Full Order Text
Final Order 4 · 28 Mar 2023 · CNR DLSH010012042023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. RAMESH KUMAR-II, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT JUDGE-01 SHAHDARA DISTRICT, KARKARDOOMA COURTS: DELHI LAC No.3/2023 IN THE MATTER OF:- (As per amended memo of parties) Sh. Suresh Chander Vij S/o Late Sh. Desh Raj Vij R/o D-242, Second Floor, Anand Vihar, Delhi-110092. .........Petitioner Versus 1. Union of India Through Secretary Land And Building Nirman Bhawan, Through D.C. Govt. of N.C.T. of Delhi 2. D.M.R.C. (Delhi Metro Rail Corporation) New Delhi. .........Respondents Date of Institution : 01.09.2008 Date of reserving judgment : 25.03.2023 Date of judgment : 28.03.2023 LAC No.3/2023 Page no. 1/9 -- 1 of 9 -- JUDGMENT 1 Vide this judgment, this Court shall decide the reference petition filed under section 18 of Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (hereinafter referred to as 'L.A. Act, 1894') arising out of award dated 20.07.1999 with respect to village Chandrawali @ Shahdara, Delhi. 2 For deciding the reference U/s 18 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (In short LA Act) r/w statement U/s 19 of the Act sent by the LAC Delhi, the relevant dates and facts which are necessary for adjudication in the present matter are being given herein-under:- i) Date of notification U/s 4 of the Act :12.06.1997 ii) Date of notification U/s 6 & 17of the Act :28.07.1997 iii) Date of award :20.07.1999 iv) Area of the locality :Chandrawali @ Shahdara v) Project :For the purpose of Delhi Metro Rail Corporation vi) The land use of the area as per the award :Residential vii) Petition referred to court on :01.09.2008 3 The facts leading to the filing of the present petition are that the petitioner was an interested person being owner and in possession of 407 sq. mtrs. of land situated at Village Chandrawali, known as Railway Road Shahdara which was acquired vide award No.1/1999-2000. The petitioner further contended that the property was being used for commercial purposes for the last more than 45 years and the petitioner has been granted various licenses to run a factory on the acquired property and there were number of shops existing on the acquired property as on the date of notification U/s 4 of the LA Act. The LAC No.3/2023 Page no. 2/9 -- 2 of 9 -- petitioner further contended that he along with his brothers was running a factory and the Govt. had duly granted a license in the year 1952 and therefore the acquired property was not residential by any stretch of imagination. The petitioner further contended that the market value assessed by the LAC was very low and was not the actual market value prevailing in the area as on the date of notification U/s 4 of LA Act. The petitioner was one of the legal heirs of the original owner Sh. Deshraj Vij who died on 24.08.1998 and the petitioner was accordingly entitled to 1/3rd share in the acquired property. 4 It has further been further averred by the petitioner that the market value of his property was not less than Rs.56,000/- per sq. yds. as on the date of notification U/s 4 of the LA Act. The land of the petitioner has been wrongly treated as residential instead of being treated as commercial and thus the LAC has undervalued the market value. The petitioner has further contended that the acquired property was situated at Shahdara in the main market known as Railway Road and the entire area is being used as a commercial market since the year 1952. The LAC has also admitted in the award that the shops were situated in the area but even then the LAC has wrongly assessed the market value on residential basis. The petitioner has further contended that the LAC has wrongly held that MCD had not declared the area as commercial whereas in the year 1969, the entire area has already been declared as commercial by the DDA. The petitioner has further contended that the cost of construction has also been fixed wrongly by the LAC. 5 The notification dated 12.06.1997 under Section 4 of the LAC No.3/2023 Page no. 3/9 -- 3 of 9 -- L.A. Act, 1894 was issued by the Land Acquisition Collector (hereinafter referred to as "LAC") for acquisition of the acquired property for the purpose of Mass Rapid Transport System [MRTS], Delhi at Chandrawali @ Shahdara which was followed by the Notification dated 28.07.1997 under Section 6 & 17 (1) of L.A. Act, 1894. Keeping in view the use of the land under acquisition, residential L&DO rates which were issued by the Ministry of Urban Development pertaining