Skip to main content
Court Order

Final Order 21

CNR DLSH01001381202324 Jul 2026
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Final Order 21 · 24 Jul 2026 · CNR DLSH010013812023

Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT
Pdf Text: MACT No. 144/23
Sarla Tyagi Vs. Mohd. Tayyab & Ors.
	Page No. 1 of 21
IN THE COURT OF SH. HARUN PRATAP, PO, MACT-02,
DISTRICT SHAHDARA, KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI
MACT No.: 144/23
CNR No. DLSH01-001381-2023
IN THE MATTER OF:-
Smt. Sarla Tyagi
w/o late Sh. Devender Tyagi
R/o H No. 1/1905, 3rd floor, Street Geeta,
Near Durga Mandir, Ram Nagar, Modern Shahdara, Delhi-110032
Also at: Khandawali, Meerut, U.P.-245206
........ (Petitioner)
Vs.
1. Mohd. Tayyab
S/o Sh. Sayyad Anwarul Islam
R/o H No. 369, Bulandshahar Road,
Samiha Garden City, Hapur, U.P-245101.
…. (Driver)
2. Sh. Surender Singh (now deceased)
S/o Sh. Narain Singh
Through legal heirs:
(i) Smt. Urmial Devi (wife)
(ii) Sh. Sandeep Rana (son )
(iii) Sh. Saransh Rana (son)
(iv) Ms. Shivanshi Rana (daughter)
All R/o H No. 1/334, Shiv Mandir Colony,
Hapur, U.P.-245101
…. (Owner)
3. The New India Assurance company Ltd.
Through Manager
Shahdara, D.O.
487, Second Floor, Zulfe Bengal, GT Road,
Dilshad Garden, Delhi-110032 ….. (Insurer)
-- 1 of 21 --
MACT No. 144/23
Sarla Tyagi Vs. Mohd. Tayyab & Ors.
	Page No. 2 of 21
4. Smt. Sumitra (mother of deceased)
w/o late Salekh Chand
R/o Kharkhoda Mandir wala,
Khandawali, Meerut, U.P.-245206
... Respondents
Date of institution of claim petition : 15.03.2023
Date of Arguments : 24.07.2026
Date of Award : 24.07.2026
Advocates appearing in the case:
For petitioner : Sh. Vijay Pal Singh
For respondent no. 1 & 2 : Sh. Nitin Garg
For respondent no. 3 i.e. insurance Co. : Sh. Pramod Kumar Singh
AWARD
Vide this award, the Tribunal shall decide the MACT claim petition
bearing no. 144/23, under section 166(4) & 140 of Motor Vehicles Act,
1988, filed for the petitioner and against the respondents as mentioned in
the memo of parties.
FACTS OF THE CASE
1. Briefly stated, the facts of the case are that on 17.03.2022, at about
01:00 pm, one Devender Tyagi (since deceased) along with his wife Sarla
Tyagi was returning to his home after worship, on a scooter bearing
registration no. DL65P-5524. It has been alleged that when they reached at
Kharkhoda Cut (bypass Meerut-Hapur road), within the jurisdiction of PS
Kharkhoda, Distt. Meerut, one Car (make Alto) bearing registration no.
UP15BY-4988 (hereinafter referred to as offending vehicle), came at a very
high speed and hit the scooter of the petitioner with a great force. It has
-- 2 of 21 --
MACT No. 144/23
Sarla Tyagi Vs. Mohd. Tayyab & Ors.
	Page No. 3 of 21
been further alleged that the offending vehicle was being driven by its
driver i.e. respondent no. 1 (R1) herein, at a very high speed and in a rash
and negligent manner without taking necessary precautions at the time of
the accident. Allegedly, both the scooter riders fell down on the road after
their scooter was hit by the offending vehicle and they were immediately
taken to Nutema hospital, Meerut, where MLC of the injured Sarla Tyagi
was prepared vide MLC No. 927, while her husband Devender Tyagi
succumbed to the injuries. The postmortem on the body of the deceased was
conducted at postmortem house, Meerut, vide PMR No. 301/22. An FIR in
this regard was also registered at PS Kharkhoda, Distt. Meerut, vide FIR no.
