Full Order Text
Final Order 2 · 15 May 2023 · CNR DLSH010027672023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: RCA 51/23 Shakuntala Gupta & Ors v. BSES YPL 15.05.2023 File taken up today on application seeking preponement of date by non-applicant Nitu Kumari. Present : Ms. Pooja Pandey, Ld. Counsel for appellants. Mr. H.S.Kumar, Ld. Counsel for non-applicant Nitu Kumari. Considering the exigencies shown on behalf of Ld. Counsel for appellants the request seeking preponement of date stands allowed. The file is taken up for consideration on joint request. The appeal is at the initial stage. By way of this appeal, Appellants have challenged the Order dated 11.04.2023 passed by Ld. ASCJ (Shahdara), Karkardooma, by virtue of which, the plaint of the Appellants under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC has been rejected. 2. Ld. Counsel for Appellants at the outset submits that appellants / plaintiffs – senior citizens are the owners of property No.5/357, Mohalla Maharam, Shahdara. They had applied for new electricity connection in the month of June 2019 and Respondent – BSES provided new electricity connection to them. Ld. Counsel refers to a Notice dated 05.01.2023 sent to Appellants by Respondent No.1 w.r.t. disconnection of electricity connection. It is submitted that on receipt of said notice, Appellants filed a Civil Suit CS 28/2023 against the alleged illegal disconnection and an ad-interim injunction was granted to RCA 51/23, Shakuntala Gupta & Ors v. BSES YPL Page No.1 of 7 -- 1 of 7 -- appellants on the condition that appellants would approach the Respondent No.2 for Completion Certificate. 3. Ld. Counsel submits that Appellants had moved an application dated 14.01.2023 with the office of Respondent and also approached the Respondent No.2 – MCD on 11.01.2023 by moving an application for completion of Building Certificate. It is submitted that without considering submissions, ld. trial court dismissed the interim application of appellants on 10.02.2023. Ld. Counsel submits that Order dated 10.02.2023 was challenged before Appellate Court of Ld. ADJ-01 where appellants obtained stay order till next date i.e. uptil 27.04.2023 and the trial court record was requisitioned by Appellate Court. Ld. Counsel submits that in the meanwhile on 11.04.2023, Ld. ASCJ dismissed the suit of Appellants under Order 7 rule 11 CPC. 4. While assailing the impugned Order dated 11.04.2023, Ld. Counsel Ms. Pooja Pandey for Appellants at the outset contends that the observations of ld. trial court are erroneous and contrary to the settled legal position. She submits that the suit has been rejected in a summary and cryptic manner without even looking into and discussing the averments of plaint. It is argued that ld. trial court did not apply its judicial mind to the cause of action in the plaint and failed to appreciate the factual matrix, where plaintiffs had specifically averred their ownership and possession over the suit property and plaint disclosed cause of action having accrued on specified dates. It is RCA 51/23, Shakuntala Gupta & Ors v. BSES YPL Page No.2 of 7 -- 2 of 7 -- argued that even otherwise, while deciding an application under order 7 rule 11 CPC, the court was required to examine only plaint and not the defence or written statement of respondents or any of the pleadings. Ld. Counsel submits that despite stay in operation from the Court of Ld. ADJ-01, ld. trial court went on to pass the Order and rejected the plaint. 5. Ld. Counsel for non-applicant Nitu Kumari submits that his application under Order 1 Rule 10 CPC was pending at the time the impugned Order was passed. He submits that he also moved an application under Section 340 CrPC against the misrepresentation of Court of Ld. ADJ-01 by Appellants by furnishing false facts. He submits that both applications were not decided on merit, while passing impugned Order rejecting the plaint. Analysis and findings of Ld. trial court 6. I have heard Ms. Pooja Pandey, Counsel for Appellants and Mr. H.S.Kumar and Advocate Kundan Kumar for non-applicant Neetu Kumari and have carefully looked into the record. 7. It would be apposite to reproduce the relevant paragraph of the impugned Order dated 11.04.2023 which reads as:- “After hearing the submissions and going through the record, this Court is of the considered RCA 51/23, Shakuntala Gupta & Ors v. BSES YPL Page No.3 of 7 -- 3 of 7 -- opinion that property has already been booked by the MCD and the said fact has been concealed by the plaintiff in the present suit. Further, there is no stay regarding proceeding in the present matter. No injunction can lie against a Government body/organization from proceeding as per the law. Therefore, the injunction as prayed for by the plaintiff is barred under the law and cannot be granted. Therefore, the suit is rejected under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC. File be consigned to Record Room after due compliance.” 