Full Order Text
Final Order 7 · 17 Dec 2024 · CNR DLSH010033372023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF VIJAY KUMAR JHA PRESIDING OFFICER: MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL-01, SHAHDARA KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI ____________________________________________________________ In the matter of : Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. MACT no. 308/2022 1. Pushpa Devi (mother of deceased Gaurav) Wife of Sh. Subhash Chandra 2. Subhash Chandra (father of deceased Gaurav) Son of Sh. Rajveer Singh 3. Saurabh (brother of deceased Gaurav) Son of Sh. Subhash Chandra 4. Rohit (brother of deceased Gaurav) Son of Sh. Subhash Chandra All R/o J-46, Jawahar Park, Sahibabad, District Ghaziabad, U.P. .……..Petitioners Versus 1. Ashu S/o Sh. Muntyaj Khan (Driver) R/o 97, Mohalla Teliyan, VPO-Kakore, District Bulandshahar, U.P. 2. Praveen Kumar (Regd. Owner) S/o Sh. Chandan Singh R/o House no.3, Gali no.9, Block-5, Geeta Colony, Delhi. 3. The New India Assurance Co. Ltd. (Insurer) Barakhamba Road, Connaught Place, New Delhi. …...Respondents Date of filing of DAR : 29.05.2023 Final arguments heard : 10.12.2024 Date of Award : 17.12.2024 ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 1 of 27 -- 1 of 27 -- J U D G M E N T 1. By this judgment, I shall decide the present DAR (Detailed Accident Report) filed by the Investigating Agency in respect of fatal injury received by Sh. Gaurav (hereinafter referred to as the ‘deceased’) in a motor vehicular accident occurred on 19.05.2023 at 11:00 a.m. at Flyover, Wazirabad Road (leading to Gagan Cinema from Gol Chakkar), near Nand Nagri Bus Depot, Nand Nagri, Delhi, involving a motorcycle bearing registration no. DL5SCK-1382 and a truck (LPT 1623) bearing registration no. DL1GE-0463. After the accident, the deceased was removed to GTB Hospital, Delhi, where he was declared brought dead. 2. As per DAR, in connection with the accident, FIR no.337/2023, under sections 279/304A IPC was registered at Police Nand Nagri, Delhi. According to the investigation, the accident of the deceased, who was driving his motorcycle bearing registration no. DL5SCK-1382, was caused by the truck (LPT 1623) bearing registration no. DL1GE-0463 (hereinafter referred as the ‘offending vehicle’) which was being driven in rash and negligent manner by its driver/ respondent no.1 Ashu. After completion of the investigation, chargesheet against the respondent no.1 was filed before the court concerned and DAR was filed before this Tribunal. The DAR has been treated as claim petition under section 166 of ‘Motor Vehicle Act, 1988’ on behalf of the petitioners/ legal representatives of the deceased. 3. All the respondents appeared at the time of filing of DAR. They were ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 2 of 27 -- 2 of 27 -- directed to file their replies/ written-statements. In response to the directions, the respondent no.3/ insurance company filed its written statement, whereas, respondent no.1 and 2 did not any reply despite expiry of the stipulated time and therefore, right of respondent no.1 and 2 was closed vide order dated 14.08.2023. 4. Respondent no.3/ The New India Assurance Company Ltd. in its written statement took preliminary objections inter-alia stating that as per contents of DAR, on 19.05.2023, a call was received from a passer-by Mr. Sandeep regarding road side accident and as per his statement, motorcycle of injured (deceased) Gaurav was moving ahead of his motorcycle at around 11:00 p.m., when motorcycle of deceased was struck with the offending truck moving ahead in the same direction. Having said so, it has been contended that since the deceased was not maintaining a proper distance from the offending truck moving ahead, which was to be maintained mandatorily as per traffic rules between the two vehicles, there was contributory negligence on the part of the deceased. It is further contended that at the time of accident, the deceased was not having a valid driving license to drive the motorcycle and he was also not wearing a helmet in violation of the traffic rules. 5. In their written-statement, though the insurance company has admitted that the offending vehicle at the time of the accident was covered under the insurance policy issued by them, however, it is contended that the liability of the insurance company is subject to insurance policy’s terms, conditions, exceptions and limitations in ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 3 of 27 -- 3 of 27 -- compliance of statutory provisions. 6. Upon completion of pleadings, my learned predecessor framed the issues on 15.03.2022, as under:- i). Whether Mr. Gaurav S/o Sh. Subhash Chandra died due to injuries suffered in a motor vehicular accident occurred on 19.05.2023 at 11:00 p.m., at Flyover, Nand Nagri, Delhi, within the jurisdiction of PS Nand Nagri, due to rash and negligent driving of offending vehicle i.e. truck (LPT 1623) bearing registration no. DL1GE-0463, driven by respondent no.1/ Ashu? OPP. ii). Whether the petitioners are entitled for compensation on account of fatal injury suffered the deceased, if yes, to what extent and from whom? OPP. iii). Relief. 