Full Order Text
Final Order 7 · 29 Apr 2025 · CNR DLSH010025212024
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. DEEPANKER MOHAN DISTRICT JUDGE-04, SHAHDARA DISTRICT, KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI RCA DJ 45/2024 In re: 1.Manish Mishra S/o Late Sh. Subhas Mishra R/o C-205, Block-C, Brij Vihar, Surya Nagar, Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh-201005. 2. Smt. Kiran Mishra W/o Late Sh. Subhas Mishra R/o C-205, Block-C, Brij Vihar, Surya Nagar, Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh-201005. …….. Appellants Versus State Bank of India Having Office at: 11, Parliament Street, New Delhi-110001. ……. Respondent 1. RCA DJ : 45/2024 2. Under Section : Appeal U/s 96. 3. Date of institution : 10/04/2024 (e-filed on 09.04.2024) 4. Reserved for judgment : 30/01/2025 5. Date of Judgment : 29/04/2025 JUDGMENT By way of this judgment, this Court shall dispose of the present appeal filed by the appellants against respondent on 10.04.2024 (e-filed on 09.04.2024). RCA DJ 45/2024 Page No.1 of 14 -- 1 of 14 -- 1. That the present appeal is being filed by the appellants/defendants against the judgment and decree dated 27.02.2022 passed by the Court of Sh. Gaurav Dahiya, Ld. CJ-03, Shahdara District, KKD Courts, Delhi in CS No.672/2019 vide which the suit of plaintiff/respondent was decreed. 2. The parties are being referred to their original ranks given/mentioned in the main suit in the present judgment. Brief facts mentioned in the plaint:- 3. The plaintiff bank is a corporate body constituted under the State Bank of India, 1955 having its Central Office at Madam Cama Road, Mumbai and is engaged in the business of banking. Plaintiff is having its local Head Office including one at 11, Parliament Street, New Delhi-110001 and various branches throughout India including one at Jangpura, New Delhi and recovery branch known as RACPC, First Floor, F-40, 2nd and 3rd Floor, Ring Road, South Extension, Part-1, New Delhi. The present suit has been filed by the Manager of the Recovery Branch i.e. RACPC namely Mr. Alok Manglik. The deceased defendant namely Subhas Mishra (father and husband of appellant No.1 and 2 respectively) had approached and requested the plaintiff bank for grant of financial assistance by way of vehicle/car loan facility at its Jangpura, New Delhi Branch and had submitted his identification, employment and income proof etc. with the plaintiff bank before sanction of loan. The plaintiff bank had sanctioned and disbursed a car loan amounting to Rs. Five lakhs to defendant on 29.06.2012 which had been availed by RCA DJ 45/2024 Page No.2 of 14 -- 2 of 14 -- defendant by purchasing TATA Indica bearing registration No.DL-5CG-2662. The said car loan was a secured loan by hypothecation of aforesaid vehicle/car. The deceased defendant namely Subhas Mishra executed and signed various documents i.e. Loan application form, Letter of arrangement dated 29.06.2012, Loan-cum-hypothecation agreement dated 29.06.2012, vehicle delivery letter and Annexure-I. Sh. Subhas Mishra agreed to pay the interest on the outstanding loan amount @ 11.25% per annum with monthly rest. Defendant has undertaken to pay 84 equal monthly installments of Rs.8,627/- each till the entire loan amount along with interest is repaid. A car loan account 32402250470 was also opened. The defendant lastly paid Rs.17,000/- on 12.07.2017 to the plaintiff bank. Due to persistent defaults committed by defendant, the loan account was classified as NPA and the loan was recalled by plaintiff bank by serving legal notice dated 23.03.2019 upon defendant through registered post and courier but despite service defendant failed to comply with the said notice. Sh. Subhas Mishra was found to be liable to pay an amount of Rs.2,46,955/- including accrued interest, towards plaintiff bank. SERVICE OF SUMMONS IN THE SUIT: 4. Summons were duly served upon Sh. Subhas Mishra through his son namely Manish Mishra i.e. appellant No.1 on 07.09.2019. On 12.09.2019 an appearance on behalf of defendant was put by Ms. Aruna, Advocate. Perusal of the record shows that on 04.12.2019, on the request on behalf of defendant, the present matter was referred to Lok Adalat, however, the same returned back unsettled. RCA DJ 45/2024 Page No.3 of 14 -- 3 of 14 -- 5. During the proceedings of the suit, Sh. Subhas Mishra had expired on 03.06.2020 and thereafter