107/2022, for the offences u/s 279/338/304A IPC. The present claim
petition thereafter came to be filed in due course on 15.03.2023.
WS / Reply of Respondents
2. In his WS filed by R1, being the driver of the offending vehicle, it has
been contended that the alleged accident took place due to sole negligence
on part of the deceased himself. It has been further contended that the
offending vehicle was duly insured with respondent no. 3. The respondent
denied the averments of the claim petition and prayed for its dismissal.
3. The respondent no. 2 (R2), happened to be the owner of the offending
vehicle at the time of the accident. However, he failed to file his WS despite
being granted several opportunities in this regard and even failed to appear
before the Tribunal, due to which he was proceeded ex parte vide order
dated 03.07.2024 of Ld. Predecessor.
-- 3 of 21 --
MACT No. 144/23
Sarla Tyagi Vs. Mohd. Tayyab & Ors.
	Page No. 4 of 21
4. Respondent no. 3 i.e. The New India Assurance Company Ltd., filed its
detailed written statement, wherein it has been admitted that the offending
vehicle was duly insured with the company vide insurance policy no.
321104312101000000264, in the name of Sh.Surender Singh i.e.
respondent no. 2 (R2) herein, with its validity from 15.06.2021 to
14.06.2022. However, it has been contended that the insurance policy in
question is void
ab initio as the same was taken in the name of R2, who was
already dead before issuance of the insurance policy in question. The
respondent no. 3 thus denied any liability on its part and prayed for the
dismissal of the claim petition.
ISSUES
5. From the pleadings of the parties, following issues were framed by
the Ld. Predecessor vide order dated 23.11.2024, as under:-
(i) Whether deceased died on account of injuries sustained in accident
having taken place on 17.03.2022 at about 01:00 pm By pass, Meerut-
Hapur Marg, Kharkhauda Kat, Halka Chowki Kasba Kharkhauda, within
the jurisdiction of PS Kharkhauda, Distt. Meerut, U.P. due to rash and
negligent driving of driver of vehicle no. UP15BY-4988 by respondent no.
1 ? OPP.
(ii) Whether petitioner is entitled to compensation, if so, to what amount
and from whom? OPP.
(iii) Relief.
PETITIONER'S EVIDENCE
6. In order to prove the case, petitioner Sarla Tyagi i.e. wife of deceased
examined herself as PW-1. She tendered her evidence by way of affidavit
Ex. PW-1/A, wherein she reiterated the contents of the claim petition and
-- 4 of 21 --
MACT No. 144/23
Sarla Tyagi Vs. Mohd. Tayyab & Ors.
	Page No. 5 of 21
relied upon the following documents:-
Sr. No. Exhibit No. Particulars
1. Ex. PW1/1
(colly)
Certified copy of criminal case records
2. Ex. PW1/2 Death certificate of deceased Devender
Kumar Tyagi
3. Ex. PW1/3
(colly) (OSR)
Educational certificate of deceased
4. Ex.PW1/4 (OSR) Copy of Aadhar card of deponent
5. Ex.PW1/5 (OSR) Copy of Aadhar card of deceased
6. Ex.PW1/6 (OSR) Copy of PAN card of deponent
7. Ex.PW1/7 (colly
3 pgs)
Medical bills of deceased totaling amonting
to Rs. 6008/-
8. Mark A Death memo of deceased
She was cross-examined and discharged.
7. The petitioner did not examine any other witness and PE stood closed
by The Tribunal vide order dated 03.09.2025, in view of the separate
statement of Ld. Counsel for petitioner recorded to this effect.
Respondents' Evidence
8. In order to prove its defence, R3 i.e. insurance company, examined
Sh. Neeraj Sharma, Assistant Manager, New India Assurance Co. Ltd. as
R3W1. He tendered his evidence by way of affidavit Ex.R3W1/A, and
relied upon the following documents:-
Sr. No. Exhibit No. Particulars
1. Ex. R3W1/1 Attested copy of policy bearing no.
32110431200100000186, for the period of
15.06.2020 to 14.06.2022
2. Ex. R3W1/2 Attested copy of policy bearing no.
32110431210100000264, for the period
-- 5 of 21 --
MACT No. 144/23
Sarla Tyagi Vs. Mohd. Tayyab & Ors.
