Full Order Text
Final Order 8 · 08 Oct 2024 · CNR DLSH010027282023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: RCA DJ No. 52/23 Shanti Vs. Vijay Singh IN THE COURT OF SH. ANKUR JAIN-II, DJ-02, SHAHDARA DISTRICT, KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI RCA DJ No.52/2023 Shanti W/o Sh. Raju R/o D-1/730/93, Gali No.13, Ashok Nagar, Mandoli, Delhi - 110093 ......Appellant/plaintiff Versus Vijay Singh S/o Sh. Mahavir Prasad R/o H. No.188, D-Block, Gali No.8, Meet Nagar, Delhi - 110094 .....Respondent/defendant JUDGMENT 1. The present appeal has been filed against judgment and decree dated 03.04.2023 passed by Ld. CJ-01, Shahdara, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi in Suit No.10868/2016, whereby the suit of the plaintiff/ appellant was partly decreed in favour of the plaintiff/ appellant but relief of damages have been declined. 2. For the sake of convenience, parties are referred as per their status in the original suit i.e. appellant is referred as ' plaintiff' and respondent is referred as ' defendant/ respondent'. Brief Facts :- 3. It is stated that the plaintiff had filed the suit seeking mandatory injunction, permanent injunction and damages against the defendant/ respondent stating that plaintiff is the Page 1 of 9 -- 1 of 9 -- RCA DJ No. 52/23 Shanti Vs. Vijay Singh lawful owner of one shop situated in property No.C-47/1, Meet Nagar, Delhi - 110094 (hereinafter referred as ' suit property'); that the suit property was given to the defendant/ respondent as a licensee on account of being brother-in-law of the plaintiff for the purpose of running a shop in the month of October, 2015; that in the month of April, 2016 when the defendant/ respondent was asked to vacate the suit property, he has failed to do so and even changed the sign board of the said shop; that despite repeated reminders and service of a legal notice on 26.08.2016, the defendant/ respondent failed to vacate the suit property. Hence, the instant suit was filed by the plaintiff/ appellant against the defendant/ respondent. Proceedings before Ld. Trial Court :- 4. Pursuant to the summons, defendant/ respondent filed their WS refuting the version of plaintiff and after completion of pleadings of parties, following issues were settled by the Ld. Trial Court Court: 1) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to decree of mandatory injunction against the defendant as prayed ? OPP 2) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to decree of permanent injunction against the defendant as prayed ? OPP 3) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to decree of damages against the defendant, damges @ 500 per day for unauthorized use and occupation of the suit property by the defendant from date of filing till realization ? OPP Page 2 of 9 -- 2 of 9 -- RCA DJ No. 52/23 Shanti Vs. Vijay Singh 4) Whether the plaintiff has purchased the suit property by committing fraud upon the defendant with defendant's money ? OPP (sic. OPD) 5) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the cost ? OPP 6) Relief. 5. Thereafter, the matter was fixed for PE and the Plaintiff Ms. Shanti only examined herself as PWl who tendered in evidence her affidavit as Ex.PW1/A. The witness relied upon the documents i.e. Aadhar Card as Ex.PW1/1, irrevocable GPA dated 04.07.2005 as Ex.PW1/2; electricity bill as Ex.PW1/3; notice dated 26.08.2016 Ex.PW1/4, postal receipts Ex.PW1/5, document related to ITR Ex.PW1/6 (Colly) and site plan Ex.PW1/7. Besides this, no other evidence was led by the appellant in support of her case. 6. The defendant/ respondent Vijay Singh examined himself as DWl and tendered in evidence his affidavit as Ex.DW1/A and DW3 Sh. Rambir Singh was examined as a summoned witness and he brought the summoned record i.e. application form of defendant/ respondent pertaining to taking the loan of Rs.50,000/- vide Sl. No.628 dated 18.08.2013 and the amount of Rs.50,000/- was provided to Sh. Vijay Singh (defendant) through cheque no.763763 dated 25.11.2013 as Ex.DW3/A (OSR). Page 3 of 9 -- 3 of 9 -- RCA DJ No. 52/23 Shanti Vs. Vijay Singh 7. Besides DW1 and DW3, two other witnesses i.e. DW2 and DW5 have been cross-examined by the plaintiff/ appellant, however, the other witnesses i.e. DW4, DW6, DW7 and DW8 were only examined-in-chief and did not appear for their cross-examination despite opportunity granted by Ld. Trial Court. 8. Thereafter, the matter was then fixed for final arguments, and after hearing arguments from both the sides, the Ld. Trial Court vide impugned judgment dated 03.04.2023, partly decreed the suit in favour of the plaintiff/ appellant and against the defendant, denying the relief of damages/ mesne profits to the plaintiff @ Rs.500/- per day from the date of filing of the suit till the date of handing over the possession of the suit property. PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THIS COURT 9. By virtue of this appeal, the appellant/ plaintiff has assailed the impugned judgment dated 03.04.2023 passed by Ld. Trial Court and prayed that the same may be modified/ altered and damages to the tune of Rs.500/- per day may be awarded in favour of the appellant/ plaintiff against the respondent for illegal occupation of the suit property from the date of the filing of the instant suit i.e. 06.10.2016 till recovering the possession of the suit property. 10.Upon issuance of notice of the present appeal, respondent appeared before the Court and filed reply. Thereafter, final arguments from both the sides. Page 4 of 9 -- 4 of 9 -- RCA DJ No. 52/23 Shanti Vs. Vijay Singh SUBMISSIONS OF APPELLANT 11. It is submitted by Ld. Counsel for the appellant/ plaintiff that Ld. Trial Court had committed error in denying the relief of damages @ Rs.500/- per day to the plaintiff by deciding the Issue no.3 against the plaintiff, as the plaintiff has specifically relied upon the documents in her examination-in-chief dated 15.10.2018 Ex.PW1/6 (OSR) (Colly) w.r.t. Income Tax return and balance sheet of the plaintiff which clearly shows that the appellant and her husband were running business under the name and style of M/s Pooja Cosmetics and it is also come in the cross- examination of the respondent dated 12.07.2019, where the respondent has duly admitted that he had changed the sign board of Pooja Cosmetics and installed the sign board of Vijay Cosmetics. 