his legal heirs were brought on record vide order dated 15.12.2021. Written statement on behalf of LR of Sh. Subhas Mishra was filed on 01.02.2023. AVERMENTS OF WRITTEN STATEMENT: 6. The appellants/LRs of deceased defendant in their written statement before Ld. Trial Court have denied all the averments of the plaint. The LRs of defendant pleaded that plaintiff bank has no cause of action as LRs of defendant had not taken any loan from plaintiff bank. It is further pleaded that the suit of the plaintiff bank is barred by law of limitation. It is further pleaded that since the LRs of defendant have not taken any loan from plaintiff bank, therefore, there is no privity of contract between them and plaintiff bank. It is further pleaded that no liability is made out against LRs of defendant. It is further pleaded that the LRs of defendant are residing at C-205, Block-C, Brij Vihar, Surya Nagar, Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh-201005 and therefore, the Courts of Delhi have no territorial jurisdiction to try and adjudicate the suit. The LRs of defendant are not liable to pay any amount to plaintiff bank AVERMENTS OF REPLICATION: 7. Replication was filed on 29.03.2023 wherein plaintiff bank has denied all the averments of the written statement and reaffirmed the contents of the plaint. RCA DJ 45/2024 Page No.4 of 14 -- 4 of 14 -- 8. Perusal of the Ld. Trial Court record shows that on 29.03.2023 Ld. Counsel for LRs of defendant stated that LRs of defendant have no personal liability to repay the loan taken by deceased defendant and even if the suit is decreed, decree cannot be executed against the LRs of defendant. 9. On 25.05.2023 the Ld. Trial Court after considering the pleadings and submissions of parties, framed the following issues: “1) Whether the LRs of deceased namely Manish and Smt. Kiran have not inherited any estate of the deceased defendant? OPD 2) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to recovery of Rs.2,46,955/- along with interest from the LRs of defendant, as prayed for? OPP 3) Relief.” 10. The Ld. Trial Court vide its order dated 25.05.2023 directed LRs of defendant to lead evidence first. Sh. Manish examined himself as DW1. LR No.2 of defendant Smt. Kiran was examined as court witness on 14.09.2023. Thereafter, on 29.11.2023, plaintiff examined Sh. Sharvan Kumar, Manager as PW1, who was also cross examined on the same day. 11. The Ld. Trial Court after considering the material on record decided all the issues in favour of plaintiff and against LRs of defendant and decreed the suit. 12. The appellant aggrieved from the judgment and decree dated 27.02.2024 passed by the Ld. Trial Court has preferred the RCA DJ 45/2024 Page No.5 of 14 -- 5 of 14 -- present appeal on the following grounds which are mentioned as under : (i) The Ld. Trial Court has erred in not appreciating the evidence of DW1 wherein he specifically deposed that the property bearing No.1/10211, Gali No.1, West Gorakh Park, Shahdara, Delhi-110032 was in the name of his mother namely Smt. Kiran and the same does not belong/owned by his father. The Ld. Trial Court has failed to appreciate that it was incumbent upon the respondent to prove that the said property belonged/owned by deceased defendant and after his demise, LRs of defendant namely Manish Mishra and Kiran have inherited the said property. (ii) The Ld. Trial Court has failed to appreciate the fact that the loan was a secured loan and the same ought to be have recovered by recovering or reprocessing the aforesaid vehicle and not by any other manner/mode. (iii) The Ld. Trial Court has failed to appreciate that the document Ex.PW1/7 is a forged and fabricated document. 13. Notice of the present appeal was issued to the plaintiff bank vide order dated 12.04.2024. 14. Plaintiff bank through his Counsel put his appearance on 22.07.2024. Reply to the appeal was filed through e-filing on 19.07.2024. It is worthwhile to mention here that subject to deposit of 505 of the decreetal amount, the operation of judgment and decree dated 27.02.2024 was stayed and the application under Order XLI Rule 5 r/w Section 151 CPC was allowed, RCA DJ 45/2024 Page No.6 of 14 -- 6 of 14 -- however, LRs of defendant failed to comply with the directions dated 12.04.2024, therefore, the order dated 12.04.2024 was vacated on 22.07.2024. 15. Final arguments were heard on 30.01.2025. 