Full Order Text
Final Order 6 · 26 Nov 2024 · CNR DLSH010034112024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. SAMEER BAJPAI ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE-3 (SHAHDARA) KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI Crl. Appeal No. 103/2024 Harsh S/o Sh. Jagpal Singh R/o H.No. D-191, Gold Coast, near Godwin School, Rohta Road, Meerut, U.P. ...Appellant V E R S U S Smt. Kiran W/o Sh. Harsh D/o Sh. Dharam Singh R/o C-1/339, C-Block, Gali No.18, Harsh Vihar, Delhi-110094. ...Respondent Date of Institution : 21.05.2024 Date of reserving order : 22.11.2024 Date of pronouncement : 26.11.2024 Decision : Appeal allowed. ORDER 1. This is an appeal preferred by the appellant against the order dated 19.04.2024 as passed by the court of Ld. MM (Mahila Court no.03), Shahdara District, KKD Court, Delhi in the Complaint Case No.955/2021 titled as Kiran Vs. Harsh, whereby the respondent was awarded Rs.4000/- as interim maintenance. Crl Appeal. No. 103/2024 Harsh Vs. Kiran Page 1 of 8 -- 1 of 8 -- 2. The Ld. Trial court noted in the impugned order that the counsel for both the parties submitted regarding award of Rs.5000/- per month by the Family Court, towards interim maintenance qua the respondent and her child. Ld. Trial court further noted that perusal of the record shows that ad-interim maintenance in the sum of Rs.4000/- had already been awarded by it qua the maintenance of the child and then ordered that the same be treated as interim maintenance qua the maintenance of the petitioner (respondent no.1 herein) as well as the child, apart from the interim maintenance as awarded by the family court. 3. The submissions on behalf of the appellant are that the marriage was solemnized between him and the respondent on 06.05.2019 and out of the wedlock, a female child was born on 14.03.2020. Further, the respondent filed a complaint case u/s. 12 of PWDV Act on 28.08.2021 as well as a petition u/s. 125 Cr.P.C on her behalf and on behalf of her child in the court of Ld. Principal Judge, Family Court, Shahdara, Kakardooma, Delhi. Further, the Family Court vide order dated 29.03.2023 granted Rs.2500/-each for the respondent and the child and as such Rs.5000/- in total. Further, Family Court, Meerut, in the petition as filed by the appellant under Section 24 of the Hindu Marriage Act, vide order dated 29.03.2023 has also awarded Rs.5000/- to the respondent and the child. Crl Appeal. No. 103/2024 Harsh Vs. Kiran Page 2 of 8 -- 2 of 8 -- 4. The main contention of the appellant is that when the Principal Judge, Family Court, Shahdara, Delhi awarded Rs.5000/- in total for both the respondent and the child, the further award of Rs.4000/- as interim maintenance was not justified. Further, the impugned order of the Ld. Trial court is non speaking order and no reason has been given in the same that as to why despite the award of Rs.5000/- of the Ld. Family Court, an additional amount of Rs.4000/- was awarded by it. Further, Ld. Family Court in order dated 28.03.2024 considered salary slips of the appellant showing the salary of the appellant as Rs.10,200/- per month and the fact that the salary was reflected in the bank account statement of the respondent for the month of May and June 2023, whereas, the Ld. Trial Court did not consider anything and pass the order without application of mind. Further, Ld. Principal Judge, Family Court specifically noted in its order dated 28.03.2024 that the respondent shall be entitled to receive the maintenance to the highest amount out of the various allowances if any, awarded to her by various courts, but despite that the Ld. Trial court awarded an additional amount of Rs.4000/- per month. 5. In her reply, the submissions of the respondent are that the appellant is trying to misguide and mislead the court. Further, the appellant has not paid a single penny to the respondent and is a habitual defaulter. Further, the appellant has not complied the directions of the Ld. Trial court as well as the order dated 29.03.2023 Crl Appeal. No. 103/2024 Harsh Vs. Kiran Page 3 of 8 -- 3 of 8 -- of the Ld. Family Court, Meerut, whereby on the petition of the appellant, the appellant was directed to pay Rs.5000/- per month to the respondent. Further, the Ld. Principal Judge, Family Court, Shahdara, Karkardooma vide order dated 28.03.2024 has granted Rs.5000/- as interim maintenance for the respondent and her daughter but the appellant has not complied the said order also and not paid even a single penny. Further, the appellant is well educated and a diploma holder in Electronic and Tele-communication and while working as a Project Manager in a Telecom company, he was getting a salary of Rs.50,000/- per month. Further, the CV of the appellant is there on record and shows his qualification and ability to earn much more and the fact that the appellant is earning just about Rs.10,000/- is false. 6. The court has gone through the record and heard arguments. 