Full Order Text
Interim Order 31 · 10 Sept 2026 · CNR DLSH010033612024
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: CNR NO. DLSH01-003361-2024 SC NO. 207/2024 STATE VS. RAMCHARAN & ANR FIR NO. 307/2022 PS NAND NAGRI INDEX Serial No. Contents Pages 1. Judgment 1-21 2. Appendix-I (List of Witnesses) 22-23 3. Appendix-II (List of Exhibits) 24-25 4. Appendix-III (List of Articles / Objects) 26 (SANJAY GARG-II) Principal District & Sessions Judge, Shahdara, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi -- 1 of 27 -- IN THE COURT OF SH. SANJAY GARG-II, PRINCIPAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE, SHAHDARA, KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI Sessions Case No. 207/2024 CNR No. DLSH01-003361-2024 State Vs. 1. Ramcharan, S/o Sh. Kalyan Singh, R/o E-117/55, Jhuggi, Sunder Nagri, Nand Nagri, Delhi. 2. Manoj, S/o Sh. Harishankar, R/o F-1/392, Gali No. 6, Sunder Nagri, Nand Nagri, Delhi. FIR No. : 307/2022 Police Station : Nand Nagri Under Sections : 308/34 IPC Chargesheet presented on : 15.09.2023 Judgment reserved on : 25.08.2026 Judgment pronounced on : 10.09.2026 J U D G M E N T 1. Accused Ramcharan and Manoj are facing trial for commission of offences punishable under Sections 341/308/34 IPC on the allegations that on 18.03.2022 at about 9:30 a.m. at Murga Market, Shani Bazaar, Sunder Nagri, Delhi, they both, in furtherance of SC No. 207/2024 State v. Ramcharan & Anr. Page 1 of 21 -- 2 of 27 -- their common intention with the CCL ‘R’, wrongfully restrained the complainant and inflicted injury on his head with a danda (wooden stick) with such intention or knowledge and under such circumstances that if by that act, they had caused the death of the complainant, they would have been guilty of committing culpable homicide not amounting to murder. CASE OF THE PROSECUTION: 2. The case of the prosecution as borne out from the chargesheet is that upon receipt of DD Nos. 44A and 45A both dated 18.03.2022 regarding quarrel and infliction of injury, SI Karan Singh along with Constable Ravinder reached the place of incident i.e. Murga Market, Shani Bazaar, near Ram Lila Ground, Sunder Nagri, Delhi, where they came to know that the injured had been taken to GTB Hospital. Accordingly, they went to the hospital and collected the MLC of the injured Sh. Ramveer. On the same day in the afternoon, the injured visited the police station and got his statement recorded. 3. In his statement, the complainant/injured stated that his wife Smt. Suman and one Smt. Meena, widow of late Sh. Harishankar, run their vegetable carts at Murga Market, Shani Bazaar, Sunder Nagri, Delhi and that for the past several days, Smt. Meena and her relatives had been quarreling with his wife over the issue of putting up the vegetable cart at the said place. On 18.03.2022 at about 9:30 a.m., he received a phone call from his wife informing SC No. 207/2024 State v. Ramcharan & Anr. Page 2 of 21 -- 3 of 27 -- that the relatives of Smt. Meena were quarreling with her. When the complainant reached at the spot, both the accused persons namely Ramcharan and Manoj and the CCL ‘R’ exhorted each other to finish him off. Thereafter, while accused Manoj and CCL ‘R’ caught hold of the complainant, accused Ramcharan struck him on the head with a danda. As a result, the complainant fell down and started bleeding from his head. His wife intervened to rescue him and made a call to the police at number 112. A PCR vehicle arrived at the spot and took him to the hospital. After receiving the treatment, the complainant returned to his home. Thereafter, he went to the police station and sought legal action against the assailants. 