Skip to main content
Court Order

Final Order 17

CNR DLSH01002310202315 Apr 2026
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Final Order 17 · 15 Apr 2026 · CNR DLSH010023102023

Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT
Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. HARUN PRATAP, PO, MACT-02,
DISTRICT SHAHDARA, KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI.
MACT No.: 214/23
CNR No. DLSH01-002310-2023
IN THE MATTER OF:-
1. Mr. Amir Khan @ Amit
S/o Sh. Mehendi,
R/o Mohalla Budh Nagar,
Gajraula, Tehsil, Dhanora, Amroha,
UP.-244233
........ (Petitioner)
Vs.
1. M/s Rana Real Estate,
Through its proprietor
Sh. Yogender Singh,
S/o Sh. Deep Singh,
R/o H. No. A-35, Gr. Floor,
D.L.F., Dilshad Garden Ext.-II,
Bhopura, Ghaziabad, U.P.-201005.
..….... (Owner)
2. Sh. Sumit Kumar,
S/o Sh. Jogender Singh,
R/o 191, Gali no. 10,
Ashok Vatika, Garima Garden,
Sahibabad, District Ghaziabad, U.P.- 201005
…...... (Driver)
3. The Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.
Office at: C/93, Subhash Road, Naveen Shahdara,
Delhi-110032.
..... (Respondents)
MACT No. 214/23 Amir Khan @ Amit Vs. M/s Rana Real Estate and Ors. Page No. 1 of 23
-- 1 of 23 --
Date of institution of claim petition : 18.04.2023
Date of Arguments : 15.04.2026
Date of Award : 15.04.2026
Advocates appearing in the case:
For petitioner : Sh. C.P. Singh
For respondent no. 01 & 02 : Ms. Archana Kumari
For respondent no. 03/Insurance Co. : Manjul Awasthi
AWARD
Vide this award, the Tribunal shall decide the MACT claim petition
bearing no. 214/23, under section 166(4) & 140 of Motor Vehicles Act,
1988, filed for the petitioner and against the respondents as mentioned in
the memo of parties.
FACTS OF THE CASE
1. Briefly stated, the facts of the petition are that on 21.01.2023, at about
11:00 p.m., petitioner Amir Khan @ Amit was standing near Water Tanki
no. 21, Near Khoda Ghaziabad, U.P., within the jurisdiction of PS Khoda,
Ghaziabad. It has been alleged that in the meanwhile a Truck bearing
registration no. UP14JT9144 (hereinafter referred to as offending vehicle),
came at a very high speed and hit the afore-said petitioner with a great
force. It has been further alleged that the aforesaid offending vehicle was
being driven by its driver i.e. respondent no. 2 (R2) herein, at a very high
speed and in a rash and negligent manner at the time of the accident. It has
been also alleged that due to such forceful impact, the petitioner fell down
on the road & sustained grievous injuries in his left leg. The injured was
thereon taken to M.M.G. Hospital, Ghaziabad for initial treatment and
MACT No. 214/23 Amir Khan @ Amit Vs. M/s Rana Real Estate and Ors. Page No. 2 of 23
-- 2 of 23 --
subsequently he was referred to Jeevan Hospital, U.P., where he remained
admitted from 22.01.2023 and 15.02.2023. An FIR in this regard also came
to be registered at PS Khoda, Ghaziabad, U.P., vide FIR no. 053/23, for the
offences u/s 279/338/427 IPC. The present claim petition thereafter came to
be filed in due course on 18.04.2023.
WS / Reply of Respondents
2. In the joint WS filed by the Respondent no. 1 and Respondent no. 2,
ie. the owner and driver of the offending vehicle respectively, it has been
contended that the respondents have been falsely implicated in the present
case and that the accident took place due to sole negligence on part of the
injured himself. The respondents nevertheless stated that the offending
vehicle was duly insured with the Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. i.e.
respondent no. 03 (R3) at the time of the accident. However, the
Respondent no. 01 & 02 denied all the contents of the claim petition and
prayed for its dismissal.
3. Respondent no. 3 i.e. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., also filed its
separate detailed written statement, wherein it has been admitted that the
offending vehicle was duly insured with the company vide insurance policy
no. 242596/31/2023/TMC/34700, in the name of M/s Rana Real Estate i.e.
R1 herein, with its validity from 31.12.2022 to 30.12.2023. However, the
respondent no. 3 denied its liability and prayed for dismissal of the claim
petition.