7. Vide order dated 11.05.2023, learned Court Commissioner was appointed (refer: Gohar Mohammed v. U.P. SRTC, (2023) 4 SCC 381) to record the evidence in this case. Ld. Court Commissioner submitted the report containing the depositions recorded by him, as under: i). PW1 Sh. Subhash Chandra, father of the deceased appeared in the witness box and tendered his examination-in-chief by way of his affidavit Ex.PW1/A regarding the manner of accident, age, education and income of deceased, identity documents of the deceased and that of the petitioners and about the losses suffered on account of the death of the deceased. He relied upon the following documents:- ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 4 of 27 -- 4 of 27 -- a) Copy of educational certificates of the deceased as Ex.PW1/1 (OSR). b) Copy of PAN Card of deceased as Ex.PW1/2 (OSR). c) Copy of Aadhar card of deceased as Ex.PW1/3 (OSR). d) Copy of ITR of deceased mentioned as Ex.PW1/4 in the affidavit is de-exhibited and is marked as Mark-X (colly). e) Copy of PAN Card of petitioner no.1 as Ex.PW1/5 (OSR). f) Copy of Aadhaar Card of petitioner no.1 as Ex.PW1/6 (OSR). g) Copy of PAN Card of petitioner no.2 as Ex.PW1/7 (OSR). h) Copy of Aadhaar Card of petitioner no.2 as Ex.PW1/8 (OSR). i) Copy of disability certificate of petitioner no.3 as Ex.PW1/9 (OSR). j) Copy of PAN Card of petitioner no.3 as Ex.PW1/10 (OSR). k) Copy of Aadhaar Card of petitioner no.3 as Ex.PW1/11 (OSR). l) Copy of PAN Card of petitioner no.4 as Ex.PW1/12 (OSR). m) Copy of Aadhaar Card of petitioner no.4 as Ex.PW1/13 (OSR). n) Attested copy of DAR as Ex.PW1/14 (colly). ii). PW2 Sh. Ram Niwas Meena, Income Tax Inspector, Income Tax Office, Ward-2(1)(2), Ghaziabad, U.P. produced his authority Ex.PW2/1 and the ITRs filed on behalf of the assessee Gaurav (deceased herein), PAN no. BVDPG3879A for the assessment years 2021-22 and 2022-23 and proved the same as Ex.PW2/2 and Ex.PW1/3, respectively, showing the income of deceased as ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 5 of 27 -- 5 of 27 -- Rs.3,75,000/- as per ITR of assessment year 2022-23. iii). PW3 Sandeep S/o Sh. Anantpal was examined as eye-witness of the accident. PW3 deposed on the strength of his affidavit Ex.PW3/A and produced copy of his Aadhaar Card as Ex.PW3/1 (OSR) and relied upon copy of his statement recorded by the police as Ex.PW3/2 (original already on record). 8. No other witness was examined on behalf of the petitioners and respondents opted not to lead any evidence. 9. I heard the final arguments advanced by learned counsel for the parties and perused the evidence and other materials placed on record. My findings on the issues are as under: ISSUE NO. 1 Whether Mr. Gaurav S/o Sh. Subhash Chandra died due to injuries suffered in a motor vehicular accident occurred on 19.05.2023 at 11:00 p.m., at Flyover, Nand Nagri, Delhi, within the jurisdiction of PS Nand Nagri, due to rash and negligent driving of offending vehicle i.e. truck (LPT 1623) bearing registration no. DL1GE-0463, driven by respondent no.1/ Ashu? OPP. 10. It is the settled proposition of law that in an action founded on the principle of fault liability, the proof of rash and negligent driving of the offending vehicle is sine qua non. However, the standard of proof is not as strict as applied in criminal cases and evidence is to be tested on the touchstone of the preponderance of probabilities. Holistic view is to be taken while dealing with the Claim Petition based upon negligence. Strict rules of evidence are not applicable in an inquiry conducted by the Claims Tribunal. Reference may be ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 6 of 27 -- 6 of 27 -- made to the judgments titled as New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Sakshi Bhutani & Others., MAC APP. No. 550/2011 decided on 02.07.2012, Bimla Devi & Others v. Himachal Road Transport Corporation & Others (2009) 13 SC 530, Parmeshwari v. Amirchand & Others 2011 (1) SCR 1096 & Mangla Ram v. Oriental Ins. Co. Ltd. & Others 2018, Law Suit (SC) 303. 11. For deciding the issue in hand, the deposition of eye-witness PW3 Sandeep is relevant to be discussed here. PW3 deposed by way of his affidavit Ex.PW3/A that on 19.05.2023 at about 11:00 p.m., he was going to his house by his motorcycle and when he reached at Nand Nagri Flyover going towards Gagan Cinema from Bhajanpura, Wazirabad Road, within the jurisdiction of PS Nand Nagri, Delhi, a motorcycle bearing no. DL5SCK-1382 was going ahead of his motorcycle. In the meantime, he saw a truck bearing no. DL1GE-0463, which was being driven by its driver rashly, negligently and in zig-zag manner, overtook the motorcycle from its wrong side and ingressed in the lane of motorcycle and truck driver applied emergency brakes in front of the motorcycle without any indication or any dipper, due to which motorcycle rider rammed into the truck from the back side, due to which he fell down on the road and sustained grievous injuries. PW3 deposed that he stopped his motorcycle and the truck driver also got down from the truck and came at the spot. PW3 stated that he informed the police about the accident at 112 number and removed the injured to hospital in a private vehicle and also informed at the injureds’ house through his mobile phone and a neighbour namely Pradeep, whose name is ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 7 of 27 -- 7 of 27 -- mentioned on the MLC of the injured, came at the hospital and thereafter, he (PW3) went to his house. PW3 deposed that on the next day on 20.05.2023, police called him on his mobile phone and recorded his statement, which is Ex.PW3/2. PW3 categorically deposed that the accident was caused due to rash and negligent driving of the truck driver and had the truck driver been careful and cautious enough, this accident could have been averted. 