16. File as well as trial court record perused. After perusing the file, this Court deems fit to frame the following points of determination which are as under: (i) Whether the LRs of deceased defendant have proved that they have not inherited any estate of the deceased defendant? (ii) Whether the document Ex.PW1/7 is a forged document? (iii) Whether the LRs of defendant are not liable to pay the outstanding amount along with interest to plaintiff bank towards the satisfaction of the loan account? Point No.1 : Whether the LRs of deceased defendant have proved that they have not inherited any estate of the deceased defendant? AND Point No.2 : Whether the document Ex.PW1/7 is a forged document? 17. It was argued by the Ld. Counsel for LRs of defendant that LRs of defendant/appellants have not inherited any movable or immovable property of late Sh. Subhas Mishra and therefore, they are not liable to make any payment towards satisfaction of the loan amount. It was further argued that LRs of defendant are protected under Section 50(2) CPC. It was further argued that plaintiff has failed to prove that the property bearing No.1/10211, Gali No.1, West Gorakh Park, Shahdara, Delhi-110032 was RCA DJ 45/2024 Page No.7 of 14 -- 7 of 14 -- owned by late Sh. Subhas Mishra. It was further argued that DW1 and Smt. Kiran has specifically deposed that the property bearing No.1/10211, Gali No.1, West Gorakh Park, Shahdara, Delhi-110032 was owned by Smt. Kiran. It was further argued that LRs of defendant are not liable to pay any amount to plaintiff bank. It also argued that the decree ought to be passed to recover the amount only qua property inherited by the LRs of defendant, if any. 18. It was argued on behalf of plaintiff bank that it was the duty of LRs of defendant to produce any cogent and reliable material to prove issue No.1 and the fact that they have not inherited any estate of deceased defendant. It was further argued that it is the LRs of defendant who has alleged forgery and therefore, the burden to prove forgery is upon them. It was further argued that LRs of defendant have failed to prove that document Ex.PW-1/7 is a forged document. It was further argued that the Ld. Trial Court has rightly passed the judgment and decree dated 27.02.2024 after appreciating the entire material on record in right perspective. It was further argued that the appeal of LRs of defendant are liable to be set aside. 19. The proposition “LRs of deceased defendant have inherited the estate of deceased defendant” has to be decided during the execution proceedings, however, the said legal argument was raised by the Ld. Counsel for LRs of defendant on 29/03/2023, therefore, Issue No.1 was also framed despite the fact that there was no such pleading in the written statement. However, the Issue No.1 was framed by Ld. Trial Court in this regard and the same was also decided against LRs of defendant. RCA DJ 45/2024 Page No.8 of 14 -- 8 of 14 -- The Appellant in the present appeal has also raised the ground that LRs of defendant have not inherited the estate of deceased and the finding of Ld. Trial Court is erroneous. 20. The onus of proof to prove the issue No.1 was upon LRs of defendant. DW1 in para no. 2 of his evidence affidavit Ex.DW1/A has deposed that “ That late Sh. Subhas Mishra i.e. father of deponent has left behind no Estate whether movable or immovable, as a consequence, the deponent received or inherited no estate (movable or immovable property) of late Sh. Subhas Mishra, after the demise of his late father.” DW1 has not produced any documentary and independent evidence to support his contentions. The wife of late Sh. Subhas Mishra namely Smt. Kiran Mishra was examined as Court witness on 14.09.2023, has deposed that her husband was also having some ancestral property in District Deoria, Gorakh Pur, U.P. She further deposed that she is not aware about the same. None of the LRs of defendant has made any reasonable enquiry regarding the status of the ancestral property of late Sh. Subhas Mishra. It is noted that after the death of late Sh. Subhas Mishra, LRs of defendant Sh. Manish Mishra and Smt. Kiran Mishra have inherited the ancestral property situated in District Deoria, Gorakh Pur, U.P. It is strange that after the demise of Sh. Subhas Mishra, none of his LRs have claimed the aforesaid property and applied for its mutation in their name. The testimony of Smt. Kiran Mishra and DW-1 are doubtful and creates suspicion over the truthfulness of their testimony. 