Full Order Text
Final Order 5 · 31 May 2023 · CNR DLSH010014892023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: 1 IN THE COURT OF SH. VINEET KUMAR: ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE-02; E COURT: SHAHDARA: KARKARDOOMA COURT: DELHI. Crl. (A) No. 35/2023 Vipin Kumar s/o Late Sh. Ved Prakash Jain r/o H. No. 176/4, Ground Floor, Shakti Khand-I, Indra Puram, Ghaziabad, UP. ............Appellant. Versus Smt. Renu w/o Sh. Vipin Kumar d/o Late Surajpal r/o H. No. C-63A, Mandawali, Unche-Per, Delhi-110092. ...........Respondent. Date of filing : 10.03.2023 Date of arguments : 30.05.2023 Date of order : 31.05.2023 O R D E R 1. The present criminal appeal under Section 29 of The Protection of Women From Domestic Violence Act, 2005’ (hereinafter referred to as 'DV Act') is filed against order dated 15.11.2022 (In short ' impugned order') in complaint case vide CT No. 3998/2017 titled as 'Smt. Renu Vs. Vipin Kumar' whereby Ld. MM-02 (Mahila Court) (Shahdara), KKD courts, Delhi (In short 'Ld. trial Court') has directed appellant (respondent before the trial court) to secure the same level of alternate accommodation to the respondent (complainant before the trial court) as enjoyed by her in the ___________________________________________________________________________ CA No. 35/2023 Vipin Kumar Vs. Renu Page No.1/8 -- 1 of 8 -- 2 shared household in terms of Section 19(1)(f) DV Act within a period of three months, with further direction to pay the rent for the same. Along with the appeal, an application seeking condonation of delay in filing the present appeal has also been filed. 2. Before proceeding to adjudicate the appeal, first of all it is necessary to decide the aforesaid application. 3. Ld. Counsel for appellant has submitted that he could not file present appeal within time as he had applied for certified copy of the impugned order on 04.01.2023 and he had received the same on 01.03.2023. It has thus been prayed that the said period may be excluded for the purpose of ascertaining the limitation period and delay, if any, may be condoned. 4. Arguments were heard and record was perused. 5. As per provisions of D.V. Act, an appeal can be filed within thirty days from the date on which an order under the said Act is passed by the Ld. Magistrate. Perusal of TCR reveals that impugned order was passed on 15.11.22 in the presence of complainant along with her Counsel and appellant as well as his Counsel. Thus, the present appeal could have been filed till 15.12.22, especially when appellant was well aware of the impugned order, however, the present appeal only came to be filed on 10.03.2023. Even if the period, when appellant had applied for certified copy i.e. 04.01.2023 to 01.03.2023 (when certified copy was received) is taken out of equation, then too, it is clear that limitation period for filing the appeal had already expired even before the certified copies were applied and moreover ___________________________________________________________________________ CA No. 35/2023 Vipin Kumar Vs. Renu Page No.2/8 -- 2 of 8 -- 3 no reason whatsoever has been put forth in the application by appellant as to why the present appeal was not filed between 15.11.22 i.e. date of passing the impugned order and 04.01.23 i.e. date of applying certified copy. Suffice, it to state that the present appeal has been filed beyond the limitation period and same is accordingly barred. Therefore, this appeal is liable to be dismissed on this count alone. 6. Even Otherwise, the present appeal, by which the impugned order has been assailed, is not sustainable on merits for reasons mentioned hereinafter. 7. Briefly, on 24.11.2017, the respondent/complainant filed an application under Section 12 DV Act seeking reliefs under Section 18, 19, 20 and 22. In addition to the above, an application u/s 23 DV Act was also filed before Ld. Trial court seeking interim reliefs under aforesaid sections. Thereafter on 15.11.22, in the presence of appellant, Ld. Counsel for complainant pressed the relief of residence order before the Ld. Trial Court by stating that complainant was residing with her mother and she has expired now and she is residing along with her brother. Thus, a prayer for residence order in her matrimonial home/separate accommodation was made. Thereupon, Ld. Trial court, while balancing the rights of complainant and her mother-in-law, directed the appellant to secure the same level of alternate accommodation to the complainant as enjoyed by her in the shared household within 3 months of the impugned order in terms of Section 19 (1)(f) D.V. Act with further direction to pay the rent for the same. Being aggrieved by the said order, Appellant (respondent before Trial Court) has preferred this appeal. ___________________________________________________________________________ CA No. 35/2023 Vipin Kumar Vs. Renu Page No.3/8 -- 3 of 8 -- 4 8. The case of the complainant is that the marriage between the appellant and complainant/respondent was solemnized on 18.04.2017 as per Hindu rites and ceremonies; that after marriage, appellant and respondent started residing at A-42, third floor, Joshi Colony, I.P. Extension, Delhi in a shared accommodation and same is her matrimonial home; that said property is owned by appellant and he is the exclusive owner of the said property; that a lavish marriage ceremony was held on the demand of appellant and his family members, but immediately thereafter, appellant started harassing the complainant. The complainant filed her ‘Assets, income and expenditure' affidavit and she sought interim residence order on the grounds of change of circumstances as earlier she was residing with her mother and after death of her mother, she was residing with her brother. Thus, respondent/complainant had prayed before the Ld. Trial Court for residence order either to reside in her matrimonial home or she be given separate accommodation. 