Full Order Text
Order 13 · 20 Dec 2025 · CNR DLSH010035222023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF GAURAV: DISTRICT JUDGE-01 SHAHDARA DISTRICT, KARKARDOOMA COURTS: DELHI CS No.405/2023 In the matter of:- Ambi Kumar K ….Plaintiff Versus C.K. Prince & Ors. ….Defendants 20.12.2025 ORDER 1. Vide this order, I shall proceed to decide the application filed by the defendant no.2 under Order VI Rule 18 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as “CPC”) seeking withdrawal of leave to amend the plaint . 2. The plaintiff has filed reply to the aforesaid application, denying all the assertions made therein and has prayed for dismissal of the same. 3. Arguments were heard at length on behalf of Ld. Counsels for parties. 4. The background of the present matter is that the plaintiff has instituted a suit for damages against the defendants, alleging defamation, maligning and tarnishing of his public reputation. During the pendency of the suit, the plaintiff moved an application CS No.405/23 Page No.1 of 5 Ambi Kumar K vs. C.K. Prince & Ors. -- 1 of 5 -- under Order VI Rule 17 CPC for amendment of the plaint. The said application was allowed by this Court vide order dated 03.05.2025, granting leave to amend and directing the plaintiff to file amended plaint within the stipulated period. The record reveals that the amended plaint was filed only on 09.07.2025, which was beyond the time prescribed. 5. Ld. Counsel for the applicant/defendant no. 2 contended that the amended plaint ought to have been filed within fourteen days from the date of order i.e. by 17.05.2025, in terms of Order VI Rule 18 CPC. The filing of the amended plaint on 01.07.2025 (through e-filing) or 09.07.2025 (through physical mode), thus, suffers from a considerable delay. 6. He further contended that no application for enlargement of time was filed either before or after expiry of the stipulated period, and hence, the leave granted stood lapsed. On these grounds, the applicant prayed that the amended plaint be struck off and the leave to amend the plaint shall be withdrawn. 7. Per contra, Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff vehemently opposed the present application and contended that the delay was minor and arose solely due to circumstances beyond his control. 8. He further contended that the plaintiff is a senior citizen aged about 64 years, suffering from serious ailments including neurological issues, chronic pancreatitis, acute diabetes, high blood pressure and post-surgical complications. 9. He further contended that the plaintiff’s erstwhile counsel failed to hand over the complete file and relevant documents to CS No.405/23 Page No.2 of 5 Ambi Kumar K vs. C.K. Prince & Ors. -- 2 of 5 -- him, necessary for filing the amended plaint. Due to his health condition and inability to reach his erstwhile counsel, the filing of amended plaint was deferred. Thereafter, the summer vacation of courts intervened and the said erstwhile counsel was unavailable. Despite these difficulties, the plaintiff somehow managed to collect the documents and the amended plaint was filed on 09.07.2025. At the end, it is prayed that the delay was neither deliberate nor mala fide but due to the reason stated above. 10. I have heard the rival contentions made by Ld. Counsels for the parties and carefully perused the entire material available on record. 11. It is pertinent to mention herein that although the plaintiff has pleaded serious medical ailments as the reason for delay, however, no medical documents or supporting material have been filed on record to substantiate such plea. The Court is, therefore, constrained to observe that the explanation remains uncorroborated. 12. Ordinarily, the absence of supporting evidence would weigh against the party seeking indulgence. However, the Court must also bear in mind that procedural rules are intended to serve the cause of justice and not to thwart it. The explanation, though unsupported by documents, does not appear to be mala fide, and the delay is not of such magnitude as to defeat the substantive rights of the plaintiff. 13. Order VI Rule 18 CPC, stipulates that if a party fails to amend the pleadings within the time allowed, or within fourteen CS No.405/23 Page No.3 of 5 Ambi Kumar K vs. C.K. Prince & Ors. -- 3 of 5 -- days if no time is prescribed, the order permitting amendment shall cease to have effect unless the time is extended by the Court. The provision is procedural in nature. Further, Section 148 CPC empowers the Court to enlarge the period for doing any act prescribed or allowed by the Code, even after expiry of the period originally fixed. The Court also retains inherent powers under Section 151 CPC to make orders necessary for the ends of justice. 14. It is imperative to mention herein that admittedly; the amended plaint was filed beyond the stipulated period. Strictly speaking, under Order VI Rule 18 CPC, the leave to amend would lapse if the amendment is not carried out within time. However, it is well settled that procedural rules are handmaids of justice and should not be applied in a manner that defeats substantive rights. The Court must adopt a liberal approach where sufficient cause is shown for delay. 15. In the present case, though the plaintiff has not filed medical documents to substantiate his plea, the circumstances narrated, coupled with his age and the intervening court vacations, provide a plausible explanation. 16. The delay, though not negligible, cannot be said to be deliberate or mala fide. The amendments had already been allowed by this Court on 03.05.2025, and striking down the amended plaint, now, would amount to denial of substantive relief already granted. The defendants’ right to file written statement to the amended plaint remains intact, and no irreparable prejudice is caused to them. At the same time, the plaintiff ought to have moved a formal application for extension of time, which he failed CS No.405/23 Page No.4 of 5 Ambi Kumar K vs. C.K. Prince & Ors. -- 4 of 5 -- to do. This omission has caused inconvenience to the defendants, who were kept uncertain about the pleadings for a considerable period. Therefore, in order to balance equities and to compensate the defendants for the inconvenience and additional effort caused by the delay, costs are required to be imposed upon the plaintiff. 17. In view of the above discussion, in the interest of justice, the delay in filing the amended plaint is hereby condoned, subject to the cost of Rs. 12,000/- (i.e. Rs. 2,000/- to be paid to each defendant). The amended plaint filed on 09.07.2025 shall be taken on record subject to the payment of cost. The costs are imposed to compensate the defendants for the delay, inconvenience and procedural uncertainty caused by the plaintiff’s failure to file the amended plaint within the stipulated period and without moving a proper application for extension of time. 18. The plaintiff is directed to supply a complete copy of the amended plaint to defendants within seven days from today against proper receipt. Upon receipt, amended written statement be filed within stipulated period. 19. The present application is hereby dismissed and disposed of accordingly. (Typed to the dictation directly, corrected and pronounced in open court on 20.12.2025). (GAURAV) DISTRICT JUDGE-01 SHAHDARA DISTRICT KARKARDOOMA COURTS DELHI CS No.405/23 Page No.5 of 5 Ambi Kumar K vs. C.K. Prince & Ors. -- 5 of 5 --
