Full Order Text
Order 13 · 11 Sept 2025 · CNR DLSH010030052024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: 1 Manish Kumar Vs. Ravinder Kumar and ors. CT Case No. 05/2024 11.09.2025 Present: Complainant with Ld. counsel. ORDER ON THE APPLICATI ON UNDER SECTION 156(3) CR.P.C. OF THE COMPlAINANT. 1. This order shall disposed of the application under Section 156 (3) Cr. PC filed by the complainant Manish Kumar alongwith the complaint under section 200 Criminal procedure code (Cr. P.C.) alleging commission of offence under section 506 Indian Penal Act (IPC) and under Section 3(s) of Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes (prevention of atrocities) Act , 1989 (hereinafter referred as SC/ST Act) against proposed accused persons. 2. By way of application in hand, complainant is seeking directions to the concerned police official(s) to register the FIR against the proposed accused persons. 3. The complainant belongs to the Scheduled Caste category and is employed as a contractual conductor with DTC, was posted at Nand Nagri Depot at the time of the alleged incident. He has stated that on 14.01.2024, while he was on duty and waiting in the control room for his bus to arrive, proposed accused no.1, Ravinder Kumar, entered the control room in a drunken condition and began conversing with the duty officer, Sh. Kanhiya Jha. During this conversation, Ravinder Kumar allegedly stated that his -- 1 of 9 -- 2 friend, Pankaj Tomar, was soon joining as ‘Regional Manager’ and, after his joining, he would ensure that the jobs of three depot’s contract servicemen be terminated. The duty officer and other clerks present in the control room were witnessing this conversation. Suddenly, Ravinder Kumar started misbehaving with the complainant by hurling abuses and addressing him with casteist remarks, repeatedly calling him “chamar.” In the meantime, proposed accused no.2 Parvesh also entered the control room in drunken condition and started abusing the complainant. Proposed accused Ravinder further threatened to kill the complainant and to falsely implicate him in a rape case. It is alleged that the entire incident took place in the presence of the duty officer, Kanhiya Jha, and one Richanshu Sharma. The complainant immediately made a call to the emergency helpline number 112 registered vide DD No. 76A, and subsequently made a complaint dated 15.01.2024 registered vide DD No. 45A at Police Station Nand Nagri. However, no action was taken by the police on either of these complaints. Hence, the present complaint under Section 200 Cr.P.C. along with the instant application under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. has been filed. 4. On receipt of the complaint, on the directions of Ld. Predecessor, action taken report (ATR) was filed by the concerned ACP along with detailed statements of Sh. Kanhaiya Jha and Richanshu Sharma in whose presence, as per complainant castiest remarks were used by the proposed accused persons against him. Perusal of their statements -- 2 of 9 -- 3 show that at the time of incident, Sh. Kanhaiya Jha was duty officer in the depot and Richanshu Sharma was conductor; both of them have confirmed the occurrence only to the extent of altercation between complainant and proposed accused Ravinder Kumar, but they stated that no castiest remarks were used by the proposed accused persons against the complainant. ACP has confirmed receiving of call at 112 number registered vide DD No. 76A dated 14.01.2024 at 22:24 hours, another DD no.4A on 15.01.2024 at 01:03 hours, written police compliant registered vide DD No. 45 A regarding incident, by the complainant. It is mentioned in the ATR that DD No. 76A was filed since the complainant did not pursue it till 15.01.2024 (next day of incident) by 5.P.M. The concerned ACP has reported that FIR was not registered since the complaint was not disclosing the commission of cognizable offence. 5. Ld. counsel for complainant has argued that the police complaints filed by the complainant clearly discloses commission of cognizable offence despite that no FIR was registered by the police. He submits that preliminary enquiry is not permissible in the cases involving SC/ST Act and conducting such inquiry is in contravention of section 18A of the SC/ST Act. He drawn attention of the court on the photocopy of relevant entry of register of duty officer Kanihya Jha, wherein he has recorded the incident including the using derogatory casteist remarks by the proposed accused persons against the complainant. He also submits that Sh. Kanhiya and Richanshu Sharma have also signed the -- 3 of 9 -- 4 complainant’s police complaint dated 15.01.2024 wherein he specifically complained regarding use of casteist remarks against him by the proposed accused persons. 