Full Order Text
Interim Order 10 · 12 Sept 2024 · CNR DLSH010013302024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: BEFORE THE COURT OF SH. SURINDER S. RATHI, DISTRICT JUDGE (COMM.)-03 SHAHDARA, KKD, DELHI Ex Comm. No.34/2024 MMTC Ltd.Vs. Davinder Kaur 12.09.2024 Order 1. Vide this order I shall dispose of application filed by the award holder/petitioner under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC for amendment of execution petition in hand. In so far as Order 6 Rule 17 CPC applies only to suits and pleadings but not to petitions under Order 21 CPC, vide order dated 28.08.2024 of this Court request of the decree holder to treat this application as application under Order 21 Rule 17(1) CPC was allowed. 2. Copy already supplied to the respondent/JD. Separate reply filed to this application. Copy supplied. 3. I have heard arguments of Sh. Sanat Kumar, Ld. Senior Advocate alongwith Sh. Akhil Sachar, Advocate for award holder/applicant and Sh. Ashok Popli, Ld. Counsel for LRs of deceased JD. 4. Brief facts necessary for disposal of this application are that MMTC Ltd., applicant/award holder is a public sector undertaking wholly owned by Govt. of India while JD, now through her LRs was a contractor with MMTC. Facts as borne out of the award dated 10.03.2016 and copies of claim petition of JD of November 2013 as also counter-claim of MMTC dated 22.04.2014 shows that MMTC is engaged in manufacturing and sale of Gold and Silver Medallians and had floated a tender for purchase of a 4-Hi Reversible Cold Rolling Mill on 13.03.2006. JD/claimant submitted her bid on 25.03.2006 which was accepted and a mutual agreement dated 27.11.2006 was signed between them. 5. A purchase order dated 01.12.2006 was placed on the JD/claimant for an amount of Rs.1,51,83,071/- for purchase of one machine apart from additional purchase order of Rs.8.98 lakhs. Certain amount was paid as advance and rest Ex Comm. No.34/2024 Page 1 of 12 MMTC Ltd. Vs. Davinder Kaur -- 1 of 12 -- was assured to be paid in due course post delivery of machine. The machine was delivered by 10.03.2008 after it was manufactured by JD/claimant. Certain disputes arose between the parties pertaining to the output of the machine and the MMTC is shown to have withheld Rs.1,55,69,128/- payable to JD/claimant which includes interest on account of delay in payments. When the payment was not made despite repeated demands the JD/claimant filed a civil suit bearing no. CS(OS)2089/2011 for recovery. MMTC filed a Section 8 Arbitration and Conciliation Act,1996 petition citing the mandatory arbitration clause, which was allowed by the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi on the Original Side vide order dated 15.02.2012. Vide same order Hon’ble High Court assigned the matter to Indian Council for Arbitration which in turn appointed retired Justice K S Gupta as Sole Arbitrator. 6. It was followed by filing of the claim petition by JD/claimant in November 2013 with following prayers: Prayer: (a) Award a Rs.1,55,69,128/- (Rs. One crore fifty five lacs sixty nine thousand one hundred and twenty eight only) to the claimant; (b) Award an interest @18% p.a. pendente lite and future from the date of filing of the present claim till the date of realization; (c) Cost of the petition, counsel fee and costs, charges and expenses may kindly be awarded; (d) Any other relief/s or order/s as this Hon’ble Arbitral Tribunal deem fit and proper, under the circumstances of the whole case, may also kindly be awarded. 7. The claim petition was contested by MMTC by filing Statement of Defence including a counter-claim with following prayers: Prayer: 1. That by a Tender Notice, the Respondent invited tenders for supply, erection and commissioning of one number of 4Hi Reversible Cold Rolling Mill in MMTC Medallions Unit at Jhandewalan, New Delhi. The terms of the tender contained a warranty clause for the supplier and supplier was bound to provide after sale services of the equipment after the warranty period of 10 years. The tender terms and specification dated 13.03.2005 have been filed by the Claimant alongwith the statement of claim and is an admitted document. Therefore, the same is not being repeated and reproduced. The tender of the claimant was accepted and order for supply of 4Hi Reversible