Full Order Text
Interim Order 17 · 20 May 2026 · CNR DLSH010037742024
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: 45 MACT 401/24 GUDDI AND ORS Vs. RANDHIR SINGH AND ORS 20.05.2026 Present: Sh. Upender Singh, Ld. Counsel for petitioner. Proxy Counsel for R1 and R2. Sh. Kumar Alok, Ld. Counsel for R3 i.e. insurance company. Heard. Perused. An application under Order XVI Rule 1 CPC r/w section 151 CPC already filed on behalf of R2 seeking summoning of witness. Reply to the application filed by the petitioners today. Submissions heard. File perused. By way of the aforesaid application, the applicant/R2 seeks summoning of a person namely Jaswant Singh as the said person was allegedly the conductor/second driver of the offending vehicle and his testimony is essential to prove the element of contributory negligence on part of the driver of the victim’s vehicle. On the other hand, the petitioners have strongly objected to the application at hand stating that the same is merely a tactic to prolong the proceedings in the present claim petition where statutory liability to make the payment of compensation amount is of the insurance company. It has been further submitted that the name of the proposed witness does not find mention in the FIR or the charge- sheet pertaining to the incident in question as there was no role of the proposed witness in the incident in question. Herein, it is pertinent to note that the driver of the offending vehicle has already been proceeded ex parte vide order dated 07.02.2025, while the applicant/R2 happens to be the registered -- 1 of 2 -- owner of the offending vehicle involved in the accident in question. It is an admitted fact on record that name of the proposed witness does not find mention in the FIR or the charge-sheet filed by the police in the criminal case pertaining to the incident in question. Similarly, it is also an admitted and apparent fact on record that the name or the role of the proposed witness has not been mentioned by the R2 even in his written statement or the list of witnesses filed along with pleadings. The applicant/R2 has not even filed any supporting documents along with the application to even show that the proposed witness was indeed the conductor/second driver of the offending vehicle which has been in the registered ownership of the applicant/R2 only. In such facts and circumstances of the case as aforesaid, the Tribunal has no hesitation in hereby arriving at the finding that the application at hand appears to have been filed in a malafide manner merely to delay the proceedings and the same is completely devoid of any merits or substance. Furthermore, the Tribunal is of the view that a strict view needs to be taken of such practice which leads to inordinate delay in award of compensation amount to the dependents of a victim in a fatal road accident. Hence, the application at hand is hereby dismissed along with an exemplary cost of Rs. 50,000/- to be paid by the applicant/R2 to the petitioners as compensation for delay caused. Be put up for further proceedings on 15.07.2026 (HARUN PRATAP) PO-MACT-02/SHD/KKD 20.05.2026 -- 2 of 2 --
