 -- 3 of 16 -- 5. Cognizance of the offence under Section 308/34 IPC was taken against the accused persons on 31.10.2023. After the compliance of the provisions of Section 207 CrPC, the chargesheet was committed to the Sessions Court on 05.06.2024. CHARGE: 6. On 23.07.2024, the charge for the commission of offence under Section 308/34 IPC was framed against the accused persons to which they pleaded not guilty and claimed trial. PROSECUTION EVIDENCE: 7. In support of its case, the prosecution examined 10 witnesses. 7.1. PW1 Sh. Sanjay Tiwari is the friend of the complainant/injured Sh. Ashok Kumar. He did not support the case of the prosecution and turned hostile. 7.2. PW2 Constable Amit had accompanied HC Ravinder to the spot as well as GTB Hospital on 08.02.2016 upon receiving information regarding a quarrel vide DD No. 61B. He deposed that on the basis of the statement of the complainant/injured Sh. Ashok Kumar recorded by HC Ravinder, the FIR was registered in the present case. 7.3. PW3 Sh. Ashok Kumar is the complainant/injured. He proved the SC No. 240/2024 State v. Mahender & Ors. Page 4 of 16 -- 4 of 16 -- statement made by him to the police on 08.02.2016 as Ex. PW3/A. He deposed that the accused Mahender was arrested by the IO at his instance. He proved the arrest memo and personal search memo of the accused Mahender as Ex. PW3/B and Ex. PW3/C respectively. 7.4. PW4 HC Mukesh Kumar had joined the investigation of the case with ASI Devi Ram on 04.12.2016. He deposed that on the pointing of the complainant Ashok Kumar, the accused Mahender was arrested and interrogated by ASI Devi Ram in his presence. He proved the disclosure statement of the accused Mahender as Ex. PW4/A. 7.5. PW5 SI Manoj Kumar is the Duty Officer. He proved the FIR as Ex. PW5/A; the endorsement made by him on the rukka as Ex. PW5/B and the certificate under Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act as Ex. PW5/C. 7.6. PW6 ASI Ravinder Kumar deposed that upon receipt of DD No. 61B on 08.02.2016, he along with Constable Amit visited the spot as well as GTB Hospital. He deposed that after obtaining the MLC of the complainant/injured Ashok Kumar, he recorded the statement of the complainant/injured in the hospital and prepared tehrir. He proved the tehrir as Ex. PW6/A. 7.7. PW7 SI Gaurav Kumar is the first IO of the case. He deposed that SC No. 240/2024 State v. Mahender & Ors. Page 5 of 16 -- 5 of 16 -- after the assignment of the investigation of the case to him, he had recorded the statement of Sh. Sanjay Tiwari on 08.02.2016, who had got admitted the complainant/injured Ashok Kumar in the GTB Hospital. He further deposed that on 14.02.2016, he had inspected the spot and prepared the site plan on the pointing of the complainant/injured Sh. Ashok Kumar. He proved the site plan of the spot as Ex. PW7/A. 7.8. PW8 Dr. Saurabh, CMO, GTB Hospital deposed that he had medically examined the complainant/injured Sh. Ashok Kumar on 08.02.2016. He proved the MLC of Sh. Ashok Kumar as Ex. PW8/A. 7.9. PW9 SI Niraj Singh is the third IO of the case. He deposed that on 10.04.2023, he had served notice under Section 41A CrPC upon the accused Sumitra, Praveen and Dinesh and proved the said notices as Ex. PW9/A, Ex. PW9/B and Ex. PW9/C respectively. He also deposed that pursuant to the said notice, the said accused persons had joined the investigation and he had recorded their disclosure statements. He proved the said disclosure statements as Ex. PW9/D to Ex. PW9/F. 7.10. PW10 SI Devi Ram is the second IO of the case. He deposed that on 04.12.2016, he had apprehended the accused Mahender on the identification of the complainant, recorded his disclosure statement, prepared his arrest memo and personal search memo SC No. 240/2024 State v. Mahender & Ors. Page 6 of 16 -- 6 of 16 -- and obtained the final opinion on the MLC of the complainant. STATEMENT OF THE ACCUSED: 8. The statement of the accused persons under Section 313 CrPC were recorded on 06.11.2025. All the incriminating material available on record was put to them to which their stand was of general denial and they stated that they were not present at the spot at the time of incident and had been falsely implicated in the case by the IO at the instance of the complainant. However, they chose not to lead any evidence in their defence. 