Cold Rolling Mill was placed. The machine was to be supplied within a period of 6 months. The other description and details have been filed by the Claimant themselves and are admitted Ex Comm. No.34/2024 Page 2 of 12 MMTC Ltd. Vs. Davinder Kaur -- 2 of 12 -- documents, therefore, no further details are being furnished in the counter claim. The claimant after being repeatedly informed to supply the ordered machine, supplied the machine but the same was not in terms of the order placed by the Respondent. The Respondent accordingly sent notice dated 30.03.2009 and repudiate the contract and claimed a sum of Rs.90,26,853/- (Rupees ninety lac twenty six thousand eight hundred fifty three only) as detailed hereunder: (a) Amount already paid i. on 01.12.2006 Rs.20,00,000.00 ii. on 19.12.2006 Rs.13,84,000.00 iii. on 07.08.2007 Rs.11,28,000.00 Rs.45,12,000.00 (b) Interest on above at 18% p.a. till 03.03.2009 Rs.16,80,456.00 (c) Amount spent on electrical connections Rs.5,32,484.00 including material (d) Cost of providing earthing pit Rs.91,913.00 (e) Loss of profit for two seasons Rs.20,00,000.00 due to non-production (f) Cost of air-conditioning and other materials for making the hall usable for the Cold Rolling Mill Rs.60,000.00 (g) Miscellaneous administrative expenses and civil work Rs.15,000.000 Total Rs.90,26,853.00 Claimant is liable for interest @18% p.a. A sum of Rs.81,95,393.00 is due towards interest. In view of the facts and circumstances and in the interest of justice, it is therefore, respectfully prayed that Claim Petition as filed by the Claimant may kindly be dismissed and the Counter Claim of the respondent may be awarded in favour of respondent and against the claimant. Any other order this Hon’ble Forum feels appropriate in the facts of the case may also be passed in favour of the Respondent and against the Claimant. 8. After completion of pleadings, following issues were identified by Ld. Tribunal on 19.08.2024: 1. Whether the contacted machine was installed and made successfully operational as alleged by the claimant? 2. Whether earthing was the responsibility of the respondent as alleged by the claimant? 3. Whether the claimant and respondent performed their respective obligations stipulated in the agreement dated 27.11.2006? 4. Whether 2-Hi Reversible Cold Rolling Mill was accepted as interim measure by the respondent and investment committee of the Directors of the respondent was justified in insisting that the plant configuration of the mill should be as per the original plant without any change? 5. Whether the claim is barred by limitation? Ex Comm. No.34/2024 Page 3 of 12 MMTC Ltd. Vs. Davinder Kaur -- 3 of 12 -- 6. Whether the claimant has failed to supply parts and render services resulting into machinery lying unused as alleged? 7. Whether the claimant was to provide maintenance and services after warranty period only upon finalising a further contract which was not done by the respondent as alleged? 8. Whether non-user of mill by the respondent after 1 and a half years of running can be a ground for refusal to make payment of the value of the mill/materials as claimed? 9. Whether the claimant is entitled to the amount claimed under Section 70 of the Contract Act? 10. Whether the Claimant is entitled to amount of Rs.85,30,845/- towards balance amount outstanding? 11. Whether the claimant is entitled to interest? If so, on which amount, at what rate and for which period? 12. Whether the respondent is entitled to counter claim on account of breach committed by the claimant. If so, under which of the heads of the amount/s? 13. Relief. 9. After a contested arbitral proceedings, the JD claimant’s claim and MMTC’s counter-claim the award in question was passed on 10.03.2016 wherein under the head Relief at issue no. 13 following finding was given: 13.“Resultantly, claim petition and the counter claim are disposed of with direction to the claimant to lift the Mill in 2-hi mode in its present condition from the respondent’s place within two months from the receipt of the copy of the award, subject to refunding of the advance money of Rs.45,12,000/- to the respondent. In case the mill is not lifted and the said amount paid within the said period, the respondent will be entitled to realise the “said sum” by selling the Mill after notice to the claimant. Excess sale proceed, if any, will be paid to the claimant. If the sale proceed is insufficient to meet the said amount, the respondent shall be entitled to recover the deficient amount from the claimant. Under the facts and circumstances of the case, the parties are left to bear their own costs.” 