	Page No. 6 of 21
15.06.2021 to 14.06.2022
He was cross-examined and discharged.
9. RE was thereon closed by the Tribunal on 17.12.2025, in view of the
separate statement of Ld. Counsel for respondent no. 3 recorded to this
effect.
10. Final arguments heard. File perused.
Issue wise findings
Issue no.1
Whether deceased died on account of injuries sustained in accident
having taken place on 17.03.2022 at about 01:00 pm By pass, Meerut-
Hapur Marg, Kharkhauda Kat, Halka Chowki Kasba Kharkhauda, within
the jurisdiction of PS Kharkhauda, Distt. Meerut, U.P. due to rash and
negligent driving of driver of vehicle no. UP15BY-4988 by respondent no.
1 ? OPP.
11. In an action founded on the principle of fault liability, the proof of
rash and negligent driving of the offending vehicle is sine qua non.
However, the standard of proof is not as strict as applied in criminal cases
and evidence is tested on the touchstone of principle of preponderance of
probabilities
. It is well settled that the procedure followed for proceedings
conducted by an accident tribunal is similar to that followed by a civil court
and in civil matters the facts are required to be established by
preponderance of probabilities only and not by strict rules of evidence or
beyond reasonable doubts as are required in a criminal prosecution. The
burden of proof in a civil case is never as heavy as that is required in a
-- 6 of 21 --
MACT No. 144/23
Sarla Tyagi Vs. Mohd. Tayyab & Ors.
	Page No. 7 of 21
criminal case, but in a claim petition under the Motor Vehicles Act, this
burden is infact even lesser than that in a civil case. Reference in this regard
can be made to the propositions of law laid down by Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of
Bimla Devi & Ors. Vs Himachal Road Transport
Corporation & Ors, reported in (2009) 13 SC 530, which were reiterated in
the subsequent judgment in the case of
Parmeshwari Vs Amir Chand & Ors,
2011 (1) SCR 1906 (Civil Appeal No. 1082 of 2011) and also recently in
another case
Mangla Ram Vs. Oriental Insurance Co. ltd. & Ors., 2018 Law
Suit (SC) 303.
12. In the present case, the petitioner (PW-1) has examined herself being
the wife of the deceased, who also happened to be a purported eye witness
of the accident as the star witness to prove the contentions regarding the
claim for compensation as PW-1. The said witness has categorically stated
in her examination on oath that the accident was caused due to rash and
negligent act of respondent no. 1 in driving the offending vehicle at the time
of the accident. The said contentions are duly corroborated by the findings
of the police as mentioned in the site plan, mechanical inspection report,
Charge sheet, postmortem report along with other documents pertaining to
criminal case in respect of the incident in question brought on record as Ex.
PW1/1 (colly) and no ground has been made out by the respondents to
disbelieve the same. The testimony of PW-1 for the petitioner has remained
consistent and no doubt has been raised by the respondents to disbelieve the
same.
-- 7 of 21 --
MACT No. 144/23
Sarla Tyagi Vs. Mohd. Tayyab & Ors.
	Page No. 8 of 21
13. The very fact that R-1 has already been specifically arrayed as an
accused in case vide FIR no. 107/2022, PS Kharkhauda, Distt. Meerut, U.P.,
for the offences u/s 279/338/304-A IPC is also a strong circumstance to
support the above said testimony of PW-1 on these issues. Furthermore, the
position of law in this regard has been made clear in the case of
“National
Insurance Co., Vs Puspha Rana”, 2009 ACJ 287 Delhi, wherein it has been
held that filing of Chargesheet is sufficient proof of the negligence and
involvement of the offending vehicle. Similar observations have been made
in the case of
“United India Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Deepak Goel and Ors.”,
2014 (2) Tac 846 Del, that if the claimant was able to prove the criminal
case on record pertaining to involvement of the offending vehicle, whereby
the criminal records showing completion of investigation by the police and
filing of Chargesheet under Section 279/304-A/338 IPC against the driver
have been proved, then, the documents mentioned above are sufficient to
establish the fact that the driver was negligent in causing the accident.
