Full Order Text
Final Order 12 · 17 Sept 2026 · CNR DLSH010037412024
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF VIJAY KUMAR JHA PRESIDING OFFICER: MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL-01, SHAHDARA KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI ____________________________________________________________ In the matter of : MACT no. 394/2021 CNR no.DLSH01-003741-2024 Rani Devi & Ors. v. Umesh & Ors. (1) Rani Devi (wife of the deceased) W/o late Sh. Giri Raj Singh (2) Suraj Singh (son of the deceased) S/o late Sh. Giri Raj Singh (3) Shivam Kumar (son of the deceased) S/o late Sh. Giri Raj Singh (4) Pawan Kumar (son of the deceased) S/o late Sh. Giri Raj Singh (5) Rakhi (daughter of the deceased) D/o late Sh. Giri Raj Singh All R/o Village Chandawli, PS Nakhasa, Sambhal, U.P. ..…….Petitioners Versus (1) Umesh Singh (Driver) S/o Sh. Ram Prakash R/o Village Aagapur Kalan, Tehsil Hasanpur, Amroha, U.P. (2) M/s Satguru Construction (Regd. Owner) Panchwati Colony, Dadri, Gautam Budh Nagar, U.P. (3) United India Insurance Co. Ltd. (Insurer) 10, Raj Block, Opposite Gyanand Cinema Building, G.T. Road, Shahdara, Delhi-110032. …....Respondents ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 394/21; Rani Devi & Ors. v. Umesh & Ors. 1 of 16 Pages -- 1 of 16 -- Date of institution : 05.07.2024 Final arguments concluded on : 17.09.2026 Date of Judgment : 17.09.2026 J U D G M E N T 1. This claim petition under Section 166 of the ‘Motor Vehicles Act, 1988’ has been filed by the petitioners i.e. the wife and four children of late Shri Giri Raj Singh (hereinafter, ‘the deceased’) claiming compensation of Rs.40 lakhs along with interest @ 18% p.a., from the respondents on account of death of the deceased as a result of a road traffic accident which occurred on 25.04.2024 at about 12:30- 01:00 P.M. at the Nangla Factory Crossing, within the jurisdiction of P.S. Asmoli, District Sambhal, U.P. 2. Brief facts of the case as per the claim petition and the supporting affidavit of petitioner no.1 are that on 25.04.2024 at about 12:30 noon, the deceased along with his wife Rani Devi wife (pillion rider), on motorcycle bearing no.UP16AS-1644 was proceeding from village Chandrawli to village Bilari via Rustampur, Nyavli and Sirsi, Sambhal, U.P. At about 01:00 p.m., when they reached at Nangla Factory Crossing, suddenly a Tata Dumper truck bearing registration number UP16ET-8507 (hereinafter, ‘offending vehicle’) being driven rashly and negligently by the respondent no.1 Umesh Singh in violation of traffic rules, struck the motorcycle. As a result of the accident, the deceased sustained fatal injuries and died on the spot and his wife/ petitioner no.1 Rani Devi, the pillion rider, sustained injuries. In connection with the accident, a criminal case bearing FIR ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 394/21; Rani Devi & Ors. v. Umesh & Ors. 2 of 16 Pages -- 2 of 16 -- no. 0141/2024 under Sections 279/338/304‑A IPC was registered at P.S. Asmoli. During investigation, it was found out that at the time of the accident, the offending vehicle was being driven by the respondent no.1, owned by the respondent no.2 and was insured with respondent no.3 United India Insurance Co. Ltd. vide insurance policy number 2507013123P113761152, valid from 22.01.2024 to 21.01.2025. 3. The deceased, aged about 43 years, is stated to have been working as a Thekedar (petty contractor) as well as a monthly labourer at a brick‑kiln, earning approximately Rs.30,000/‑ per month, self‑employed, and is survived by his wife and four children, who claim to have been wholly dependent on his income. 4. On notice of the claim petition, all the respondents appeared and they were directed to file their replies/ written-statements, which they filed subsequently. 5. Respondent no.1 (driver) and respondent no.2 (registered owner) filed a joint written statement denying the allegations of the claim petition. They claimed that no accident was caused by the respondent no.1 and that the offending vehicle was falsely implicated. It was alternatively submitted that the accident occurred due to a head-on collision between the motorcycle and the offending vehicle, and that the deceased came under the tyres of the offending vehicle. They claimed that the driver held a valid driving license and that the vehicle was insured with respondent no.3. ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 394/21; Rani Devi & Ors. v. Umesh & Ors. 3 of 16 Pages -- 3 of 16 -- 6. Respondent no.3/ insurance company filed its written statement, taking preliminary objections regarding the maintainability of the petition, lack of territorial jurisdiction, and non-compliance with Section 158(6) of the Act. It was submitted that the accident occurred due to the negligence of the deceased. The insurer also claimed that it would not be liable to indemnify the insured/ owner if there was a breach of policy conditions, such as the driver not holding a valid license or the vehicle not having a valid permit or fitness certificate. It was further submitted that the compensation claimed was excessive and that the interest, if any, should be limited to the current bank rate. On completion of the pleadings of the parties, following issues were framed vide order dated 24.07.2025, as under: (i) Whether Sh. Giri Raj Singh died in a motor vehicular accident occurred on 25.04.2024 (sic. 24.04.2024) at 01.00 p.m. at Nangal Factory Crossing, Distt. Sambhal, U.P. within jurisdiction of PS Nakhasa, due to rash and negligent driving of offending vehicle i.e. motorcycle bearing registration no. UP-16AS-1644 driven by respondent no.1 Sh. Umesh Singh (driver)? (OPP) (ii) Whether petitioners are entitled for compensation, if so, to what extent and from whom? OPP. (iii) Relief. No other issue arose or pressed for and matter was adjourned for petitioner’s evidence. 7. In order to establish their case, on behalf of the petitioners only one witness i.e. PW1 Rani Devi, wife of the deceased has been ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 394/21; Rani Devi & Ors. v. Umesh & Ors. 4 of 16 Pages -- 4 of 16 -- examined. PW1 deposed by way of her affidavit Ex.PW1/A regarding the accident of the deceased, employment and income of the deceased and regarding the losses suffered as a result of the death of the deceased due to road accident. PW1 relied upon the following documents: (i) Certified copy of the FIR, chargesheet, site plan, etc. as PW1/1 (colly). (ii) Aadhaar Card of the petitioners as Ex.PW1/2. (iii) Aadhaar Card and PAN Card of the deceased as Ex.PW1//3. 8. In her cross‑examination conducted on behalf of the respondents, PW1 deposed, inter-alia, that she was the pillion rider and had personally witnessed the accident; that her husband was driving the motorcycle properly and not at high speed; that the offending vehicle/ dumper came from the left‑hand side at the crossing and struck the motorcycle from its front‑left side; that the dumper had 5‑6 persons riding in its cabin who got down after the accident; that the motorcycle was borrowed from her brother‑in‑law, Hari Raj, as they had to perform a long journey that day; that the deceased earned Rs.30,000/‑ per month in cash as a labourer‑cum‑contractor at a brick‑kiln, that no bank record of the same exists, and that her three younger children were students with no independent income, while the eldest son was employed outside the State but had stopped remitting money. Nothing material was elicited in cross‑examination to discredit her account of how the accident occurred and her testimony on the manner of the accident remained unshaken. ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 394/21; Rani Devi & Ors. v. Umesh & Ors. 5 of 16 Pages -- 5 of 16 -- 9. No evidence was led on behalf of respondents no.1, 2 and 3 to substantiate the bald plea of contributory negligence or the alternative, self‑contradictory version set out in the written statements (referring, inexplicably, to a collision between “two motorcycles”). 10. This Tribunal heard the final arguments advanced by learned counsels for the parties and also perused the evidence and other materials placed on record. My findings on the issues are as under:- ISSUE NO.1 Whether petitioners are entitled for compensation, if so, to what extent and from whom? OPP. 11. It is settled proposition of law that, in an action founded on the principle of fault liability, the proof of rash and negligent driving of the offending vehicle is sine-qua-non. However, the standard of proof is not as strict as applied in criminal cases and evidence is to be tested on the touchstone of the preponderance of probabilities. A holistic view is to be taken while dealing with the Claim Petition based upon negligence. Strict rules of evidence are not applicable in an inquiry conducted by the Claims Tribunal. However, that does not mean that a Tribunal that has been approached with a claim for compensation under the Motor Vehicle Act should ignore all basic principles of law in determining the claim for compensation. The relevant provisions of the Act are not intended to jettison all principles of law relating to a claim for compensation, which is still based on a tortious liability. Reference may be made to the judgments titled as New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Sakshi Bhutani ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 394/21; Rani Devi & Ors. v. Umesh & Ors. 6 of 16 Pages -- 6 of 16 -- & Others., MAC APP. No. 550/2011 decided on 02.07.2012; Bimla Devi & Others v. Himachal Road Transport Corporation & Others (2009) 13 SC 530; Parmeshwari v. Amirchand & Others 2011 (1) SCR 1096; Mangla Ram v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. & Others 2018, Law Suit (SC) 303; & Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Meena Variyal & Ors., (2007) 5 SCC 428. 