ISSUES
MACT No. 214/23 Amir Khan @ Amit Vs. M/s Rana Real Estate and Ors. Page No. 3 of 23
-- 3 of 23 --
4. From the pleadings of the parties, following issues were framed by
the Tribunal vide order dated 22.01.2025, as under:-
(i) Whether petitioner suffered injuries in the motor accident caused by
rash and negligent driving of vehicle no UP14JT9144 by respondent no. 1
on 21.01.2023 at about 11:00 pm near Water Tanki No. 21, Khoda Colony,
Ghaziabad, within the jurisdiction of PS Khoda Ghaziabad? Opp.
(ii) Whether petitioner is entitled for compensation, if so, to what extend
and from whom? OPP.
(iii) Relief.
PETITIONER'S EVIDENCE
5. In order to prove her case, petitioner Mr. Amir Khan @ Amit
examined himself as PW1. He tendered his evidence by way of affidavit Ex.
PW1/A, wherein he reiterated the contents of the claim petition and relied
upon the following documents:-
Sl. No. Exhibit No. Particulars
1 Ex. PW1/1
(colly)
Certified copy of charge-sheet, FIR, MLC, Site
Plan
2 Ex.PW1/2 (colly)
(OSR)
Copy of Aadhar card and PAN Card of the
injured
3 Ex.PW1/3 (colly) Discharge Card
4 Ex.PW1/4(colly) Medical Hospital bills of Rs. 6,32,552.48
5 Ex.PW1/5 (Colly) Photograph of deponent
6 Ex.PW1/6 (OSR) Photograph of DL
He was cross-examined and discharged.
6. The petitioner did not examine any other witness and PE stood closed
MACT No. 214/23 Amir Khan @ Amit Vs. M/s Rana Real Estate and Ors. Page No. 4 of 23
-- 4 of 23 --
by the Tribunal vide order dated 30.07.2025, in view of the separate
statement of ld. Counsel for petitioner recorded to this effect.
Respondents' Evidence
7. The respondents failed to examine any witness and RE was thereon
closed by the Tribunal vide order dated 14.01.2026, in view of the separate
statement of Ld. Counsels for R3/Insurance Company and R1 & R2
recorded to this effect.
8. Final arguments heard. File perused.
Issue wise findings
ISSUE NO. 1
Whether petitioner suffered injuries in the motor accident caused by
rash and negligent driving of vehicle no UP14JT9144 by respondent no. 1
on 21.01.2023 at about 11:00 pm near Water Tanki No. 21, Khoda Colony,
Ghaziabad, within the jurisdiction of PS Khoda Ghaziabad? Opp.
9. In an action founded on the principle of fault liability, the proof of
rash and negligent driving of the offending vehicle is sine qua non.
However, the standard of proof is not as strict as applied in criminal cases
and evidence is tested on the touchstone of principle of preponderance of
probabilities
. It is well settled that the procedure followed for proceedings
conducted by an accident tribunal is similar to that followed by a civil court
and in civil matters the facts are required to be established by
preponderance of probabilities only and not by strict rules of evidence or
beyond reasonable doubts as are required in a criminal prosecution. The
burden of proof in a civil case is never as heavy as that is required in a
MACT No. 214/23 Amir Khan @ Amit Vs. M/s Rana Real Estate and Ors. Page No. 5 of 23
-- 5 of 23 --
criminal case, but in a claim petition under the Motor Vehicles Act, this
burden is infact even lesser than that in a civil case. Reference in this regard
can be made to the propositions of law laid down by Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of
Bimla Devi & Ors. Vs Himachal Road Transport
Corporation & Ors, reported in (2009) 13 SC 530, which were reiterated in
the subsequent judgment in the case of
Parmeshwari Vs Amir Chand & Ors,
2011 (1) SCR 1906 (Civil Appeal No. 1082 of 2011) and also recently in
another case
Mangla Ram Vs. Oriental Insurance Co. ltd. & Ors., 2018 Law
Suit (SC) 303.
10. Herein the present case, the petitioner has examined himself as the
star witness to show that the R-2 being the driver of the offending vehicle
was rash and negligent in his driving of the offending vehicle and that
grievous injuries were caused to him on account of the accident in question.