to different areas of Delhi w.e.f. 1.4.1996 for Zone 5 was assessed by the LAC and accordingly the LAC assessed an amount of Rs.2,805/- per sq. mtrs. Further, solatium at the rate of 30% of market value alongwith the additional amount @ 12% of market value w.e.f. 12.06.1997 to 20.07.1999 was allowed apart from cost of structure appended to the said land and statutory interest under Section 34 of Act. Thus, an Award for total amount of Rs.18,48,55,526/- was passed by the LAC. 6 Being aggrieved from the lesser rate fixed by the LAC for the acquired land, the petitioner filed a petition under Section 18 of L.A. Act, 1894 before the LAC. The LAC sent the present reference petition to this court for adjudication and court notices were issued to the parties and thereafter, on 01.10.2008, DMRC was impleaded as necessary and proper party in this reference being the beneficiary of the acquired land. Subsequently the present case was listed for trial and finally after adjudication of the evidence filed by all the parties, Ld. predecessor of this court finally announced an award/ judgment dated 07.09.2016 in which he relied upon the circle rates notified under the provisions of Delhi Stamp [Prevention of LAC No.3/2023 Page no. 4/9 -- 4 of 9 -- Undervaluation of Instruments] Rules 2007 and enhanced the market value from Rs.2805/- to Rs.5865/- per sq. mtrs.. 7 Separate written statement was filed on behalf of respondent nos. 1 and 2. Both the respondents took various pleas in their written statement and averred that the market value assessed by the LAC was completely fair and had been assessed after considering the existing market value, locality, situation of area, quality, potentiality and the use of the land in question. The respondents also stated that the acquired property was being used for agricultural purposes and the petitioner was not entitled for any enhancement. 8 The present case has been passed through two rounds of litigation. My Ld. Predecessor had already determined/assessed the market value of the acquired property @ Rs.5865/- per sq. mtrs. vide judgment and decree dated 07.09.2016. The said judgment was passed on the basis of market value assessed on the basis of the judgment passed in case titled Chandra Pratap Singh Vs. UOI & Anr. which was in respect of award No.2/07-08, Jhilmil Tahirpur Delhi wherein the date of notification was 12.04.2006. 9 The said judgment was eventually challenged by the respondent no.2 and the matter was remanded back by the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi for adducing of additional evidence by both the parties. 10 Vide order dated 06.12.2010, following issues were framed by the Ld. Predecessor of this court as:- 1 Whether the petitioner is entitled for LAC No.3/2023 Page no. 5/9 -- 5 of 9 -- compensation at the enhanced rate as claimed? OPP 2 Relief. 11 In earlier proceedings, the petitioner examined as many as three witnesses including himself as PW1. 12 On the other hand, ld. counsel for the Union of India/respondent no.1 tendered the copy of the award no.1/1999- 2000 pertaining to Village Chandrawali as Ex.R1 in evidence. 13 The said award Ex.R1 had been adopted by Sh. Manish Kumar, Legal Assistant of respondent no.2/DMRC. 14 In additional evidence, the petitioner examined as many as six witnesses including himself as PW1. The petitioner has adopted evidence led in case titled as Subhash Chander Vij Vs Union of India & Anr. bearing LAC No.23/16/08 and closed his evidence on 28.02.2020. 15 The respondent no.1 did not lead any additional evidence after the present reference was remanded to this court for adducing additional evidence and relied upon the earlier evidence which was the award Ex.R-1. 16 The respondent no.2, in the earlier proceedings, adopted the evidence led by the Union of India i.e. respondent no.1, however when the present matter was remanded back, the respondent no.2 has examined Sh. Vijay Kumar, Section Officer, Legal, DMRC, Metro Bhawan, Barakhamba Road, New Delhi as R2W1, who tendered in evidence certified copies of sale deeds which are Ex.R2W1/1 to Ex.R2W1/12. Thereafter, respondent no.2 also closed his evidence on 28.02.2020. 17 After conclusion of additional evidence of both the parties matter was fixed for final arguments. LAC No.3/2023 Page no. 6/9 -- 6 of 9 -- 18 Ld. counsels for all the parties have filed their written arguments in support of their respective stands and they submitted that they do not want to submit anything else beyond written arguments. 