Where FIR is lodged, Chargesheet is filed, especially in a case where driver
after causing the accident had fled away from the spot, then the documents
mentioned above are sufficient to establish the fact that the driver of the
offending vehicle was negligent in causing the accident particularly when
there was no defence available from his side before the Learned Tribunal.
The position of law has been recently reiterated by Hon’ble Supreme Court
in case titled as
“Ranjeet & Anr. Vs. Abdul Kayam Neb & Anr.” arising out
of SLP (C ) No. 10351/2019, wherein it has been held that:-
“It is settled in law that once a charge-sheet has been filed and
-- 8 of 21 --
MACT No. 144/23
Sarla Tyagi Vs. Mohd. Tayyab & Ors.
	Page No. 9 of 21
the driver has been held negligent, no further evidence is
required to prove that the bus was being negligently driven by
the bus driver. Even if the eye witnesses are not examined, that
will not be fatal to prove the death of the deceased due to
negligence of the bus driver.”
14. Besides the above, respondent no. 1 namely Mohd. Tayyab was the
best witness who could have stepped into the witness box to challenge the
depositions being made by PW-1 regarding the above accident and its
manner etc., but he has not done so. Therefore, an adverse inference on this
aspect is also required to be drawn against the respondents in view of the
law laid down in case of
Cholamandalam M.S. General Insurance Company
Ltd. Vs. Kamlesh, reported in 2009 (3) AD (Delhi)
15. In view of the above, it could be safely assumed that the offending
vehicle was being driven by R-1 indeed at the time of incident and the fatal
injuries to the deceased took place on account of the incident in question
itself.
16. Having ruled so, this Tribunal now proceeds to assess the wrongful
act, neglect or default of R-1, if any, in driving the offending vehicle at the
relevant time. Admittedly, R-1 has not explained the circumstances under
which his vehicle (i.e. the offending vehicle) hit the scooter of the deceased
with a great force. In the absence of any averment or evidence regarding
any mechanical defect in the offending vehicle or any material depicting
any negligent/sudden act or omission on the part of the injured or any other
such person, the only inference possible in the given facts and
-- 9 of 21 --
MACT No. 144/23
Sarla Tyagi Vs. Mohd. Tayyab & Ors.
	Page No. 10 of 21
circumstances is that of neglect and default on the part of R-1 in driving the
offending vehicle at the relevant time. In view of the above discussion, this
tribunal is constrained to hold R-1 guilty of gross neglect and default in
driving the offending vehicle at the relevant time leading to the fatal injuries
to the deceased Devender Tyagi.
17. Furthermore, in view of the medical records, postmortem report
placed on record by the petitioners, no doubt or dispute is left regarding the
fatal injuries to the deceased Devender Tyagi in the above accident.
18. Therefore, in view of the above discussion, this Tribunal holds that
the deceased Devender Kumar suffered fatal injuries on account of neglect
and default of R-1 while driving the offending vehicle at the relevant time.
The issue at hand is thus decided against the respondents and in favour of
the petitioners.
Issue no. (ii)
Whether petitioners are entitled for compensation, if so, to what amount and
from whom? OPP.
19. On the basis of findings upon issue no. (i), it is clear that the incident
in question had occurred due to rash and negligent driving of offending
vehicle by R-1 and fatal injuries had been caused to the deceased in the
incident. Hence, the petitioners being LRs i.e. wife and mother of the
deceased are entitled to compensation in this case as the claim of the
petitioners being dependent of the deceased has neither been denied nor
-- 10 of 21 --
MACT No. 144/23
Sarla Tyagi Vs. Mohd. Tayyab & Ors.
	Page No. 11 of 21
disputed in any manner by the respondents during the entire proceedings.
20. The issue at hand is accordingly decided in favour of the petitioners
and against the respondents.