It has been specifically stated by the PW-1 that he was hit by the truck being
driven by R-2. The said assertions made by the petitioner while deposing as
PW-1 have remained unimpeached despite his extensive cross examination
by the respondents. The claim put forth by the petitioner and the contentions
regarding the rash and negligent act of R-2 in driving the offending vehicle
at the time of the accident is duly corroborated by the findings of the
IO/police as mentioned in the site plan, mechanical inspection report,
seizure memo, Charge sheet along with other documents pertaining to
criminal case in respect of the incident in question brought on record as Ex.
PW1/1 and no ground has been made out by the respondents to disbelieve
the same. The testimony of petitioner as PW1 has remained consistent and
MACT No. 214/23 Amir Khan @ Amit Vs. M/s Rana Real Estate and Ors. Page No. 6 of 23
-- 6 of 23 --
no doubt has been raised by the respondents to disbelieve the same.
11. The respondent no. 1 ie. owner, respondent no. 2 ie. driver and
respondent no.3 ie. insurance company have neither impeached the
testimony of PW-1 nor they have led any defence evidence to substantiate
their claim that the accident was not caused due to fault of the driver of the
offending vehicle or that they have been falsely implicated in the present
case. The evidence of the star witness in this case i.e. PW-1, on the aspect of
rash and negligent act of respondent no.2 while driving the offending
vehicle, has remained unimpeached and his testimony has to be accepted on
its face value itself as the same has successfully stood the test of cross-
examination.
12. The very fact that R-2 has already been specifically arrayed as an
accused in case FIR No. 053/23, PS Khoda, Ghaziabad, U.P., for the
offences u/s 279/338/427 IPC is also a strong circumstance to support the
above said testimony of PW-1 on these issues. The copies of FIR, Site plan,
report u/s 173 Cr.PC and mechanical inspection report brought on record as
Ex. PW1/1 also corroborate the oral testimony of PW-1. Furthermore, the
position of law in this regard has been made clear in the case of
“National
Insurance Co., Vs Puspha Rana”, 2009 ACJ 287 Delhi, wherein it has been
held that filing of Chargesheet is sufficient proof of the negligence and
involvement of the offending vehicle. Similar observations have been made
in the case of
“United India Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Deepak Goel and Ors.”,
2014 (2) Tac 846 Del, that if the claimant was able to prove the criminal
MACT No. 214/23 Amir Khan @ Amit Vs. M/s Rana Real Estate and Ors. Page No. 7 of 23
-- 7 of 23 --
case on record pertaining to involvement of the offending vehicle, whereby
the criminal records showing completion of investigation by the police and
filing of Chargesheet under Section 279/304-A/337 IPC against the driver
have been proved, then, the documents mentioned above are sufficient to
establish the fact that the driver was negligent in causing the accident.
Where FIR is lodged, Chargesheet is filed, especially in a case where driver
after causing the accident had fled away from the spot, then the documents
mentioned above are sufficient to establish the fact that the driver of the
offending vehicle was negligent in causing the accident particularly when
there was no defence available from his side before the Learned Tribunal.
The position of law has been recently reiterated by Hon’ble Supreme Court
in case titled as
“Ranjeet & Anr. Vs. Abdul Kayam Neb & Anr.” arising out
of SLP (C ) No. 10351/2019, wherein it has been held that:-
“It is settled in law that once a charge-sheet has been filed and the
driver has been held negligent, no further evidence is required to
prove that the bus was being negligently driven by the bus driver.
Even if the eye witnesses are not examined, that will not be fatal to
prove the death of the deceased due to negligence of the bus driver.”
13. Besides the above, respondent no. 2 namely Sumit Kumar was the
best witness who could have stepped into the witness box to challenge the
depositions being made by PW-1 regarding the above accident and its
manner etc., but he has not done so. Therefore, an adverse inference on this
aspect is also required to be drawn against the respondents in view of the
law laid down in case of
Cholamandalam M.S. General Insurance Company
MACT No. 214/23 Amir Khan @ Amit Vs. M/s Rana Real Estate and Ors. Page No. 8 of 23
-- 8 of 23 --
Ltd. Vs. Kamlesh, reported in 2009 (3) AD (Delhi).
14. In view of the above, it could be safely assumed that the offending
vehicle being driven by R-2 at the relevant time had indeed hit the petitioner
thus resulting into grievous injuries being caused to the petitioner.