4. On the basis of the statement of the complainant, FIR No. 307/2022 under Section 308/34 IPC was registered. During investigation, IO SI Karan Singh prepared the site plan of the place of incident at the instance of the complainant and recorded the statements of the witnesses under Section 161 CrPC. Pursuant to the notice under Section 41 A CrPC, both the accused persons joined the investigation. The opinion of the doctor on the MLC of the injured was obtained, wherein the nature of injury was opined to be ‘simple’. After completion of the investigation, the chargesheet was filed against the accused Ramcharan and Manoj without arrest before the Ld. MM on 15.09.2023. Qua the CCL ‘R’, a separate police investigation report was filed before the Ld. JJB. SC No. 207/2024 State v. Ramcharan & Anr. Page 3 of 21 -- 4 of 27 -- 5. After compliance of the provisions of Section 207 CrPC, the chargesheet was committed to the Sessions Court for trial. CHARGE: 6. On 16.07.2024, the charge for the commission of offences punishable under Sections 341/308/34 IPC was framed against the accused Ramcharan and Manoj to which they pleaded not guilty and claimed trial. PROSECUTION EVIDENCE: 7. In support of its case, the prosecution examined 7 witnesses. 8. PW1 Sh. Ramveer is the complainant/injured. He proved the statement made by him to the police as Ex. PW1/A and the site plan of the place of incident as Ex. PW1/B. 9. PW2 Smt. Suman is the wife of the complainant/injured Sh. Ramveer. She is the eyewitness to the incident. 10. PW3 Retd. SI Naresh Kumar is the Duty Officer. He proved the DD No. 45A dated 18.03.2022 as Ex. PW3/A; the DD No. 44A dated 18.03.2022 as Ex. PW3/B; the copy of the FIR as Ex. PW3/C; and the endorsement made by him on the rukka and the certificate under Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act as Ex. PW3/D. SC No. 207/2024 State v. Ramcharan & Anr. Page 4 of 21 -- 5 of 27 -- 11. PW4 HC Ravinder Kumar had taken the original rukka and copy of the FIR to the spot and handed over to IO SI Karan Singh. 12. PW5 Retd. SI Karan Singh is the IO of the case. He proved the rukka prepared by him as Ex. PW5/A and the notice under Section 41A CrPC served upon the accused Ramcharan and Manoj as Ex. PW5/B and Ex. PW5/C respectively. 13. PW6 Dr. Shitiz, Senior Resident, Neurosurgery, GTB Hospital, Delhi was examined to prove the opinion given by Dr. Mohit Bhalla on the MLC of the complainant Sh. Ramveer. He identified the signature of Dr. Mohit Bhalla at point X and proved the MLC as Ex. PW6/A. 14. PW7 Dr. Irshad, CMO, GTB Hospital, Delhi deposed that he had examined the patient Sh. Ramveer on 18.03.2022 and prepared MLC in that regard. He proved the MLC as Ex. PW6/A. STATEMENT OF THE ACCUSED: 15. The statement of the accused Ramcharan and Manoj under Section 313 CrPC were recorded on 29.10.2025. All the incriminating evidence available on record was put to them to which their stand was of general denial. They took the defence that they were not even present at the spot at the time of the incident and, in fact, the quarrel had taken place between the mother and younger sisters of the accused Manoj, on the one hand, and the complainant and his wife, on the other. Both of them stated that the complainant used SC No. 207/2024 State v. Ramcharan & Anr. Page 5 of 21 -- 6 of 27 -- to misbehave with the younger sisters of accused Manoj as they were also selling the vegetables from the spot. They also stated that though the sisters of accused Manoj informed the police about the incident and their MLCs were prepared in the GTB Hospital but the police did not make any investigation on the said information and the complainant Ramveer had falsely implicated the accused in the present case in order to save him from punishment. DEFENCE EVIDENCE: 16. In support of their case, the accused persons examined two witnesses. 17. Retd. SI Karan Singh, the IO of the present case, was examined as DW1. Though he admitted that prior to the present incident, complaints used to be received from the complainant as well as the accused persons regarding dispute over placing of their vegetable carts at Murga Market, Shani Bazaar, Sunder Nagri, Delhi but expressed ignorance if any complaint had been received from the sisters of accused Manoj regarding the incident dated 18.03.2022. 