12. In the case in hand, the occurrence of the accident, the death of Giri Raj Singh, and the involvement of offending vehicle/ dumper bearing registration number UP‑16‑ET‑8507 stand duly established by the FIR, the charge-sheet filed under Sections 279/338/304‑A IPC (Ex.PW1/1 colly), and the unimpeached testimony of PW1, an eyewitness as well as the pillion rider who survived the accident. Her account that the dumper approached from the left at the crossing and struck the motorcycle on its front‑left side while the deceased was riding at a normal speed remained undisturbed in cross‑examination. 13. Against this, respondent no.1 to 3 have led no evidence whatsoever. The defence set up in the written-statements is self‑contradictory on its face (postulating a collision between “two motorcycles”, a version that does not even correspond to the admitted facts of a single two‑wheeler being involved) and amounts to no more than a bare denial. 14. It is settled law that a written statement unsupported by evidence cannot displace the sworn and unshaken testimony of an eye-witness, more so in third‑party motor accident claims where the standard of proof is one of preponderance of probability and not the proof ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 394/21; Rani Devi & Ors. v. Umesh & Ors. 7 of 16 Pages -- 7 of 16 -- beyond reasonable doubt. 15. The non‑filing of the MLC/ PMR of the deceased, while ordinarily a relevant document, is not fatal on the facts of this case since the fact and immediate cause of death (fatal injuries in the collision, died on the spot) is not seriously disputed by the respondents; nor are proceedings before the Tribunal governed by the strict procedural rigour of Order VII Rule 14 CPC in view of Section 169 of the Act. The plea of contributory negligence, being wholly unsubstantiated, is rejected. 16. Thus, in the light of the above discussion and the evidence brought on record, it is held that the petitioners have been able to prove on the basis of preponderance of probabilities that the accident had occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the offending vehicle by respondent no.1 and that resulted into fatal injuries to the deceased Giri Raj Singh. Issue no.1 is, accordingly, decided in favour of petitioners. ISSUE NO.2 Whether petitioners are entitled for compensation, if so, to what extent and from whom? OPP 17. On the basis of findings upon issue no.1 above, it is established on record that the incident in question had occurred due to rash and negligent driving of offending vehicle by the respondent no.1, resulting in the death of the deceased. Hence, it is held that petitioners are entitled to get the compensation in this case. ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 394/21; Rani Devi & Ors. v. Umesh & Ors. 8 of 16 Pages -- 8 of 16 -- QUANTUM OF COMPENSATION 18. Section Section 168 of the Act enjoins the Claims Tribunal to hold an inquiry into the claim to make an award determining the amount of compensation, which appears to be just and reasonable. It has to be borne in mind that the compensation is not expected to be a windfall or a bonanza nor it should be a pittance. 19. In Sarla Verma and Others v. Delhi Transport Corporation & Anr. (2009) 6 Supreme Court Cases 121, the relevant guidelines were laid down for death cases, which have been reiterated by the Constitution Bench of Hon’ble Supreme Court in a case titled as National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. (AIR 2017 SC 5157 laying down the general principles for computation of compensation in death cases. Therefore, in view of the aforesaid judgments, it is essential to take into consideration the following parameters: PECUNIARY DAMAGE Age of the deceased 20. The Aadhaar Card of the deceased Giriraj reveals his date of birth as 01.01.1979, which would mean that on the date of accident on 25.04.2024, he was 45 years of age. Assessment of Income of the deceased 21. PW1 Rani Devi, wife of the deceased in her cross-examination has stated that her deceased husband was working in a brick klin as monthly labourer as well as a contractor and he was earning Rs.30,000/- per month, however, she stated that she does not know that name of the employer who used to pay the salary. PW1 stated ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 394/21; Rani Devi & Ors. v. Umesh & Ors. 9 of 16 Pages -- 9 of 16 -- that her deceased husband used to get salary in cash. Further, PW1 stated that her husband was educated till 7-8 