15. Having ruled so, this Tribunal now proceeds to assess the wrongful
act, neglect or default of R-2, if any, in driving the offending vehicle at the
relevant time. Admittedly, R-2 has not explained the circumstances under
which his vehicle (i.e. the offending vehicle) hit the injured. In the absence
of any averment or evidence regarding any mechanical defect in the
offending vehicle or any material depicting any negligent/sudden act or
omission on the part of the injured, the only inference possible in the given
facts and circumstances is that of neglect and default on the part of R-2 in
driving the offending vehicle at the relevant time. In view of the above
discussion, this tribunal is constrained to hold R-2 guilty of gross neglect
and default in driving the offending vehicle at the relevant time leading to
the injuries to the petitioner.
16. In view of the medical treatment documents placed on record by the
petitioner, no dispute is left regarding the grievous injuries sustained by him
in the incident in question.
17. Therefore, in view of the above discussion, this Tribunal has no
hesitation in hereby arriving at the finding that the petitioner suffered
grievous injuries on his person on account of neglect and default of R-2
MACT No. 214/23 Amir Khan @ Amit Vs. M/s Rana Real Estate and Ors. Page No. 9 of 23
-- 9 of 23 --
while driving the offending vehicle at the relevant time. The issue at hand
thus hereby stands decided against the respondents and in favour of the
petitioner accordingly.
Issue no. (ii)
Whether petitioner is entitled for compensation, if so, to what extent
and from whom? OPP.
18. In view of the finding on Issue no. 1, petitioner Amir Khan @ Amit is
entitled to get compensation. However, quantum of compensation still needs to
be adjudicated. Section 168 of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 enjoins upon the
claim Tribunal to hold an inquiry into the claim to make an award determining
the amount of compensation, which appears to be just and reasonable. As per
settled law, compensation is not expected to be windfall or a bonanza nor it
should be pittance. A man is not compensated for the physical injury : he is
compensated for the loss which he suffers as a result of that injury (Baker v.
Willoughby (1970) Ac 467 at page 492 per Lord Reid).
19. The present DAR/claim petition pertains to injury and scope of
compensation in injury cases has been considered by Hon’ble Supreme Court
in case titled as Mr. R.D. Hattangadi v. M/S Pest Control (India) Pvt. Ltd.,
1995 AIR 755. The relevant extract is as under:
“Broadly speaking while fixing an amount of compensation
payable to a victim of an accident, the damages have to be
assessed separately as pecuniary damages and special damages.
Pecuniary damages are those which the victim has actually
incurred and which is capable of being calculated in terms of
money-, whereas non-pecuniary damages are those which are
incapable of being assessed by arithmetical calculations. In
order to appreciate two concepts pecuniary damages may,
MACT No. 214/23 Amir Khan @ Amit Vs. M/s Rana Real Estate and Ors. Page No. 10 of 23
-- 10 of 23 --
include expenses incurred by the claimant: (i) medical
attendance; (ii) loss of earning of profit upto the date of trial;
(iii) other material loss. So far non- pecuniary damages are
concerned, they may include (i) damages for mental and
physical shock, pain suffering, already suffered or likely to be
suffered in future; (ii) damages to compensate for the loss of
amenities of life which may include a variety of matters i.e. on
account of injury the claimant may not be able to walk, run or
sit; (iii) damages for the loss of expectation of life, i.e. on
account of injury the normal longevity of the person concerned
is shortened; (iv) inconvenience, discomfort, disappointment,
hardship, frustration and mental stress in life.”
20. Further, in Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar & another (2011) 1 SCC 343,
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India laid down general principles for computation
of compensation in injury cases. The relevant paras of the judgment are
reproduced as under:
5. The provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (“the
Act”, for short) makes it clear that the award must be just,
which means that compensation should, to the extent possible,
fully and adequately restore the claimant to the position prior
to the accident. The object of awarding damages is to make
good the loss suffered as a result of wrong done as far as
money can do so, in a fair, reasonable and equitable manner.
The court or the Tribunal shall have to assess the damages
objectively and exclude from consideration any speculation or
fancy, though some conjecture with reference to the nature of
disability and its consequences, is inevitable. A person is not
only to be compensated for the physical injury, but also for
the loss which he suffered as a result of such injury. This
means that he is to be compensated for his inability to lead a
full life, his inability to enjoy those normal amenities which
he would have enjoyed but for the injuries, and his inability to
earn as much as he used to earn or could have earned.
6. The heads under which compensation is awarded in
personal injury cases are the following:
MACT No. 214/23 Amir Khan @ Amit Vs. M/s Rana Real Estate and Ors. Page No. 11 of 23
-- 11 of 23 --
Pecuniary Damages (special damages)
(i) Expenses relating to treatment, hospitalization, medicines,
transportation, nourishing food and miscellaneous
expenditure.
