Full Order Text
Final Order 4 · 03 Jul 2023 · CNR DLSH010038032023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: Bail Application No. 1183/2023 FIR No.169/2023 U/s 394/34 IPC Police Station: M.S. Park State vs. Rajan 03.07.2023 Order on Bail Application Present: Shri Anurag Kumar, Ld. Addl. PP for the State. Shri Amit Tyagi, Ld. Counsel for accused/applicant. Shri Narvir Dabbas, Ld. Counsel for complainant. IO/SI Yogesh Kumar in person. 1. This is an application u/s 439 Cr.P.C for grant of regular bail moved on behalf of applicant/accused. 2. Reply filed. Taken on record. Copy supplied. 3. It is stated by Ld. Defence counsel that accused/applicant has been falsely implicated in the present case by complainant. It is stated that accused/applicant has been undergoing judicial custody since 10.06.2023. It is stated that nothing (katta, cash or documents) has been recovered from the possession of accused/applicant despite one day police custody remand. It is stated that name of accused/applicant has not been mentioned in the FIR. It is argued that a case of road accident has falsely been converted into a case of robbery and the mechanical inspection report of both the vehicles corroborate his argument. It is submitted that investigation of the case has already been completed and no purpose would be served by keeping the accused/applicant in custody. It is stated that accused/applicant is Vice-President (Sales) in SME Cargo Pvt. Ltd and has good reputation in the society. It is stated that accused/applicant has no previous involvement. It is stated that accused/applicant shall abide by all the conditions imposed by the -- 1 of 3 -- -2- Court, if ordered to be released on bail. 4. The bail application has been opposed by Ld. Addl. PP for State assisted by IO and Ld. Counsel for complainant arguing that there are serious allegations against the accused/applicant wherein one katta was used to rob the complainant, and if he is ordered to be released on bail, he may threaten or influence the complainant and the same shall also hamper investigation. It is argued that failure of IO to recover either the katta or the case property cannot be a ground to release the accused/applicant on bail. It is submitted that two other accused are yet to be arrested and therefore, no ground to allow the application is made out. 5. Submissions heard. Record perused. 6. This Court has also gone through the case file of IO to appreciate the submissions of both the parties. It is observed that accused/applicant was arrested at the identification of complainant in the police station. In fact, co-accused Vishal was also arrested in the same way. At the time of arrest, complainant did not identify accused/applicant Rajan to be the person who allegedly used a pistol like weapon to commit the alleged offence. Further, there is no reference either to the involvement of four persons or to the use of any weapon in the disclosure statement of accused/applicant. Court fails to understand the argument of prosecution as to how grant of bail to accused/applicant would affect investigation and particularly the arrest of remaining accused when the investigating agency is not even asserting the involvement of any person other than accused/applicant and his co-accused. Investigating agency has not even referred to involvement of more than two person in any document other than the FIR and as such, the apprehension or arrest -- 2 of 3 -- -3- of any other person is out of question. 7. It is observed that despite one day police custody of accused/applicant, neither the katta allegedly used nor any of the allegedly robbed articles could be recovered. As such, the only material against accused/applicant as on today is the statement of complainant/victim. No further recovery is to be effected from the possession of accused/applicant and as such, his further custody does not appear necessary. 8. It is also noted that accused/applicant has no previous involvement and has roots in the society. Further, he has been undergoing judicial custody since 10.06.2023. Furthermore, as per the record of IO, one cross complaint has been filed against complainant herein by wife of accused/applicant on behalf of her husband. Taking note of the overall facts and circumstances of the case as discussed above, the request for grant of bail to accused/applicant appears justified. Accordingly, accused/applicant Rajan is admitted to bail on furnishing Bail Bond in the sum of Rs. 25,000/- with two sureties in the like amount to the satisfaction of Ld. MM/Duty MM, as the case may be. 9. The bail is further subject to the condition that applicant/accused shall not approach the prosecution witnesses directly or indirectly. He shall also not threaten or influence the prosecution witnesses. He shall attend the Court hearing on regular basis and shall intimate any change of his address to the IO/Court immediately. 10. Application is disposed of accordingly. (ARVIND BANSAL) Addl. Sessions Judge-05 (Shahdara) Karkardooma Courts, Delhi/03.07.2023 -- 3 of 3 --