12. The eye-witness PW3 was cross-examined at length by learned counsel for the insurance company. During cross-examination, PW3 replied that on the day of the accident on 19.05.2023, he was going to his house from Bhajanpura on his motorcycle and he left Bhajanpura market at about 10:30 p.m. PW3 stated that width of the road was about 30 feet and the road was two-lane one-way road and there was no divider on the road. The flyover which he was using to reach his house was Nand Nagri flyover and he was driving his vehicle on the left side of the road and there was no footpath on the road. In view of the above reply given by the eye-witness in his cross-examination, the reason of his being present at the spot at the time of accident is found believable because for going to his house at Pratap Nagar, Delhi from Bhajanpura, the use of Nand Nagri flyover is justified and further the description given by him regarding the width of the road (30 feet) and it being a two-lane one-way road with no divider also appears to be factually correct from Google map when the given description of the road is seen alone, though as per Google map, the Nand Nagri flyover is a two-way road with divider, however, its one side road on which the accident happened is one ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 8 of 27 -- 8 of 27 -- way 30 feet wide road with no divider. 13. PW3 in his cross-examination further explained the manner of accident by deposing that the offending truck overtook him from his right side and thereafter, it overtook the motorcycle of the victim from its left side and then suddenly applied the emergency brakes, due to which the motorcycle of victim strucked from its behind at the right side and after the accident, he stopped on the spot and called the police at 100 number and he saw the injured person and blood was oozing from his head. He specified that the victim’s bike struck from the back side of the offending truck, due to its emergency brakes applied by the truck driver. The front portion of the motorcycle was damaged. He stated that he left the spot to remove the injured to GTB Hospital by an auto. PW3 was given certain suggestions inter-alia that he is not the eye-witness of the accident or that he had not seen the number of the offending truck, however, PW3 promptly denied the said suggestions. 14. This is the argument of learned counsel for the insurance company that since the deceased was not maintaining a proper distance from the offending truck moving ahead, which was to be maintained mandatorily as per traffic rules between the two vehicles, there was contributory negligence on the part of the deceased. To buttress arguments, the learned counsel for the insurance company has relied upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of ‘Nishan Singh v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.’, (2018) 6 SCC 765. In this regard, the eye-witness (PW3) was put a question in his cross- ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 9 of 27 -- 9 of 27 -- examination that what was the distance between his/ PW3’s vehicle and offending vehicle and between victim vehicle and offending vehicle, to which PW3 replied that he was around 25-30 feet behind the motorcycle of victim and, in the meantime, truck from backside came and overtook his motorcycle and victim’s motorcycle and suddenly applied emergency brakes. The said manner of accident as explained by the eye-witness indicates that there was a reasonable distance between the victim’s vehicle and the offending vehicle but since the offending vehicle came from backside and overtook his motorcycle and victim’s motorcycle and suddenly applied emergency brakes, the accident happened. 15. It is not the case of the respondents that the deceased was under the influence of alcohol at the time when the accident in question happened. It is also not the case of the respondents that the motor- cycle on which the deceased was travelling had any mechanical defects i.e., its break system had failed, etc. but the important fact which has come in the cross-examination of PW3 is that the lights of the offending truck was not blinking. Though on the said part of the deposition have been volunteered by PW3 but as no cross- examination was done to the facts which was volunteered by the witness PW3, it has to be assumed that the respondents had no objection with respect to the facts which had been volunteered by PW3. Be that as it may, it has not been clarified by PW3 as which lights of the offending truck were not blinking, however, PW3 had volunteered the facts with respect to the question put by the learned counsel for respondent no.3/ insurance company with respect to how ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 10 of 27 -- 10 of 27 -- many lights were there at the back of the offending truck. 