(ii) Loss of earnings (and other gains) which the injured
would have made had he not been injured, comprising:
(a) Loss of earning during the period of treatment.
(b) Loss of future earnings on account of permanent
disability.
(iii) Future medical expenses.
Non-Pecuniary Damages (general damages)
(iv) Damages to pain, suffering and trauma as a consequence
of the injuries.
(v) Loss of amenities (and/or loss of prospects of marriage)
(vi) Loss of expectation of life (shortening of normal
longevity).
In routine personal injury cases, compensation will be
awarded only under heads (I), (ii), (a) and (iv). It is only in
serious cases of injury, where there is specific medical
evidence corroborating the evidence of the claimant, that
compensation will be granted under any of the heads (ii), (b),
(iii), (v) and (vi) relating to loss of future earnings on account
of permanent disability, future medical expenses, loss of
amenities (and/or loss of prospects of marriage) and loss of
expectation of life.
COMPUTATION OF COMPENSATION
NATURE AND EXTENT OF INJURIES
MACT No. 214/23 Amir Khan @ Amit Vs. M/s Rana Real Estate and Ors. Page No. 12 of 23
-- 12 of 23 --
21. As per the medical treatment record pertaining to petitioner/
injured Amir Khan @ Amit, the latter sustained grievous injuries due to the
accident in this case.
Nature of Injuries: As per the MLC of the victim/injured, the
latter suffered “
Massive-(L) Leg and Roof United Fractures Leg” . The
injuries suffered by the petitioner resulted into permanent locomotor disability
of 76 % in relation to his left lower limb as per the Disability Certificate No.
1044/80/9/2025, dated 18.09.2025, issued by GTB Hospital, Delhi.
Disability, if any: As per the aforementioned disability certificate,
the petitioner has suffered permanent physical disability of 76 % in relation to
his left lower limb. The petitioner happens to be a carpenter and as such he
needs fully functional limbs to continue his profession for earning his
livelihood and the disability suffered by him will make him permanently
disabled. Therefore, on the basis of material available on record, the Tribunal
is of the view that the permanent disability of 76% in relation to left lower
limb will amount to 76 % functional disability of the petitioner in his
profession as a carpenter.
MEDICINES AND TREATMENT
23. In the present case, as per record, the petitioner/ injured has
undergone initial treatment at MMG Hospital, Delhi apart from taking
subsequent treatment from Jeevan Hospital, where he remained admitted
from 22.01.2023 to 13.02.2023. At the same time, the petitioner has also filed
bills for his treatment from Jeevan Hospital and a particular cost of medicines
& treatment has also been mentioned in the evidence affidavit by the
MACT No. 214/23 Amir Khan @ Amit Vs. M/s Rana Real Estate and Ors. Page No. 13 of 23
-- 13 of 23 --
petitioner. The petitioner has brought on record bills totaling Rs. 6,19,471/- as
the cost of the medicines borne by his during the treatment and the same have
not been denied or disputed by the respondents. Not even a single suggestion
has been put to the witness regarding the specific bills and there is no reason to
doubt the veracity or genuineness of the said bills / receipts. In these
circumstances and in view of the material on record, the petitioner / injured
shall be entitled to sum of Rs. 6,19,471/- and accordingly, the petitioner /
injured Amir Khan @ Amit is hereby awarded the said amount i.e. Rs.
6,19,471/- towards Medicines and Medical Treatment.
CONVEYANCE AND SPECIAL DIET
24. In the present case, as per the medical treatment record, petitioner /
injured Amir Khan @ Amit suffered grievous injuries. In these
circumstances, the petitioner / injured must have visited the hospital /
doctors for his treatment and would also have required special diet for
certain period to recover from the injuries sustained in the accident. In the
present case, the petitioner must have undergone treatment for about 06
months from the date of accident as is apparent from his treatment record.
In these circumstances and in view of the material on record, the petitioner /
injured shall be entitled to a sum of Rs. 30,000/- towards conveyance
charges. Furthermore, in view of the above-said grievous injuries suffered
by him, the petitioner / injured must have needed special diet for a similar
period to have a fast and proper recovery. Hence, the petitioner / injured is
hereby awarded Rs. 30,000/- towards expenses for special diet.
