Full Order Text
Final Order 5 · 20 Sept 2024 · CNR DLSH010035572024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: T. P. Civil No. 33/24 Seema Sharma Vs. Akshey Patodia & Ors. 20.09.2024 Present : None. 1. This is a transfer application moved under Section 24 CPC r/w Section 151 CPC by the applicant for transfer of case bearing CS No. 160/23 titled as Seema Sharma Vs. Akshey Patodia & Anr. pending adjudication in the court of Sh. Gaurav Dahiya, Ld. CJ-03 to some other court. 2. It is stated in the application that the applicant/plaintiff had filed the said suit for permanent and mandatory injunction because of quarreling, abusing, creating nuisance or threatening the applicant/plaintiff by the defendant by way of parking their vehicles to create hurdles for the applicant and her family members. Due to the conduct of the defendants, the plaintiff and her family members were not able to park their vehicle in the parking area. It is asserted that the plaintiff was the sole and absolute owner of the property bearing No. 1/1104, Plot No. 26, out of Khasra No. 242/281 situated at Village Chandrawali, in the abadi of Mansarover Park, GT Road, Shahdara, Delhi, and the entire property was built-up by the husband and mother-in-law of the plaintiff on which the husband and mother-in-law of the plaintiff had kept reserve parking for Car and area next to the lift for two wheelers which is covered with iron channel for the safety of two wheelers and thereafter sold the flats to the defendants. 3. It is submitted that on 15.09.2023, the defendant No. -- 1 of 13 -- -2- 2 had created a scene by way of quarreling and abusing to the plaintiff and her family members and asked plaintiff to remove the channel from the reserve parking of two wheelers otherwise they will break the locks and will remove the channel. It is further stated that the same thing was repeated by the defendants again and again and the plaintiff was compelled to file the suit to restrain the defendants from creating nuisance or breaking the locks or removing the channel. Thereafter, Ld. Trial Court dismissed the application under Order 39 Rule 1 & 2 r/w Section 151 CPC of the plaintiff and the Ld. Judge had passed unnecessary and unimaginary comments upon the plaintiff while rejecting the application under Order 39 Rule 1 & 2 CPC. It is further averred that on 15.05.2024, Ld. Judge again passed comments upon the plaintiff stating that 'ya to aap apna iron channel parking se khud hi hata lo nahi to mai ise hatwane ka order pass karunga' and also orally directed to the defendants that 'aap MCD ko party banao aur mai is case ko kharij karunga aur mai MCD ko direction doonga ki is property ki parking me iron channel remove karo'. It is further stated that the plaintiff/applicant has an apprehension that Ld. Judge is not impartial and is pre-determined and unfair with the plaintiff and will definitely support the defendants and will pass the directions to remove the channel from the parking which was constructed by the husband and mother-in-law of plaintiff at the time of construction of the building being the lawful owner of the entire property. 4. It is further averred that the plaintiff did not get the -- 2 of 13 -- -3- fair justice from the court of Shri Gaurav Dahiya, Ld. Civil Judge, Shahdara District, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi and compelled to move the present application for transfer of the suit to any other court and in case the suit is not transferred from the court of Shri Gaurav Dahiya, Ld. Civil Judge, Shahdara District, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi, plaintiff shall suffer irreparable loss and injury. 5. After filing of the present application, notice of the same was issued to the non-applicants and since, the application disclosed the allegations of biasness against the presiding offficer, the comments of the presiding officer were also called. 6. Ld. Counsel for non-applicant no.1 has not filed any reply and has advanced arguments straight away. 7. In the reply filed by non-applicant no.2, it is stated that the present application is not maintainable. No relief in the nature as claimed can be granted in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant and the application is frivolous and farfetched. It is vexatious and without any merits and is an abuse of the process of law. It is further stated that the plaintiff has illegally encroached the space on the stilt parking which is in common use of dwellers of the entire building and now by way of the present application the plaintiff is trying to justify his illegal act of encroachment. It is further stated that the plaintiff has not approached this Hon'ble Court with clean hands and is guilty of suppression and concealing of material facts and has not given the true and correct disclosure of the events. It is further -- 3 of 13 -- -4- averred that the Plaintiff has filed the present application with an intention to harass the defendant and his family members, create impediments in the enjoyment of property which lawfully belongs to the Defendants. Plaintiff, her husband and her mother in law have cheated the defendant by encroaching the space on stilt common parking at the ground floor of the premises. It is stated that the space of the parking of the building is of common use. The defendant no. 2 has objected that the plaintiff do not have any reserved area to park her vehicle in the parking space of the buildings. It is stated that Plaintiff is claiming to be the owner of the reserved parking portion however, the plaintiff is a co- sharer