16. In the rear side of the vehicle, any light which blinks is the indicator light and the brake light when the brake pedal is pushed in succession. The mechanical inspection report of the offending vehicle clarifies the deposition of PW3 with respect to the lights of the offending truck not blinking. And from the mechanical inspection report of the offending truck which is at page no. 86 of the DAR, it is apparent that the taillight of left-side was broken and both the taillights were not working and therefore, from the deposition of PW3 regarding the lights of the offending truck not blinking, in all probability PW3 meant that the taillights of the offending vehicle did not blink when the sudden brakes were applied by the driver of the offending vehicle. 17. The time of the accident was about 11:00 p.m. i.e. it was night time. There is nothing on record to suggest as to what was the light condition at the spot of accident. But whatever may have been the light condition at the spot of accident at the time of the accident, one thing which is very clear is that during the night time, much less cues are available to the human eyes to ascertain whether something is moving or is stationary. The driver of the vehicle in whose front there is another vehicle during the night time ascertains the speed/motion of the vehicle through its taillight especially when there is darkness or the roadlights are not working properly. In most of the vehicle the taillight and the brake lights are interconnected i.e. when the brake pedal is pushed the taillight becomes much brighter ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 11 of 27 -- 11 of 27 -- which is an indication to the driver who is behind that in the vehicle in front, brakes have been applied or that the said vehicle is going to slow down or come to a standstill. That indication by change of the brightness in the brake lights is sufficient for the driver of the vehicle which is behind to moderate its speed. 18. If the taillights are not working, the drivers who are behind such vehicle would not come to know that the brakes have been applied or not and this appears to be the case what has led to the accident in question. 19. The offending vehicle, as iis taillights were not working when it slowed down because of whatever reasons including the fact that there was any speed breaker in front of the offending vehicle, the deceased could not have come to know about the fact that the brakes had been applied so that the deceased could have moderated the speed of his motor-cycle and the defective taillight in the present case has led to the accident in question. The rashness and negligence of the driver of the offending vehicle lied in the fact that the driver of the offending vehicle was negligent in not ascertaining whether the taillights of the offending vehicle was working properly or not and therefore, he was rash and negligent in driving the offending vehicle during the night time. It may also be noted in the factual scenario discussed herein above, the ratio of the judgment in Nishan Singh (supra) is not applicable. 20. From the entire evidence of eye-witness (PW3), this Tribunal finds nothing which may demolish his testimony on the aspect of rash and ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 12 of 27 -- 12 of 27 -- negligent act of respondent no.1 while driving the offending vehicle. Besides, nothing else is available on record which may suggest any falsity or untruth in the oral testimony of eye-witness. 21. Further, there is no challenge from the respondent no.1/ driver of the offending vehicle to the version of the eye-witness. The respondent no.1 was the best witness, who could have stepped into the witness box to challenge the testimony of the eye-witness (PW3) regarding the above accident and its manner but he preferred not to enter into the witness box during the course of inquiry. Thus, an adverse inference is liable to be drawn against him to the effect that the accident in question occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the offending vehicle by him in view of the law laid down in case of Cholamandalam M.S. General Insurance Company Ltd. v. Kamlesh, 2009(3) AD (Delhi) 310. 22. Furthermore, it is evident that FIR was registered after a few hours of the accident and registration number of the offending truck finds clear mention in the FIR. The seizure memos of the offending truck bearing no. DL1GE-0463 and the motorcycle of deceased bearing no. DL5SCK-1382 at page no. 32 and 34, respectively, of the DAR, clearly show that the same were taken into police possession in accidental condition from the spot of accident itself. The mechanical inspection report of the offending truck reflects the point of impact on its side showing rear bumper (left side) and bumper bracket damaged and tail light broken and not in working condition and further, the mechanical inspection report of the motorcycle of the ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 13 of 27 -- 13 of 27 -- deceased reflects the point of impact on its front portion showing head light, wizor, handle bars and indicators, etc, damaged. Such damages on the vehicles involved in the accident as well as the Site Plan (at page no. 82 of the DAR) are found ot have corroborated the version of the eye-witness with respect to the manner of accident. 