LIABILITY
21. Now, the question arises as to which of the respondent is liable to pay
the compensation amount. The respondent no. 1 Mohd. Tayyab is the
principal principal
tort feasor being the driver of the offending vehicle,
while the respondent no. 2 is vicariously liable being the owner of the
offending vehicle for the acts of his employee i.e. driver. However, it is
pertinent to note that the respondent no. 3 i.e. Insurance Company has
specifically admitted in its written statement that the offending vehicle was
duly insured at the time of accident with respondent no. 3, vide policy
bearing no. 321104312101000000264, in the name of Sh. Surender Singh
i.e. respondent no. 2 (R2) herein, with its validity from 15.06.2021 to
14.06.2022. Nevertheless, it is also an admitted fact on record that the said
respondent no. 2 had already expired before the issuance of policy in
question. In view thereof, it has been contended on behalf of insurance
company that the policy is void
ab initio and the insurance company has no
liability to make the payment of compensation under such contract.
However, the position of the law in similar circumstances has been clearly
laid down in this regard by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case titled as
“
United India Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Santro Devi & Ors.” Civil Appeal no.
7009 of 2008 (Arising out of SLP (C) No. 4301 of 2006) , wherein it has
been held that:-
-- 11 of 21 --
MACT No. 144/23
Sarla Tyagi Vs. Mohd. Tayyab & Ors.
	Page No. 12 of 21
14. The provisions of compulsory insurance have been framed to advance
a social object. It is in a way part of the social justice doctrine. When a
certificate of insurance is issued, in law, the insurance company is bound
to reimburse the owner. There cannot be any doubt whatsoever that a
contract of insurance must fulfill the statutory requirements of formation
of a valid contract but in case of a third party risk, the question has to be
considered from a different angle.
15. Section 146 provides for statutory insurance. An insurance is
mandatorily required to be obtained by the person in charge of or in
possession of the vehicle. There is no provision in the Motor Vehicles Act
that unless the name(s) of the heirs of the owner of a vehicle is/are
substituted on the certificate of insurance or in the certificate of
registration in place of the original owner (since deceased), the motor
vehicle cannot be allowed to be used in a public place. Thus, in a case
where the owner of a motor vehicle has expired, although there does not
exist any statutory interdict for the person in possession of the vehicle to
ply the same on road; but there being a statutory injunction that the same
cannot be plied unless a policy of insurance is obtained, we are of the
opinion that the contract of insurance would be enforceable. It would be so
in a case of this nature as for the purpose of renewal of insurance policy
only the premium is to be paid. It is not in dispute that quantum of
premium paid for renewal of the policy is in terms of the provisions of the
Insurance Act, 1938.
In this case, the statute itself takes care of validity of the contract. It is
mandatory. Once a valid contract is entered into, only because of a
mistake or otherwise, the name of the original owner has not been
mentioned in the certificate of registration and/or the documents of
hypothecation of the vehicle with the bank had still been continuing in his
name, it cannot be said that the contract itself is void unless it was shown
that in obtaining the said contract a fraud had been practised. Not only the
particulars of fraud had not been pleaded, but even no witness was
examined on behalf of the appellant. It cannot, thus, be said that a case of
fraud in the matter of entering into the contract of insurance had been
made out by the appellant.
Furthermore, it is pertinent to note that the insurance company has
failed to bring any material on record to show that in obtaining the
-- 12 of 21 --
MACT No. 144/23
Sarla Tyagi Vs. Mohd. Tayyab & Ors.
	Page No. 13 of 21
insurance policy in question, a fraud had been practised. Neither the
particulars of any such fraud has been pleaded nor any witness has been
examined on behalf of the insurance company to prove a fraud in obtaining
the insurance policy. In such circumstances, the insurance policy in question
is thus a valid statutory contract of insurance for which premium amount
has been duly paid for and also received by the insurance company.
Therefore, in view of the afore-said discussion, the Tribunal has no
hesitation in hereby arriving at the finding that the insurance company
cannot avoid its liability to pay the compensation in the present case.
Nevertheless, as far as the insured and the insurer are concerned in such
policy taken out in the name of the a dead person, the insurance company is
hereby granted recovery rights as benefit cannot be claimed in such a
contract which is void ab initio between the parties entering into such
contract. Reliance is placed in this regard upon the decision of Hon’ble
Delhi High Court in case titled as:- Pankaj Aggarwal & Anr. Vs. Tata AIG
General Insurance Co. Ltd. & Anr. (MAC. APP. 313/2015 and CM APP.