of the 1/4th undivided portion of the entire parking area which is of common use. Further, the documents filed with the application is nothing but are sham documents which were created in collusion with the erstwhile owner who is the husband of the plaintiff who has no right, title or interest to execute the rectification deed dated 14.06.2023 with regard to the parking area. It is also submitted that the plaintiff has created nuisance and hurdle by affixing iron channel gate and is trying to grab the common parking area for her exclusive use and it is the plaintiff who kept the household scrap in the common parking area with the sole motive to create hurdle and nuisance for the parking of the defendant's vehicles and by misusing the process of law, the plaintiff has filed the false, bogus and frivolous application. It is further stated that as per the sanctioned site plan by MCD and sale deed of the defendant no. 2, no demarcated space has been shown or mentioned for the exclusive parking space for the -- 4 of 13 -- -5- vehicles of the plaintiff. In fact, it is the encroachment of the parking of the common use by the plaintiff and now by way of this civil suit the plaintiff is just trying to justify and legalize her illegal advancement in the parking of the common use of the property. 8. On merits, the non-applicant has denied the averments of the applicant. It is stated that it is vehemently denied that on 15.05.2024 the Ld. Judge again was pleased to pass comment upon the plaintiff and the counsel of the plaintiff astonished and surprised to see the comments of the Ld. Judge by stating that "ya to aap apna iron channel parking se khud hi hata lo nahin to mai ise hatwane ka order pass karunga" it is further specifically denied that or also orally directed to the defendants that "aap MCD ko party banao aur mal is caso ko kharij karunga aur mai MCD ko direction doonga ki is property ki parking me iron channel remove karo." It is matter of record that the Ld. Judge also was please to keep the case for argument on maintainability for the case for 29.07.2024. It is respectfully submitted that the plaintiff is not entitled for any relief as prayed for. It is vehemently denied that the Ld. Judge is not partial and entirely against the plaintiff or due to the afore said reason the plaintiff has apprehension that the Ld. Civil Judge is pre- determined and unfair with the plaintiff and will will definitely support the defendants and will pass the direction to remove the channel from the parking which was constructed by the husband and other in law plaintiff at the time of the construction of the building as they were lawful owner of the entire property. It is -- 5 of 13 -- -6- denied that defendants have kept flower pot or other household articles in the shaft used for ventilation. It is denied that in case the present suit is not transfer from the court of Shri Gaurav Dahiya Ld. Civil Judge, Shahdara District, Karkardooma District Court, Delhi to any other court in that event the plaintiff shall suffer irreparable loss and injury because the Ld. Civil Judge is predetermined to get remove the iron channel of plaintiff from the parking which was constructed for the safety of two wheeler parking only. It is submitted that the plaintiff is not entitle for any relief as prayed for. Hence, it is prayed that the present application be dismissed with heavy cost. 9. I have heard the submissions and have perused the record as well as the comments of Ld. Presiding Officer. 10. Before deciding the transfer application, it is relevant to note down the observations and the law on the point of ‘bias’, as discussed by Hon’ble Ms. Justice Swarna Kanta Sharma in the judgment titled as Directorate of Enforcement Vs. Ajay S. Mittal, Crl. M.C. 4014/2024 & Crl. M.A. 15285/2024, wherein the Hon’ble High Court has elaborated and elucidated the concept of ‘bias’ by referring to its meaning in various dictionaries and on the basis of various pronouncements of Hon’ble Apex Court. 11. In the case of Directorate of Enforcement Vs. Ajay S. Mittal (Supra), the Court has referred to the judgment of Kumaon Mandal Vikas Nigam Ltd. v. Girja Shankar Pant (2001) 1 SCC 182, wherein the Hon‘ble Supreme Court has defined and explained the idea of ‘Bias’ in the following words: -- 6 of 13 -- -7- “10. The word “bias” in popular English parlance stands included within the attributes and broader purview of the word “malice”, which in common acceptation means and implies “spite” or “ill-will” (Stroud's Judicial Dictionary, 5th Edn., Vol. 3) and it is now well settled that mere general statements will not be sufficient for the purposes of indication of ill-will. There must be cogent evidence available on record to come to the conclusion as to whether in fact there was existing a bias which resulted in the miscarriage of justice. *** 27. The concept of “bias” however has had a steady refinement with the changing structure of the society: modernisation of the society, with the passage of time, has its due impact on the concept of bias as well. Three decades ago this Court in S. Parthasarathi v. State of A.P. [(1974) 3 SCC 459 : 1973 SCC (L&S) 580] proceeded on the footing of real likelihood of ‘bias’ and there was in fact a total unanimity on this score between the English and the Indian Courts. *** 29. Lord Thankerton however in Franklin v. Minister of Town and Country Planning [1948 AC 87 : (1947) 2 All ER 289 (HL)] had this to state: “… I could wish that the use of the word “bias” should be confined to its proper sphere. Its proper significance, in my opinion, is to denote a departure from the standard of even- handed justice which the law requires for those who occupy judicial office, or those who are commonly regarded as holding a quasi-judicial office, such as an arbitrator. The reason for this clearly is that, having to adjudicate as between two or more parties, he must come to his adjudication with an independent mind, without any inclination or bias towards one side or other in the dispute.” 