23. It is not disputed that charge-sheet was filed against the driver of the offending vehicle/ respondent no.1 after detailed investigation and in case of motor vehicular accident claims, contents of charge sheet are corroborating the facts of the present case. 24. A perusal of the postmortem report, which is at page no. 111 to 112 of the DAR reflects that deceased Gaurav was observed to have sustained multiple antemortem injuries and cause of his death was combined effect of craniocerebral damages and shock consequent upon blunt force trauma/ surface impact to head and abdomen and all the injuries were noted to be antemortem in nature. 25. Thus, in the light of the above discussion and the evidence brought on record, it is held that the petitioners have been able to prove on the basis of the preponderance of probabilities that the accident had occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the offending vehicle by respondent no.1, which resulted into fatal injuries to deceased Gaurav. Issue no.1 is, accordingly, decided in favour of petitioners. ISSUE NO. 2 26. In view of the finding on issue no.1, petitioners herein are held entitled to get compensation, however, the quantum of compensation ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 14 of 27 -- 14 of 27 -- still needs to be adjudicated. Section 168 of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 enjoins upon the claim Tribunal to hold an inquiry into the claim to make an award determining the amount of compensation, which appears to be just and reasonable. As per settled law, compensation is not expected to be a windfall or a bonanza nor it should be pittances. A man is not compensated for the physical injury, he is compensated for the loss which he suffers as a result of that injury (Baker v. Willoughby (1970) AC 467 at page 492 per Lord Reid). COMPUTATION OF COMPENSATION 27. Section 168 of the Act enjoins the Claims Tribunal to hold an inquiry into the claim to make an award determining the amount of compensation which appears to be just and reasonable. It has to be borne in mind that the compensation is not expected to be a windfall or a bonanza nor it should be a pittance. 28. In Sarla Verma and Others v. Delhi Transport Corporation & Anr. (2009) 6 Supreme Court Cases 121, the relevant guidelines for compensation were laid down in death cases, which have been reiterated by the Constitution Bench of Hon’ble Supreme Court in a case titled as National Insurance Company vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. Decided on 31.10.2017, laying down the general principles for computation of compensation in death cases. The relevant paras of the judgment are reproduced here as under: “18. Basically only three facts need to be established by the claimants for assessing compensation in the case of death: (a) age of the deceased; ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 15 of 27 -- 15 of 27 -- (b) income of the deceased; and (c) the number of dependents. These issues to be determined by the Tribunal to arrive at the loss of dependency are: (i) additions/deductions to be made for arriving at the income; (ii) the deduction to be made towards the personal living expenses of the deceased; and iii) the multiplier to be applied with reference to the age of the deceased. If these determinations are standardized, there will be uniformity and consistency in the decisions. There will be lesser need for detailed evidence. It will also be easier for the insurance companies to settle accident claims without delay. 19. To have uniformity and consistency, the Tribunals should determine compensation in cases of death, by the following well-settled steps: Step-1 (Ascertaining the multiplicand) The income of the deceased per annum should be determined. Out of the said income, a deduction should be made in regard to the amount which the deceased would have spent on himself by way of personal and living expenses. The balance which is considered to be the contribution to the dependent family, constitutes the multiplicand. Step-2 (Ascertaining the multiplier) Having regard to the age of the deceased and period of active career, the appropriate multiplier should be selected. This does not mean ascertaining the number of years he would have lived or worked but for the accident. Having regard to several imponderables in life and economic factors, a table of multipliers with reference to the age has been identified by this Court. The multiplier should be chosen from the said table with reference to the age of the deceased. Step-3 (Actual Calculation) The annual contribution to the family (multiplicand) when multiplied by such multiplier gives the ‘loss of dependency’ to the family. Thereafter, a conventional amount in the range of Rs.5,000/- to Rs.10,000/- may be added as loss of estates. Where the deceased is survived by his widow, another conventional amount in the range of Rs.5,000 to Rs.10,000 should be added under the head of loss of consortium. But no amount is ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 16 of 27 -- 16 of 27 -- to be awarded under the head of pain, suffering or hardship caused to the legal heirs of the deceased. The funeral expenses, cost of transportation of the body (if incurred) and the cost of any medical treatment of the deceased before death (if incurred) should also be added.” In view of the aforesaid judgments, the compensation in the present case has to be ascertained as under: PECUNIARY DAMAGES: Age of deceased & Application of Multiplier 29. As per Secondary School Examination Certificate (Ex.PW1/1), PAN Card (Ex.PW1/2) and Aadhaar Card (Ex.PW1/3) of the deceased Gaurav, his