class. She admitted that no educational document of her deceased husband is available with her. As per Aadhaar Card of the deceased as well as that of the petitioners, they all are resident of Uttar Pradesh. In these circumstances, admittedly, when no documentary evidence with respect to employment, income and education of the deceased has been proved on record, income of the deceased has to be assessed at par with minimum wages payable to the unskilled workers of Uttar Pradesh on the date of accident (25.04.2024), which were Rs.10,648/- per month. Hence, income of the deceased for the purpose of computing loss of dependency is determined as Rs.10,648/- per month. Application of Multiplier 22. The deceased was 45 years of age at the time of the accident. Accordingly, a multiplier of 14, applicable to the age group of 41-45 years, has to be applied in this case to determine the compensation (refer: Sarla Verma v. DTC (2009) 6 SCC 121). Future Prospects 23. The deceased was 45 years of age. Considering him self-employed who belonged to age group between 40 to 50 years, an addition of 25% to his income has to be taken into consideration (refer: National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. (AIR 2017 SC 5157). Deduction towards Personal Living Expenses 24. There are five claimants in this case, who are wife and four children of the deceased. In her cross-examination, PW1 (wife of the ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 394/21; Rani Devi & Ors. v. Umesh & Ors. 10 of 16 Pages -- 10 of 16 -- deceased) has fairly admitted that her eldest son Suraj Singh was working in Katra, Jammu & Kashmir since one year earlier to the death of her husband and he used to send money earlier, now he is not sending money and he is unmarried. PW1 further stated that her other son Shivam Kumar is studying and her other children namely Pawan Kumar and Rakhi are also pursuing their studies. PW1 stated that her children who are studying are not earning anything. Admittedly, when the eldest son of the deceased had already started earning one year prior to the death of the deceased, he cannot be considered to be dependent upon the deceased. Considering rest of the petitioners i.e. wife and three children of the deceased to be dependent upon the deceased, 1/4th of the income of the deceased is to be deducted towards his personal living expenses. Loss of Dependency 25. In view of the settled guidelines as laid down in the various judgments herein above, by adding the future prospects @ 25% to the income of the deceased (Rs.10,648/- per month), applying the multiplier of 14, after making deduction of 1/4th of the income of the deceased, the loss of dependency is computed as Rs.16,77,060/- (10,648x125/100x3/4x14x12). NON-PECUNIARY DAMAGES 26. In the light of the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court, dated 31.10.2017, in case of Pranay Sethi & Others (Supra), a compensation of Rs.40,000/-, 15,000/- and Rs.15,000/- respectively has been fixed on account of loss of consortium, loss of estate and ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 394/21; Rani Devi & Ors. v. Umesh & Ors. 11 of 16 Pages -- 11 of 16 -- funeral expenses and further, it is required to be enhanced @ 10% in every three years. The accident of the deceased in this case occurred on 25.04.2024. Therefore, a compensation of Rs.48,000/-, Rs.18,000/- and Rs.18,000/- respectively on account of loss of consortium, loss of estate and funeral expenses is required to be granted. Further, in view of the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case titled as United India Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Satinder Kaur @ Satwinder Kaur & Ors., Civil Appeal no. 2705 of 2020, decided on 30.06.2020, claimants are required to be granted spousal consortium, parental consortium and filial consortium. Accordingly, petitioner no.1 being wife of the deceased shall be entitled to spousal consortium, petitioner no.2 to 5 being children of the deceased shall be entitled to parental consortium. Thus, the following amounts are awarded under the conventional heads: S. No. Conventional Head Amount 1. Spousal Consortium Parental Consortium Rs.1,92,000/- (Rs.48,000x4) 2. Loss of Estate Rs.18,000/- 3. Loss of Funeral Expenses Rs.18,000/- Total = Rs.2,28,000/- Accordingly, the total compensation comes to Rs.19,05,060/- (16,77,060+2,28,000). INTEREST 27. The petitioners shall also be entitled for interest @ 7% per annum on the award amount from the date of filing of the claim petition (05.07.2024) till realization. ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 394/21; Rani Devi & Ors. v. Umesh & Ors. 12 of 16 Pages -- 12 of 16 -- LIABILITY 28. Now, the question arises as to which of the respondents is liable to pay the compensation amount. An insurance company has contractual and statutory liability to indemnify the insured if any term or condition of insurance policy is not breached/ violated by insured. In this case, insurance company has not adduced any evidence to prove violation of any of the terms/ conditions of the insurance policy. Hence, insurance company/ respondent no.3 is held liable to pay the compensation to the petitioners. RELIEF 29. In the light of the decision on substantive issues framed, the present claim petition is allowed and the following award is being passed: AWARD 30. This Tribunal awards a compensation of Rs.19,05,060/- (Rs. Nineteen Lakhs Five Thousand Sixty Only) to the petitioners along with interest @ 7% per annum from the date of filing of claim petition (05.07.2024) till realization to be paid by the respondent no.3/ United India Insurance Company Limited, who shall deposit the award amount in A/c no.20780110171912 (IFSC Code UCBA0002078), UCO Bank, Karkardooma, Delhi, of PO MACT, Shahdara, through RTGS/ NEFT, within 30 days from today. Entitlement, Apportionment and Disbursement 31. The claimants/ petitioners in the present claim case are the wife and four children of the deceased. Hence, all the petitioners shall be entitled to the compensation. Apportionment and disbursement of the ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 394/21; Rani Devi & Ors. v. Umesh & Ors. 13 of 16 Pages -- 13 of 16 -- award amount shall be done after deposit of the award amount by the insurance company. Directions for opening bank account of claimants 32. The petitioners are directed to get opened their saving bank account near the place of their residence. The Bank of petitioner(s) is directed to comply with the following conditions: (i) No Cheque Book and ATM/Debit Card be issued to the claimants/ petitioners without permission of the Court. However, in case the ATM/Debit Card and/or Cheque Book have already been issued bank shall cancel the same before the disbursement of the amount. (ii) The Bank shall not permit any joint name(s) to be added in the savings bank account or fixed deposit accounts of the claimant(s). However, money may be released by means of withdrawal slip. (iii) The Bank Manager of petitioners’ bank is/ are also directed to make endorsement regarding compliance of aforesaid directions on the passbook(s). 33. As per ‘The Central Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989 (Annexure-XIII), the relevant Form to be incorporated in the award is as under: FORM - XV SUMMARY OF COMPUTATION OF AWARD AMOUNT IN DEATH CASES TO BE INCORPORATED IN THE AWARD 1. Date of accident : 25.04.2024 2. Name of the deceased : Rani Devi 3. Age of the deceased : 45 years 4. Occupation of the deceased : Self-employed 5. Income of the deceased : Rs.10,648/- per month 6. Name, age and relationship of legal representatives of deceased: S. No. Name Age Relation with the deceased i Rani Devi 44 years Wife ii Suraj Singh 27 years Son ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 394/21; Rani Devi & Ors. v. Umesh & Ors. 14 of 16 Pages -- 14 of 16 -- iii Shivam Kumar 25 years Son iv Pawan Kumar 21 years & 11 months Son v Rakhi 21 years Daughter Computation of Compensation S. No. Heads Awarded by the Claims Tribunal 7. Annual Income of the deceased (A) Rs.1,27,776/- (10,648x12) 8. Add-Future Prospects (B) @ 25% Rs.31,944/- 9. Less- Personal expenses of deceased (C) @ 1/4 Rs.39,930/- 10. Annual loss of dependency [(A+B)-C = D] Rs.1,19,790/- 11. Multiplier (E) 14 12. Total loss of dependency (Dx12xE = F) Rs.16,77,060/- 13. Medical Expenses (G) Nil 14. Compensation for loss of consortium (H) (48,000x4) Rs.1,92,000/- 15. Compensation for love & affection (I) -- 16. Compensation for loss of estate (J) Rs.18,000/- 17. Compensation for funeral expenses (K) Rs.18,000/- 18. TOTAL COMPENSATION (F+G+H+I+J+K= L) Rs.19,05,060/- 19. RATE OF INTEREST AWARDED 7% 20. Interest amount up to the date of award (M) (for 02 years, 02 months & 12 days) Rs.2,93,379/- 21. Total amount including interest (L+M) Rs.21,98,439/- 22. Award amount released Would be decided after deposit of award amount 23. Award amount kept in FDRs Would be decided after deposit of award amount 24. Mode of disbursement of the award amount to the claimants (s). Bank transfer 25. Next Date for compliance of the award. 28.10.2026 ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 394/21; Rani Devi & Ors. v. Umesh & Ors. 15 of 16 Pages -- 15 of 16 -- 34. With these observations, the claim petition is disposed of. File be consigned to Record Room. Announced in the open (VIJAY KUMAR JHA) Court on 17.09.2026 Presiding Officer-MACT-01 (Shahdara) Karkardooma, Delhi ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 394/21; Rani Devi & Ors. v. Umesh & Ors. 16 of 16 Pages -- 16 of 16 --