6. I have considered the arguments advanced by the Ld. Counsel of complainant and perused the record. 7. This court finds no force in the argument of complainant that primarily inquiry is not permissible under the Act since in Avdesh VS. O.P. Singh criminal appeal no.7557/2019 decided on 05.01.2022, the Hon’ble Apex Court has held that preliminary inquiry is not barred under the Act and action taken report cannot be equated with preliminary inquiry. The relevant portion of the judgement is reproduced as under: - “ 22…….A plain reading of section 18A(1)(a) of SC/ST Act makes it clear that preliminary enquiry shall not be required for registration of an FIR against any person. In other words, preliminary enquiry is not a prerequisite for registration of a FIR. The aforesaid provision empowers the concerned Police Officer to register an FIR without preliminary enquiry. Section 18A(1)(a) does not bar a preliminary enquiry. The Police Officer concerned may, in his discretion, conduct a preliminary enquiry if the nature and tenor of the complaint so requires. Subsection (b) of Section 18A(1) empowers the Investigating Officer to arrest any person against whom an accusation of committing an offence under the SC/ST Act has been made, without obtaining approval for arrest, if the arrest of such person is necessary. The enabling provisions of Section 18A(1) are not to be construed as a bar on preliminary enquiry or a mandate to arrest every person against whom an accusation of having committed an offence under the SC/ST Act is made. The power to arrest may be exercised without approval for the arrest only if such arrest is necessary. Similarly, an FIR may be registered without a preliminary enquiry. There is no bar on -- 4 of 9 -- 5 holding a preliminary enquiry, or obtaining an approval before arresting a person. The High Court, in exercise of its extraordinary jurisdiction under Articles 226 or 227 of the Constitution of India or its inherent jurisdiction under section 482 of the Cr.P.C., 1973 to prevent the abuses of the process of any Court or otherwise to secure the ends of justice, does not interfere with proceedings under the SC/ST Act on the sole ground that a preliminary enquiry had been held or on the ground that an arrest had been made after obtaining approval. Moreover, section 18A of the SC/ST Act has no application to proceedings under section 156(3) of the Cr.P.C., 1973 in a Court of law. 23. In any case, the High Court has very rightly held that calling for an ATR cannot be equated to directing an inquiry or even preliminary enquiry.” 8. With regard to the powers of the court to direct registeration of FIR under section 156(3) Cr.P.C, the law is well settled that court is empowered to verify the veracity of the complaint to ensure that it has not been filed with oblique motive to harass a person and to settle personal scores. Verification of complainant’s assertion is necessary, to assess not only the disclosure of commission of cognizable offence but also to rule out the possibility of harassment by unscrupulous litigant to innocents. The directions to register a FIR has serious consequences and may lead to curtail somebody’s personal liberty as well, therefore, action taken reports filed by the police cannot be brushed aside lightly especially when it is not filed in routine but contains important aspects of the matter. 9. In Kartar Singh & Anr. Vs. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi) & Ors. 265 (2019) Delhi Law Times 559, Hon'ble Delhi High Court held that the direction under Section -- 5 of 9 -- 6 156(3) Cr.P.C. is to be issued only after application of mind by the Magistrate. 10. In Anjuri Kumari Vs. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi) & Ors., 2023: DHC: 8544, Hon’ble Delhi High Court observed that the Magistrate is not bound to direct investigation by the police even if all allegations made in the complaint disclose ingredients of a cognizable offence. Relevant observations regarding the same are extracted as under: " 17. In view of the discussions mentioned hereinabove, I am of the view that the directions for investigation under Section 156(3) of the Code cannot be given by the Magistrate mechanically. Such a direction can be given only on application of mind by the Magistrate, who is not bound to direct investigation by the police even if all allegations made in the complaint disclose ingredients of a cognizable offence. Each case has to be viewed depending upon the facts and circumstances involved