Full Order Text
Final Order 5 · 05 Aug 2023 · CNR DLSH010028822023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. REETESH SINGH, DISTRICT JUDGE COMMERCIAL COURT-04, SHAHDARA, KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI CNR No. DLSH01-0088D-2023 EX. (Comm) No. 130/2023 In the matter of :- M/s HDB Financial Services Ltd. Having Its Registered Office at: Radhika, Second Floor, Law Garden Road, Navrangpura,Ahmedabad-380009, Gujrat and Branch/Lending Office at: Khasra No.47, 2nd Floor Wing Opp Dussehra Ground Budella, Near Oxford School, Vikas Puri, New Delhi. Through its Authorized Representative Mr. Amit Sharma ......Decree Holder Through Sh. Saurav Tyagi, Ld. Counsel) VERSUS Babu Lal Meena, S/o Lala Ram Meena R/o B-89 Type 11 Telecoms Staff Quarters Vivek Vihar Delhi-110095 ----Judgment Debtor O R D E R 05.08.2023 1. This execution application has been filed by Decree Holder praying for execution of an ex-parte arbitral award dated 25.06.2022 passed by Sh. Sanjay Aggarwal, the Ld. Sole Arbitrator appointed by Decree Holder. By the said award, the Ld. Arbitrator has found the Decree Holder to be entitled to recovery of Rs. 4,84,226/- (Rupees Four Lakh Eighty Four Thousand Two Hundred Twenty Six Only) along with interest @ 18% with effect from 19.04.2022 till the date of realization and costs of Rs. 10,000/- from the Judgment Debtor. Ex. (Comm) No. 130/23 1 /4 -- 1 of 4 -- 2. The Hon’ble Division Bench of the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in the case of Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. Vs. Narender Kumar Prajapat EFA (COMM) 3/2023 decided on 17.05.2023 (Neutral Citation No: 2023: DHC: 3705-DB) has been pleased to hold that an arbitration award rendered by a person who is ineligible to act as an Arbitrator under Section 12 (5) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter referred to as the said Act) is a nullity and therefore cannot be enforced. In view of the ratio laid down by the Hon'ble High Court in the said case this Court vide orders dated 08.07.2023, 17.07.2023 and 28.07.2023 granted an opportunity to the Decree Holder to make submissions regarding the enforceability of the award under execution. 3. Sh. Sh. Saurav Tyagi, Ld. Proxy Counsel for the Decree Holder has submitted that a similar question as decided in the case of Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. Vs. Narender Kumar Prajapat (supra) is pending before the Hon'ble Constitution Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court and as such the judgment of the Hon'ble High Court is yet to attain finality. 4. I have heard the Ld. Counsel for the Decree Holder and have perused the record of the execution application. In the case of Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. Vs. Narender Kumar Prajapat (Supra) the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi had considered an appeal against an order dated 23.11.2022 of the Ld. Commercial Court which had rejected an application of the appellant (before the Hon'ble High Court) for enforcement of an ex-parte arbitral award passed by Sole Arbitrator. The Ld. Commercial Court had found that the arbitral award had been rendered ex-parte by an Arbitrator who had been appointed ‘unilaterally’ by the Decree Holder/appellant without any recourse or consent of the Judgment Debtor/respondent in violation of the provisions of Section 12(5) of the Act. In such circumstances, as the award was rendered by an ineligible person, the same was a nullity and could not be enforced. The Hon'ble High Court by order dated 17.05.2023 dismissed the said Ex. (Comm) No. 130/23 2 /4 -- 2 of 4 -- appeal and upheld the findings of the Ld. Commercial Court. The Hon'ble High Court was pleased to observe as under: - "13. The Learned Commercial Court has held that an award rendered by a person who is ineligible to act as an Arbitrator by virtue of the provisions of Sections 12(5) of the A & C Act is a nullity and, therefore, cannot be enforced. It has accordingly dismissed the enforcement petition under Section 36 of the A&C Act with the cost quantified as Rs. 25,000/-. 