18. DW2 Sh. Sumer Singh Meena, Assistant Section Officer, GTB Hospital, Delhi produced the original record regarding the treatment of patient Ms. Diksha on 18.03.2022. He proved the carbon copy of Emergency Registration Card of Ms. Diksha as Ex. DW2/A and her Progress Report (in original) as Ex. DW2/B. SC No. 207/2024 State v. Ramcharan & Anr. Page 6 of 21 -- 7 of 27 -- ARGUMENTS ADVANCED: 19. Learned Addl. PP for the State has submitted that the complainant/injured Sh. Ramveer (PW1) and his wife Smt. Suman (PW2) are the prime witnesses of the case of the prosecution and both of them have deposed in unison that on the date of incident, the accused persons had given a danda blow on the head of the complainant, as a result of which he sustained injury on the parietal region. He has submitted that both the said witnesses have identified the accused persons during their testimony and the accused persons have failed to dent their version. He has argued that from the unshaken testimony of PW1 and PW2, which is also corroborated by the medical evidence, the prosecution has succeeded in proving its case against the accused persons beyond reasonable doubt and thus, they are liable to be convicted for the charges against them. 20. On the other hand, the learned defence counsel has submitted that the accused persons were not present at the spot on the date of incident and that they have been falsely implicated due to strained relations between the parties. She has submitted that on the date of incident, the complainant had misbehaved with the sisters of the accused Manoj in respect of which his mother Smt. Meena had given a written complaint on 25.03.2022 but the police failed to take any action on the said complaint. She has further submitted that since the complainant (PW1) and his wife (PW2) are the interested witnesses, no reliance can be placed on their testimony SC No. 207/2024 State v. Ramcharan & Anr. Page 7 of 21 -- 8 of 27 -- in the absence of any independent corroboration. She has argued that there are contradictions and material improvements in the testimony of PW1 and PW2, which also make the case of the prosecution unreliable. She has contended that even otherwise, from the ocular and medical evidence produced on record, the prosecution has failed to prove the essential ingredients of offences under Sections 341 and 308 IPC and accordingly, the accused persons are entitled to acquittal. LEGAL PROVISIONS INVOLVED: 21. Section 341 IPC provides punishment for wrongful restraint. Section 339 IPC lays down that whoever voluntarily obstructs any person so as to prevent that person from proceeding in any direction in which that person has a right to proceed, is said wrongfully to restrain that person. 22. Section 308 IPC, which deals with attempt to commit culpable homicide, reads as under: “308. Attempt to commit culpable homicide.— Whoever does any act with such intention or knowledge and under such circumstances that, if he by that act caused death, he would be guilty of culpable homicide not amounting to murder, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to three years, or with fine, or with both; and, if hurt is caused to any person by such act, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to seven years, or with fine, or with both.” 23. Section 34 IPC essentially involves vicarious liability. It provides that when a criminal act is done by several persons in furtherance SC No. 207/2024 State v. Ramcharan & Anr. Page 8 of 21 -- 9 of 27 -- of the common intention of all, each of such persons is liable for that act in the same manner as if it were done by him alone. ANALYSIS AND REASONING: 24. The criminal law was set in motion by the complainant/injured Sh. Ramveer, who has been examined as PW1 by the prosecution. In his testimony, PW1 deposed that he is a driver by profession and his wife used to run a vegetable cart in Murga Market, Shani Bazaar, Sunder Nagri, Delhi; that one lady Smt. Meena used to put up her vegetable cart near the cart of his wife in the said market and the relatives of Smt. Meena used to quarrel with his wife for putting up her cart at the said place; that on 18.03.2022 at about 9.30 a.m., when he was present near Kabutar Chowk, he received a call from his wife informing that Smt. Meena and her relatives were quarreling with her for putting up the cart in the market; that he reached at the cart of his wife and when he intervened in the quarrel to save her from accused Ramcharan and Manoj and CCL ‘R’, all three of them started assaulting him, stating that they would finish him off; that CCL ‘R’ and accused Manoj caught hold of him and accused Ramcharan hit a danda on his head; that his head started bleeding and the accused persons ran away from the spot. He further deposed that his wife made a call to the police