10.Even though the award dated 10.03.2016 categorically granted relief to MMTC whereby JD claimant was directed to take back the machine within two months from MMTC after refunding advance money of Rs.45.12 lakhs,. The award further went on to authorise MMTC to sell the machines in case the same is not lifted by JD claimant within two months, so as to realize recovery of Rs.45.12 lakhs. No step was taken by the MMTC for execution of this award till 2024 i.e. eight long years. 11.The award was challenged by JD claimant by filing Section 34 A & C petition OMP (Comm.) No.324/2016 dated 16.07.2016 before Hon’ble High Court but no stay was granted on the relief granted to MMTC in the above award. But Ex Comm. No.34/2024 Page 4 of 12 MMTC Ltd. Vs. Davinder Kaur -- 4 of 12 -- still the MMTC did not care to file any execution petition under Section 36 of A & C Act. 12.It is submitted by Ld. Senior Counsel for MMTC that while this award was passed on 10.03.2016, Section 36 of A& C Act stood amended by 2015 Act made effective from 23.10.2015 which brought to an end the era of automatic stay, still by virtue of Section 26 of the Amending Act, 2015 the amended Section 36 was not applicable to the award in question. 13.It is evident that in 2019 Amendment by virtue of Section 15 of the Amending Act, Section 26 of 2015 Amending Act was omitted from the back date i.e. 23.10.2015 but as rightly pointed out by Ld. Senior Counsel the newly introduced Section 87 was declared constitutionally invalid by Three Judge Bench of Hon’ble Supreme Court in HCC Vs. Union of India, 2019 Latest Caselaw 1160 SC. 14.Consequently, the futuristic legislative intervention of mandating seeking of stay against execution of an award and pulling curtains on automatic stay was restored and in the absence of any stay granted to the JD the MMTC had all the opportunity to file Section 36 petition but still no petition was filed after HCC judgment supra which was passed on 27.11.2019. A plea is raised on behalf of MMTC that some negotiations were going on with the JD but admittedly no proof of the same has been placed on record. Moreover, as per Ld. Counsel for JD no negotiations were going on between MMTC and his client as claimed. 15.Another plea raised on behalf of MMTC is that from March 2020 the Covid Pandemic gripped the nation and as such MMTC could not file execution petition under Section 36 A& C Act against the JD. No doubt the functioning of the Court also suffered during this period but it is a matter of record that there was no bar on e-filing of fresh petition/suit at least in civil jurisdictions. Even if this plea is considered, the freeze on limitation of Hon’ble Supreme Ex Comm. No.34/2024 Page 5 of 12 MMTC Ltd. Vs. Davinder Kaur -- 5 of 12 -- Court ended on 28.02.2022 but MMTC took another leisurely two years in approaching this Court with petition in hand. 16.The above conduct of sitting over a relief granted by an Arbitral Tribunal was taken note of by this Court and certain directions were issued to its Chairman to ascertain as to who is responsible for non-enforcement of relief/award of Rs.45.12 lakhs to the MMTC which is evidently public money, instead of carrying out an introspection and ascertaining the reason behind it, MMTC moved an application before this Court on 14.03.2024 seeking to withdraw the execution petition filed by it after 8 long years through its counsel Sh. Ashok Chhabra supported by affidavit of Senior Manager, MMTC Nityanand Sinha. When an objection to the same was taken and it was insisted that the management of MMTC shall look into reasons for 8 years delay, the directions of this Court were challenged in CM(Main) 2490/2024 whereby interim stay was granted to the MMTC from holding any internal inquiry qua the delay. 