date of birth was 20.10.1996. Accordingly, on the date of the accident (19.05.2023), the deceased was 26 years of age. Accordingly, the multiplier of 17 shall be applicable as the deceased belonged to the age group 26-30 years (refer: Sarla Verma v. DTC (2009) 6 SCC 121. Assessment of Income of deceased 30. PW2 Sh. Ram Niwas Meena, the concerned Income Tax Inspector has produced the ITRs filed on behalf of the assessee Gaurav (deceased herein) for the assessment years 2021-22 and 2022-23 and proved the same as Ex.PW2/2 and Ex.PW2/3, respectively. The accident happened on 19.05.2023 and therefore, the relevant ITR for assessing the income of deceased would be the ITR of assessment year 2022-23, which has been proved on record by PW2 as Ex.PW2/3. There is nothing on record to discredit the above- mentioned ITR nor the same has been challenged by the respondents in cross-examination. In this regard, reliance can be placed upon the ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 17 of 27 -- 17 of 27 -- case titled Malarvizhi & Ors. v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd. & Ors. (2020) 4 SCC 228, wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court observed as under: “10……. We are in agreement with the High Court that the determination must proceed on the basis of the income tax returns, where available. The income tax return is a statutory document on which reliance may be placed to determine the annual income of the deceased.” 31. The income of the deceased, therefore, can be taken as per ITR of the assessment year 2022-23, which reflects the annual total gross income of the deceased as Rs.3,75,000/- and the total tax paid as Rs.27,953/-, however, the said paid income tax has been shown ‘refundable’ and therefore, the tax payable comes to zero. After deduction of tax (zero), the net annual income is computed as Rs.3,75,000/-. Thus, the income of the deceased is assessed as Rs.3,75,000/- per annum. Future Prospects 32. The deceased, who was aged 26 years at the time of accident, can be considered a self-employed as per the ITRs produced on record. Being below 40 years of age, an addition of 40% to the income of the deceased has to be considered towards future prospects (refer: National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi and Ors). Deduction towards Personal Living Expenses 33. There are four petitioners in the present case, who are parents and two brothers of the deceased. However, it has nowhere been claimed by the petitioners that the deceased was married. Therefore, ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 18 of 27 -- 18 of 27 -- considering the deceased unmarried, half of his income has to be deducted towards his personal living expenses [(refer: as Reshma Kumari & Ors. v. Madan Mohan & Anr., (2013) 9 SCC 65]. Loss of Dependency: 34. In view of the settled guidelines as laid down in the various judgments herein above, in this case, by adding 40% future prospects to the income of deceased and making half deduction therefrom towards personal expenses of the deceased and then applying the multiplier of 17 thereto, the loss of dependency is computed as Rs.44,62,500/- (3,75,000x140/100x1/2x17). NON-PECUNIARY DAMAGES 35. In the light of the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court, dated 31.10.2017, in case of National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi and Ors. (AIR 2017 SC 5157), a compensation of Rs.40,000/-, 15,000/- and Rs.15,000/- respectively has been fixed on account of loss of consortium, loss of estate and funeral expenses and further, it is required to be enhanced @ 10% in every three years. 36. The accident in this case occurred on 19.05.2023, therefore, a compensation of Rs.44,000/-, Rs.16,500/- and Rs.16,500/- respectively on account of loss of consortium, loss of estate and funeral expenses is required to be granted. Further, in view of the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case titled as United India Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Satinder Kaur @ Satwinder Kaur & Ors., Civil Appeal no. 2705 of 2020, decided on 30.06.2020, petitioner no.1 and 2 being parents of the deceased shall be entitled to filial ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 19 of 27 -- 19 of 27 -- consortium. Hence, the following amounts are awarded under the conventional heads: S. No. Conventional Head Amount 1. Loss of Filial Consortium Rs.88,000/- (44,000x2) 2. Loss of Estate Rs.16,500/- 3. Funeral Expenses Rs.16,500/- Total = Rs.1,21,000/- 37. Thus, the compensation under this head comes to Rs.1,21,000/-. 