and a PCR van came to the spot and took him to GTB Hospital. After treatment, he went to his home as he was feeling dizzy and on the next day in the morning, he went to the police station and got his statement recorded. He proved the statement made by him SC No. 207/2024 State v. Ramcharan & Anr. Page 9 of 21 -- 10 of 27 -- to the police as Ex. PW1/A and the site plan of the place of occurrence as Ex. PW1/B. 25. Since the complainant (PW1) had given an incorrect version regarding the date on which his statement was recorded by the police, he was cross-examined by the learned Addl. PP for the State. During the said cross-examination, PW1 stated that on account of lapse of time, he had inadvertently stated that he had visited the police station on the next day of the incident i.e. 19.03.2022 to lodge complaint whereas, in fact, he had visited the police station on the same day after taking treatment from the hospital. The witness was thereafter subjected to cross- examination on behalf of the accused persons. However, nothing material could be elicited in such cross-examination so as to discredit or impeach his testimony with regard to the manner in which the occurrence took place or the infliction of injury upon his head by the accused persons. 26. Learned counsel for the accused persons has contended that the failure of the complainant to correctly state the date on which he visited the police station to lodge the complaint constitutes a material contradiction and is sufficient to render his testimony unreliable. 27. The said contention does not merit acceptance. A careful appreciation of the testimony of the complainant (PW1) shows that his narration with regard to the occurrence and the manner in SC No. 207/2024 State v. Ramcharan & Anr. Page 10 of 21 -- 11 of 27 -- which the injury was inflicted upon his head by the accused persons has remained consistent and substantially unshaken throughout. The discrepancy with regard to the date of visit for lodging the complaint is, at best, a minor lapse relating to a peripheral aspect of the matter. It is noteworthy that the incident in question took place on 18.03.2022 and the testimony of the complainant was recorded after a lapse of more than three years on 23.05.2025. Thus, the explanation furnished by the witness for the said discrepancy by attributing the same to the lapse of time appears to be plausible. Further, such a discrepancy, which neither touches the substratum of the prosecution case nor creates any doubt regarding the occurrence itself or the identity and role of the accused persons, can not be said to be a material contradiction. 28. The version of the complainant (PW1) with regard to the occurrence finds material corroboration from the testimony of his wife Smt. Suman, who has been examined as PW2. PW2 has deposed that she runs a vegetable cart in Murga Market, Shani Bazaar, Sunder Nagri, Delhi and that on 18.03.2022 at about 9.30 a.m., while she was selling vegetables from her cart, accused Manoj and Ramcharan, CCL ‘R’ and Meena started quarreling with her and stopped her from selling vegetables from the said place. She telephonically informed her husband i.e. the complainant about the incident. The complainant reached the spot and confronted the accused persons. PW2 further deposed that the accused persons and CCL ‘R’ started saying that they would finish SC No. 207/2024 State v. Ramcharan & Anr. Page 11 of 21 -- 12 of 27 -- off her husband and while the accused Manoj and CCL ‘R’ caught hold of her husband, accused Ramcharan hit a danda on the head of her husband, due to which her husband started bleeding. PW2 thereafter made a call at 112 number, pursuant to which a PCR van reached the spot and took her husband to the GTB Hospital. She also identified the accused persons in the Court. 