5919/2015 & 5920/2015).
22. Therefore, in view of the afore-said facts and circumstances, the
Tribunal has no hesitation in hereby arriving at the finding that the liability
to make the payment of compensation amount in this case is indeed of R3
i.e. insurance company, but the insurance company is hereby granted
recovery rights to recover the compensation from R1 and R2 jointly and
severally. The issue at hand is accordingly decided in favour of the
petitioner and against the respondents.
-- 13 of 21 --
MACT No. 144/23
Sarla Tyagi Vs. Mohd. Tayyab & Ors.
	Page No. 14 of 21
COMPUTATION OF COMPENSATION
23. As far as computation of compensation is concerned, the same shall
be under the following heads :-
MEDICAL EXPENSES
24. In the present case, as per material brought on record, the victim had
undergone initial treatment after the accident at Nutema Hospital, where he
succumbed to his injuries on 17.03.2022 itself. In regard to the treatment
undergone by the victim, petitioner has deposed that the entire treatment
was from Nutema hospital. The petitioner has filed bills for treatment of
victim at the said hospital apart from mentioning particular cost of treatment
in the evidence affidavit. Perusal of file reveals that the petitioners have
brought on record bills totaling Rs. 6008/- as Ex. PW1/7 being the cost of
medicines borne by them during the entire treatment of the victim and the
same have not been denied or disputed by the respondents. There is no
reason to doubt the veracity or genuineness of the said bills/receipts. Hence,
total amount awarded to the petitioner under the head “Medical expenses” is
Rs. 6008/-.
LOSS OF DEPENDENCY
25. In the present case, perusal of the high school certificate and Aadhar
card of the deceased i.e. Ex.PW1/3 and Ex. PW1/5 respectively, reveals
that the date of birth of the deceased was 17.10.1957 and the same has not
been disputed in any manner by the respondents. Therefore, the deceased
was thus aged about 64 years at the time of the incident resulting in his
-- 14 of 21 --
MACT No. 144/23
Sarla Tyagi Vs. Mohd. Tayyab & Ors.
	Page No. 15 of 21
death on 17.03.2022.
26. Petitioner Smt. Sarla Tyagi (PW1) in her deposition stated that at the
time of accident, her deceased husband was working as a labour and that he
was earning Rs. 20,000/- per month. However, the petitioner has failed to
file any document or material on record to substantiate the said claim.
Nevertheless, the petitioner has duly brought on record the Senior School
Certificate of deceased as Ex. PW1/3 (colly) to show that the deceased had
studied upto 12th standard at the time of the accident and the said fact has
neither been denied nor been disputed in any manner by the respondents.
Furthermore, it is pertinent to note that the deceased and his entire family
were residents of U.P. at the time of the accident. Therefore, this Tribunal
has assessed the income of deceased at parity with minimum wages of
‘
semi-skilled’ of U.P. prevalent at the time of accident i.e. Rs. 10,102/- per
month.
27. Furthermore, as per the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court titled
as
“National Insurance Company Limited Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. (2017)
16 SCC 680”, 0% (Nil) addition shall be given to the deceased towards
future prospects as he was above the age of 60 years at the time of incident
and he was self-employed. Therefore, the monthly income of the deceased
with 0% (Nil) future prospects comes out to be Rs. 10,102/-.
28. As revealed on record, the deceased Devender Tyagi was married and
having his wife and mother dependent upon him on the date of the incident.
Therefore, both the petitioner and proforma respondent no. 4 i.e. the mother
-- 15 of 21 --
MACT No. 144/23
Sarla Tyagi Vs. Mohd. Tayyab & Ors.
	Page No. 16 of 21
of the deceased shall be treated as dependents of the deceased for the
purpose of the present petition. Accordingly, 1/3rd of the earnings of the
deceased shall be deducted towards his personal and living expenses.
Therefore, in the entire given facts and circumstances, deduction of 1/3rd of
total income is made for personal living expenses of deceased. Hence, an
amount of Rs. 3,367/- (Rs. 10,102/3) is required to be deducted from
monthly income of deceased. Finally, annual dependency of dependent is
calculated as under (annual income) – (annual expenses of deceased) i.e.