12. The High Court has put forth the judicial precedent on the test of real apprehension of bias and likelihood of bias to know what constitutes a real apprehension of bias sufficient to transfer a case from one court to the other. In that context the court has referred to the judgment of Gurcharan Dass Chadha v. State of Rajasthan 1965 SCC OnLine SC 341, wherein a three judge bench of Hon’ble Apex Court had held that mere -- 7 of 13 -- -8- allegations of apprehension are insufficient and the Court must determine if the apprehension is objectively reasonable. The relevant observations are as under: “… The law with regard to transfer of cases is well-settled. A case is transferred if there is a reasonable apprehension on the part of a party to a case that justice will not be done. A petitioner is not required to demonstrate that justice will inevitably fail. He is entitled to a transfer if he shows circumstances from which it can be inferred that he entertains an apprehension and that it is reasonable in the circumstances alleged. It is one of the principles of the administration of justice that justice should not only be done but it should be seen to be done. However, a mere allegation that there is apprehension that justice will not be done in a given case does not suffice. The Court has further to see whether the apprehension is reasonable or not. To judge the reasonableness of the apprehension the state of the mind of the person who entertains the apprehension is no doubt relevant but that is not all. The apprehension must not only be entertained but must appear to the Court to be a reasonable apprehension”. 13. Further, the Hon‘ble Apex Court in case of S. Parthasarathi v. State of A.P. (1974) 3 SCC 459 has held as under on the real likelihood of bias “16. …If right-minded persons would think that there is real likelihood of bias on the part of an inquiring officer, he must not conduct the inquiry; nevertheless, there must be a real likelihood of bias. Surmise or conjecture would not be enough. There must exist circumstances from which reasonable men would think it probable or likely that the inquiring officer will be prejudiced against the delinquent…” 14. The Hon‘ble Apex Court in Kumaon Mandal Vikas Nigam Ltd. (supra) has laid down the test for determining apprehension or real danger of bias. These -- 8 of 13 -- -9- observations are reproduced as under: “35. The test, therefore, is as to whether a mere apprehension of bias or there being a real danger of bias and it is on this score that the surrounding circumstances must and ought to be collated and necessary conclusion drawn therefrom — in the event however the conclusion is otherwise inescapable that there is existing a real danger of bias, the administrative action cannot be sustained: If on the other hand, the allegations pertaining to bias is rather fanciful and otherwise to avoid a particular court, Tribunal or authority, question of declaring them to be unsustainable would not arise. The requirement is availability of positive and cogent evidence and it is in this context that we do record our concurrence with the view expressed by the Court of Appeal in Locabail case [2000 QB 451] . 15. The Hon’ble Delhi High Court in above stated judgment of Directorate of Enforcement Vs. Ajay S. Mittal (supra), has also referred to other judgment on ‘bias’, titled as State of Punjab v. Davinder Singh Bhullar (2011) 14 SCC 770 , wherein the Hon’ble Apex Court had discussed the concept of bias, and the test of real likelihood of bias. The relevant portion of the judgment is as under: “ 27. In Bhajan Lal v. Jindal Strips Ltd. [(1994) 6 SCC 19], this Court observed that there may be some consternation and apprehension in the mind of a party and undoubtedly, he has a right to have fair trial, as guaranteed by the Constitution. The apprehension of bias must be reasonable i.e. which a reasonable person can entertain. Even in that case, he has no right to ask for a change of Bench, for the reason that such an apprehension may be inadequate and he cannot be permitted to have the Bench of his choice. The Court held as under : (SCC pp. 26-27, para 23) ― “―23. Bias is the second limb of natural justice. Prima facie no one should be a judge in what is to be regarded as ‗sua causa‘, whether or not he is named as a party. The decision-maker should have no interest by way of gain or detriment in the outcome of a proceeding. Interest may -- 9 of 13 -- -10- take many forms. It may be direct, it may be indirect, it may arise from a personal relationship or from a relationship with the subject-matter, from a close relationship or from a tenuous one.‖ *** 31. The test of real likelihood of bias is whether a reasonable person, in possession of relevant information, would have thought that bias was likely and whether the adjudicator was likely to be disposed to decide the matter only in a particular way. Public policy requires that there should be no doubt about the purity of the adjudication process/administration of justice. The Court has to proceed observing the minimal requirements of natural justice i.e. the Judge has to act fairly and without bias and in good faith. A judgment which is the result of bias or want of impartiality, is a nullity and the trial coram non judice. Therefore, the consequential order, if any, is liable to be quashed.” 