Full Order Text
Order 5 · 21 Nov 2024 · CNR DLSH010036972024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS No. 356/24 Tejinder & Anr. vs. Mamta 21.11.2024 Present : Sh. M.A. Khan Ld. Counsel for plaintiffs with plaintiff no. 2. Sh. Narveen Dabbas Ld. Counsel for D1 and D2. None for D-3, D5, D7 and D8. D-4 in person. He is also appearing for D-3 being her husband. D-6 through VC. Sh. Pawan Gupta Advocate stated to be appearing for D6 and D9 (He undertakes to file v/nama during the course of the day. Be filed through proper channel). Perusal of record shows that, D-4 has refused to received summons for himself as well as for D-3 (being her husband) on 23.10.2024. However, D-4 has appeared in person and he is also appearing for D-3, therefore, the proceeding qua service of D-3 and D-4 is hereby dispensed with. D3 and D4 are directed to file WS within stipulated period with advance copy to the opposite party. As per report, D-5 has been served on 24.10.2024 through affixation with the report ‘no one by the name of D-5 resides at the given address’. Plaintiff directed to provide fresh and correct address of D-5 within 10 working days from today, subsequent to which notice be issued to D-5 on PF/RC, returnable for NDOH. Process issued to D-6 received back unserved with the report ‘no such person at given address’. However, D-6 has appeared through VC, therefore, the proceeding qua service of D-6 is hereby dispensed with. -- 1 of 3 -- -2- Process issued to D-9 received back unserved with the report ‘left after selling out the house’. However, Advocate for D-9 has appeared, therefore, the proceeding qua service of D-9 is hereby dispensed with. D-6 and D-9 are directed to file WS within stipulated period with advance copy to the opposite party. Process issued to D-7 and D-8 received back unserved with the report ‘no one by the name of D-7 resides at the given address’ and ‘left without address’, respectively. Plaintiff is directed to provide fresh and correct address of D-7 and D-8 within 10 working days from today, subsequent to which summons be issued to D-7 and D-8 on PF/RC, returnable for NDOH. At this stage, Ld. Counsel for D1 and D2 submits that he has already filed an application u/o 8 r 1 CPC a/w WS of D1 and D2 and reply to the application u/o 39 R 1 and 2 CPC a/w LOD and v/nama. On perusal of record, same are find placed. Copy already supplied. At this stage, Ld. Counsel for D1 and D2 has pressed his application u/o 8 r 1 CPC, vide which D1 and D2 is seeking condonation of delay in filing their WS. At this stage, Ld. Counsel for plaintiff submits that he has no objection to the aforesaid application filed by D1 and D2 and the same may be allowed, subject to imposition of heavy cost. Submissions heard. Record perused. Keeping in view the aforesaid facts and -- 2 of 3 -- -3- circumstances, reasons mentioned in the aforesaid application as well as on the basis of submissions made by the Ld. Counsel for D1 and D2, the no objection given by the Ld. Counsel for plaintiff, considering that it is well settled that the cases should be decided on merits, rather than on technicalities and also considering the fact that the present suit is at initial stage and issues are yet to be framed, the application u/o 8 R 1 CPC of D1 and D2 is disposed off as allowed, subject to imposition of cost of Rs. 5000/- (Rs. 2500/- each) to be paid by D1 and D2 to the plaintiff. Ld. Counsel for D1 and D2 undertakes to pay the aforesaid cost on NDOH to the plaintiff. Heard. The delay in filing the WS of D1 and D2 shall be condoned and their WS shall be taken on record, subject to payment of aforesaid cost. Matter be listed for payment of cost, appearance of D5, D7 and D8 on 20.03.2025. NDOH is given as per convenience of the Ld. Counsels for the parties. (Gaurav) District Judge-01/ SHD KKD/Delhi/21.11.2024(ch) -- 3 of 3 --
