Full Order Text
Order 4 · 04 Jan 2025 · CNR DLSH010025722024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS No. 249/24 Rajeshwari vs. Raj Kumar 04.01.2025 Present : Sh. Pankaj Singhal Ld. Counsel for plaintiffs with plaintiffs. Sh. Yatin Pal Ld. Counsel for D1, D3 and D5. Sh. Yash Kumar Rajput Ld. Counsel for D-2 through VC. None for D-4. None for proposed defendant Neelam despite service on 06.09.2024. Summons issued to D-4 received back through affixation with the report ‘D-4 was not found at given address’. Plaintiffs are at liberty to proceed as per law. Previous cost not paid. At this stage, an application u/s 151 CPC has been filed on behalf of D-2 for waiver of cost imposed by this court vide order dated 28.09.2024. Same be taken on record. Copy already supplied. Reply filed. Same be taken on record. Copy supplied. At this stage, Ld. counsel for D-2 submits that he does not wish to pursue the aforesaid application u/s 151 CPC and wants to withdraw the same. He further undertakes to pay the cost on NDOH. Heard. In view of the submissions of Ld. counsel for D-2, the aforesaid application u/s 151 CPC is disposed off as withdrawn. D-2 is directed to pay the cost on NDOH. At this stage, replies to the application u/o 1 R 10 CPC and application u/o 6 r 17 r/w S. 151 CPC have been -- 1 of 4 -- -2- filed on behalf of D-2. Same be taken on record. Copy supplied. Arguments heard on the applications u/o 6 R 17 CPC as well as u/o 1 R 10 CPC. Record perused. Application u/o 6 R 17 r/w S. 151 CPC By way of aforesaid application, plaintiff is seeking amendment in the plaint to the effect that the alleged documents dated 21.10.1997 filed by D-2 as well as the Gift deed dated 31.01.2024 in favour of wife of D-2 i.e. proposed defendant Smt. Neelam, w.r.t. suit property, executed by D-2, be declared as null and void. Therefore, plaintiff wants to add para no. 10(a), as mentioned in the application as well as want to amend para no. 11, 14 and prayer clause 1 to 6 of the plaint, as mentioned in the application. The application is supported by an affidavit and the same is accompanied by the amended plaint a/w affidavit. In reply to the aforesaid application, defendant no. 2 has prayed for dismissal of the aforesaid application being misconceived, frivolous and without merit. In view of the reasons mentioned in the aforesaid application as well as on the basis of submissions made by the Ld. Counsel for parties, considering that the suit is at initial stage and issues are yet to be framed, this court is of the opinion that the amendments sought by way of present application are very much necessary to determine the real controversy between the parties and to meet the end of justice and not to defeat the law. The application u/o 6 r 17 r/w S. -- 2 of 4 -- -3- 151 CPC is disposed off as allowed. Amended plaint is taken on record. Plaintiff is also directed to file deficient court fees, accordingly. Application u/o 1 R 10 CPC By way of application u/o 1 r 10 CPC, plaintiff seeks to implead proposed defendant Smt. Neelam as defendant no. 6 in the array of parties. Ld. Counsel for plaintiff submits that impleadment of the proposed defendant is necessary for the proper adjudication of the suit as the D-2 has further executed a Gift Deed dated 31.01.2024, w.r.t. suit property, in favour of his wife i.e. proposed defendant. On the other hand, in reply to the aforesaid application, defendant no. 2 has prayed for dismissal of the aforesaid application being baseless, frivolous and without merit. Though the proposed defendant Smt. Neelam has been served with the notice of the aforesaid application, but none appeared for proposed defendant to address arguments on the aforesaid application despite calls. As per Order 1 R 10 (2) CPC, the Court may at any stage of the proceedings, either upon or without the application of the either party, order that the name of any person who ought to have been joined, whether as a plaintiff or defendant or whose presence before the Court may be necessary to enable the court to adjudicate upon and settle all questions involved in the suit, be added. In view of the aforesaid submissions made by Ld. Counsels for the parties as well as for the reasons mentioned in the application, this court is of the view that the proposed defendant, being a -- 3 of 4 -- -4- necessary party, should be impleaded in the suit to ensure a comprehensive adjudication of the issues involved. Further, the impleadment of proposed defendant shall not prejudice any of the party, therefore, the aforesaid application u/o 1 R 10 CPC is disposed off as allowed. Proposed defendant Smt. Neelam is added in the array of defendants as defendant no. 6. Amended memo of parties be filed on or before NDOH. D-6 Smt. Neelam is also directed to file WS within stipulated period with advance copy to the opposite party. Matter is adjourned. Matter be listed for payment of cost / filing deficit court fees / amended memo of parties / further proceedings on 22.03.2025. (Gaurav) District Judge-01/ SHD KKD/Delhi/04.01.2025(ch) -- 4 of 4 --