7. As a matter of fact, the respondent has three orders in her favour of different courts, whereby she has been awarded different amounts for maintenance. The first order is of the Family Court, Meerut dated 29.03.2023, whereby she was awarded Rs.5000/-. The second order is of Ld. Principal Judge, Family Court passed on 28.03.2024, whereby the Ld. Family Court awarded Rs.2500/- per month each for the respondent and her child i.e. Rs.5000/- per month in total. The third order is the impugned order, whereby the respondent was awarded Rs.4000/- per month for herself and the child. Crl Appeal. No. 103/2024 Harsh Vs. Kiran Page 4 of 8 -- 4 of 8 -- 8. The Ld. Principal Judge, Family Court, Shahdara in its order has already made it clear that as per the settled law, the petitioners (respondent and her child) shall be entitled to receive the maintenance to the highest amount out of the various allowances, if any, awarded to her by various courts. Thus, practically even if the Ld. Trial Court awarded the amount of Rs.4000/- per month, the entitlement of the respondent and the child would be to receive only Rs.5000/- per month as awarded by ld. Family Court and the respondent and her child cannot claim the said amount of Rs.4000/-. 9. Still, as far as the merits of the case in hand is concerned, although in a complaint u/s.12 of PWDV Act, 2005, the main consideration for a court must be to consider if the petitioner is subject to domestic violence and only thereafter the court is supposed to consider the maintenance for the complainant. 10. To make the facts clear, the court deems it appropriate to reproduce the relevant part of the impugned order as under: “It is a matter of record that petitioner has a young female child of aged around 3.5 year alongwith her and she is stated to be dependent on her parents for her maintenance as well as maintenance of her child. Upon inquiry petitioner submits that despite being well educate she is not Crl Appeal. No. 103/2024 Harsh Vs. Kiran Page 5 of 8 -- 5 of 8 -- able to do the job because of the child. However, she is searching for the job. It is not disputed by R-1 that he is father of child and being the father, it is the sacrosanct duty of R-1 to maintain his child. Therefore, R-1 is directed to pay ad-interim maintenance in the sum of Rs.4000/- per month to the petitioner qua the maintenance of the child either in cash against receiving or through online mode from the date of filing of application seeking interim maintenance moved on behalf of the petitioner till the decision on the application.” 11. In the impugned order, the Trial court noted that as per the record, ad-interim maintenance in the sum of Rs.4000/- had already been awarded by the court qua the maintenance of the child and then noted that the same be treated as interim maintenance qua the maintenance of the petitioner as well as of the child, apart from interim maintenance awarded by the Family Court. 12. The ad-interim maintenance order as mentioned by the Ld. Trial Court in the impugned order was passed just on the previous date i.e. 28.11.2023, which shows that the Ld. Trial court inquired from the petitioner (respondent herein) and the petitioner submitted that despite being well educated, she was unable to do any job because of the child. The Ld. Trial court then noted that un-disputedly, the respondent no.1 (appellant herein) was the father of the child and Crl Appeal. No. 103/2024 Harsh Vs. Kiran Page 6 of 8 -- 6 of 8 -- directed the respondent to pay an ad-interim maintenance in the sum of Rs.4000/- per month qua the maintenance of the child. 13. The impugned order dated 19.04.2024 as well as the previous order of the Ld. Trial Court dated 28.11.2023 show that they were passed only after taking submissions of the Ld. Counsel for the parties and not after considering the record and the merits of the case. The Ld. Trial court although noted that the amount of Rs.4000/- was awarded apart from the amount of interim maintenance as awarded by Ld. Family court, but the Ld. Trial court did not explain as to why it awarded a separate amount of Rs.4000/- to the respondent. To the mind of the court, if the Ld. Trial court was awarding an additional amount to the respondent, it was supposed to first satisfy itself, considering the facts as alleged by the respondent in her petition that the respondent was subject to domestic violence and then was supposed to give reasons for awarding the amount and the reasons could be given only after considering the income of the parties, their expenditure and other material on record, but the Ld. Trial Court did not do so. 14. To the mind of the court, the order of Ld. Trial court is not justified and the same is hereby set aside. 15. Ld. Trial Court is directed to take evidence and only then to Crl Appeal. No. 103/2024 Harsh Vs. Kiran Page 7 of 8 -- 7 of 8 -- decide if the respondent and her child would be entitled for any amount under the PWDV Act. 16. TCR be sent back along with copy of the order to the Ld. Trial Court. Appeal file be consigned to record room. (Sameer Bajpai) Addl. Sessions Judge-03 Shahdara District, Karkardooma Courts, Dated: 26.11.2024 Crl Appeal. No. 103/2024 Harsh Vs. Kiran Page 8 of 8 -- 8 of 8 --