therein. In the facts and circumstances of a given case, the Magistrate may take a decision that the complainant can prove the facts alleged in the complaint without the assistance of the police. In such cases, the Magistrate may proceed with the complaint u/s 200 of the Code and examine witnesses produced by the complainant. The Magistrate ought to direct investigation by the police if the evidence is required to be collected with the assistance of the police. In the present case, all the facts and evidence are within the knowledge of the petitioner, which he can adduce during the inquiry conducted by the learned Magistrate u/s 200 of the Code." 11. Refrence to the decision in Alok Kumar Vs. Harsh Mander & Anr., 2023: DHC:5045, by Hon’ble Delhi Court is also relevant here, wherein court categorically encapsulated the pre-conditions while directing registration of FIR under Section 156(3) Cr. PC. For the sake of brevity, -- 6 of 9 -- 7 relevant portion is extracted as under:- 40. To summarise, a conspectus of the above- mentioned judicial precedents reveal the following: (i) Power u/s 156(3) Cr.P.C. necessitates application of judicial mind. (ii) Such power is to be exercised in a judicious manner, and cannot be exercised mechanically or arbitrarily. (iii) Magistrates cannot direct registration of FIR on mere asking of complainant. 12. Adverting to the facts of the present case:- the complainant has alleged that the proposed accused persons used casteist remarks against him and also intimidated him, but no action was taken by the police on his complaints. According to the complainant, the entire incident occurred in the presence of duty officer Kanhiya and one Richanshu Sharma. Action Taken Report filed by the concerned ACP is supported with the statements of both Kanhiya and Richanshu Sharma, who confirmed that an altercation did take place between the complainant and the proposed accused persons, but they specifically denied that any casteist remarks were used by the proposed accused in their presence. It is further noted that the duty officer Kanhiya has stated that the entry made in the duty register regarding the incident was made only at the instance of the complainant. The Court is of the considered view that if both these witnesses have disclosed about the altercation, there is no plausible reason why they would have withheld disclosure of casteist remarks, had such remarks in fact been made in their presence. -- 7 of 9 -- 8 13. Furthermore, on perusal of contents of the complaint, it is found that the entire evidence is within the reach of the complainant. In Mona Panwar vs. High Court of Judicature of Allahabad [2011] 3 SCC 496, Hon'ble Supreme Court in para No.23 held as under: “…..If on reading of a complaint the Magistrate finds that the allegations therein disclose a cognizable offence and forwarding of the complaint to the police for investigation under Section 156(3) of the Code will not be conducive to justice, he will be justified in adopting the course suggested in Section 200 of the Code”. 14. In the case of M/s Skipper Beverages Pvt. Ltd. vs. State, 2001 IV AD (Delhi), it was held by the Hon’ble Court that:- “ A Magistrate must apply his mind before passing an order under Section 156(3) Cr. P.C. and must not pass these orders mechanically on the mere asking by the complainant. These powers ought to be exercised primarily in those cases where the allegations are quite serious or evidence is beyond the reach of the complainant or custodial interrogation appears to be necessary for some recovery of articles or discovery of facts.” 15. On reading of complaint in hand, it is clear that complainant herein is well acquainted with the entire factual matrix of the present case and is in possession of all the evidence surrounding the same. Suffice it to state that he can prove his complaint by examining witnesses, in presence of whom, the respondents had allegedly threatened him and uttered castiest remarks against him. Moreover, there seems to be no requirement of custodial interrogation in the present -- 8 of 9 -- 9 matter as nothing is to be recovered. Further, if required at later stage, any kind of fair recourse to Section 202 Cr. PC can be taken. 16. In view of above discussion, I do not find, this case fit for issuing direction for registration of FIR u/s 156(3) Cr.P.C. As a result, the application u/s 156(3) Cr. PC stands dismissed. However, this court is inclined to grant an opportunity to the complainant to lead pre-summoning evidence. Put up for pre-summoning evidence on 19.12.2025. (Charu Aggarwal) ASJ-02/E-Court/Shahdara KKD/Delhi/11.09.2025 -- 9 of 9 --