(Rs. 1,21,224/- – Rs. 40,407/-) = Rs. 80,817/- per annum.
29. Moreover, in view of the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in case of “
Sarla Verma & Ors. Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation &
Anr”., (2009) 6 SCC 121, which has also been upheld by the Constitutional
Bench of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of “
National Insurance
Company Ltd. Vs Pranay Sethi & Ors”. SLP (Civil) No. 25590 of 2014,
decided on 31.10.2017, the multiplier of ‘7’ is held applicable for
calculating the loss of dependency caused to the petitioners on account of
death of the deceased. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, the
total loss of dependency qua the deceased in the present case comes out to
be Rs. 80,817/- X 7 = Rs. 5,65,719/-.
LOSS OF CONSORTIUM / LOSS OF LOVE AND AFFECTION
30. In “
Magma Vs. General Insurance Co. Ltd Vs. Nanu Ram & Ors”.
2018 ACJ 2782, it was observed by Hon'ble Supreme Court that
'consortium' is a compendious term, which encompasses 'spousal
consortium', 'parental consortium' and 'filial consortium'. The right to
-- 16 of 21 --
MACT No. 144/23
Sarla Tyagi Vs. Mohd. Tayyab & Ors.
	Page No. 17 of 21
consortium would include the company, care, help, comfort, guidance,
solace and affection of the deceased, which is a loss to his entire family.
Spousal Consortium allows compensation to surviving spouse for loss of
'company, society, co-operation, affection and aid of the other in every
conjugal relation'. The Hon'ble Supreme Court further observed in said
judgment that parental consortium is granted to the child upon the
premature death of a parent, for loss of 'parental aid, protection, affection,
society, discipline, guidance and training. Similarly, filial consortium is to
be granted to each of the surviving dependent parents on the death of their
child.
31. In the facts and circumstances of the present case, the computation of
compensation under this head is as follows :
Filial Consortium : Rs. 48,000/- (Rs. 48,000/- X 1)
Spousal Consortium : Rs. 48,000/- (Rs. 48,000/- X1)
Parental Consortium : Rs. 0/- (Rs. 48,000/- X 0)
32. Hence, the petitioner is hereby awarded a total sum of Rs. 96,000/- on
account of loss of consortium/loss of love and affection under this head.
LOSS OF ESTATE & FUNERAL EXPENSES
33. A total sum of Rs. 36,000/- is awarded in favour of petitioner and R4
under both the heads i.e. Rs. 18,000/- on account of 'loss of estate' and
Rs.18,000/- for 'funeral expenses' of the deceased, as per the law laid down
in “
National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors.” (Supra).
-- 17 of 21 --
MACT No. 144/23
Sarla Tyagi Vs. Mohd. Tayyab & Ors.
	Page No. 18 of 21
34. The total amount of compensation to be granted in favour of the
petitioner and R4 in this case is thus Rs.5,65,719/- + Rs. 96,000/- + Rs.
36,000/- + Rs. 6,008/- (medical bills) = Rs. 7,03,727/-.
ISSUE NO.3 / RELIEF
35. In view of the the findings on the aforesaid issues, the petitioner and
R4 are hereby awarded a sum of Rs.7,03,727/- (Rupees Seven Lakh Three
Thousand Seven Hundred Twenty Seven Only) along with interest @ 8%
per annum from the date of filing of claim petition till its deposition by the
insurer i.e. respondent no. 3. However, it is directed that the amount of
interim award alongwith waiver of interest, if any, shall be excluded from
the above amount and calculations of compensation.
RELEASE/APPORTIONMENT OF COMPENSATION TO THE
PETITIONER
36. As per the aforesaid statement, none of the dependent were earning
anything and petitioners had their bank account in UCO Bank, KKD
Branch, Delhi. The photocopy of the passbooks of the bank accounts of the
petitioners maintained with respective Banks, were also placed on record by
the petitioners. Photocopies of Aadhar Card and PAN Card were also placed
on record by the petitioners, apart from two photographs each of the
petitioners.