LOSS OF INCOME
MACT No. 214/23 Amir Khan @ Amit Vs. M/s Rana Real Estate and Ors. Page No. 14 of 23
-- 14 of 23 --
25. In the present case, the petitioner / injured has claimed that at the time of
accident, he was working as a carpenter and was earning Rs. 25,000/- per
month. However, no documentary evidence in this regard has been placed
on record to substantiate that the petitioner was indeed engaged in a job or
that he had acquired any specific skill. Nevertheless, the petitioner has
specifically claimed himself to be engaged in a skillful job of carpentary
and the respondents have not brought any material to dispute the same.
Furthermore, the petitioner has stated himself to be a resident of U.P. and
there is no other material on record to show otherwise. Hence, this Tribunal
has thus assessed the income of injured at parity with the minimum wages
of ‘
skilled worker’ of U.P. prevalent at the time of accident i.e. Rs. 12,005/-
per month. Furthermore, the Tribunal is of the view that the petitioner must
have suffered loss of earning for a reasonable period of 06 months during
the course of his treatment for the injuries suffered in the accident. Hence,
the petitioner is hereby held entitled to a sum of Rs. 12,005/- X 6 months =
Rs. 72,030/- under the head Loss of Income during the treatment.
ATTENDANT CHARGES
26. The petitioner / injured has not deposed about keeping an attendant
or spending any money on an attendant during the time of his treatment for
the injuries suffered by him on account of incident in question. Neither any
attendant has been examined nor any documentary proof regarding the
payment being made to any such attendant have been brought on record by
the petitioner / injured in this case. However, considering the nature of
injuries, extensive treatment and the prolonged recovery period, the
MACT No. 214/23 Amir Khan @ Amit Vs. M/s Rana Real Estate and Ors. Page No. 15 of 23
-- 15 of 23 --
petitioner must have required the services of an attendant for about 06
months. It is pertinent to note that the petitioner / injured would have also
needed an attendant to look after him, even if the gratuitous services were
rendered by the some or the other of his family members. In the case titled
as
Delhi Transport Corporation and Anr. Vs. Lalita (AIR 1981 Delhi 558), it
has been held by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi that a victim cannot be
deprived of compensation towards gratuitous services rendered by some of
the family members. Further, the petitioner must have spent at least Rs.
7,000/- per month if he had an attendant. In these circumstances, the
petitioner shall be entitled to an amount of Rs. 42,000/- (Rs. 7,000 X 6
months) towards attendant charges.
PAIN AND SUFFERINGS
27. As per the settled law, for assessing the pain and sufferings, the
following factors have to be taken into account:-
(a) Nature of injury
(b) Parts of body where injuries occurred
(c) Surgeries, if any
(d) Confinement in hospital
(e) Duration of the treatment
28. In the instant case, the petitioner has suffered 76 % permanent physical
disability in his left leg and the same will render him as 76 % functionally
disabled person for several jobs and day to day activities of life. Furthermore,
undergoing the operation for the injuries suffered by the petitioner would have
caused him unimaginable pain and sufferings. In these circumstances and in
view of the law laid down in the case titled as
Rekha Jain Vs. National
MACT No. 214/23 Amir Khan @ Amit Vs. M/s Rana Real Estate and Ors. Page No. 16 of 23
-- 16 of 23 --
Insurance Co. Ltd. (arising out of SLP (C) No. 5649-51 of 2012), the petitioner
/ injured is entitled to compensation on account of pain and suffering due to
the accident. The pain and sufferings of petitioner / injured cannot be
adequately compensated in terms of money as no amount of money can be
substitute for the lost function of a limb, but nevertheless, a sum of Rs.
25,000/- is hereby awarded to petitioner towards the head “pain and
sufferings”.
LOSS OF ENJOYMENT OF LIFE AND AMENITIES
29. The petitioner / injured has claimed that he has suffered loss of
enjoyment of life and other amenities on account of the accident. The
petitioner / injured was about 28 years 11 months old at the time of accident
and has suffered grievous injuries. Loss of ability to indulge in physical
activity is also likely to adversely affect his overall health. In these
circumstances and in view of the law laid down in the case titled as
Rekha
Jain (Supra), the petitioner / injured is hereby awarded a sum of Rs.
25,000/- as compensation towards loss of enjoyment of life and amenities.
In addition to this, the petitioner is also awarded a sum of Rs. 25,000/- as
just and fair compensation for mental and physical shock suffered by him
due to the accident in this case.