29. During her cross-examination on behalf of the accused persons, PW2 admitted that there had been previous quarrels between her and the accused persons regarding the running of vegetable cart from the spot. She also admitted that the daughters of Smt. Meena had made several police complaints against her husband alleging misbehaviour on his part. 30. Learned counsel for the accused has placed considerable reliance upon the above admissions to contend that the relations between the parties were admittedly strained and, therefore, PW1 and PW2 had the motive to falsely implicate the accused persons. She has further argued that the occurrence allegedly took place in a market where several public persons were present, yet none of them was associated with the investigation or examined by the prosecution. She has contended that the testimony of PW1 and PW2, being interested witnesses, can not safely be relied upon in the absence of corroboration from an independent public witness. 31. The above contention does not find favour with the Court. The mere fact that PW2 is the wife of the complainant does not render SC No. 207/2024 State v. Ramcharan & Anr. Page 12 of 21 -- 13 of 27 -- her testimony unreliable. While the evidence of a related witness and the existence of prior disputes warrant cautious scrutiny, these circumstances, by themselves, can not justify discarding otherwise cogent and trustworthy ocular testimony. The testimony of PW2 is in sync with the version of the PW1 regarding the occurrence and participation of the accused persons. Her presence at the spot has not been disputed by the accused persons. The examination of the testimony of PW2, in entirety, shows that she has furnished a natural account of the events leading to the occurrence, including her telephonic communication with PW1, his arrival at the spot, the assault upon him and the making of the call to the police by her. Nothing material has emerged in her cross-examination which would render her account of the occurrence doubtful. 32. The contention regarding the non-examination of any independent public witness also does not persuade the Court to discard the ocular testimony of PW1 and PW2. It is undoubtedly desirable that where an occurrence takes place at a public place, the investigating agency should make an endeavour to associate available independent witnesses. However, an omission or lapse on the part of the investigating agency can not enure to the benefit of the accused when the substantive evidence adduced by the prosecution is found to be reliable and trustworthy. The Court is required to assess the quality of the evidence available on record rather than its mere quantity. The ocular evidence of PW1 and PW2 also receives corroboration from the medical evidence. The SC No. 207/2024 State v. Ramcharan & Anr. Page 13 of 21 -- 14 of 27 -- MLC of the complainant (Ex. PW6/A) records a lacerated wound over his parietal region. The existence and location of the injury are thus consistent with the prosecution version that the complainant was struck on his head during the occurrence. 33. Consequently, on the cumulative appreciation of the testimony of PW1 and PW2, which has remained unshaken, and the corroboration furnished by the medical evidence, this Court finds their testimony to be reliable and worthy of acceptance. The mere existence of prior disputes between the parties or the non- examination of independent public witnesses, therefore, does not create a reasonable doubt regarding the occurrence or the involvement of the accused persons therein. 34. In their statement under Section 351 BNSS, the accused persons have raised the defence that they were not present at the spot on the day of incident i.e. 18.03.2022. In this regard, it is apt to refer to Section 103 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, which provides that the burden of proof as to any particular fact lies on that person who wishes the Court to believe in its existence, unless it is provided by any law that the proof of that fact shall lie on any particular person. The illustration to the above section sufficiently points out the meaning. All the facts, however numerous and complicated, which go to make up the accused's guilt, must be proved by the prosecution. If the accused wishes to prove a particular fact, his alibi for instance, he must prove it. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has consistently held that once the prosecution has SC No. 207/2024 State v. Ramcharan & Anr. Page 14 of 21 -- 15 of 27 -- discharged its burden of proving the presence and participation of the accused in the occurrence, the burden upon the accused raising a plea of alibi is a heavy one and such plea must be established by leading cogent and reliable evidence so as to completely exclude the possibility of his presence at the place of occurrence. In Dudh Nath Pandey v. State of U.P., (1981) 2 SCC 166 and subsequently reiterated in Binay Kumar Singh v. State of Bihar, (1997) 1 SCC 283, the Hon'ble Supreme Court observed that a plea of alibi requires strict proof and cannot be accepted merely on the basis of a bald assertion. 35. In the instant case, though the accused persons have taken a plea of alibi, however, they have failed to adduce any evidence whatsoever in support of their said plea. Not only have they failed to establish their presence at any other place at the relevant time, they have not even disclosed the place where they claim to have been when the occurrence took place. Hence, the plea of alibi raised by the accused persons, being devoid of any evidentiary support, is liable to be rejected. 36. The accused persons have, in their statement recorded under Section 351 BNSS, also taken the defence that on the date of incident, a quarrel had taken place between Smt. Meena and her daughters, on the one hand, and the complainant Sh. Ramveer and his wife Smt. Suman, on the other. It has further been stated that although the daughters of Smt. Meena had made a call to the police and Smt. Meena had subsequently lodged a complaint SC No. 207/2024 State v. Ramcharan & Anr. Page 15 of 21 -- 16 of 27 -- against the complainant, no action was taken by the police thereon. According to the accused persons, the present case was falsely instituted by the complainant with a view to save himself from the legal consequences of his acts. In support of the above defence, the learned counsel for the accused persons has drawn the attention of the Court to the photocopy of the complaint stated to have been lodged by Smt. Meena and to the testimony of DW2 Sh. Sumer Singh Meena, Assistant Section Officer, who was examined from GTB Hospital to prove the medical record i.e. Emergency Registration Card Ex. DW2/A and Progress Record Ex. DW2/B of Ms. Diksha, one of the daughters of Smt. Meena. It has been argued that the above material establish that on the date of incident, the complainant had assaulted Smt. Meena and her daughters. 37. The aforesaid submission does not withstand scrutiny. The medical record proved through DW2 shows that the sister of accused Manoj namely Ms. Diksha was examined on 18.03.2022 with an alleged history of physical assault and complaint of pain in left arm. However, the said injured person was not examined by the accused persons as a defence witness. She was the best person to explain the circumstances in which the injury was sustained and to depose as to the manner in which the alleged assault had taken place. Her non-examination assumes significance particularly when the accused persons seek to rely upon the said injury as a circumstance supporting their defence. Likewise, the complaint SC No. 207/2024 State v. Ramcharan & Anr. Page 16 of 21 -- 17 of 27 -- dated 25.03.2022 relied upon by the accused persons remained unproved. Neither any effort was made to produce the original complaint nor the daughters of Smt. Meena, who are alleged to have been the victims of the incident referred therein, have been examined. Further, the copy of the complaint placed on record shows that though the incident alleged in the complaint is stated to have occurred on 18.03.2022, the complaint was lodged only on 25.03.2022. More importantly, the defence emerging from the cross-examination of the complainant (PW1) and his wife (PW2) is materially inconsistent with the allegations contained in the said complaint. During the cross-examination of PW1 and PW2, it was suggested that on the date of incident, they had caused injuries to Smt. Meena whereas the complaint dated 25.03.2022 contains an altogether different allegation namely, that the complainant and his son had sexually assaulted the daughters of Smt. Meena namely Ms. Diksha and Ms. Bindiya. There is a further material inconsistency with regard to the injury sustained by the complainant. During the cross-examination of PW1 and PW2, the accused persons suggested that the injury on the head of the complainant had been sustained by him accidentally as he had slipped