38. Accordingly, the total compensation comes to Rs.45,83,500/- (44,62,500+1,21,000/-). INTEREST ON AWARD 39. The petitioners shall also be entitled to the interest on the award amount @ 7% from the date of filing of the DAR/ claim petition till realization. LIABILITY 40. Now, the question arises as to which of the respondents is liable to pay the compensation amount. The insurance company has contractual and statutory liability to indemnify the insured and in this case, the insurance company has not been able to prove on record that any term or condition of insurance policy was breached/ violated by insured. Therefore, respondent no.3/ insurance company is held liable to pay the aforesaid compensation amount. RELIEF 41. In the light of the decision on substantive issues framed the present ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 20 of 27 -- 20 of 27 -- claim petition is allowed and the following award is being passed: AWARD 42. This Tribunal awards a compensation of Rs.45,83,500/- (Rs. Forty Five Lakhs Eighty Three Thousand Five Hundred Only) to the petitioners along with interest @ 7% per annum from the date of filing of DAR/ claim petition till realization to be paid by the respondent no.3/ insurance company. The interim compensation, if any, shall be adjusted against this award amount along with the waiver of interest, if any, as directed by the Tribunal during the pendency of this case. 43. Respondent no.3/ insurance company is directed to deposit the award amount in A/c no.20780110171912 (IFSC Code UCBA0002078), UCO Bank, Karkardooma, Delhi, of PO MACT, Shahdara, through RTGS/ NEFT, within 30 days from today. Entitlement, Apportionment and Disbursement 44. The petitioners in this case are the parents and brothers of the deceased. As per decision in case of Sarla Verma & Ors. vs. DTC & Anr., (2009) 6 SCC 121, Father cannot be considered dependent on his deceased son in absence of any evidence to the effect that he was unemployed or incapable to earn on account of illness, etc. In this case, PW1 (father of deceased), aged 52 years, in his cross- examination has deposed that previously, he was working as Electrician and presently, he is not working anywhere and is dependent upon his sons, whereas, in the same cross-examination, he further stated that his son Rohit is pursuing B.A. and his other son ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 21 of 27 -- 21 of 27 -- Saurabh is not working anywhere. Thus, the deposition of the father of the deceased with respect to he being presently dependent upon his sons, when as per him, one of his sons is studying and another is working, cannot be believed and further, considering the admission of father of deceased that he was previously working as Electrician, he cannot be considered dependent upon the deceased and shall not be entitled to the compensation, however, he shall be entitled to the consortium amount only. It is settled law that if parents are alive, the siblings cannot be considered depandent upon the deceased brother and consequently, the petitioner no.3 and 4 (brothers of the deceased) shall also not be entitled to any compensation. Thus, the petitioner no.1 i.e. the mother of the deceased shall only be entitled to the entire compensation amount. 45. Accordingly, the award amount of Rs. 45,83,500/- along with interest thereon shall be shared by the petitioners in the following manner: S. No Name of the Petitioner Age (Present Age) Relation with Deceased Share in the Award Amount 1 Pushpa Devi 48 years Mother Rs.45,39,500/- along with the interest on entire award amount. 2 Subhash Chandra 50 years Father Rs.44,000/- along with the corresponding interest 46. Manager, UCO Bank, Karkardooma, Delhi is directed that after the deposit of the award amount, a sum of Rs.5,39,500/- along with the corresponding interest shall be forthwith released to the petitioner no.1 Pushpa Devi by way of transferring the said amount into her ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 22 of 27 -- 22 of 27 -- MACT Saving Bank Account and the balance award amount of Rs.40,00,000/- along with the corresponding interest thereon shall be kept secured with UCO Bank, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi in MACAD (Motor Accident Claims Annuity Deposit) in the form of 120 monthly FDRs (Fixed Deposit Receipts) to be prepared in her name, payable to her for a period of 1 to 120 months in succession, as per the scheme formulated by Hon'ble Delhi High Court vide order dated 07.12.2018 in FAO No. 8433/2003, titled as Rajesh Tyagi & Others v. Jaibir Singh & Others. The amount of aforesaid FDRs on maturity would be released in MACT saving bank account of the petitioner no.1 without any further order to that effect. 47. Further, Manager, UCO Bank, Karkardooma is directed that entire share of petitioner no.2 amounting to Rs.44,000/- along with the corresponding interest shall be released forthwith to him by way of transferring the said amount into his MACT Saving Bank Account. Direction to Petitioner(s) & their Bank(s) 48. The claimant(s) is/ are directed to get opened saving bank accounts near the place of their residence. The Bank of claimant(s) is/ are directed to comply with the following conditions: (a) The bank shall not permit any joint name(s) to be added in the savings bank account or fixed deposit accounts of the claimant(s) i.e., the savings bank account(s) of the claimant(s) shall be an individual savings bank account(s) and not a joint account(s). (b) The original fixed deposit shall be retained by the bank in safe custody. However, the statement containing FDR number, FDR amount, date of maturity and maturity amount shall be furnished by the bank to the claimant(s). (c) The monthly interest be credited by Electronic Clearing System (ECS) in the savings bank account of the claimant(s) near the place ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 23 of 27 -- 23 of 27 -- of their residence. (d) The maturity amounts of the FDR(s) be credited by Electronic Clearing System (ECS) in the savings bank account of the claimant(s) near the place of their residence. (e) No loan, advance, withdrawal or premature