12.It is further submitted by Ld. Counsel for the appellant/ plaintiff that admittedly, the Ld. Trial Court has granted the relief of mandatory injunction in favour of the appellant thereby holding that the respondent is not entitled to remain in possession of the suit property and despite terminating the license of the respondent vide legal notice dated 26.08.2016 given by Ld. Counsel for the appellant to the respondent, the respondent illegally deprived the appellant to possess the suit property and earn her living therefrom. Therefore, the impugned judgment is liable to be modified to the extent that the respondent may be directed to pay damages to the appellant @ Rs.500/- per day from the date Page 5 of 9 -- 5 of 9 -- RCA DJ No. 52/23 Shanti Vs. Vijay Singh of filing of the suit till the date of handing over the possession of the suit property. SUBMISSIONS OF RESPONDENT 13.Per contra, it is submitted by Ld. Counsel for the respondent that the appellant has also sought an alternative prayer to produce additional evidence U/o 41 Rule 27 CPC in the present appeal so as to prove the claim or grant of damages as sought by the appellant herein, without filing any appropriate application nor mentioned any grounds for not leading any evidence before the Ld. Trial Court in this regard. 14.It is further submitted by Ld. Counsel for the respondent that Ld. Trial Court has duly passed the impugned judgment after appreciating each and every facts and the respondent has already vacated the suit property/ shop in question within the prescribed time period and also handed over the same to the appellant in compliance of the judgment dated 03.04.2023. Hence, the present appeal is liable to be dismissed. ANALYSIS:- 15. I have heard respective submissions of Ld. Counsel for the appellant and Ld. Counsel for respondent in the light of evidence adduced before the Ld. Trial Court and law applicable to the facts of the present case. Page 6 of 9 -- 6 of 9 -- RCA DJ No. 52/23 Shanti Vs. Vijay Singh 16.Perusal of impugned judgment dated 03.04.2023 passed by Ld. CJ-01, Shahdara, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi in Suit No.10868/2016 shows that the Ld. Trial Court while passing the impugned judgment has observed that the appellant has not led any credible ocular or documentary evidence to justify the claim of grant of damages @ Rs.500/- per day from the date of filing of the present suit, and Issue no.3 was accordingly, decided in favour of the respondent and against the plaintiff herein. 17.It is trite law that calculation of mesne profits always involves some guess work and Court in several cases have taken judicial notice U/s 57 of Indian Evidence Act, 1872 of the prevalent market rents of different areas within the city while awarding mesne profits; rent may vary based on location of properties, nature of construction, purpose/ user for which the premises are let, variation between demand for tenanted premises and availability of premises and even factors relating to the position of the economy - the list is not exhaustive. 18. However, the appellant has nowhere pleaded in the instant suit as to whether she was taking any license fee from the respondent, or any rent was paid by the respondent to the appellant from the period of October, 2015 till April, 2016. 19.The appellant has also not mentioned even the measurement of the suit property/ shop in question for the purpose of assessment of any damages. Page 7 of 9 -- 7 of 9 -- RCA DJ No. 52/23 Shanti Vs. Vijay Singh 20.Further, the appellant has also not proved in the trial nor led any evidence w.r.t. the rate of rent fetched by similar properties in the area where the suit property is located. 21.In view of the above, no scope of guess work can be done by the Court in such cases, where even the foundational facts qua rent of the property has not been proved by the appellant, nor can the Court conduct any inquiry U/o 20 Rule 12 CPC for the purpose of assessing any increase in the rent amount as per the prevailing market rate. 22.Without prejudice to the above, the appellant has also sought alternative prayer to lead additional evidence U/o 41 Rule 27 r/w section 151 CPC in the present appeal. However, this Court agrees with the submissions of Ld. Counsel for the respondent that no application has been filed by the appellant in this regard by mentioning any specific grounds as to what additional evidence, the appellant wants to lead before the Ld. Trial Court or why the same was not led before Ld. Trial Court when the appellant was having all the opportunities to lead the same or whether any such evidence could not be led by the appellant before the Ld. Trial Court during the trial in her PE, despite her due diligence. 23.In view of the above, the appellant is not entitled for grant of damages @ Rs.500/- per day from the date of filing of the instant suit against the respondent, nor the appellant is Page 8 of 9 -- 8 of 9 -- RCA DJ No. 52/23 Shanti Vs. Vijay Singh entitled for grant of any alternative relief so as to allow her to produce additional evidence U/o 41 Rule 27 CPC r/w section 151 CPC before the Ld. Trial Court, as sought by the appellant in the present appeal. CONCLUSION 24.Accordingly, I find no error or illegality in the impugned judgment dated 03.04.2023 passed by Ld. CJ-01, Shahdara, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi and in view of the above stated discussion, no ground is made out for allowing the present appeal. 25. Hence, present appeal stands dismissed. 26. No order as to costs. 27. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly. 28.Appeal file be consigned to record room after due compliance, as per rules. 29. Trial court record be sent back with copy of the judgment. Announced in the Open Court on this 08th day of October, 2024 (ANKUR JAIN-II) DISTRICT JUDGE –02, SHAHDARA, KKD COURTS, DELHI Page 9 of 9 -- 9 of 9 --