LOSS OF MARRIAGE PROSPECTS
30. The petitioner in this case happened to be already married at the time
of the incident. Furthermore, the petitioner has neither contended nor proved
any adverse effects on his matrimonial prospects due to the injuries suffered by
him in any manner. Therefore, in absence of any material or evidence on
MACT No. 214/23 Amir Khan @ Amit Vs. M/s Rana Real Estate and Ors. Page No. 17 of 23
-- 17 of 23 --
record, the Tribunal finds no ground to award any compensation to the
petitioner under this head.
LOSS OF FUTURE INCOME / PROSPECTS
31. In the present case, as per medical record, petitioner / injured Amir
Khan @ Amit has suffered permanent physical disability of 76 % in relation to
his left leg and has received treatment for about 6 months. The petitioner has
failed to furnish documents to show that at the time of accident, he was
earning Rs. 25,000/- per month. As held above, the income of the petitioner
has been calculated on the basis of minimum wages of
“ skilled worker” of
U.P. at the relevant time @ Rs. 12,005/- per month and it has already been
held that the injuries suffered by the petitioner would result in 76 % functional
disability in pursuing the job of carpenter by the petitioner. Further in terms of
the principles laid down in National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi
(2017 (13) SCALE 12), the petitioner is also entitled to future prospects.
AGE: As per her aadhar card on record, the petitioner was born on
09.02.1994. Thus, at the time of accident, he was about 28 years 11 months
old. Further in terms of the principles laid down in the case Sarla Verma Vs.
DTC (AIR 2009 SC 2104), a multiplier of 17 would be applicable to the
present case. Hence, he will be entitled to future prospects @ 40 % as he was
below 40 years of age at the time of accident and was not having permanent
job. Therefore, the loss of future prospects / income is calculated as:
Minimum Wages Rs. 12,005/- X 40% (Future Prospects) Rs. 4,802/-
Rs. 12,005 /- + Rs. 4,802 /- Rs. 16,807/-
Rs. 16,807/- X 76 % (Disability) Rs. 12,773/-
MACT No. 214/23 Amir Khan @ Amit Vs. M/s Rana Real Estate and Ors. Page No. 18 of 23
-- 18 of 23 --
Rs. 12,773 /- X 12 X 17 (Multiplier) Rs. 26,05,692/-
Hence, the petitioner shall be entitled to compensation of Rs.
26,05,692/- under this head.
32. The break-up of compensation that has been awarded to petitioner
/ injured Amir Khan @ Amit is tabulated as below:-
S. No. HEADS AMOUNT (Rs.)
1 Medicines and Treatment 6,19,471.00
2 Conveyance 30,000.00
3 Special Diet 30,000.00
4 Loss of income 72,030.00
5 Attendant Charges 42,000.00
6 Pain and Sufferings 25,000.00
7 Loss of Enjoyment of Life and Amenities 25,000.00
8 Compensation for mental and physical
shock
25,000.00
9 Loss of marriage prospects 00.00
10 Loss of future income 26,05,692.00
Total 34,74,193.00
LIABILITY
33. Now, the question arises as to which of the respondents is liable to
pay the compensation amount. The driver of the offending vehicle is the
principal
tort feasor on account of his rash and negligent driving, while the
owner of the offending vehicle is vicariously liable for the acts of his agent
MACT No. 214/23 Amir Khan @ Amit Vs. M/s Rana Real Estate and Ors. Page No. 19 of 23
-- 19 of 23 --
i.e. driver. Herein, it is pertinent to note that the respondent no. 3 i.e.
insurance Company has specifically admitted in its written statement that
the offending vehicle was duly insured at the time of accident with
respondent no. 3 vide policy No. OG-21-3366-1802-00000498, in the name
of M/s Rana Real Estate i.e. R1 herein, with its validity from 31.12.2022 to
30.12.2023. At the same time, the respondent no. 3/insurance company has
failed to bring on record or to prove any breach of the terms or conditions of
the said insurance policy by the respondent no. 1 & 2 in any manner.
33. Hence, on the basis of entire above stated facts and circumstances and
discussion of evidence, this Tribunal is of the opinion that respondent no.3
i.e. insurance company, is liable to pay the entire compensation to the
petitioners on behalf of respondent no. 1 & 2 without any recovery rights.
The issue at hand is thus decided against the respondents and in favour of
the petitioner accordingly.