and fallen at the spot. On the other hand, in the complaint dated 25.03.2022, it has been alleged by Smt. Meena that when she and her daughters raised a cry for help, the complainant himself inflicted an injury on his head with a measuring weight. The above circumstances seriously impair the credibility of the defence version and it appears that the complaint dated 25.03.2022 SC No. 207/2024 State v. Ramcharan & Anr. Page 17 of 21 -- 18 of 27 -- had been filed by Smt. Meena as a counterblast to the FIR registered at the instance of the complainant. Accordingly, the defence plea that the present case is a false case instituted by the complainant apprehending legal action for the alleged sexual assault by him on the daughters of Smt. Meena is not worthy of acceptance. 38. From the unshattered testimony of the complainant Sh. Ramveer (PW1) and his wife/eyewitness Smt. Suman (PW2) and the medical evidence brought on record, it is evident that the prosecution has succeeded in proving that the accused persons had caused injury on the head of the complainant in furtherance of their common intention. 39. Now the question which arises for consideration is whether the act of the accused persons in causing injury to the complainant attracts the offence under Section 308 IPC. In order to constitute the offence under Section 308 IPC, it must be proved that the accused persons had caused the injury with the intention or knowledge that by inflicting such injury, they were likely to cause death. The requisite intention or knowledge has to be gathered from the totality of the circumstances, including the manner in which the assault was committed, the nature and severity of the injury, the weapon used, the part of the body targeted, the force employed and the circumstances preceding and attending the occurrence. In the present case, from the narration of the incident given by the complainant and his wife, it emerges that the complainant reached SC No. 207/2024 State v. Ramcharan & Anr. Page 18 of 21 -- 19 of 27 -- the spot upon being informed by his wife about the quarrel. When he confronted the accused persons, they assaulted him with a danda, causing an injury on his head. The circumstances brought on record indicate that the incident arose suddenly out of a verbal altercation between the parties and escalated into a physical assault in the heat of the moment. There is no material on record to suggest any prior preparation or premeditation on the part of the accused persons. Significantly, only a single blow was attributed to the accused persons. As per the MLC of the complainant, he sustained a lacerated wound measuring 3 cm x 1 cm over the parietal region of the head, which was opined to be simple in nature. The nature of the injury, the fact that only a single blow was inflicted, the absence of any evidence of repeated or sustained assault and the circumstances in which the occurrence took place do not support an inference that the accused persons possessed the requisite intention or knowledge contemplated under Section 308 IPC. Although the head is undoubtedly a vital part of the body, the mere fact that an injury was caused on the head, by itself, can not lead to an inference that the assailants intended or knew that their act was likely to cause death. Resultantly, the injury caused to the complainant falls within the ambit of Section 323 read with Section 34 IPC. 40. As regards the charge under Section 341 read with Section 34 IPC, the prosecution has alleged that the accused Manoj and CCL ‘R’ caught hold of the complainant, while accused Ramcharan SC No. 207/2024 State v. Ramcharan & Anr. Page 19 of 21 -- 20 of 27 -- inflicted a blow upon his head with a danda. For constituting wrongful restraint within the meaning of Section 339 IPC, it is necessary to establish that the person concerned was voluntarily obstructed from proceeding in a direction in which he had a right to proceed. Thus, the prosecution was required to bring on record some evidence to show that the complainant intended to proceed in a particular direction and that his movement in that direction was voluntarily obstructed by the accused. Notably, neither the testimony of the complainant (PW1) nor that of his wife (PW2) discloses that the complainant