Skip to main content
Court Order

Final Order 20

CNR DLSH01002346202313 Dec 2025
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Final Order 20 · 13 Dec 2025 · CNR DLSH010023462023

Order Details: COPY OF ORDER
Pdf Text: MCA No. 53/2023
Kunwar Pal vs. DDA & Ors. Page No. 1 of 12
IN THE COURT OF GAURAV: DISTRICT JUDGE-01
SHAHDARA DISTRICT, KARKARDOOMA COURTS:
DELHI
DLSH010023462023
MCA No. 53/2023
In the matter of:-
Kunwar Pal
S/o Sh. Chet Ram
R/o Jhuggi No. 24,
Behind Deepak Memorial Hospital,
Near Karkardooma Village,
Delhi-110092 …Appellant
Versus
1. Delhi Development Authority,
Through its Director/Vice Chairman
Vikas Sadan, INA, New Delhi.
2. Slum and JJ Department,
Through its director,
Punarwas Bhawan, A-4,
Vikas Kutir, ITO,
New Delhi-110002.
3. Govt of NCT of Delhi
Through its secretary,
Urban Development Department,
9th Level “C” Wing, Delhi Secretariate,
IP Estate New Delhi-110002. …Respondents
13.12.2025
ORDER
1. Vide this order, I shall dispose of the present
miscellaneous civil appeal under Order XLIII Rule 1(r) read with
-- 1 of 12 --
MCA No. 53/2023
Kunwar Pal vs. DDA & Ors. Page No. 2 of 12
Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
(hereinafter
referred as CPC), which has been filed by the appellant/plaintiff
against the impugned order dated 17.12.2022, passed by the Ld.
Trial Court whereby the application under Order XXXIX Rule 1
and 2 CPC has been dismissed. It is matter of record that the
application under section 5 of Limitation Act, 1963; seeking
condonation of delay in filing the present miscellaneous civil
appeal under Order XLIII Rule 1(r) of the CPC, had already been
disposed of as allowed vide order dated 06.06.2025.
2. To avoid confusion and for the ease of reference and
clarity in the order, the appellant and respondents herein, shall be
referred to by their original nomenclature in the suit as
“plaintiff”, “defendant no. 1”, “defendant no. 2” and
“defendant
no. 3” respectively, throughout the present order.
BRIEF MATRIX OF THE SUIT
3. The case of the plaintiff is that he is the owner and
occupant of one of the jhuggis situated behind Deepak Memorial
Hospital in Karkardooma village, Delhi, and has been residing
therein along with his family members for a considerable length
of time.
4. It is the further case of the plaintiff that the said jhuggi
forms part of a larger cluster comprising more than sixty
dwellings, all of which have been in existence for over two
decades, thereby evidencing a settled habitation rather than a
transient encroachment. In order to substantiate his claim of
continuous residence and possession, the plaintiff has relied upon
various official documents issued in his favour, including his
Election Identity Card, Ration Card, and Aadhaar Card.
-- 2 of 12 --
MCA No. 53/2023
Kunwar Pal vs. DDA & Ors. Page No. 3 of 12
5. According to plaintiff, these documents are demonstrative
of his long-standing occupation of the premises and establish his
entitlement to protection under the statutory and policy
framework governing slum dwellers in the National Capital
Territory of Delhi.
6. The grievance of the plaintiff is that officials of defendant
no. 1 i.e. Delhi Development Authority
(hereinafter referred to as
“DDA”) have on several occasions visited the site and threatened
him and his family members with forcible dispossession. Such
threats are unlawful and contrary to the policy of the Government
of NCT of Delhi, which, according to him, recognizes the rights
of long-term jhuggi dwellers and does not treat them as mere
encroachers upon public land.
7. It is the further case of the plaintiff that his possession is
safeguarded under the provisions of the Delhi Urban Shelter
Improvement Board (DUSIB) Amendment Act, 2015. The said
enactment, read conjointly with the Master Plan for Delhi, 2021,
provides protection to slum dwellers against arbitrary eviction
and mandates the provision of alternative accommodation prior
to any displacement.
8. It is the further case of the plaintiff that these instruments
confer upon him a legal right not to be evicted without due
process and without the assurance of rehabilitation. On the
strength of the aforesaid statutory provisions and policy
guidelines, the plaintiff has claimed that defendant no. 2 i.e. the
Slum and JJ Department of the Government of Delhi
(hereinafter
referred to as “DUSIB”), be directed to prepare a list of eligible
persons and to allot alternative land to those found entitled.