17.Record reveals that thereafter there was change of guards qua the legal representation of the MMTC and a fresh counsel Sh. Akhil Sachar filed a vakalatnama. In so far as while lamenting MMTC for sitting over an award for 8 years even though no interest was granted to it by the Tribunal, Ld. Additional Solicitor General appearing for MMTC before Hon’ble High Court made a statement that actually the award does grant future interest to the MMTC on Rs.45.12. Lakhs as a relief but somehow the same was not added in the execution petition filed under Section 36 of A& C Act r/w Order 21 CPC before this Court. 18.In this backdrop application in hand for amendment of execution petition was moved on 17.05.2024 seeking to include the relief that MMTC is entitled to recover Rs.45.12 lakhs alongwith future (post-award) interest @9%. The amendment application also invoke Section 31 (7) (b) of A& C Act 1996 for claiming post-award interest. Ex Comm. No.34/2024 Page 6 of 12 MMTC Ltd. Vs. Davinder Kaur -- 6 of 12 -- 19.While opening his submissions on behalf of MMTC Ld. Senior Counsel submitted that in the counter-claim petition MMTC had sought pre-suit, pendente lite and future interest as well on its claim amount. The relief sought in the claim petition shows that MMTC is seeking recovery of money from JD under two heads namely principal Rs.45,12,000/- alongwith additional claim heads including interest making it Rs.90,26,853/- and another Rs.81,95,393/- as interest @18% on Rs.90,26,853/-. It is submitted that in the prayer clause of the counter-claim the usage of the phrase “claimant is liable for interest @18% p.a.” shows MMTC’s intent to seek interest @18% on both the heads i.e. Rs.90,26,853/- and Rs.81,95,393/-. However, on the observation of this Court and there is no contest that the prayer clause in the counter-claim does not give a consolidated figure. Likewise, there is no contest that the prayer clause does not contain any word “future” or “future interest”. 20.On the contrary, it is submitted by Ld. Counsel for JD non-applicant that the above prayer of MMTC in the counter-claim does not seek any future interest. It is submitted that the usage of phrase “claimant is liable for interest @18% p.a.” pertains to pre-suit period only as it is evident from the fact that it had been used before inclusion of Rs.81,95,393/-. 21.Appreciating the above submissions in the light of the copies of the pleadings placed on record it is evident that the prayer clause of the MMTC’s counter- claim is ambiguous and is not worded in such a manner so as to make it clear that they are seeking recovery of future interest. Absence of phrases “future interest” in the prayer clause and the manner in which it conveyed to Ld. Arbitrator clearly goes on to show that MMTC did not seek any pendente lite and future interest on either of the two amounts. 22.The manner in which issue no. 11 and 12 were casted on the basis of reliefs prayed by original claimant/JD and counter-claimant/MMTC respectively Ex Comm. No.34/2024 Page 7 of 12 MMTC Ltd. Vs. Davinder Kaur -- 7 of 12 -- shows that Ld. Tribunal did not frame any issue for grant of future interest to the counter-claimant/MMTC. 23.The second aspect of appreciating the amendment sought in the execution petition is as to whether the award dated 10.03.2016 grants any relief to the MMTC under the head pendente lite and future interest. 24.While opening his submissions on behalf of MMTC Ld. Senior Counsel has submitted that according to his client’s interpretation on the award MMTC was awarded 18% interest on Rs.45.12 lakhs as claimed for pre-suit and pendente lite period and out of the same 9% was adjusted towards setting off the JD claimant’s claim of damages under Section 70 of Indian Contract Act and remaining 9% interest on Rs.45.12 lakhs is payable by the JD to MMTC. 25.It is stated that the award is ambiguous on the aspect of awarding of future interest on Rs.45.12 lakhs as against the total counter-claimed amount of Rs.1,72,22,246/- submitted by MMTC in the counter-claim. 26.This submission is opposed by Ld counsel for JD/original claimant it is submitted that as against the counter-claim of Rs.1,72,22,246/- MMTC was awarded only Rs.45.12 lakhs with 9% interest only for the pre-suit period and no interest has been awarded for pendente lite and future as sought to be made out on behalf of MMTC. The rival submission can be appreciated by combined reading of closing lines of internal page 31 on issues no.1,3,4,8,10,11 and part of counter-claim of Rs.45.12 lakhs, “as a corollary to the finding, it must follow that the claimant has to take back the mill in the present condition after refunding the amount received towards advance money with interest as claimed by way of counter-claim, to the respondent”. This para also mentions that the JD/claimant’s demand for compensation for usage of his machine by MMTC has been dealt in separately under Issue no. 9. 