37. Finally, out of the aforesaid awarded amount, the petitioner namely
Sarla Tyagi i.e. wife of deceased, is hereby awarded a sum of Rs. 5,03,727/-
out of which Rs.4,00,000/- is directed to be kept with
UCO Bank,
-- 18 of 21 --
MACT No. 144/23
Sarla Tyagi Vs. Mohd. Tayyab & Ors.
	Page No. 19 of 21
Karkardooma Court Branch, Delhi bearing account no. 20780110171912;
IFSC: UCBA0002078 in MACAD in the form of 20 monthly fixed deposit
receipts (FDRs) of Rs. 20,000/- payable in equal amounts for a period of 1
to 20 months in succession, as per the scheme formulated by the Hon'ble
Delhi High Court vide order dated 08.01.2021 in FAO No. 842/2003, titled
as
Rajesh Tyagi & Ors. Vs. Jaibir Singh & Ors. The amount of FDRs on
maturity would be released in her savings/MACT Claims SB Account,
maintained with UCO Bank, KKD Branch, Delhi. Remaining amount of Rs.
1,03,727/- and the interest component to be paid by the respondent no. 3 is
also directed to be released into her account, which can be withdrawn and
utilized by the petitioner as per her volition.
38. Out of the aforesaid awarded amount, the R4 namely Sumitra i.e.
mother of deceased, is hereby awarded a sum of Rs.2,00,000/-, out of which
total amount of Rs.2,00,000/- is directed to be released in her
savings/MACT Claims SB Account, maintained with UCO Bank, KKD
Branch, Delhi which can be withdrawn and utilized by the her as per her
volition.
39. All the FDRs to be prepared as per aforesaid directions, shall be
subject to the following conditions:-
(a) The original fixed deposit shall be retained by the bank in safe
custody and copies of the same be provided to the petitioner(s) with the
statement containing FDR number, FDR amount, date of maturity and
maturity amount.
-- 19 of 21 --
MACT No. 144/23
Sarla Tyagi Vs. Mohd. Tayyab & Ors.
	Page No. 20 of 21
(b) The maturity amounts of the FDR(s) be credited by Electronic
Clearing System (ECS) in the savings bank account of the claimant.
(c) No loan, advance, withdrawal or pre-mature discharge be allowed on
the fixed deposits without permission of the Court.
(d) The concerned bank shall not issue any cheque book and/or debit
card to claimant / his guardian. However, in case the debit card and /or
cheque book have already been issued, bank shall cancel the same before
the disbursement of the award amount.
(e) The bank shall make an endorsement on the passbook of the claimant
to the effect that no cheque book and/or debit card have been issued and
shall not be issued without the permission of the Court.
40. Respondent no. 3, being insurer of the offending vehicle, is directed
to deposit the award amount with interest @ 8% per annum till date with
UCO Bank, Karkardooma Court Branch within 30 days as per above order,
failing which insurance company shall be liable to pay interest @ 12% p.a
for the period of delay. Concerned Branch Manager, UCO Bank,
Karkardooma Court Branch is directed to transfer the share amount of the
petitioner in his bank account / FDRs as per above-said directions, on
completing necessary formalities as per rules. The Branch Manager, is
further directed to keep the said amounts in fixed deposits in name of this
Court in auto renewal mode every 15 days, till the claimants approach the
bank for disbursement, so that the award amount starts earning interest from
the date of clearance of the cheques. Soft copy of the award be uploaded on
official website of Delhi District Courts i.e. https://delhidistrictcourts.nic.in.
-- 20 of 21 --
MACT No. 144/23
Sarla Tyagi Vs. Mohd. Tayyab & Ors.
	Page No. 21 of 21
41. Form IV-A and Form-V, in terms of MCTAP, shall be read as part of
the Award. Copy of the award be given dasti to the petitioner and also to
counsel for the insurance company for compliance. Copy of this award
alongwith one photograph each, specimen signatures, copy of bank
passbooks and copy of residence proof of the petitioner, be sent to Nodal
Officer of UCO Bank, Karkardooma Court Branch, Delhi for information
and necessary compliance.
Announced in open Court on this
On this his 24th Day of July, 2026
(HARUN PRATAP)
PO-(MACT-02), SHAHDARA
KKD COURTS/DELHI.
-- 21 of 21 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.