Pending such determination, the plaintiff has prayed for an order
-- 3 of 12 --
MCA No. 53/2023
Kunwar Pal vs. DDA & Ors. Page No. 4 of 12
of interim injunction restraining the defendants from
dispossessing him and his family members from the suit premises
during the pendency of the suit.
DEFENCE OF DEFENDANT NO. 1/DDA
9. In the written statement filed on behalf of DDA, it is
asserted that the plaintiff has not approached this Court with
clean hands and has suppressed material facts. The plaintiff has
no documentary proof in support of his alleged ownership of the
suit property and is attempting to unlawfully grab land belonging
to the DDA.
10. It is further asserted that the land in question is owned by
the DDA and that possession thereof was duly taken by the
Authority on 03.12.1968. The plaintiff has not sought any relief
of declaration with respect to ownership or title, and therefore,
the present suit is not maintainable in law.
11. The defendant has categorically denied the plaintiff’s
claim of lawful possession and has described him as a trespasser
who is not entitled to any discretionary relief from the Court. In
support of this contention, the defendant no.1 has pointed out that
the electricity connection at the suit premises shows the date of
energisation as 2016, which is inconsistent with the plaintiff’s
assertion of possession prior to the year 2005.
12. It is further asserted that mere possession of documents
such as a bank account, voter identity card, or other personal
identification records does not confer ownership rights over
immovable property. Such documents only establish the identity
of a person and cannot be relied upon to claim title or lawful
-- 4 of 12 --
MCA No. 53/2023
Kunwar Pal vs. DDA & Ors. Page No. 5 of 12
possession of land belonging to the DDA.
13. It is further asserted that the suit property was encroached
upon by labourers of one Jai Bhagwan, who sought to take
advantage of a status quo order passed by the Hon’ble High
Court of Delhi in W.P.(C) No. 10067/2015 titled
Jai Bhagwan vs.
Union of India. The said writ petition, however, has since been
dismissed, and therefore, no protection or benefit can be claimed
by the plaintiff under the garb of the said proceedings.
DEFENCE OF DEFENDANT NO. 2/DUSIB
14. In the written statement filed on behalf of DUSIB, it is
asserted that it is the nodal agency entrusted with the
responsibility of relocation and rehabilitation of jhuggi jhopri
situated on lands belonging to the Municipal Corporation of
Delhi (MCD), the Government of NCT of Delhi, and its various
Departments and Agencies.
15. It is further asserted that the jhuggi cluster referred to in
the present suit, does not find mention in the list of 675 identified
bastis, nor in the additional 82 bastis subsequently recognized,
under the Delhi Slum and Jhuggi Jhopri Rehabilitation and
Relocation Policy, 2015.
16. After hearing both the parties, the application under Order
XXXIX Rule 1 and 2 CPC was dismissed by the Ld. Trial Court,
vide impugned order dated 17.12.2022.
17. The plaintiff being aggrieved by the said impugned order
dated 17.12.2022 passed by Ld. Trial Court, preferred the present
appeal mainly on the grounds that:
1.) Because the Ld. Trial Court failed to appreciate that
-- 5 of 12 --
MCA No. 53/2023
Kunwar Pal vs. DDA & Ors. Page No. 6 of 12
the cluster where the appellant resides is covered
under Section 2(g) of the Delhi Urban Shelter
Improvement Board Act, 2010, and respondent no. 2
has filed relevant documents confirming its
existence as per the 2015 policy dated 15.01.2020.
2.) Because the Ld. Trial Court ignored the site
inspection report dated 27.01.2020 by Ms. K. Gupta,
which recorded about 60–70 jhuggies at the site,
identified DDA as the land-owning agency, and
noted valid occupancy proofs such as OPD cards
(2002), bank passbooks (2006), ration cards,
Aadhaar, and voter IDs issued prior to 2015, though
the camp was not listed in the official DUSIB cluster
list.
3.) Because the Ld. Trial Court failed to consider that
respondent no.2’s own visit confirmed compliance
with the 2015 policy and that the sociological
department of DUSIB found the residents were not
encroachers.
4.) Because the Ld. Trial Court overlooked that the
DUSIB official’s report supports the appellant’s
cluster as a notified area, and denial by respondent
no.2 amounts to evasion of duty. Possession is prima
facie in favour of the appellant, supported by the
Delhi High Court judgment in
Manoj Kumar & Ors.
vs. DUSIB & Ors.
5.) Because the Ld. Trial Court failed to require
respondent no.2 to file the compliance survey report
along with affidavit, which remains absent.
6.) Because the Ld. Trial Court ignored the binding
precedent of
Sudama Singh vs. Govt. of NCT of
Delhi, affirmed by the Supreme Court, which
supports the appellant’s case.