16. In Chandra Kumar Chopra v. Union of India ( 2012) 6 SCC 369, it was held that plea of bias cannot be a facet of one’s imagination. The noteworthy observations are as under: “25… mere suspicion or apprehension is not good enough to entertain a plea of bias. It cannot be a facet of one's imagination. It must be in accord with the prudence of a reasonable man. The circumstances brought on record would show that it can create an impression in the mind of a reasonable man that there is real likelihood of bias. It is not to be forgotten that in a democratic polity, justice in its conceptual eventuality and inherent quintessentiality forms the bedrock of good governance. In a democratic system that is governed by the rule of law, fairness of action, propriety, reasonability, institutional impeccability and non-biased justice delivery system constitute the pillars on which its survival remains in continuum.” 17. In the present transfer application, the applicant has raised the allegations of biasedness against the presiding officer that he had passed certain comments against the plaintiff stating -- 10 of 13 -- -11- that 'ya to aap apna iron channel parking se khud hi hata lo nahi to mai ise hatwane ka order pass karunga' and also orally directed to the defendants that 'aap MCD ko party banao aur mai is case ko kharij karunga aur mai MCD ko direction doonga ki is property ki parking me iron channel remove karo'. The applicant has made serious allegations against the Presiding Officer, though no proof has been placed on record with respect to the same. The other party has vehemently denied that the trial court has uttered any such word as alleged. 18. I have also seen the comments sent by the trial court. As is revealed from the trial court record, the application filed by the plaintiff under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 CPC was dismissed by the trial court on 19.03.2024 and on the next date the trial court had fixed the matter for arguments on maintainability of the suit, observing in the order dated 15.05.2024 that- “the court is of the view that the plaintiff has no ownership/title documents to show title in the portion of stilt parking and simplicitor suit for injunction is not maintainable in such circumstances and accordingly, one opportunity is given to the plaintiff to address arguments on the maintainability of the suit” and thereafter the court proceeded to fix the matter on 29.07.2024 for arguments on maintainability. 19. It is only after passing of the aforesaid order of 15.05.2024 by the trial court, that the applicant/ plaintiff in the case had moved the transfer application raising allegations of bias. -- 11 of 13 -- -12- 20. No party is entitled to get a case transferred from one court to the other, unless the court is biased or there are some reasonable grounds for the same. Mere allegations that there is apprehension that justice will not be done in a given case is not sufficient. The apprehension is to be reasonable and should be real which may be treated as sufficient to transfer a case from one court to the other. 21. As observed in the case of State of Punjab Vs. Devender Singh Bhullar (supra), “the test of real likelihood of bias is whether a reasonable person, in possession of relevant information, would have thought that the bias was likely and whether the adjudicator was likely to be disposed to decide the matter only in a particular way.” The case was fixed by the court for arguments on maintainability of the suit and it nowhere suggests that the court is biased otherwise the court would not have fixed the case for arguments on maintainability and now it is for the plaintiff/ applicant to satisfy the court that he has a valid and legal right to proceed with the case. 22. As per the allegations of the applicant in the transfer application, the trial court was pleased to pass unnecessary and unimaginary comments upon the plaintiff while rejecting the application of the plaintiff under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 CPC. It is pertinent to mention that the application of the plaintiff under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 was dismissed by the trial court on 19.03.2024 whereas the present transfer application was moved much later after more than 02 months on 29.05.2024. The -- 12 of 13 -- -13- applicant has not even mentioned what unnecessary and unimaginary comments were passed by the trial court on 19.03.2024. 23. Accordingly, in view of above discussion, the apprehensions of the applicant are not found reasonable nor can be treated as real likelihood of bias which a reasonable person can entertain. The apprehension is to be reasonable and should be real which may be treated as sufficient to transfer a case from one court to the other. 24. It is held in the case of Balraj Singh & Anr Vs. Ajit Singh, Raj 120 that the transfer of case from one court to another indirectly casts doubt on the competence and integrity of the judge from whom the case is sought to be transferred. Only good and sufficient grounds, clearly set out in the order, may justify the transfer. 25. Hence, finding no merits, the present transfer application is hereby dismissed. Miscellaneous file be consigned to record room. TCR be sent back alongwith copy of this order. (RENU BHATNAGAR) Principal District & Sessions Judge Shahdara, KKD Delhi/20.09.2024 -- 13 of 13 --