ISSUE NO.3 / RELIEF
34. In view of the the findings on the aforesaid issues, the petitioner is
hereby awarded a sum of Rs. 34,74,193/- (Rupees Thirty Four Lakh Seventy
Four Thousand One Hundred Ninety Three Only) along with interest @ 8%
per annum from the date of filing of claim petition till its deposition by the
respondent no. 3 i.e. insurance company. However, it is directed that the
amount of interim award alongwith waiver of interest, if any, shall be
excluded from the above amount and calculations of compensation.
MACT No. 214/23 Amir Khan @ Amit Vs. M/s Rana Real Estate and Ors. Page No. 20 of 23
-- 20 of 23 --
RELEASE/APPORTIONMENT OF COMPENSATION TO THE
PETITIONERS
35. Finally, out of the aforesaid awarded amount, the petitioner namely
Amir Khan @ Amit is hereby awarded a sum of Rs. 34,74,193/-, out of
which Rs. 30,00,000/- is directed to be kept with
UCO Bank, Karkardooma
Court Branch, Delhi bearing account no. 20780110171912; IFSC:
UCBA0002078 in MACAD in the form of 120 monthly fixed deposit
receipts (FDRs) of Rs. 25,000/- payable in equal amounts for a period of 1
to 120 months in succession, as per the scheme formulated by the Hon'ble
Delhi High Court vide order dated 08.01.2021 in FAO No. 842/2003, titled
as
Rajesh Tyagi & Ors. Vs. Jaibir Singh & Ors. The amount of FDRs on
maturity would be released in his savings/MACT Claims SB Account,
maintained with UCO Bank, KKD Branch, Delhi. Remaining amount of Rs.
4,74,193/- and the interest component to be paid by the respondent no.
3/insurance company is directed to be released into his savings account,
which can be withdrawn and utilized by him as per his volition.
36. The FDRs to be prepared as per aforesaid directions, shall be subject
to the following conditions:-
(a) The original fixed deposit shall be retained by the bank in safe
custody and copies of the same be provided to the petitioner with the
statement containing FDR number, FDR amount, date of maturity and
maturity amount.
(b) The maturity amounts of the FDR(s) be credited by Electronic
MACT No. 214/23 Amir Khan @ Amit Vs. M/s Rana Real Estate and Ors. Page No. 21 of 23
-- 21 of 23 --
Clearing System (ECS) in the savings bank account of the claimant.
(c) No loan, advance, withdrawal or pre-mature discharge be allowed on
the fixed deposits without permission of the Court.
(d) The concerned bank shall not issue any cheque book and/or debit
card to claimant / his guardian. However, in case the debit card and /or
cheque book have already been issued, bank shall cancel the same before
the disbursement of the award amount.
(e) The bank shall make an endorsement on the passbook of the claimant
to the effect that no cheque book and/or debit card have been issued and
shall not be issued without the permission of the Court.
37. Respondent no. 3/insurance company is directed to deposit the award
amount with interest @ 8% per annum from the date of filing of claim
petition/DAR to till date with UCO Bank, Karkardooma Court Branch
within 30 days as per above order, failing which respondent no. 3/insurance
company shall be liable to pay interest @ 12% p.a for the period of delay.
Concerned Branch Manager, UCO Bank, Karkardooma Court Branch is
directed to transfer the share amount of the petitioner(s) in his/her/their
bank account / FDRs as per above-said directions, on completing necessary
formalities as per rules. The Branch Manager, is further directed to keep the
said amounts in fixed deposits in name of this Court in auto renewal mode
every 15 days, till the claimants approach the bank for disbursement, so that
the award amount starts earning interest from the date of clearance of the
cheques. Soft copy of the award be uploaded on official website of Delhi
District Courts i.e. https://delhidistrictcourts.nic.in.
MACT No. 214/23 Amir Khan @ Amit Vs. M/s Rana Real Estate and Ors. Page No. 22 of 23
-- 22 of 23 --
38. Form IV-A and Form-V, in terms of MCTAP, shall be read as part of
the Award. Copy of the award be given dasti to the petitioner and also to
counsel for the insurance company for compliance. Copy of this award
alongwith one photograph each, specimen signatures, copy of bank
passbooks and copy of residence proof of the petitioners, be sent to Nodal
Officer of UCO Bank, Karkardooma Court Branch, Delhi for information
and necessary compliance.
Announced in open Court on this
15th Day of April, 2026
(HARUN PRATAP)
PO-(MACT-02), SHAHDARA
KKD COURTS/DELHI
MACT No. 214/23 Amir Khan @ Amit Vs. M/s Rana Real Estate and Ors. Page No. 23 of 23
-- 23 of 23 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.