9. I have heard the Ld. Addl. PP for the State as well as the Ld. Counsel for the accused persons. Material on record has also been perused. ARGUMENTS ADVANCED: 10. Ld. Addl. PP for the State has submitted that the complainant Sh. Ashok Kumar (PW3) is the star witness of the case of the prosecution and in his testimony, he has not only supported the case of the prosecution in entirety but also identified the accused persons in the Court. He has submitted that though the eye witness of the incident Sh. Sanjay Tiwari (PW1) resiled from his statement under Section 161 CrPC but the testimony of the complainant is corroborated by the medical evidence produced on record. He has submitted that all the accused persons had acted in concert with SC No. 240/2024 State v. Mahender & Ors. Page 7 of 16 -- 7 of 16 -- each other and in furtherance of their common intention, the accused Praveen inflicted injury with a brick on the parietal region of the skull of the complainant. He has argued that from the unshattered testimony of the complainant and his MLC proved on record, the prosecution has succeeded in establishing the guilt of the accused persons beyond reasonable doubt and therefore, they are liable to be convicted for the commission of offence punishable under Section 308/34 IPC. 11. Per contra, the Ld. Counsel for the accused persons has contended that the accused persons have been falsely implicated in the case and no such incident had taken place. He has submitted that the alleged eye witness of the incident did not support the case of the prosecution and in the absence of any independent corroboration of the deposition of the complainant, the accused persons can not be convicted on the sole testimony of the complainant, who is an interested witness. He has submitted that it has come on record that the complainant is the bad character of the area and was involved in 8-10 cases registered under the provisions of the Public Gambling Act and therefore, he can not be treated as a trustworthy witness. He has argued that since the prosecution has neither examined the boys with whom the accused persons were allegedly quarreling on the date of incident nor any recovery of weapon was effected from the accused persons, it has miserably failed to prove the case against the accused persons and thus, the accused persons deserve to be acquitted. SC No. 240/2024 State v. Mahender & Ors. Page 8 of 16 -- 8 of 16 -- ANALYSIS AND REASONING: 12. Before proceeding to evaluate the evidence on record, it would be beneficial to have a glance on the provision of Section 308 IPC, which reads as under: “308. Attempt to commit culpable homicide.—Whoever does any act with such intention or knowledge and under such circumstances that, if he by that act caused death, he would be guilty of culpable homicide not amounting to murder, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to three years, or with fine, or with both; and, if hurt is caused to any person by such act, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to seven years, or with fine, or with both.” 13. From the above provision, it follows that in order to bring home the guilt of the accused persons, the prosecution is required to prove: (i) That the accused persons had caused injury to the complainant on the date of incident; (ii) That the said injury had been caused with such intention or knowledge and under such circumstances that if the complainant had died, the accused would have been guilty of culpable homicide not amounting to murder; and (iii) That the above act had been committed by the accused persons in furtherance of their common intention. 14. The complainant/injured Sh. Ashok Kumar (PW3) is the star witness of the case of the prosecution. In his testimony, the SC No. 240/2024 State v. Mahender & Ors. Page 9 of 16 -- 9 of 16 -- complainant has deposed that on 08.02.2016 at about 2:15 p.m., while he was going to A-4, Nand Nagri and had reached near the school, he saw that some boys were quarreling with each other and when he tried to pacify the matter, the accused persons got offended and caused injuries to him. He narrated the specific roles played by the accused persons during the incident and deposed that while the accused Sumitra had caught hold of his collar, accused Mahender gave a danda blow on his right hand and the accused Dinesh gave beatings to him with kicks and fist blows. He deposed that the accused Praveen had come from behind and hit his head with a brick as a result of which, blood started oozing from his head and he fell down. During the cross-examination of the complainant, no suggestion was put to him by the accused persons disputing their presence at the spot at the time of incident. For the first time in their statement under Section 313 CrPC, the accused persons took the plea that they were not present at the spot at the the time of incident. In this regard, it is pertinent to mention that PW6 ASI Ravinder Kumar, who had reached the spot on receipt of DD No. 61B regarding a quarrel, had been suggested in his cross-examination that the said DD had been recorded pursuant to the information given by the accused Dinesh and that on the basis of the said DD, FIR No. 127/2016 had been registered prior to the registration of the instant FIR. Though the copy of DD No. 61B and FIR No. 127/2016 have not been produced on record by the accused persons but from the above suggestions given to PW6 SC No. 240/2024 State v. Mahender & Ors. Page 10 of 16 -- 10 of 16 -- ASI Ravinder Kumar, it is clear that the presence of the accused persons at the time of incident was not in dispute. Thus, the defence that they were not present at the spot had been raised by the accused persons in their statement under Section 313 CrPC as an afterthought. 