7.) Because the Ld. Trial Court failed to appreciate that
Ajay Makan vs. Union of India (para 112.11)
reiterated the principle from
Sudama Singh that
jhuggi dwellers must not be treated as second-class
-- 6 of 12 --
MCA No. 53/2023
Kunwar Pal vs. DDA & Ors. Page No. 7 of 12
citizens.
8.) Because the Ld. Trial Court wrongly applied
Manoj
Kumar & Ors. judgment, where the 2015 policy
criteria were not met. In contrast, the appellant’s
cluster fulfils the policy, with about 70 households
existing prior to 01.01.2006.
9.) Because the Ld. Trial Court wrongly equated the
appellant’s case with
Dinesh Singh & Ors. vs. DDA
and
Kasturba Nagar Residents Welfare Association
vs. Govt. of NCT of Delhi, which are
distinguishable.
10.) Because the Ld. Trial Court failed to consider the
Government of NCT Delhi’s order dated
16.02.2015, which directed that no demolitions of
jhuggies or residential houses be carried out without
prior approval of the Urban Development Minister.
11.) Because the Ld. Trial Court ignored respondent
no.2’s own admission under Part A Clause 2(v) of
the 2015 Policy, which prohibits demolition of
eligible jhuggi bastis except under limited
circumstances: (i) court orders, (ii) encroachment on
public ways or safety zones, or (iii) urgent public
projects under the Special Provisions Act, 2011.
18. Notice of this appeal was sent to defendants and trial
court record was also requisitioned for adjudicating the present
appeal.
19. Defendant no. 1 and defendant no. 2 have duly appeared
through counsel and filed written submission/reply to the appeal,
denying all the assertions made therein and have prayed for
dismissal of the same.
20. Having heard the rival contentions of Ld. Counsels for the
parties and meticulously perused the impugned order, trial court
record, and the documents placed before this Court, as well as the
-- 7 of 12 --
MCA No. 53/2023
Kunwar Pal vs. DDA & Ors. Page No. 8 of 12
relevant provisions of law.
21. The main question that arises for consideration in the
present miscellaneous civil appeal is whether the plaintiff was
able to establish a
prima facie case,
balance of convenience, and
irreparable loss so as to warrant the grant of interim injunction,
and whether the Ld. Trial Court was justified in dismissing the
application under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 CPC.
22. Before adverting to the merits of the present miscellaneous
civil appeal, it would be apposite to refer to the relevant
provisions of Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 CPC, which provide
for the grant of temporary injunctions. Rule 1 CPC provides that
where in any suit it is proved by affidavit or otherwise: that any
property in dispute in a suit is in danger of being wasted,
damaged, or alienated by any party to the suit, or wrongfully sold
in execution of a decree; or that the defendant threatens or
intends to remove or dispose of his property with a view to
defraud his creditors; the Court may by order grant a temporary
injunction to restrain such act. Rule 2 CPC empowers the Court
to grant an injunction to restrain the defendant from committing a
breach of contract or other injury of any kind to the plaintiff in
relation to any property in dispute in the suit.
23. It is a settled principle that, while considering an
application under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 CPC, the court
must examine whether a
prima facie case exists, where the
balance of convenience lies, and whether
irreparable harm would
ensue if interim relief is not granted.
24. It is imperative to mention herein that during the course of
arguments, Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff placed on record two
orders passed by the Court of Sh. Mayank Goyal, Ld.
-- 8 of 12 --
MCA No. 53/2023
Kunwar Pal vs. DDA & Ors. Page No. 9 of 12
JSCC/ASCJ, Shahdara District, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi; in
CS No. 1387/19 titled as
“Lochan Lal vs. DDA & Ors.” dated
23.10.2024 and CS No. 262/20
“Sanjay Kumar vs. DDA & Ors.”
dated 23.10.2024. In both matters, the defendants were restrained
from dispossessing the plaintiffs from their respective jhuggis
situated behind Deepak Memorial Hospital, Karkardooma
Village, Dayanand Vihar, Delhi, without following due process of
law. Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff contended that these orders
pertain to the same cluster in which the present plaintiff resides,
and therefore, the plaintiff is entitled to similar protection.
25. On being specifically queried from the defendant no.
1/DDA to which Ld. Sr. Counsel for the defendant no. 1 fairly
submitted that the aforesaid orders have not been challenged
before any higher forum. At the same time, he contended that
those directions were passed in separate suits and cannot bind
this Court while deciding the present appeal. He further
contended that the appellant cannot derive any vested right
merely because neighbouring residents obtained interim
protection.