27.Plain reading of the above observation of Ld. Tribunal shows that on the one hand it has concluded that JD/claimant has to take back his machine and return Ex Comm. No.34/2024 Page 8 of 12 MMTC Ltd. Vs. Davinder Kaur -- 8 of 12 -- the MMTC’s advance of Rs.45.12 lakhs. The Tribunal is indicating awarding interest to MMTC but the fact that as against prayer of awarding 18% interest no specific rate of interest is mentioned in this para. 28.The second portion relevant here is observation of the Tribunal at bottom of page 33 and opening lines of Page 34 while deciding issue no. 9, “parties have not adduced any evidence to quantify that compensation. Though respondent has claimed interest @18% per annum on the advance paid, it would be reasonable to award interest @9% per annum as damages/compensation”. 29.Plain reading of this portion shows that the prayer of MMTC to award interest on advance payment on Rs.45.12 lakhs was actually dealt with by the Tribunal and apparently for all the three stages i.e. pre-suit, pendente lite and future but as against request/prayer for 18% only interest @9% is awarded. Also even this 9% component on Rs.45.12 lakhs has been adjusted/set off qua JD claimant’s acknowledged right to seek compensation from MMTC for usage of his machine/mill under Section 70 of Contract Act. 30.Issue 12 on para 34 which sums up all the reliefs sought by MMTC under the counter-claim is of vital importance. For ready reference the same is reproduced hereunder: 12. By way of counter claim, total amount of Rs.90,26,853/- including that of advance of Rs.45,12,000/- has been claimed. Without incurring expenses on electric connection, cost in providing earth pits, cost of air conditioning and civil work as claimed, the mill could not have been commissioned and used for 1 and a half years. The respondent who suffered loss due to lower productivity etc. has not given break-up of loss of profit of Rs.20,00,000/- nor adduced any satisfactory evidence in support thereof. It is therefore not entitled to the counter- claim of Rs.90,26,853/- minus Rs.45,12,000/-, for which amount it has been found entitled to claim from the respondent. 31.Plain reading of this observation shows that as against counter-claim claim of Rs1,72,22,246/- under two heads of Rs.90,26,853/- and Rs.81,95,393/- apart from 18% interest on the cumulative figure for pendente lite and future period relief has been granted only under the head 1a of the prayer clause of Rs.45.12 lakhs in the counter-claim pertaining to the principal amount paid by MMTC to Ex Comm. No.34/2024 Page 9 of 12 MMTC Ltd. Vs. Davinder Kaur -- 9 of 12 -- JD/claimant. Rest of the claimed heads have been specifically discussed and declined. 32.The page 35 covering issue no. 19 titled Relief sums up the entire discussion on the part of the Tribunal which is reproduced hereunder for ready reference: 13.“Resultantly, claim petition and the counter claim are disposed of with direction to the claimant to lift the Mill in 2-hi mode in its present condition from the respondent’s place within two months from the receipt of the copy of the award, subject to refunding of the advance money of Rs.45,12,000/- to the respondent. In case the mill is not lifted and the said amount paid within the said period, the respondent will be entitled to realise the “said sum” by selling the Mill after notice to the claimant. Excess sale proceed, if any, will be paid to the claimant. If the sale proceed is insufficient to meet the said amount, the respondent shall be entitled to recover the deficient amount from the claimant. Under the facts and circumstances of the case, the parties are left to bear their own costs.” 