8. Law with regard to Order VII Rule 11 CPC is well settled. The court has to consider only the averments made in the plaint and not the defence of the Defendant or the contents of the application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC. In Liverpool & London S.P. & I Assn. Ltd. v. M.V. Sea Success I, (2004) 9 SCC 512, it was observed that whether a plaint discloses a cause of action or not is essentially a question of fact. But whether it does or does not must be found out from reading the plaint itself. For the said purpose, the averments made in the plaint in their entirety must be held to be correct. 9. For the purposes of deciding an application under clauses (a) and (d) of Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code, only the averments in the plaint are germane; the pleas taken by the Defendant in the written statement would be wholly irrelevant at that stage. The law with regard to Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC was further propounded by Hon’ble Supreme Court in Dahiben vs. Arvindbhai Kalyanji Bhanusali & Ors. 2020 SCC OnLine RCA 51/23, Shakuntala Gupta & Ors v. BSES YPL Page No.4 of 7 -- 4 of 7 -- SC 562. Reference in this regard may be made to relevant paragraphs of the judgment, which are set out below: " ….23.9. In exercise of power under this provision, the court would determine if the assertions made in the plaint are contrary to statutory law, or judicial dicta, for deciding whether a case for rejecting the plaint at the threshold is made out. 23.10. At this stage, the pleas taken by the defendant in the written statement and application for rejection of the plaint on the merits, would be irrelevant, and cannot be adverted to, or taken into consideration. [Sopan Sukhdeo Sable v. Charity Commr., (2004) 3 SCC 137] 23.11. The test for exercising the power under Order 7 Rule 11 is that if the averments made in the plaint are taken in entirety, in conjunction with the documents relied upon, would the same result in a decree being passed. This test was laid down in Liverpool & London S.P. & I Assn. Ltd. v. M.V. Sea Success I [Liverpool & London S.P. & I Assn. Ltd. v. M.V. Sea Success I, (2004) 9 SCC 512]…..” 10. The impugned Order shows that ld. trial court while rejecting the suit of Appellants placed reliance upon the defence of Respondents and observed that the property was already booked by the MCD – Respondent and the said factum was concealed by Appellants. Ld. trial court further observed that there was no stay in respect of the proceedings in the suit and that no injunction could lie against a Govt. Body / Organization from RCA 51/23, Shakuntala Gupta & Ors v. BSES YPL Page No.5 of 7 -- 5 of 7 -- proceeding as per law. It is needless to say that the impugned Order is a cryptic and non-speaking O.rder 11. Re-adverting to the facts of case in the light of legal conspectus, I observe that the impugned Order does not contain any reasons needed to show how the Plaint did not have cause of action or under which of sub-rules of Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC, the same was rejected. In the Judgment of G.Saraswathi & Anr v. Rathinammal & Ors (2018) 3 SCC 340 it was held by Hon’ble Supreme Court that: “…… 10. Time and again, this court has emphasised on the courts, the need to pass reasoned order in every case which must contain the narration of the bare facts of the case of the parties to the lis, the issues arising in the case, the submissions urged by the parties, the legal principles applicable to the issues involved and the reasons in support of the findings on all the issues arising in the case and urged by the learned counsel for the parties in support of its conclusion. It is really unfortunate that the Division Bench failed to keep in mind this principle while disposing off the appeal and passed a cryptic and unreasonable order. Such order, in our view, has undoubtedly caused prejudice to the parties because it deprived them to know the reasons as to why one party has won and other has lost. ….." Conclusion 12. In these circumstances and for the abovesaid reasons, this Court observes that the impugned Order of ld. trial court is not sustainable under law. This Court finds it suitable to RCA 51/23, Shakuntala Gupta & Ors v. BSES YPL Page No.6 of 7 -- 6 of 7 -- allow the present appeal and set aside the Order dated 11.04.2023 passed by ld. trial court. 13. The Appeal stands allowed and Suit stands restored to its original number. Trial court is directed to proceed further in the matter in accordance with law. Parties are directed to appear before ld. trial court on 02.06.2023. Nothing in this order shall tantamount to an expression of an opinion on the merits of the case. NDOH before this court stands cancelled. TCR be sent back along with copy of this order. Appeal file be consigned to record room after due compliance. (Ravinder Bedi) Add District Judge-02/Shahdara KKD Courts, Delhi: 15.05.2023 RCA 51/23, Shakuntala Gupta & Ors v. BSES YPL Page No.7 of 7 -- 7 of 7 --
