Full Order Text
Order 10 · 29 Nov 2025 · CNR DLSH010034422024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: Ex. No.87/24 Shyam Sunder vs. UOI 29.11.2025 Present : Ms. Dimple Dhamija Ld. counsel for the DH. Sh. R.L. Saini Ld. Counsel for JD no. 1 through VC. Sh. A.S. Rao DGM Legal for JD no.2 through VC. Today, matter is listed for order on objections. Be awaited. (Gaurav) District Judge-01/ SHD KKD/Delhi/29.11.2025 (04.25 pm) Present : None. ORDER 1. Vide this order, I shall dispose of the objections filed by Judgment Debtor No. 2/DMRC (hereinafter referred to as “JD no. 2”) directing the District Nazir to prepare fresh report and to refund the excess amount deposited by JD no. 2. 2. Reply to the objections were filed on behalf of DH, denying all the assertions made therein and has prayed for dismissal of the aforesaid applications. 3. By way of the present objection, Ld. Counsel for JD no. 2 has preferred objection to the calculations made by the Nazir, as the Nazir has calculated the statutory interest @ 15% on the solatium apart from Ex. No.87/24 Shyam Sunder vs. UOI Page 1 of 5 -- 1 of 5 -- the market value determined by the Ld. Reference Court. In support of his contention, he has placed reliance upon the judgment passed on 13.01.2021 by Hon’ble Apex Court in Civil Appeal No. 94/2021, titled as ‘Tamil Nadu Housing Board Vs. Abdul Salam Sarkar & Ors.’. The relevant paragraph is reproduced herein below for the reference: - “In the above view of the matter, we confirm the direction of the High Court to the effect that the claimants- Respondents would be entitled to the payment of interest on solatium. However, insofar as the exact mathematical computation is concerned, it would be appropriate to leave it to the reference court to verify the computations and to pass appropriate orders. Since during the pendency of these proceedings, a deposit has been made by the Appellant in terms of the interim orders, the amount which has been deposited will be permitted to be withdrawn by the Respondents and shall be given due credit for in arriving at the final amount which is due and payable. We also clarify that in terms of the judgment of the Constitution Bench in Gurpreet Singh (supra), interest on solatium will be payable with effect from the date of the judgment in Sunder v. Union of India (19 September 2001).” 4. He further contended that as per the aforesaid observation of Hon’ble Apex Court, the interest @ 15% on Solatium cannot be granted before 19.09.2001, However, in the present matter, it has been calculated since the date of notification under Section 4 of the LA Act 1894 i.e. 12.06.1997. 5. Per contra, Ld. Counsel for the decree holder has vehemently opposed the objections and contended that the JD No. 2 is attempting to delay the execution of the decree and deprive the landowners of their Ex. No.87/24 Shyam Sunder vs. UOI Page 2 of 5 -- 2 of 5 -- rightful compensation. 6. She further contended that the decree passed by the Ld. Reference Court specifically grants solatium at 30% under Section 23(2), additional amount at 12% per annum under Section 23(1A), and statutory interest under Section 28 of the Land Acquisition Act. 7. She further contended that once the Ld. Reference Court has expressly granted these statutory benefits, the executing court is bound to enforce them and cannot go behind the decree. Moreover, the judgment relied upon by JD No. 2 is distinguishable on facts. 8. She further contended that at Para-7 of the said judgment i.e. “ Tamil Nadu Housing Board” (supra) itself holds that an executing court cannot go behind the decree. Thus, JD No. 2’s reliance is misplaced. 9. She further emphasizes that para-10 of the said judgment i.e. “ Tamil Nadu Housing Board” (supra) must be read conjointly with para-8, which clarifies that interest on solatium is to be granted in cases where the Ld. Reference Court had not expressly awarded it. In the present case, however, the Ld. Reference Court has expressly awarded solatium and statutory interest. She also relied upon the principle laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in Sunder v. Union of India, (2001) 7 SCC 211 and Gurpreet Singh v. Union of India (2006) 8 SCC 457, wherein the Hon’ble Apex Court recognized entitlement of landowners to interest on solatium and additional amounts. Ex. No.87/24 Shyam Sunder vs. UOI Page 3 of 5 -- 3 of 5 -- 10. She further contended that the Nazir’s calculation is a mere arithmetical exercise in compliance with the decree, and objections raised by JD No. 2 are not maintainable before the executing court. 11. Having considered the rival submissions and entire material available on record, I find that the objections filed by JD No. 2 are devoid of merit. 12. It is a settled principle of law that the executing court cannot go behind the decree. The decree passed by the Ld. Reference Court in the present matter specifically grants solatium, additional amount, and statutory interest. Once such benefits are expressly awarded, the executing court is bound to enforce them and cannot re-examine their legality. The reliance placed by JD No. 2 on the judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court in Tamil Nadu Housing Board v. Abdul Salam Sarkar (supra) is misplaced, as the said judgment dealt with cases where the Ld. Reference Court had not expressly granted interest on solatium. The Hon’ble Apex Court clarified that in such cases, interest would be payable only after 19.09.2001. However, in the present case, the Ld. Reference Court has expressly awarded solatium and statutory interest. Thus, the factual matrix is materially distinct, and reliance on the judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court in Tamil Nadu Housing Board (supra), with due respect, is inapplicable. 13. It is further to be noted that Sections 23(2), 23(1A), and 28 of the Land Acquisition Act mandate grants of solatium, additional amount, Ex. No.87/24 Shyam Sunder vs. UOI Page 4 of 5 -- 4 of 5 -- and interest. The Nazir’s calculation is in consonance with this statutory mandate and with the decree passed by the Ld. Reference Court. The objections filed by JD No. 2 appear to be an attempt to delay execution and frustrate the landowners’ entitlement. Such objections, which challenge the decree itself, ought to have been raised before the appellate court and not in execution. The Nazir’s report is a mechanical exercise of computation based on the decree. Once the decree provides for statutory benefits, the Nazir is duty-bound to calculate them. The objections raised do not point to any arithmetical error but seek to re-open substantive issues already adjudicated. 14. In view of the above discussion and finding, I hold that the objections filed by JD No. 2/DMRC are without merit. The Nazir’s calculation is in accordance with the decree and statutory mandate. The executing court cannot entertain objections which in effect challenge the decree itself. Accordingly, the objections filed by JD No. 2 are hereby dismissed and disposed of. JDs are directed to comply with the decree forthwith and ensure payment to the decree holder without further delay. No order as to costs. The execution proceedings shall continue in accordance with law. 15. Matter be listed for further proceedings on 16.01.2026. (Gaurav) District Judge-01/ SHD KKD/Delhi/29.11.2025 Ex. No.87/24 Shyam Sunder vs. UOI Page 5 of 5 -- 5 of 5 --