discharge be allowed on the fixed deposits without permission of the Court. (f) The concerned bank shall not issue any cheque book and/or debit card to claimant(s). However, in case the debit card and/or cheque book have already been issued, bank shall cancel the same before the disbursement of the award amount. The bank shall debit card(s) freeze the account of the claimant(s) so that no debit card be issued in respect of the account of the claimant(s) from any other branch of the bank. (g) The bank shall make an endorsement on the passbook of the claimant(s) to the effect that no cheque book and/or debit card have been issued and shall not be issued without the permission of the Court and claimant(s) shall produce the passbook with the necessary endorsement before the Court on the next date fixed for compliance. 49. As per ‘The Central Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989 (Annexure-XIII), the relevant Forms to be incorporated in the award are as under: FORM - XV SUMMARY OF COMPUTATION OF AWARD AMOUNT IN DEATH CASES TO BE INCORPORATED IN THE AWARD 1. Date of accident : 19.05.2023 2. Name of the deceased : Gaurav 3. Age of the deceased : 26 years 4. Occupation of the deceased : Self employed 5. Income of the deceased : Rs.3,75,000/- per annum 6. Name, age and relationship of legal representatives of deceased: S. No Name of the Petitioner Age (Present Age) Relation with Deceased 1 Pushpa Devi 48 years Mother 2 Subhash Chandra 50 years Father ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 24 of 27 -- 24 of 27 -- Computation of Compensation S. No. Heads Awarded by the Claims Tribunal 7. Income of the deceased (A) Rs.3,75,000/- pe annum 8. Add-Future Prospects (B) @ 40% Rs.1,50,000/- 9. Less- Personal expenses of the deceased (C) @ 50% Rs.2,62,000/- 10. Annual loss of dependency [(A+B)-C = D] Rs.2,62,000/- 11. Multiplier (E) 17 12. Total loss of dependency (Dx12xE = F) Rs.44,62,500/- 13. Medical Expenses (G) Nil 14. Compensation for loss of consortium (H) (44,000x2) Rs.88,000/- 15. Compensation for loss of love and affection (I) -- 16. Compensation for loss of estate (J) Rs.16,500/- 17. Compensation towards funeral expenses (K) Rs.16,500/- 18. TOTAL COMPENSATION (F+G+H+I+J+K = L) Rs.45,83,500/- 19. RATE OF INTEREST AWARDED 7% 20. Interest amount up to the date of award (M) (for one year, 06 months & 18 days) Rs.4,97,310/- 21. Total amount including interest (L+M) Rs.50,80,810/- 22. Award amount released Rs.5,83,500/- along with interest on this amount 23. Award amount kept in FDRs Rs.40,00,000/- along with interest on this amount 24. Mode of disbursement of the award amount to the claimants (s). Bank transfer 25. Next Date for compliance of the award. 01.02.2025 ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 25 of 27 -- 25 of 27 -- FORM – XVII COMPLIANCE OF THE PROVISIONS OF THE SCHEME TO BE MENTIONED IN THE AWARD 1 Date of Accident 19.05.2023 2 Date of filing of Form-I- First Accident Report (FAR) Not available 3 Date of delivery of Form-II to the victim(s) Not available 4 Date of receipt of Form-III from the Driver Not available 5 Date of receipt of Form-IV from the Owner Not available 6 Date of filing of the Form-V- Interim Accident Report (IAR) Not available 7 Date of receipt of Form-VI- and Form-VIA from the victims(s) Not available 8 Date of filing of Form-VII- Detailed Accident Report (DAR) Not available 9 Whether there was any delay or deficiency on the part of the Investigating Officer? If so, whether any action/ direction warranted? No 10 Date of appointment of the Designated Officer by the Insurance Company Not available 11 Whether the Designated Officer of the Insurance Company submitted his report within thirty (30) days of the DAR? No 12 Whether there was any delay or deficiency on the part of the Designated Officer of the Insurance Company? If so, whether any action/ direction warranted? No 13 Date of response of the claimant(s) to the offer of the Insurance Company Legal offer not filed 14 Date of Award 17.12.2024 15 Whether the claimant(s) were directed to open saving bank account(s) near the place of residence? Yes 16 Whether the claimant(s) were directed to open Yes ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 26 of 27 -- 26 of 27 -- saving bank account(s) near his place of residence and produce PA861/-N Card and Aadhaar Card and the direction to the bank to not issue any cheque book/ debit card to the claimant(s) and make an endorsement to this effect on the passbook. 17 Date on which the claimant(s) produced the passbook of their saving bank account near the place of their residence along with the endorsement, PAN Card and Aadhaar Card? To be produced at the time of compliance of award 18 Permanent Residential Address of the claimant(s) J-46, Jawahar Park, Sahibabad, Ghaziabad, U.P. 19 Whether the claimant(s) saving bank account(s) is near his place of residence? Direction given 20 Whether the claimant(s) were examined at the time of passing of the award to ascertain his/her/ their financial condition? No 50. The claim petition is accordingly disposed of. File be consigned to Record Room. Announced in the open (VIJAY KUMAR JHA) Court on 17.12.2024 Presiding Officer-MACT (Shahdara) Karkardooma Courts, Delhi ______________________________________________________________________ MACT no. 308/2023 Pushpa Devi & Ors. v. Ashu & Ors. Page 27 of 27 -- 27 of 27 --