was prevented from moving in any particular direction or that he was otherwise obstructed from proceeding to a place where he had a right to go. The evidence, at its highest, establishes that the accused Manoj caught hold of the complainant during the occurrence. Such an act may undoubtedly be indicative of his participation in the assault and may be relevant while determining his common intention in relation to the offence of voluntarily causing hurt. However, the same can not, in the absence of proof of obstruction of movement as contemplated by Section 339 IPC, be said to constitute the distinct offence of wrongful restraint. In view of the aforesaid deficiency in the prosecution evidence, a reasonable doubt arises as to whether the complainant was wrongfully restrained within the meaning of Section 339 IPC. The benefit of such doubt must necessarily go to the accused. Accordingly, the charge under Section 341 read with Section 34 IPC has not been proved against the accused persons. SC No. 207/2024 State v. Ramcharan & Anr. Page 20 of 21 -- 21 of 27 -- The accused are, therefore, entitled to be acquitted of the said charge. CONCLUSION: 41. In the light of the above discussion, the accused Ramcharan and Manoj are convicted for the commission of offence punishable under Section 323 read with Section 34 IPC and they are acquitted of the charge under Section 341/34 IPC against them. 42. Copy of the judgment be supplied to the convicts free of cost. 43. The convicts shall now be heard on the point of sentence. Pronounced in the open court (SANJAY GARG-II) on 10.09.2026 Principal District & Sessions Judge, Shahdara, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi SC No. 207/2024 State v. Ramcharan & Anr. Page 21 of 21 -- 22 of 27 -- 22 Appendix-I LIST OF PROSECUTION / DEFENCE / COURT WITNESSES A. PROSECUTION WITNESSES: Witness No. Name of witness Description / Role of the witness PW1 Sh. Ramveer Complainant/injured PW2 Smt. Suman Wife of the complainant / eyewitness PW3 Retd. SI Naresh Kumar Duty Officer PW4 HC Ravinder Kumar Police witness PW5 Retd. SI Karan Singh Investigating Officer PW6 Dr. Shitiz Senior Resident, Neurosurgery, GTB Hospital, Delhi. PW7 Dr. Irshad CMO, GTB Hospital, Delhi B. DEFENCE WITNESSES, IF ANY: Witness No. Name of witness Description / Role of the witness DW1 Retd. SI Karan Singh Investigating Officer -- 23 of 27 -- 23 DW2 Sh. Sumer Singh Meena Assistant Section Officer, GTB Hospital, Delhi C. COURT WITNESSES, IF ANY: NIL (SANJAY GARG-II) Principal District & Sessions Judge, Shahdara, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi -- 24 of 27 -- 24 Appendix-II LIST OF PROSECUTION / DEFENCE / COURT EXHIBITS A. PROSECUTION: Exhibit No. Description of the Exhibit Proved by / Attested by Ex. PW1/A Statement dated 18.03.2022 of the complainant Sh. Ramveer recorded by the police. PW1 and PW5 Ex. PW1/B Site plan of the place of incident prepared by the IO at the instance of the complainant. PW1 and PW5 Ex. PW3/A Copy of DD No. 45A dated 18.03.2022. PW3 and PW5 Ex. PW3/B Copy of DD No. 44A dated 18.03.2022. PW3 & PW5 Ex. PW3/C Copy of the FIR PW3 Ex. PW3/D Endorsement on the rukka made by the duty officer. Ex. PW3/D Certificate under Section 65 B of Indian Evidence Act regarding the registration of FIR. Ex. PW5/A Rukka prepared by the IO. PW5 Ex. PW5/B Notice under Section 41 A CrPC served upon the accused Ramcharan. -- 25 of 27 -- 25 Ex. PW5/C Notice under Section 41 A CrPC served upon the accused Manoj. PW5 Ex. PW6/A MLC No. 1493/2022 dated 18.03.2022 of complainant Sh. Ramveer. PW6 and PW7 B. DEFENCE: Exhibit No. Description of the Exhibit Proved by / Attested by Ex. DW2/A Carbon copy of Emergency Registration Card of patient Ms. Diksha issued by GTB Hosiptal. DW2 Ex. DW2/B Progress report (in original) of patient Ms. Diksha issued by GTB Hosiptal. C. COURT EXHIBITS: NIL. (SANJAY GARG-II) Principal District & Sessions Judge, Shahdara, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi -- 26 of 27 -- 26 Appendix-III LIST OF ARTICLES / OBJECTS: Material Object Number Description of the Object / Exhibit Proved by / Attested by Nil Nil Nil. (SANJAY GARG-II) Principal District & Sessions Judge, Shahdara, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi -- 27 of 27 --
