Full Order Text
Final Order 3 · 18 Aug 2023 · CNR DLSH010025802023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: Ex. Comm. No. 116/23 Kotak Mahindra Bank vs. Rajiv Kumar & Anr. 18.08.2023 Present : None for the DH since morning despite repeated calls. Case file is perused. It is observed that on 17.05.2023, a query was raised by the court regarding the executability of the ‘exparte’ award dated 17.06.2022, in view of the unilateral appointment of the Ld. Arbitrator. Thereafter, none has appeared, on behalf of the DH, to make the clarifications in this regard. None has appeared on behalf of the DH even today and therefore, I deem it appropriate to decide the executability of the award dated 17.06.2022, on merits, on the basis of material on record. 2. I have carefully perused the case file. Perusal of the record shows that the present execution petition has been preferred, on behalf of the Decree Holder, for execution of the award dated 17.06.2022, passed by Sh. Nirmal Kr. Agarwal, the Ld. Sole Arbitrator. 3. Perusal of the award dated 17.06.2022, further shows that the said arbitration award has been passed by the Ld. Arbitrator, who was unilaterally appointed by the award holder, vide reference letter dated 03.02.2022. Furthermore, the arbitration proceedings were conducted by the Ld. Arbitrator, without participation of the award debtors as the award debtors were proceeded ‘exparte’ by the Ld. Arbitrator, vide order dated Ex.Comm.No.116/23 page 1 of 4 D.J.(Commercial Court)-01/Shahdara/KKD/Delhi -- 1 of 4 -- 20.04.2022. Consequently, the arbitral award, dated 17.06.2022, was passed. 4. The issue of non-executability of an arbitration award, where the Ld. Arbitrator was appointed unilaterally has already been settled by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, in case titled as, ‘TRF Limited vs. Energo Engineering Products Ltd.’, reported as, ‘(2017) 7 SCR 409’ and subsequently, in ‘Perkins Eastman Architects DPC & Anr. vs. HSCC (India) Ltd.’, reported as, ‘(2019) 17 SCR 275’. 5. Recently, the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi, has also discussed the same issue, in case titled as, ‘Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. vs. Narendra Kumar Prajapat’, bearing, ‘EFA Commercial No.3/2023, and vide order dated 17.05.2023 (Neutral Citation No.: 2023:DHC:3705-DB), it was held as under : “4. In TRF Ltd. v. Energo Engineering Projects Ltd.: (2017) 8 SCC 377, the Supreme Court held that once the Arbitrator has become ineligible by operation of law, he cannot nominate another as an arbitrator. In Perkins Eastman Architects DPC & Anr. v. HSCC (India) Ltd.: (2020) 20 SCC 760, the Supreme Court, following the earlier decision in TRF Ltd. (supra), held that the Chairman-cum-Managing Director of a party was ineligible to appoint an arbitrator. Following the aforesaid decisions, this court in Proddatur Cable TV Digi Services v. Siti Cable Network Limited: (2020) 267 DLT 51 held that it is not permissible for a party to unilaterally appoint an arbitrator without the consent of the other party(ies). It is important to note that the aforesaid decisions were rendered in the context of Section 12(5) of the A&C Act. xxx xxx xxx xxx 7. We find little merit in the aforesaid contentions. The proviso to Section 12(5) of the A&C Act is unambiguous. A party can waive its right to object to the ineligibility of an arbitrator under Section 12(5) of the A&C Act but the same is subject to two conditions. First, that the waiver is required to be by and Ex.Comm.No.116/23 page 2 of 4 D.J.(Commercial Court)-01/Shahdara/KKD/Delhi -- 2 of 4 -- done by an express agreement in writing; and second, that such agreement is entered into after the disputes have arisen. Unless both the aforesaid conditions are satisfied, there can be no waiver of the ineligibility of an arbitrator. 8. In Bharat Broadband Network Limited v. United Telecoms Limited: (2019) 5 SCC 755, the Supreme Court had authoritatively held that waiver of a right to object to ineligibility of an arbitrator under Section 12(5) of the A&C Act cannot be inferred by conduct of a party. Such waiver can only be by an express agreement in writing. The Court had also clarified that “the expression ‘express agreement in writing’ refers to an agreement made in words as opposed to an agreement which is to be inferred by conduct”. 9. In view of the above, the failure, if any, on the part of the respondent to object to the unilateral appointment of the sole arbitrator, cannot be construed as waiver of his right under Section 12(5) of the A&C Act. 10. The award rendered by an arbitrator who is ineligible to be appointed as such cannot be enforced. 11. In HRD Corporation v. GAIL (India) Ltd.: (2018) 12 SCC 471, the Supreme Court held as under: “Since ineligibility goes to the root of the appointment, Section 12(5) read with the Seventh Schedule makes it clear that if the arbitrator falls in any one of the categories specified in the Seventh Schedule, he becomes “ineligible” to act as arbitrator. Once he becomes ineligible, it is clear that, under Section 14(1)(a), he then becomes dejure unable to perform his functions inasmuch as, in law, he is regarded as “ineligible”. In order to determine whether an arbitrator is de jure unable to perform his functions, it is not necessary to go to the Arbitral Tribunal under Section 13. Since such a person would lack inherent jurisdiction to proceed any further, an application may be filed under Section 14(2) to the Court to decide on the termination of his/her mandate on this ground.” [emphasis added] 12. In Govind Singh v. M/S Satya Group Pvt Ltd & Anr.: 2023/DHC/000081 this court held as under: “In view of the above, the remaining question to be addressed is whether an arbitral award rendered by a person who is ineligible to act as an arbitrator is valid or binding on the parties. Clearly, the answer must be in the negative. The arbitral award rendered by a person who is ineligible to act as an arbitrator cannot be considered as Ex.Comm.No.116/23 page 3 of 4 D.J.(Commercial Court)-01/Shahdara/KKD/Delhi -- 3 of 4 -- an arbitral award. The ineligibility of the arbitrator goes to the root of his jurisdiction. Plainly an arbitral award rendered by the arbitral tribunal which lacks the inherent jurisdiction cannot be considered as valid. In the aforesaid view, the impugned award is liable to be set aside as being wholly without jurisdiction. xxx xxx xxx xxx 14. This Court finds no infirmity with the aforesaid view. A person who is ineligible to act an Arbitrator, lacks the inherent jurisdiction to render an Arbitral Award under the A&C Act. It is trite law that a decision, by any authority, which lacks inherent jurisdiction to make such a decision, cannot be considered as valid. Thus, clearly, such an impugned award cannot be enforced.” (emphasis supplied) 6. In these circumstances and the legal position, as discussed above, this court is of the considered opinion that the ‘exparte’ award dated 17.06.2022, is non-est in the eyes of law and is therefore, non-executable, being a ‘nullity’. Accordingly, the present execution petition is hereby dismissed. It is ordered accordingly. File be consigned to record room, after due compliance. Announced in open court on this 18th Day of August, 2023 (Brijesh Kumar Garg) District Judge (Commercial Court)-01 Shahdara Distt, KKD Ex.Comm.No.116/23 page 4 of 4 D.J.(Commercial Court)-01/Shahdara/KKD/Delhi -- 4 of 4 --