21. Court witness Smt. Kiran Mishra has also deposed that “ The property bearing H.No.1/10211, Gali No.1, West Gorakh RCA DJ 45/2024 Page No.9 of 14 -- 9 of 14 -- Park, Shahdara, Delhi-110032 belonged to me and same was purchased by me.” Smt. Kiran Mishra has not filed any title/ownership document of the aforesaid property which can establish that the aforesaid property was purchased by her. The LRs of defendant has also not produced any document which can show that the aforesaid property had been sold by Smt. Kiran Mishra. The LRs of defendant have not disclosed the name of the person to whom they have sold the afore-said property and for what amount. The LRs of defendant have also not summoned the buyer/vendee to whom they have sold the aforesaid property. No date has been mentioned when did the aforesaid property was sold. If the LRs of defendant would have called the buyer/vendee in the witness box, then he would have produced the ownership/title documents along with its previous chain and the same would have proved that the aforesaid property was in the name of Smt. Kiran Mishra and not of deceased defendant. Non production of the title/ownership documents of the aforesaid property creates probable doubts on the testimony of LRs of defendant. Mere stating that the aforesaid property belongs to Smt. Kiran Mishra would not serve the purpose for LRs of defendant to shift their burden particularly when deceased defendant has disclosed in his statement of assets and liability given to the plaintiff bank (Ex.PW1/7) that the aforesaid property belongs to him and its market value is Rs.15 lakhs. 22. The use of words “failed to satisfy the court” in Section 52(2) of CPC show that the burden to proof the fact that he has not received the property from the hands of deceased lies on the LRs of deceased and not on the plaintiff. LRs of deceased will be bound to account for all sorts of property that he got, such as RCA DJ 45/2024 Page No.10 of 14 -- 10 of 14 -- money, movables, immovables, accounts papers etc. If the LR of defendant fails to satisfy the Court that he has duly applied the property of the deceased, he is personally liable to the extent of the property in respect of which he has failed to satisfy the Court. 23. During the course of arguments, LRs of defendant admit the factum of sanction and disbursement of loan by plaintiff bank to deceased defendant. The LRs of defendant in their written statement have not disputed the signatures of Sh. Subhas Mishra on the documents filed by plaintiff including Ex.PW1/7. The LRs of defendant have also not raised any objection in their written statement that the documents Ex.PW1/7 is a forged document. The LRs of defendant have also not made any complaint to Police or competent authority regarding the aforesaid forgery. The burden to prove forgery is upon the LRs of defendant, however, neither they have pleaded nor they have produced any evidence to prove the alleged forgery. It is worthwhile to mention here that the evidence affidavit Ex.DW1/A is also silent about the alleged forgery. The deceased defendant while applying for the loan with plaintiff bank has signed and disclosed the fact in document Ex.PW1/7 that the property bearing No.1/10211, Gali No.1, West Gorakh Park, Shahdara, Delhi-110032 belongs to him and the same is valued Rs.15 lakhs. The best piece of evidence that the property bearing No.1/10211, Gali No.1, West Gorakh Park, Shahdara, Delhi-110032 was not owned by late Sh. Subhas Mishra would be the title documents of the said property which were in the possession and custody of the LRs of defendant. However, the LRs of defendant have not produced the best evidence to prove that the aforesaid property was owned by Smt. RCA DJ 45/2024 Page No.11 of 14 -- 11 of 14 -- Kiran Mishra and not by late Sh. Subhas Mishra and therefore, an adverse inference is drawn against the LRs of defendant. 