15. The Ld. Counsel for the accused persons has submitted that while it has come on record in the testimony of the complainant Sh. Ashok Kumar (PW3) that he had involvement in 8-10 cases under the provisions of the Public Gambling Act, PW6 ASI Ravinder Kumar has admitted that the complainant is the bad character of the area. He has argued that considering the antecedents of the complainant, he can not be considered as a credible witness and thus, no reliance can be placed on his testimony. The Court is unable to accept the said contention. Apart from the fact that the complainant has deposed that he has already been acquitted in the said cases, the character of a witness is immaterial under the Indian criminal law. The real test to evaluate the evidentiary value of the testimony of a witness is the truthfulness of the statement made by him. What would be relevant is the consistency of the statement right from the starting point till the end, namely, at the time when the witness makes the initial statement and ultimately before the Court. There should not be any prevarication in the version of the witness. The witness should be in a position to withstand the cross-examination and should not give room to any doubt as to the factum of occurrence, the persons involved as well SC No. 240/2024 State v. Mahender & Ors. Page 11 of 16 -- 11 of 16 -- as the sequence of it. If the testimony of a witness is natural and consistent with the case of the prosecution qua the accused and is corroborated by other material such as medical evidence, the Court has no reason to discard the same. 16. The Ld. Counsel for the accused persons has next contended that in the absence of any independent corroboration of the version of the complainant, the accused persons can not be held guilty on the basis of the sole testimony of the complainant. He has submitted that the friend of the complainant, who was shown to be the eye witness of the incident, failed to support the case of the prosecution and was declared hostile. He has further submitted that the investigating agency has also failed to establish the identity and examine the boys with whom the accused persons were allegedly quarreling at the time of incident. He has argued that the rule of prudence requires corroboration of the testimony of the complainant before acting upon the same. 17. As per Section 134 of the Indian Evidence Act, no particular number of witnesses is required to prove a fact. Plurality of witnesses in a criminal trial is not the legislative intent. It is the quality of evidence and not the quantity of witnesses that matters. As a general rule, the Court may act on the testimony of a sole witness if it is found reliable on the touchstone of credibility and is above reproach and suspicion. The necessity of corroboration arises if there is any reasonable doubt for suspecting the veracity SC No. 240/2024 State v. Mahender & Ors. Page 12 of 16 -- 12 of 16 -- of such a witness and the Court needs reassurance before acting upon the same. If a witness has received injury during an incident, his testimony is usually considered to be very reliable and is given due weightage being a stamped witness. While dealing with the evidentiary value of the testimony of an injured witness, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Abdul Sayeed v. State of Madhya Pradesh, (2010) 10 SCC 259 observed thus: “30. The law on the point can be summarised to the effect that the testimony of the injured witness is accorded a special status in law. This is as a consequence of the fact that the injury to the witness is an inbuilt guarantee of his presence at the scene of the crime and because the witness will not want to let his actual assailant go unpunished merely to falsely implicate a third party for the commission of the offence. Thus, the deposition of the injured witness should be relied upon unless there are strong grounds for rejection of his evidence on the basis of major contradictions and discrepancies therein.” 