9. The impugned order has been primarily assailed on the following grounds: (a) That Ld. Trial Court has passed the impugned judgment based upon surmises and conjectures, as such, the same is liable to be set aside. (b) That the impugned order passed by Ld. Trial Court is not sustainable as respondent herself had left the conjugal society of the appellant. (c) That the impugned order has been passed without any change of circumstances and in the absence of any ___________________________________________________________________________ CA No. 35/2023 Vipin Kumar Vs. Renu Page No.4/8 -- 4 of 8 -- 5 application filed by the respondent before the Ld. Trial Court. (d) That the impugned order is liable to be dismissed as the application u/s 12 of DV Act is totally false, frivolous, manipulated and without any iota of truth. 10. Perusal of the grounds stated above makes it clear that the primary grievance of the Appellant is that the impugned order has been passed without any application and that no arguments were heard before passing the impugned order. Also, the said order has been assailed on the ground that appellant is an unemployed person and respondent is residing at her parental house, so there has been no change of circumstance as such. 11. On the other hand, Ld. Counsel for respondent has argued that there is no requirement of filing separate application for seeking interim relief u/s 19 of D.V. Act and complainant was well within her rights to ask for residence order being an aggrieved person within the ambit of DV Act. 12. I have heard respective submissions addressed on behalf of both sides and perused the material available on record. 13. Section 19 of the DV Act empowers the Ld. Magistrate to pass a residence order in favour of an aggrieved person. Such residence orders include restraining the other party from dispossessing the aggrieved person from the shared household or to direct the other party to secure the same level of alternate accommodation for the aggrieved person as enjoyed by her in the shared household or to pay rent for the same if the circumstances so require. Section 19 ___________________________________________________________________________ CA No. 35/2023 Vipin Kumar Vs. Renu Page No.5/8 -- 5 of 8 -- 6 (1) of the DV Act lays down a pre-condition for passing of any residence orders i.e. the court must be satisfied that domestic violence has taken place against the aggrieved person. Domestic violence is defined under Section 3 the DV Act. 14. In the case in hand, Ld. Trial Court has held that respondent/complainant is an aggrieved person and she has been in a domestic relationship with the appellant and his mother and has resided in a shared household with appellant. Also, the DIR is on record, which seems to indicate that complainant has been subjected to domestic violence. Further, in the matter of Rajnesh v. Neha in (2021) 2 SCC 324, the Hon'ble Supreme Court was pleased to hold that Section 19 (1) (f) of the DV Act provides that the Ld. Magistrate may pass a residence order inter alia directing the husband to secure the same level of alternate accommodation for the aggrieved woman as enjoyed by her in the shared household. While passing such an order, the Ld. Magistrate may direct the respondent to pay the rent and other payments, having regard to the financial needs and resources of the parties. Thus, once it is there on record that respondent prima facie has been subjected to domestic violence and is an aggrieved person, she becomes entitled to reliefs under the DV Act including orders in terms of Section 19 DV Act. 15. Further, it is worth mentioning that the contention of Ld. Counsel for appellant that no application was filed by respondent seeking residence order before trial court, does not have any force in the absence of any bar in this regard. In ___________________________________________________________________________ CA No. 35/2023 Vipin Kumar Vs. Renu Page No.6/8 -- 6 of 8 -- 7 addition to it, Ld. Counsel was enquired about there being any case law or authority, which prohibits a relief with respect to residence order being granted in the absence of a separate application. In response to the same, he could not bring any such authority to the attention of this court. Moreover, the respondent had already filed application u/s 23 DV Act along with the application u/s 12 DV Act, seeking interim reliefs under various sections including Section 19 DV Act. Also, this court cannot lose sight of the fact that DV Act is meant to be a welfare legislation, so mere technicality of not filing a specific application cannot be allowed to defeat the purpose of the Act. 16. Further, appellant being an able-bodied person cannot be permitted to take the refuge of being unemployed as a pretext of avoiding the direction of arranging for alternate accommodation for the respondent. Moreover, appellant may well raise all his objections and contentions, inter alia the plea of no change of circumstance, before the Trial Court during the course of trial and importantly, evidence if any, to the contrary can be led by the appellant before the Ld. Trial Court to disprove the claim of respondent/complainant and same may be taken into consideration and appreciated by Ld. Trial Court at an appropriate stage before final disposal of the petition u/s 12 D.V. Act. 17. Thus, in view of discussion above as well as in the light of facts and circumstances of the case in hand, the impugned order does not seem to be unreasonable by any stretch of imagination. Therefore, no interference is warranted in the same. ___________________________________________________________________________ CA No. 35/2023 Vipin Kumar Vs. Renu Page No.7/8 -- 7 of 8 -- 8 18. Accordingly, the present appeal filed by the appellant stands dismissed. A copy of judgment along with trial Court record be sent back to the trial Court. Appeal file be consigned to record room. Announced in the open (Vineet Kumar) court on 31st day of ASJ-02/E-COURT May 2023. Shahdara/KKD Courts, Delhi. ___________________________________________________________________________ CA No. 35/2023 Vipin Kumar Vs. Renu Page No.8/8 -- 8 of 8 --