33.Plain reading of the above clearly shows that as against plaintiff’s specific claim of recovery of Rs.1,72,22,246/- alongwith pendente lite and future interest the relief granted to original claimant/JD was to take the machine back from MMTC within two months. The only relief granted to MMTC as against its prayer for recovery of Rs.1,72,22,246/- with 18% interest the relief granted is refund of Rs.45.12 lakhs. As against the MMTC’s claim of pendente lite and future interest the same was apparently denied/declined. In the name of interest, as against MMTC’s claim of interest of Rs.81,95,393/- on the first head Rs.90,26,853/- for the pre-suit period no specific amount of compensation was granted except an observation that as against 18% only 9% is awarded on Rs.45.12 lakhs which too is adjusted/set off against the JD/original claimant’s claim of compensation for usage of her machine by the MMTC. 34.In the light of the above the application of the plaintiff under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC (considered as Order 21 Rule 17 (1) CPC) seeking to add reliefs which are hitherto not awarded by the Tribunal is found to be devoid of merits and is accordingly dismissed. At this juncture a reference is made by Ld. Senior counsel for MMTC that his client’s request for compensation under Section 31 Ex Comm. No.34/2024 Page 10 of 12 MMTC Ltd. Vs. Davinder Kaur -- 10 of 12 -- (7) (b) may also be considered. For ready reference the same is reproduced hereunder: Section 31 A & C Act, 1996 : Form and Contents of arbitral award (7) (b)“A sum directed to be paid by an arbitral award shall, unless the award otherwise directs, carry interest at the rate of two per cent higher than the current rate of interest prevalent on the date of award, from the date of award to the date of payment.” 35.Plain reading of the above statute shows that the statute is applicable to only such awards where the award is silent on the interest component. However, in cases where interest is specifically prayed for all the three stages namely pre- suit, pendente lite and future and the award considers the prayer and declines the same, there is no applicability of this provision. Ld. Senior Counsel for the plaintiff has relied on case titled Morgan Securities and Credits Private Ltd. Vs. Videocon Industries Limited, 2022 Latest Caselaw 681 SC wherein in para 25 Hon’ble Supreme Court held that: “25.Section 31 (7) (a) confers a wide discretion upon the arbitrator in regard to the grant of pre-award interest. The arbitrator has the discretion to determine the rate of reasonable interest, the sum on which the interest is to be paid, that is whether on the whole or any part of the principal amount, and the period for which payment of interest is to be made – whether it should be for the whole or any part of the period between the date on which the cause of action arose and the date of the award. When a discretion has been conferred on the arbitrator in regard to the grant of pre-award interest, it would be against the grain of statutory interpretation to presuppose that the legislative intent was to reduce the discretionary power of the arbitrator for the grant of post-awrd interest under clause (b). Clause (b) only contemplates a situation where the arbitration award is silent on post-award interest, in which even the award holder is entitled to a post-award interest of eighteen per cent.” 36.In so far as MMTC has already taken a stand that the award in question is not silent and has discussions and observations which have awarded interest to the MMTC, hence this judgment is not applicable on the facts of the case in hand. 37.Another plea raised is that the component of future interest is ambiguous but in the considered view of this Court, as per above discussions, once a relief is prayed and the same is declined after discussion, it cannot be stated that the award is silent. The MMTC cannot be allowed to take contradictory stands where on the one hand it says that the Tribunal concedes its prayers for Ex Comm. No.34/2024 Page 11 of 12 MMTC Ltd. Vs. Davinder Kaur -- 11 of 12 -- awarding of interest and actually awarded relief under the head “interest”. On the same hand a plea is raised that the award is silent/ambiguous. I see no merits in this application. The same is accordingly dismissed. (SURINDER S. RATHI) District Judge Commercial Court-03 Shahdara District, KKD Delhi/12.09.2024 Ex Comm. No.34/2024 Page 12 of 12 MMTC Ltd. Vs. Davinder Kaur -- 12 of 12 --