18. In the case on hand, the testimony of the complainant Sh. Ashok Kumar (PW3) is consistent and has not wavered at any stage. In his deposition before the Court, the complainant has supported his initial statement under Section 161 CrPC in entirety. The accused persons have failed to dent the testimony of the complainant with regard to the occurrence and the manner of the commission of offence. Though the accused persons have raised the plea that they have been falsely implicated by the complainant with the help of the police officials, however, they have failed to disclose any circumstance which would have furnished the motive to the complainant to falsely implicate them in the case. After sustaining SC No. 240/2024 State v. Mahender & Ors. Page 13 of 16 -- 13 of 16 -- injury during the incident in question, the complainant was taken to GTB Hospital for medical treatment on the same day. The MLC of the complainant has been proved on record by PW8 Dr. Saurabh as Ex. PW8/A. As per his MLC, a laceration over parietal region of skull and mild tenderness over the right forearm were found. The above medical evidence substantiates the version of the complainant regarding the injuries inflicted upon him by the accused persons. 19. No doubt, the friend of the complainant Sh. Sanjay Tiwari (PW1) turned hostile and stated that neither he had seen the accused persons giving beatings to the complainant nor he had taken the complainant to GTB Hospital but it is seen from the MLC of the complainant that he had been brought to the hospital by Sh. Sanjay. PW8 Dr. Saurabh has also deposed that the complainant had been brought to the hospital with the alleged history of physical assault by one Sanjay. Considering the same, it appears that PW1 Sh. Sanjay Tiwari did not depose truthfully before the Court. As far as the failure of the investigating agency to establish the identity and examine the boys with whom the accused persons were quarreling prior to the intervention of the complainant is concerned, the said lapse on the part of the investigating agency does not cast any doubt on the version of the complainant. 20. From the unshattered testimony of the complainant Sh. Ashok Kumar (PW3) and the medical evidence brought on record, the SC No. 240/2024 State v. Mahender & Ors. Page 14 of 16 -- 14 of 16 -- prosecution has succeeded in proving that the accused persons had caused injuries to the complainant in furtherance of their common intention during the incident. 21. Now the question which needs to be considered is whether the acts of the accused persons in causing injuries to the complainant attract the offence under Section 308 IPC. In order to constitute the offence under Section 308 IPC, it must be proved that the accused persons had caused the injuries with the intention or knowledge that by inflicting such injuries, they were likely to cause death. The intention or knowledge on the part of the accused persons is to be gathered from the circumstances in which the injuries had been caused, the nature of the injuries and the body part where such injuries were suffered. It has come on record in the testimony of the complainant (PW3) that the parties were known to each other and there was no prior dispute between them. From the narration of the incident given by the complainant, it is evident that when he had tried to intervene in a quarrel between the accused persons and some boys, the accused persons got offended and on the spur of the moment, they inflicted injuries on the person of the complainant. Thus, there was no premeditation on the part of the accused persons. As per the MLC of the complainant, he had sustained a lacerated wound of 3 cm x 0.5 cm over the parietal region of his skull and mild tenderness over the right forearm. The said injuries were opined to be simple in nature. Since the injury on the head was in the form of laceration, it is SC No. 240/2024 State v. Mahender & Ors. Page 15 of 16 -- 15 of 16 -- clear that the same had been caused by the impact of blunt force. Merely because one of the injuries was sustained by the complainant on his head, it can not be said that the accused persons had caused the said injury with the intention or knowledge to commit culpable homicide not amounting to murder. Considering the overall facts and circumstances of the case, this Court is of the considered opinion that the requisite intention or knowledge on the part of the accused persons to commit the offence under Section 308 IPC is not made out. Resultantly, the injuries caused to the complainant by the accused persons fall within the ambit of Section 323 IPC. CONCLUSION: 22. In the light of the above discussion, the accused Mahender, Sumitra, Praveen @ Chander Shekhar and Dinesh are hereby convicted for the commission of offence punishable under Section 323/34 IPC. 23. Copy of the judgment be supplied to the convicts free of cost. 24. The convicts shall now be heard on the point of sentence. Pronounced in the open court (SANJAY GARG-II) on 14.03.2026 Principal District & Sessions Judge, Shahdara, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi SC No. 240/2024 State v. Mahender & Ors. Page 16 of 16 -- 16 of 16 --