24. In view of the above observations, this Court is of the opinion that LRs of defendant have failed to prove by leading cogent, reliable and independent evidence that they have not inherited any property (movable or immovable property) left by late Sh. Subhas Mishra. As per the deposition of court witness Smt. Kiran Mishra, LR of defendant namely Manish Mishra and Smt. Kiran Mishra have inherited the property in District Deoria, Gorakh Pur, Uttar Pradesh. The LRs of defendant have failed to prove that the property bearing No.1/10211, Gali No.1, West Gorakh Park, Shahdara, Delhi-110032 was owned by Smt. Kiran Mishra, therefore, in absence of any cogent and reliable evidence, the deposition of DW1 and court witness cannot be considered as true. Under the present circumstances, inference can be drawn that the property bearing No.1/10211, Gali No.1, West Gorakh Park, Shahdara, Delhi-110032 belongs to deceased Subhas Mishra and the same has also been inherited by Sh. Manish Mishra and Smt. Kiran Mishra. 25. In view of the above observations, this Court concludes that the Ld. Trial Court has rightly decided the issue No.1 in favour of plaintiff bank and against the LRs of defendant. The point No.1 and 2 are accordingly decided against LRs of defendant and in favour of plaintiff bank. Point No.3: (iii) Whether the LRs of defendant are not liable to pay the outstanding amount along with interest to plaintiff bank. RCA DJ 45/2024 Page No.12 of 14 -- 12 of 14 -- 26. It is admitted position that deceased defendant has availed a vehicle loan from plaintiff bank. Perusal of the record shows that deceased defendant has handed over the vehicle to one Sh. Hari Om without prior permission of plaintiff bank. LRs of defendant have not produced any material on record which can show that prior to handing over possession of the vehicle to Sh. Hari Om, deceased defendant has taken prior permission of the plaintiff bank. The deceased defendant had violated the terms of the loan agreement. The deceased defendant by handing over the vehicle to another person i.e. Hari Om has gained profit and caused wrongful loss to plaintiff bank. It is noted that statement of account Ex.PW1/11(colly) specifically reflects that deceased defendant has made various defaults and has not paid the entire loan amount along with interest to plaintiff bank. The statement of account Ex.PW1/11 (colly) is duly stamped as per law. It is noted that no question/suggestion has been put to PW1 to challenge the authenticity of the statement of account Ex.PW1/11 (colly). As per statement of account Ex.PW1/11 (colly) deceased defendant is liable to pay an amount of Rs.2,46,955/- to plaintiff bank as on 14.02.2019. 27. As per the statement of account, deceased defendant has taken the loan from plaintiff bank on 30.06.2012 and lastly paid Rs.17,000/- to plaintiff bank. The suit was filed on 04.06.2019. Under the present circumstances and considering the statement of account Ex.PW1/11(colly) the suit is well within limitation. 28. The deceased defendant at the time of applying for the vehicle loan with plaintiff bank has disclosed that he is residing at property bearing No.1/10211, Gali No.1, West Gorakh Park, RCA DJ 45/2024 Page No.13 of 14 -- 13 of 14 -- Shahdara, Delhi-110032. The service of summons of the suit was effected upon defendant on the aforesaid address. The aforesaid address falls within the jurisdiction of Civil Courts, Shahdara, Karkardooma, Delhi, therefore, the contention of LR of defendant that the Courts of Shahdara, KKD, Delhi does not have territorial jurisdiction to try the suit, is not sustainable and same is rejected. 29. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, material came on record, the loan amount taken by deceased defendant was a public money and above observations, therefore, this Court is of the view that plaintiff is entitled to recover an amount of Rs.2,46,955/- along with pendente lite and future interest on the aforesaid amount @ 10.30% per annum at monthly rest from the date of institution of the suit till its realization, against LRs of defendant. The judgment passed by Ld. Trial Court does not need interference and the same is upheld. Point No.3 is accordingly decided in favour of plaintiff bank and against LRs of deceased. 30. The appeal of LRs of defendant is accordingly dismissed on merits and disposed of accordingly. 31. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly. 32. Trial Court record be sent back to the Ld. Trial Court along with the copy of this judgment and decree sheet. 33. File be consigned to the Record Room, after due compliance. Announced in the open Court on 29th April, 2025 (DEEPANKER MOHAN) DISTRICT JUDGE-04, SHAHDARA DISTRICT KKD Courts, Delhi. RCA DJ 45/2024 Page No.14 of 14 -- 14 of 14 --