14. This court finds no infirmity with the aforesaid view. A person who is ineligible to act an Arbitrator, lacks the inherent jurisdiction to render an Arbitral Award under the A& C Act. It is trite law that a decision, by any authority, which lacks inherent jurisdiction to make such a decision, cannot be considered as valid. Thus, clearly, such an impugned award cannot be enforced." 5. The Hon'ble High Court while dismissing the appeal in the case of Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. Vs. Narender Kumar Prajapat (Supra) was pleased to refer to the following case law: - (a) TRF Ltd. V. Energo Engineering Projects Ltd. reported in (2017) 8 SCC 377 - in which the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that once an Arbitrator becomes ineligible by operation of law, he cannot nominate another as an Arbitrator; (b) Perkins Eastman Architects DPC & Anr. V. HSCC (India) Ltd. reported in (2020) 20 SCC 760 - in which following the decision in TRF Ltd. (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that a person who has an interest in the outcome of the dispute must not have the power to appoint a Sole Arbitrator and that a Chairman- cum-Managing Director of a party was ineligible to appoint an Arbitrator; (c) Proddatur Cable TV Digi Services V. Siti Cable Network Limited reported in (2020) 267 DLT 51- in which it was held that it is not permissible for a party to unilaterally appoint an Arbitrator without the consent of the other party; (d) Bharat Broadband Network Limited V. United Telecoms Limited reported in (2019) 5 SCC 755- in which it was held that where the Arbitrator is unable to perform his function, being ineligible under section 12 (5) of the Act, the appointment of the Arbitrator itself was illegal; waiver of a right to object to ineligibility of an arbitrator under Section 12(5) of the A&C Act cannot be inferred by conduct of a party; such waiver can only be by an express agreement in writing subsequent to disputes having arisen; the expression 'express agreement in writing' refers to an agreement made in words as opposed to an agreement which is to be inferred by conduct; and (e) HRD Corporation V. GAIL (INDIA) Ltd.: (2018) 12 SCC 471 and Govind Singh Vs. M/S Satya Group Pvt Ltd & Anr.: 2023/DHC/000081 – in which it was held that as ineligibility goes Ex. (Comm) No. 130/23 3 /4 -- 3 of 4 -- to the root of the matter, an award rendered by an Arbitrator who is ineligible to be appointed cannot be enforced. 6. It had been submitted on behalf of the Decree Holder that a simi- lar question was pending before the Hon'ble Constitution Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court and thus the judgment of the Hon'ble High Court in the case of Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. Vs. Narender Kumar Prajapat had not attained finality. The said submission has no merit as there is no order produced on behalf of the Decree Holder by which the judgment of the Hon'ble High Court or the ratio laid down in the same has been stayed. This court being a subordinate court is bound by the judgment of the Hon'ble High Court. 7. In the present case the Decree Holder had appointed Sh. Sanjay Aggarwal as the Sole Arbitrator. His appointment was unilateral. The Ld. Arbitrator proceeded ex-parte against the Judgment Debtor and rendered an ex-parte award. There is nothing to indicate that the Judgment Debtor had, by an express agreement in writing and subsequent to disputes having arisen waived his right to object to the ineligibility of the Ld. Sole Arbitrator unilaterally appointed by the Decree Holder. Such unilat- eral appointment of the Ld. Sole Arbitrator by the Decree Holder made without consent of the Judgment Debtor, in violation of the provisions of Section 12(5) of the Act, rendered him de jure ineligible to act as an Ar- bitrator. As the award has been passed by an ineligible person, the same is a nullity and cannot be enforced. 8. Hence for the reasons recorded above this execution application is dismissed. File be consigned to the Record Room. Announced in the open (REETESH SINGH) court on this 5th day DISTRICT JUDGE of August 2023 (COMMERCIAL COURT)-04 SHAHDARA, KKD COURTS, DELHI Ex. (Comm) No. 130/23 4 /4 -- 4 of 4 --