19 I have perused the written arguments as filed by the parties and also perused the record. On perusal of record, my issue-wise finding is as follows:- ISSUE NO.1 20 Onus to prove this issue was upon the petitioner. However, during the course of trial, the parties have apprised this court that the market value with respect to the property acquired vide the same notification and same award has already been decided by the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi vide judgment dated 07.06.2019 passed in case titled UOI Vs. M.L. Gupta & Ors. in which the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi was pleased to fix the market value of the properties acquired vide the same notification and same award @ Rs.4692/- per sq. mtr. along with statutory benefits. The Hon’ble High Court of Delhi was pleased to assess the said market value after allowing a reduction of 20% on the rate of Rs.5865/- per sq. mtrs. which was previously determined by my Ld. Predecessor. 21 The petitioner has contended in his written arguments that the rate of Rs.5865/- per sq. mtrs. was assessed by my ld. Predecessor on the basis of judgment passed in case titled Chandra Pratap Singh Vs. UOI in which the market value was assessed as Rs.21920/- per sq. mtrs. however the said market value has now been enhanced to Rs.48,000/- per sq. mtrs. and based on the said LAC No.3/2023 Page no. 7/9 -- 7 of 9 -- analogy, the market value of the petitioner ought not to be less than Rs.25,000/- per sq. mtrs. 22 Be that as it may, this court is not inclined to go into any evidence or judgment subsequent to the passing of the judgment by the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in case titled UOI Vs. M.L. Gupta (Supra) wherein the market value for the properties acquired vide the same notification and same award have already been assessed @ Rs.4692/- per sq. mtrs. as on the date of notification i.e. 12.06.1997. 23 The respondent no.2 has further argued that an SLP is still pending before the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India with respect to the determination of market value, however from the perusal of the record, it is apparent that the SLP filed by the respondents has been dismissed however the SLP filed by the petitioner therein namely Sh. M.L. Gupta is still pending adjudication. Thus the market value assessed by the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi has reached finality qua the respondents. RELIEF 24 In view of the above noted findings, the petitioner is entitled to the market value @ Rs.4,692/- per sq. mtrs. as on 12.06.1997 with respect to their land acquired as per the statement U/s 19 of the LA Act. In addition, the petitioner would also be entitled to all statutory benefits i.e. 30% solatium on the market value in view of the compulsory nature of acquisition U/s 23 (2) of the LA Act. The petitioner would be entitled to additional amount @ 12% per annum U/s 23 (1A) of the LA Act from the date of notification U/s 4 of the LA Act i.e. 12.06.1997 till the date of dispossession i.e. 20.07.1999. Besides this, the petitioner would LAC No.3/2023 Page no. 8/9 -- 8 of 9 -- also be entitled to interest on the enhanced amount of compensation @ 9% per annum on excess amount awarded by the court for one year from the date of notification and thereafter @ 15% per annum till the date of payment of the balance amount. The respondents no.1 & 2 shall be jointly and severally liable to make the payment of the enhanced amount of compensation as determined herein-above to the petitioner. 25 The perusal of the record shows that the respondent no.2 has already deposited the enhanced amount of compensation @ Rs.5865/- per sq. mtrs. and therefore I hereby direct that any balance amount, after payable of the decreetal amount to the petitioner, be sent back to the respondent no.2. If however, additional amount requires to be deposited by the respondent no.2 in terms of the present judgment, the same be remitted by the respondent no.2 with immediate effect. 26 The reference petition stands answered accordingly. Both the sides will bear their own costs. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly. 27 A copy of this judgement be sent to the concerned LAC for information and necessary compliance within three months of its receipt. File be consigned to Record Room as per rules. (Typed to the dictation directly corrected and pronounced in open court on 28.03.2023). (RAMESH KUMAR-II) ADDL. DISTRICT JUDGE-01 SHADARA DISTRICT KARKARDOOMA COURTS DELHI LAC No.3/2023 Page no. 9/9 -- 9 of 9 --