26. This Court is conscious of the fact that the orders relied
upon by the plaintiff were passed by a Ld. ASCJ and, strictly
speaking, are not binding precedents upon this Court. However,
the significance of those orders lies in the fact that they pertain to
the same cluster of jhuggis and were passed after consideration
of similar facts and circumstances. The admitted position that
those orders remain unchallenged lends weight to the plaintiff’s
contention and that the defendants have not sought to disturb the
judicial protection already extended to similarly situated
residents. While not binding, such orders are relevant for
-- 9 of 12 --
MCA No. 53/2023
Kunwar Pal vs. DDA & Ors. Page No. 10 of 12
assessing the existence of a
prima facie case and the balance of
convenience.
27. Turning now to the essential requirements of Order
XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 CPC, the first requirement is whether the
plaintiff has disclosed a
prima facie case. The plaintiff has
produced documentary evidence of residence, including voter ID,
electricity bill, passbook, ration card, medical card and Aadhaar
card, prior to the year 2015. The site inspection report dated
27.01.2020 records the existence of 60–70 jhuggis at the site and
identifies the DDA as the land-owning agency. The aforesaid
unchallenged orders in
“Lochan Lal vs. DDA & Ors.” and
“Sanjay Kumar vs. DDA & Ors.” further corroborate that
residents of the same cluster have been recognized as being in
possession. While the defendants contended that identity
documents do not confer ownership and that the land belongs to
DDA since 1968, it is herein clarified that the plaintiff is not
seeking declaration of ownership at this stage but only protection
of his residence until the suit is finally adjudicated. In these
circumstances, a
prima facie case stands established.
28. The second requirement is the
balance of convenience. The
plaintiff resides in the suit premises along with his family, and
eviction at this stage would result in immediate homelessness.
The defendants, being statutory authorities, are bound to act in
accordance with law and policy, and maintaining status quo
during the pendency of the suit does not cause them any
prejudice. The fact that similarly placed residents in the same
cluster have already been granted protection by competent courts,
and those orders remain unchallenged, further tilts the
balance of
convenience in favour of the plaintiff. To deny him similar
-- 10 of 12 --
MCA No. 53/2023
Kunwar Pal vs. DDA & Ors. Page No. 11 of 12
protection would result in unequal treatment of persons similarly
situated.
29. The third requirement is
irreparable loss. It is well settled
that deprivation of shelter amounts to irreparable injury which
cannot be compensated in monetary terms. In the present case,
refusal of interim protection would expose the plaintiff to
precisely such irreparable harm. The contention of defendant no.
1/DDA that the electricity connection was obtained only in 2016
does not negate the plaintiff’s claim of prior residence, as the
inspection report dated 27.01.2020 shows occupation prior to that
date.
30. At the same time, it is necessary to clarify herein that the
grant of interim protection does not amount to recognition of
ownership or title in favour of the plaintiff. The restraint order is
intended only to preserve the status quo and to ensure that the
plaintiff is not dispossessed during the pendency of the suit. The
rights of the parties shall be determined finally at the stage of
trial, and nothing stated herein shall prejudice that determination.
The plaintiff’s protection is limited to safeguarding his residence
until the suit is adjudicated, and does not confer any proprietary
rights over the land in question.
31. In view of the above observations, this Court finds that the
plaintiff has established a
prima facie case, the
balance of
convenience lies in his favour, and
irreparable loss would ensue
if interim protection is denied. The impugned order dated
17.12.2022 passed by the Ld. Trial Court is accordingly set aside.
The appeal is hereby disposed of as allowed. The defendants are
restrained from dispossessing the plaintiff from the suit premises
until the final disposal of the suit.
-- 11 of 12 --
MCA No. 53/2023
Kunwar Pal vs. DDA & Ors. Page No. 12 of 12
32. It is clarified that nothing stated herein shall be construed
as a final expression on the merits of the suit.
33. Ld. Trial Court is also requested to proceed with the suit
expeditiously and decide the same on its own merits without
being influenced by any observations made in this order.
34. A copy of this order along with the trial court record be
sent back to the Ld. Trial Court for information.
35. Appeal file be consigned to Record Room as per rules.
(Typed to the dictation directly, corrected and
pronounced in open court on 13.12.2025).
(GAURAV)
DISTRICT JUDGE-01
SHAHDARA DISTRICT
KARKARDOOMA COURTS
DELHI
Certified that this judgment contains 12 pages and each page bears
my signature.
(GAURAV)
DISTRICT JUDGE-01
SHAHDARA DISTRICT
KARKARDOOMA COURTS
DELHI
-- 12 of 12 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.